Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at school predicted A level grade

189 replies

user29 · 14/09/2022 18:27

How can DD be predicted a lower grade than she has proved she is capable of achieving (by a margin) in her mock?

OP posts:
user29 · 14/09/2022 22:04

'Professional judgment' sounds suspiciously like a black box, to obfuscate conscious and unconscious prejudice

OP posts:
carryingawatermelon · 14/09/2022 22:00

Piggywaspushed · 14/09/2022 21:54

This whole debating the UCAS grades is enormously stressful to teachers and directly leads to a load of parents shouting at teachers to raise them, and then shouting at teachers in August when the students don't achieve them. The whole TAGs debacle (the first year) illuminated to me that a lot of parents (not so much the children) expect the UCAS grade as some kind of foregone conclusion and - actually - didn't understand (and still don't) the aspirational bit.

This.

Worth saying also OP that when looking for the ‘method’ of setting predictions, some of this is professional judgement. This might not be as clearly tangible as a mock exam score or the same across all subjects, but it’s still valid - just like in every job and every industry. A teacher might think about similar students they’ve taught in the past and how they performed, or note how a student responds to challenging problems in class, or use their understanding of the exam style / grade boundaries / likely trajectory.

GretaVanFleet · 14/09/2022 21:55

My DD was predicted a D in A level English lit despite doing better in her mocks. With hindsight the teacher kept under marking her compared to when other teachers had looked independently at her essays. No constructive advice was given from the under marking teacher despite requests. She got a C but then the head of English contacted me on results day to obtain DDs permission for the paper to be re-graded and that the school would cover the cost. She was upgraded to B. So I would keep communicating with the school, ask for second opinions on work and support your child emphasising the good work she’s been doing. Good luck Flowers

Piggywaspushed · 14/09/2022 21:54

This whole debating the UCAS grades is enormously stressful to teachers and directly leads to a load of parents shouting at teachers to raise them, and then shouting at teachers in August when the students don't achieve them. The whole TAGs debacle (the first year) illuminated to me that a lot of parents (not so much the children) expect the UCAS grade as some kind of foregone conclusion and - actually - didn't understand (and still don't) the aspirational bit.

Piggywaspushed · 14/09/2022 21:49

Whokno · 14/09/2022 20:48

It's the very definition of helicopter parenting. Young adult faces a challenge, young adult is not required to do anything about challenge (including a simple question) & parent takes it upon themselves to sort it out and get involved in some sort of "appeal" when in reality there are only two options 1) predicted grade is unfair, in which case young adult should have a sensible conversation with teacher or 2) predicted grade is fair, in which case over invested parent should stay out of it. The mental health rate at oxbridge is the reason I think that teaching your child to be resilient is more important than the name of the uni they go to.

Actually , this is lawnmower parenting... not just hovering anxiously but forcibly clearing all obstacles from the child's path.

OP your DD will also have to do an interview and possibly an entrance test and write a stonking personal statement. The predicted grades aren't the biggest thing.

ABBAsnumberonefan · 14/09/2022 21:39

I applied to oxbridge when I was at college not that long ago and all my teachers were more than willing to help, so she really shouldn’t have a problem. If she can’t ask that how the hell will her interview go?

ABBAsnumberonefan · 14/09/2022 21:37

Fucking hell, no you should not be angry. The teacher is the professional with actual knowledge on these things - you’re not. If you and your daughter are so ANGRY then she needs to speak to her teacher.

user29 · 14/09/2022 21:37

Givenuptotally · 14/09/2022 21:33

they should have a schoolwide policy ie not chemistry and maths doing it one way and biology doing it a different way

subjects are all different in what they are assessing and how it is assessed. I don’t think I’ve ever predicted an A* this early and rarely predict at all because they are so difficult to achieve - it really is the best students that get the highest grades and it doesn’t take much to miss it

Does that mean you have never predicted an early applicant an A*?

OP posts:
user29 · 14/09/2022 21:36

well to be fair she didn't know her PG until she got home from school at 4.30.
We will see what enlightenment tomorrow brings!

OP posts:
Melawati · 14/09/2022 21:34

I just don’t get why you’re so dead set against just asking the teacher/hod who emailed you the predicted grade?
Each department will have their own way of doing things because each subject is different.
And if your DD can’t say ‘Mrs X, you know I’m applying to Oxbridge and I need to get my form in early, please can I have my predicted grades?’, she’s not Oxbridge ready.

Givenuptotally · 14/09/2022 21:33

Apologies, not sure why that came out underlined

Givenuptotally · 14/09/2022 21:33

they should have a schoolwide policy ie not chemistry and maths doing it one way and biology doing it a different way

subjects are all different in what they are assessing and how it is assessed. I don’t think I’ve ever predicted an A* this early and rarely predict at all because they are so difficult to achieve - it really is the best students that get the highest grades and it doesn’t take much to miss it

carryingawatermelon · 14/09/2022 21:32

user29 · 14/09/2022 21:28

the school, by not having a clear method , and communicating it to students in advance, risk opening themselves up to accusations or and actual prejudice

You know what would help here? Asking the school / teacher what their process for setting predictions is! Maybe this has been communicated to students, but either way, I’m sure the teacher will be happy to explain.

Eggza · 14/09/2022 21:30

user29 · 14/09/2022 21:28

the school, by not having a clear method , and communicating it to students in advance, risk opening themselves up to accusations or and actual prejudice

As the teacher hasn't given it to the class they may explain it then. Honestly just ask them why.

user29 · 14/09/2022 21:29

LimpBiskit · 14/09/2022 21:26

You clearly have no understanding of pupil progression.

When i was at school i used to pull it out of the hat in exams, the rest of the time i CBA

OP posts:
Dotcheck · 14/09/2022 21:29

user29 · 14/09/2022 19:52

The mock in question, was sat last term and was a real AS paper based on teh full years work they had done. The grade boundaries in raw marks D 51,c61, B71,A 81 and she scored 94, so i can't see how thi doesnt mean the AS equivalnt of an A She got 9 at GCSE. She has ben predicted A in Maths , FM,Chem and biology but it is biology she wants to study and needs an A* in it

These are adults in a position of power who Students have been drilled for 13 years not to question. It is not an equal relationship.
I think I am going to pull together lots of data to support our case and hope the squeakiest wheel gets oiled

Jesus- what drama! Just tell her to ask if it can be changed.
I presume she isn’t going to school in the 1800’s? If not just ask!!!

Christ on a bike!!!

user29 · 14/09/2022 21:28

the school, by not having a clear method , and communicating it to students in advance, risk opening themselves up to accusations or and actual prejudice

OP posts:
LimpBiskit · 14/09/2022 21:26

user29 · 14/09/2022 21:14

I hope you didn't accuse a student of that with no evidence! They may just have not bothered revising til the exam

You clearly have no understanding of pupil progression.

user29 · 14/09/2022 21:25

Midsizegal29 · 14/09/2022 21:16

Quite often, predicted grades are a more cautious prediction. Teachers get absolutely slated if their predictions are over, so it could be that she is averaging an A at the moment (even though she scored the equivalent of an A* in the mock) based on that set of papers and other bits of work & assessments completed over the year. A predicted grade is never just based on one assessment.

The sensible thing to do would be to ask her teacher if you’d like clarification. I’m sure they’d be more than happy to explain it to you.

They should take account of trajectory not an avearge. they should have a schoolwide policy ie not chemistry and maths doing it one way and biology doing it a different way

OP posts:
Teacherontherun · 14/09/2022 21:24

Trust me as a teacher, you can tell when I pupil cheats. I have seen students cpy exam codes like "awrt" which is an abbreviation used ( answers which round to) would never ever need to be written in an exam by a student. They use lines of working out that feel wrong or have mistakes but then correct final answers. Questions on non calculator papers which are impossible to do in your head, and they get correct answers. Students who cheat are rarely as clever as they think

Whyarewehardofthinking · 14/09/2022 21:23

@user29 That is the point, most don't get predicted A*s. And she hasn't completed a real exam series, despite doing a few. This has been explained on here before but the reason most TAGs were higher than previous years results were because a student wasn't 'allowed' to have a bad day, as they were tested and tested to gain the evidence. This removed the normal element of nerves, anxiety, feeling unwell etc that does impact the results of a cohort. Your daughter could be one of those students, and she gained exceptionally high results for that reason. She also could react that way in her A Level exams. She could also misinterpret just one question and not gain the marks for (what we predict) will be high grade boundaries.

Also, in some schools teaching staff will be crucified for overpredicting, so would naturally be cautious around the very high end grades.

Finally, you mentioned to another poster that they shouldn't accuse a student with surprisingly high results; you can tell they have seen a mark scheme, so do not need 'evidence'. Each student has a particular writing style and it will never be mark scheme perfect. Especially when you are looking at Maths and the Sciences, because not showing any working is the biggest pointer to cheating, which is why we drill into them about showing all of their working (as well as to secure them marks if their answer is incorrect).

Hopeandlove · 14/09/2022 21:23

noblegiraffe · 14/09/2022 19:24

As a matter of principle you've decided not to ask the teacher about the predicted grade that seems low based on previous assessments and have decided to moan on MN instead? Confused

Ask. A test on the topic is not the same as a past paper though

9thlife · 14/09/2022 21:22

Op your daughter needs to be doing this.
if she wants to go to to a top uni then she needs to have a simple discussion with her teacher regarding her grade.

FacebookPhotos · 14/09/2022 21:21

As has been explained, A level is harder than AS and the really challenging content hasn’t been taught yet. What exam board was it? In my school (we do AQA), our Head of Science did some tracking scores and found that the students who achieved A star at A level had almost invariably scored over 100 across the two papers at AS.

The first step is for DD to talk to her teacher. Obviously it isn’t a relationship of equals, but that doesn’t mean she can’t ask a question. If the school and teachers are so horrid that she can’t speak to them, why on Earth didn’t she move schools after GCSE?! If she’s simply a person who doesn’t like questioning authority this is a really good opportunity for her to practise.

Personally, I wouldn’t give predicted grades to parents until after they had been discussed with the student and (if necessary) the reference writer (usually form tutor). In my current school we are asked to make a judgement call rather than being too optimistic and the reference writer deals with any grades being moved up.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 14/09/2022 21:19

I suspect OP doesn’t know how uni admissions work and thinks a prediction exceeding the stated ‘typical offer’ guidance will get her child a place.

OP ring the head of sixth form or the school’s uni admissions person in the morning and get advice on what you actually need and how to accomplish it.

Bear in mind oxbridge will look at so much more than grades and might not be the right place for your child, too.