Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at school predicted A level grade

189 replies

user29 · 14/09/2022 18:27

How can DD be predicted a lower grade than she has proved she is capable of achieving (by a margin) in her mock?

OP posts:
Murdoch1949 · 15/09/2022 01:56

Students having an A at GCSE will not necessarily get a Grade A at AS level, and definitely not at A level. The leap from GCSE to AS then A level is huge. Teachers will use a battery of data to make their predictions for UCAS, needing to be fair to the student, the universities to which they are applying and the school. Teachers are accountable for their predictions, if they are too generous or too harsh they will be taken to task, do it's not something they do without thought. Talk to the teacher not Mumsnet.

clary · 15/09/2022 00:21

Yeps @Ihavethisthingwithcolour I agree, much harder to achieve an A* than a 9. A-levels are so challenging. My DC gained 9s in their best subjects but B and A at A level in those same subjects.

JaffavsCookie · 15/09/2022 00:15

@Ihavethisthingwithcolour absolutely. In my new year 12 biology cohorts i have lots and lots of students with 9s ( partly the adjustment effect tbh). Not all of them will get A* by any means. A bright enough kid can get 9s at GCSE without needing to work too hard. At A level they all need to put a shift in.

Ihavethisthingwithcolour · 14/09/2022 23:54

Can I please ask… and I don’t mean to high jack your thread op forgive me. But is it harder to get an a* at a level than it is to get a 9 in gcse?

Zitouna · 14/09/2022 23:29

Hi OP, your post reminded me that, a few years ago when clearing out some papers, my mum found and gave to me, a copy of the letter she had written to my school challenging my predicted A-level grade (more than 20 years ago).

My mum was a teacher, so knew her stuff. I’d had a couple of early mock papers at a B grade, and had been predicted a B. From what I remember, my mum’s argument rested on the data/trajectory - she basically said that, given my test scores throughout school, if they genuinely thought I was only going to get a B then they needed to think hard about what was going on with the teaching.

The tone of the letter was really respectful tho - saying she supported the school, and hadn’t told me she was writing because I would have been mortified (correct). I recall I was really upset about it at the time (had lots of other things going on in the background) but absolutely no way would I have dared challenge the teacher. Was nice to see, years later, that my mum had had my back - in a classy way, that didn’t make things awkward for me at school.

They did change my predicted grade - though i didn’t know why at the time (and I got an A in the end!).

If there’s anything I’d take from that is that it’s worth challenging, and might get a better outcome for your DD generally if you’re not too guns blazing?

Gymnopedie · 14/09/2022 23:23

user29 · 14/09/2022 22:04

'Professional judgment' sounds suspiciously like a black box, to obfuscate conscious and unconscious prejudice

OP your paranoia is showing. From what you've written throughout the thread you seem to be convinced that the teachers are deliberately doing your DD down. They are not obliged to predict DD an A* just because you she wants one. You will only get an answer of you actually ask the question so why are you holding back? Is it because you fear they will give you a perfectly fair and rational explanation that you won't be able to argue with?

larkstar · 14/09/2022 23:13

When was the mock? How was the mock exam constructed? If she is in the second year she still had a considerable amount of the coursework to complete so it makes sense that the mock up not include questions on the topics she has not yet been exposed to. She might be graded at a high grade of she had learned the material that she had been exposed to so far. The teacher, who may well have been testing their subject for a good many years to hundreds, possibly thousands of students will have a pretty good idea how your daughter is likely to perform when compared against all of those other students. I doubt think you do your daughter any favours at all by reacting so angrily when you not smart enough to go and ask about things that you do not understand - go and ask for things to be explained before you get yourself and your daughter all wound up for no good reason.

Herejustforthisone · 14/09/2022 23:05

Maybe the daughter can’t ask because she’s got a slightly frightening mum contracting her teachers demanding to know her predicted grades ahead of publication, and then going off on one about it? Just a thought…

titchy · 14/09/2022 23:01

Thatsnotmycar · 14/09/2022 22:27

OP you haven’t acknowledged the posts saying DD doesn’t require A* in Biology for Oxbridge. Is that because your dissatisfaction isn’t anything to do with the grades required for university?

That would be a waste of an AIBU thread though wouldn't it? As would actually talking to the teacher! 🤷‍♀️

converseandjeans · 14/09/2022 22:39

the AS equivalent of A*

I don't believe you can get A* at AS level. So A is highest grade possible.

We usually have a predicted grade and UCAS grade. Often the students will push for higher UCAS grade than they got in mock. Maybe they can check with teacher & ask if they can push UCAS grade up a bit? If you don't ask you don't get.

A grade 9 two years ago was Teacher Assessed so it's hard to know if they are really at that level.

XelaM · 14/09/2022 22:36

Their top students*

XelaM · 14/09/2022 22:35

OP I agree with you. Teachers should actually support their too students trying to get into Oxbridge, not ruin their chances. When I was applying to Cambridge Law many moons ago, one if my teachers was extremely supportive, another was an absolute cow. I still got invited for an interview though but messed that up 🫣

carryingawatermelon · 14/09/2022 22:35

user29 · 14/09/2022 22:04

'Professional judgment' sounds suspiciously like a black box, to obfuscate conscious and unconscious prejudice

There’s no obfuscation - I’ve actually given a few examples of what a teacher’s professional judgment might involve.

IrisVersicolor · 14/09/2022 22:30

Are they thus aware that the prediction could impact her application?

That should say “are they aware that she thinks the prediction could impact” etc.

Assuming that it’s she who thinks this not you.

Thatsnotmycar · 14/09/2022 22:27

OP you haven’t acknowledged the posts saying DD doesn’t require A* in Biology for Oxbridge. Is that because your dissatisfaction isn’t anything to do with the grades required for university?

IrisVersicolor · 14/09/2022 22:25

OP, was Oxbridge application not discussed in the first A level year? That’s when schools give feedback to students that they’re likely to be a standard to apply, and that’s when additional Oxbridge classes start.

Are the school aware that DD is wanting to apply, has she talked it through with the teacher of the subject she intends to apply for? Are they thus aware that the prediction could impact her application?

carryingawatermelon · 14/09/2022 22:21

TheSpringyGuyAndTheCheeseEater · 14/09/2022 22:14

So you believe that nobody gets predicted an A*? All predictions will be made at a similar time so the limitations you describe would apply to all schools. And the OP has stated already that this is not the criteria being applied in other subjects at the same school. Your post doesn't appear to explain what has happened here.

Yes, A star predictions are made (I’ve done it!) but it’s quite possible the teacher doesn’t want to do this solely on the basis of a mock exam that didn’t contain any A star material. Which is why I suggest talking to the teacher about any opportunity to demonstrate A star potential. It’s not uncommon for predicted grades to be reviewed as more evidence becomes available.

user29 · 14/09/2022 22:20

Piggywaspushed · 14/09/2022 22:15

Presume it is an internal school deadline for checking and feedback.

Yes , checking and attaching reference

OP posts:
Piggywaspushed · 14/09/2022 22:15

Presume it is an internal school deadline for checking and feedback.

SkygardenTower · 14/09/2022 22:14

Not really the point, but where does the Oxbridge application deadline of the 23rd of September come from?

Oxford and Cambridge you need to apply for tests by the 30th of September. UCAT has to be sat before 29th September and LNAT for Oxbridge need to register by tomorrow.

The application doesn’t need to be in until the 15th October.

(On the main topic -she needs to talk to the teacher, not you. If she doesn’t get an answer she agrees with then you can help, but give her a chance first.)

TheSpringyGuyAndTheCheeseEater · 14/09/2022 22:14

carryingawatermelon · 14/09/2022 20:45

I understand why it’s stressful but refusing to engage with the teacher isn’t going to help.

There is no A grade in AS levels, which is why you don’t have that grade boundary when looking at the mock marks. The A work (the most challenging content) tends to appear in the second year of the course. Therefore, given that we are only a week or so into the A2 year of the course, it’s quite possible the teacher simply hasn’t seen any A quality work from any pupil yet, so cannot justify an A prediction.

I wouldn’t advise going in with a stack of ‘evidence’ like you know better than the teacher… A better conversation (ideally between your DD and their teacher if I’m honest) would be to ask about the A prediction and whether there will be any opportunity between now and submitting her UCAS form (which I appreciate will be early) to demonstrate her ability to achieve an A* grade, given that the mock won’t have contained that content.

The school may well have a policy about this kind of thing - it’s very difficult to predict an A* when that content hasn’t even been taught yet. I’m sure you can see how it can cause trouble later if there’s no evidence to back up what turns out to be an over-prediction.

(Just in case… I previously ran UCAS applications in a large school, currently an A level examiner)

So you believe that nobody gets predicted an A*? All predictions will be made at a similar time so the limitations you describe would apply to all schools. And the OP has stated already that this is not the criteria being applied in other subjects at the same school. Your post doesn't appear to explain what has happened here.

noblegiraffe · 14/09/2022 22:13

Piggywaspushed · 14/09/2022 22:09

Jeez, if your DD actually spoke to the teacher , they might raise the grade to an A*

Where's the fun in that, though?

TheSpringyGuyAndTheCheeseEater · 14/09/2022 22:11

IrisVersicolor · 14/09/2022 20:38

These are adults in a position of power who Students have been drilled for 13 years not to question.

What kind of school teaches students not to question adults? Very much the opposite of my school.

Most schools do this.

Follow a timetable. Dress like clones. Do not question authority. Do not ask for a rationale for the rules applied. Etc.

This is why so many people who are highly intelligent and very successful later in life, but happen not to have a blind rule-following mentality, really struggle to flourish in that environment.

Piggywaspushed · 14/09/2022 22:09

Jeez, if your DD actually spoke to the teacher , they might raise the grade to an A*

Wex · 14/09/2022 22:04

There is a difference between the grades "predicted " on a UCAS application and those the teachers actually expect the child to get. Usually a bit generous on the former.

Swipe left for the next trending thread