Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not (yet) understand the purpose of pronouns in emails?

217 replies

Bobby80 · 14/09/2022 17:31

I'm aware this is a sensitive topic for some but I'm looking for some education on this. I didn't want to post in the gender issues boards as I thought I might come across as very ignorant and maybe I am! I also wanted a broad 'audience'.

Pronouns in emails- what's the purpose? Should I have my pronouns in my work email signature? We have no guidance on it at work so some people do and some don't. I don't feel the need personally to have a pronoun in mine but wouldn't want to offend others. Is the purpose of it for the send ie me or for the receiver or both? Is it really meaningful or a box ticking exercise?

OP posts:
UWhatNow · 14/09/2022 19:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Etinoxaurus · 14/09/2022 19:15

yetanotherusernameAgain · 14/09/2022 17:38

You might as well have posted on the Feminism boards because you're going to get the same people telling you it's a load of bollocks and virtue-signalling.

It can be helpful if you have a first name that is ambiguous (eg Sam) or unusual and people won't know if you're a man or woman.

I have an ambiguous name and that’s an extra reason to not put my pronouns. Studies have shown women are perceived worse- why should I advertise the fact?

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 19:13

midgetastic · 14/09/2022 19:08

How does pronouns harm women ?

It has been shown that reminding females of their sex makes them underperform.?pronouns in emails reminds females of their sex

It has been shown that making people aware that a person is female causes them to downgrade how they view that person - reject from interview for example a female but not a male with the same cv. Pronouns in emails will make it easier for men to disregard the email

How many examples would be enough ?

Ok, so me choosing to use pronouns might harm me, but how does it harm others?

Up to me if I choose to do something which might harm me (while being I formed about the culture of my work place) in order to support another vulnerable group.

I absolutely do not think women are obliged to declare their pronouns, particularly if they would be negatively effected by it.

FOJN · 14/09/2022 19:12

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 19:03

I didn't say my lived experience was more valid. I said it is a discussion that I feel I have a valid perspective on. You are just looking for a fight.

I'm aware how strongly some posters feel about issues relating to supporting transgender people. But to wildly state that any woman who sees things differently to you "lacks self-respect" is preposterous.

I'm really not looking for a fight. I quoted your exact words, which were:

"I have a lived experience of being a woman so am better positioned to have a view about whether this is harmful to women."

I don't think I can be held responsible for thinking you were attempting to speak for all women.

I maintain that women with self respect will push back against misogyny. You keep making the mistake of asserting that women standing up for themselves are "anti trans", that is misogyny. I can defend women's rights without hate for anyone else but equally I will not stay silent if accomodating another group is done at the expense of women.

Scianel · 14/09/2022 19:12

It's to show that you belong to the Church of Woke.

Belledan1 · 14/09/2022 19:11

I was really confused with it but someone explained to me it's people showing support to tansgender people that they can identify whatever sex they want. I too thought it was say your name was Jamie you would use it to show what sex you are. I not going to put it on my signature though

cobblerwobbler · 14/09/2022 19:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LakieLady · 14/09/2022 19:09

I work for an organisation with (I suspect) a higher than average proportion of trans/gender fluid/gender neutral/attention seeking people among its workforce.

It is mandatory to have your pronouns in your email signature to avoid misgendering. 😏Even if your name is one that is almost invariably used by one gender only, and your gender is consistent with that. 😖And it is a disciplinary matter to misgender or deadname someone who has transitioned. A former colleague got a written warning for this heinous offence.

Having said that, I've noticed an increasing number of people who don't have their pronouns in emails, so maybe no-one's policing it. The organisation has a bit of a history of introducing "rules", and a few months later you find you're the only one still observing them and no-one else seems to give a fuck.

AliTheMinx · 14/09/2022 19:09

I hate the idea of pronouns in emails. I just do not get it and hate all this wokery... gah!

midgetastic · 14/09/2022 19:08

How does pronouns harm women ?

It has been shown that reminding females of their sex makes them underperform.?pronouns in emails reminds females of their sex

It has been shown that making people aware that a person is female causes them to downgrade how they view that person - reject from interview for example a female but not a male with the same cv. Pronouns in emails will make it easier for men to disregard the email

How many examples would be enough ?

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 19:08

purpleboy · 14/09/2022 18:57

I have a lived experience of being a woman so am better positioned to have a view about whether this is harmful to women. I'm not trans, so my role is to listen to trans people in respect of their experiences.

What about the women who tell you this can be harmful? Do their lived experience not count? Or is it just one group of "women" who you deem worth enough to listen to?

I have literally just asked for further information about how me putting my pronouns in my email is harming others.

I hate the way any thread about transgender issues deteriorates into a horrible name calling slanging match. If people don't want a discussion, why start a thread?

Uncomfortable as it may make some posters, there is not only one way to be a feminist.

BaronessBomburst · 14/09/2022 19:08

I work in a male-dominated field with lots of MCPs who can't get their heads around the fact that a woman could answer a technical query. I get round this by not using my name and replying as A. Smith or Kind regards, Technical Support.
So I'm definitely not going to be adding my pronouns to my email signature!

EveSix · 14/09/2022 19:07

I'm definitely not disclosing my sex in work emails. I do a lot of inter and multi agency work, interacting with people I don't know, in a field where pronoun signatures are definitely on the up, and I don't want to risk disadvantaging myself or the outcomes for the people I represent by signalling a) that I am a woman and b) that I subscribe to gender ideology.

Vapeyvapevape · 14/09/2022 19:06

In this age of 'equality' it shouldn't matter what sex or gender you are. All I want is the correct information or answer to my question. I couldn't care less whether it's a he or she . I hate all this pronoun shit.

MrsGamgee · 14/09/2022 19:05

No point in them at all apart from the chance to virtue signal.

Some people at my work have their names broken down phonetically as well, I can see the use in that if it's a name that is hard to pronounce, but I don't think it's very necessary when your name is Re-Bec-Cah

LovinglifeAF · 14/09/2022 19:05

They are a lot of crap dressed up as “be kind”. Never will I adhere to this practice and I think less of people who do.

bellinisurge · 14/09/2022 19:04

If I see it in someone's email, I assume either narcissist, drone or bullied. Either way it's not a good look.

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 19:03

FOJN · 14/09/2022 18:52

I have a lived experience of being a woman so am better positioned to have a view about whether this is harmful to women.

How is your lived experience more valid than other women's lives experience?

I'm not trans, so my role is to listen to trans people in respect of their experiences.

Do you mean actual trans people or trans activists? One of the biggest trans YouTubers was cancelled a couple of years ago for saying that as a transwoman they would prefer people to assume their pronouns rather than them having to state them.

Women (or anyone else) refusing to put pronouns in their emails are trying to protect themselves from discrimination and asserting their boundaries. Implying that anything other than total capitulations to gender ideology is anti trans is deeply misogynistic, expect push back from women who have some self respect.

I didn't say my lived experience was more valid. I said it is a discussion that I feel I have a valid perspective on. You are just looking for a fight.

I'm aware how strongly some posters feel about issues relating to supporting transgender people. But to wildly state that any woman who sees things differently to you "lacks self-respect" is preposterous.

FKATondelayo · 14/09/2022 19:03

It can be helpful if you have a first name that is ambiguous (eg Sam) or unusual and people won't know if you're a man or woman.

Actual Sam here to tell you that in the nearly 5 decades I have been on this planet, this has never been a problem. In fact, I work in an industry where people assuming I'm a male Sam is a bonus. It gets things done a lot quicker.

To the OP:
On the tube yesterday there were 2 women talking about how to pronounce a third colleague's name and apparently this colleague puts the correct pronunciation in her email sign off. Now THAT is far more useful than fucking pronouns.

I have a lived experience of being a woman so am better positioned to have a view about whether this is harmful to women. I'm not trans, so my role is to listen to trans people in respect of their experiences.

"I'm a woman so I speak on behalf of all women. Except transwomen who tell me what to think and do." Make it make sense.

Stichintimesavesstapling · 14/09/2022 19:02

It doesn't help unisex names because presumably female or male born Sam could be non binary or trans.

KassandraOfSparta · 14/09/2022 18:59

I have a friend with a name which can be either a woman or a man. She is called Lee.

Her point is that people should treat her the same whether she is a male or female, and in a work context it doesn't matter.

purpleboy · 14/09/2022 18:57

I have a lived experience of being a woman so am better positioned to have a view about whether this is harmful to women. I'm not trans, so my role is to listen to trans people in respect of their experiences.

What about the women who tell you this can be harmful? Do their lived experience not count? Or is it just one group of "women" who you deem worth enough to listen to?

BloodyHellKen · 14/09/2022 18:53

OP there is no purpose other that it being a really quick way of identifying absolute tools 😂

FOJN · 14/09/2022 18:52

I have a lived experience of being a woman so am better positioned to have a view about whether this is harmful to women.

How is your lived experience more valid than other women's lives experience?

I'm not trans, so my role is to listen to trans people in respect of their experiences.

Do you mean actual trans people or trans activists? One of the biggest trans YouTubers was cancelled a couple of years ago for saying that as a transwoman they would prefer people to assume their pronouns rather than them having to state them.

Women (or anyone else) refusing to put pronouns in their emails are trying to protect themselves from discrimination and asserting their boundaries. Implying that anything other than total capitulations to gender ideology is anti trans is deeply misogynistic, expect push back from women who have some self respect.

FlissyPaps · 14/09/2022 18:51

PuppyMonkey · 14/09/2022 17:40

It can be helpful if you have a first name that is ambiguous (eg Sam) or unusual and people won't know if you're a man or woman

Does it matter if you’re a man or a woman sending an email?

Yes it does. I have a name that can have a masculine ending and a feminine ending. E.g: George/Georgia Alexander/Alexandra Daniel/Danielle Paul/Paula

My feminine name is clearly spelt in my email signature and I still get regretted to as a “he” “sir” “Daniel/Paul” multiple times a week. It’s annoying.