Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not (yet) understand the purpose of pronouns in emails?

217 replies

Bobby80 · 14/09/2022 17:31

I'm aware this is a sensitive topic for some but I'm looking for some education on this. I didn't want to post in the gender issues boards as I thought I might come across as very ignorant and maybe I am! I also wanted a broad 'audience'.

Pronouns in emails- what's the purpose? Should I have my pronouns in my work email signature? We have no guidance on it at work so some people do and some don't. I don't feel the need personally to have a pronoun in mine but wouldn't want to offend others. Is the purpose of it for the send ie me or for the receiver or both? Is it really meaningful or a box ticking exercise?

OP posts:
JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 14/09/2022 19:58

If I get an email with pronouns I roll my eyes. I'm hardly going to use her/she in my response so don't see the point. I've never been asked to add them to my emails, thank god, and never will. HTH.

cobblerwobbler · 14/09/2022 19:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

FKATondelayo · 14/09/2022 19:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Are you calling people who don't put their pronouns in their signature transphobic? Bit of a leap.

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 19:47

FKATondelayo · 14/09/2022 19:44

  1. Judges have told female victims in UK courts that they must refer to their assailants by their preferred pronouns.
  2. 'Transgender' is not a protected characteristic - it's gender reassignment and I'm not sure what's that got to do with pronoun declarations? Having pronouns in signature does not indicate transgender status. That's the whole point isn't it?
  3. Not believing in gender identity / being gender critical is confirmed as a protected belief under EA 2010 - see Forstater v CGD Europe and Bailey v Garden Court Chambers.

Thanks, this is helpful information.

KentuckyDerbyandJoan · 14/09/2022 19:46

yetanotherusernameAgain · 14/09/2022 17:38

You might as well have posted on the Feminism boards because you're going to get the same people telling you it's a load of bollocks and virtue-signalling.

It can be helpful if you have a first name that is ambiguous (eg Sam) or unusual and people won't know if you're a man or woman.

Absolute rubbish, this isn’t the reason at all.

FKATondelayo · 14/09/2022 19:44

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 19:25

With regards to point two, there is no NHS Trust that requires you to address people by a pronoun other than the one they prefer for accuracy. I think you might have got the wrong impression about this.

The Equalities Act notes being transgender as a protected characteristic. I'm not aware of it offering any protection to people who don't believe in gender identity, though I'm happy to learn about this if I am wrong.

  1. Judges have told female victims in UK courts that they must refer to their assailants by their preferred pronouns.
  2. 'Transgender' is not a protected characteristic - it's gender reassignment and I'm not sure what's that got to do with pronoun declarations? Having pronouns in signature does not indicate transgender status. That's the whole point isn't it?
  3. Not believing in gender identity / being gender critical is confirmed as a protected belief under EA 2010 - see Forstater v CGD Europe and Bailey v Garden Court Chambers.
SynchOrSwim · 14/09/2022 19:42

I don't get why you'd ask this on Mumsnet, you know the answers you're going to get here!

cobblerwobbler · 14/09/2022 19:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

orbitalcrisis · 14/09/2022 19:39

It's simply about telling others how you wish to be addressed/referred to. It helps to prevent unintentional upset.

cobblerwobbler · 14/09/2022 19:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

CallMeLinda · 14/09/2022 19:35

I don't care particularly, but I fail to see how it is useful. I have never once had an work email that refers to me using pronouns. I can not fathom a scenario that would, for example:
"Linda, please could your female self action the attached"
"Linda, as a woman, I would appreciate your feedback" etc etc.
It's always "you" or "your" and fairly formal in my workplace!
I can maybe see an email trail.. "Linda sent me an email and I replied to her stating..." (although in my workplace it would surely be a curt "please see email trail. I replied to Linda on the 7/9...")

Happyher · 14/09/2022 19:33

If you’ve managed so far in your life without using them you don’t need them. If anyone gets offended that’s their issue not yours

Surtsey · 14/09/2022 19:33

You're not going to get reasonable or non biased replies on AIBU

Oh, but there are reasonable and non biased replies (surely that should be unbiased, but I digress). It's just that some of the people reading them are so blinkered that they are incapable of seeing reason when it is in front of them.

FOJN · 14/09/2022 19:33

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 19:20

I literally said nothing to imply I spoke for other women. I said I have lived experience. I've read back my quote and not sure how you took that from what I said.

I disagree with your statement that supporting the use of pronouns makes me a misogynist. I am a feminist, just not a trans-exclusitory one. There are many beliefs which come under the heading of feminism and no one group gets to be the gatekeeper of who is a feminist.

I don't love your tone of derision for women who are not actively fighting misogyny. There are lots of reasons women aren't able to. The onus for change rests with the oppressor, not the oppressed. It is great if women feel able to fight the fight, but being critical of women who can't is misdirected in my opinion.

But, I think I do fight misogyny. I just have no interest in excluding transgender women from the group I want to fight for.

You read your quote and don't see how I thought you were trying to speak for all women? I would be confused but the rest of the post makes it quite clear you wilfully misunderstand statements when it suits you.

It's is not your support of pronouns which is misogynistic, it's your assertion that people who don't support them are anti trans, which simply isn't true. My point about self respect is connected to the very same point, I will not accept being branded anti trans because I'm pro women. If you are unhappy about some of your views being labelled misogynistic when you feel you are just supporting trans people then you will understand how unfair this feels.

I am not being critical of women I'm being critical of gender idealogues who refer to women, who understand their rights are predicated on an understanding of them as a sex class, as anti trans.

You cannot fight for women's rights if you include men in that group, women's rights become meaningless.

I lived with a trans person for 5 years, I must have hidden my anti trans sentiments really well.

IncognitoIsMyFavouriteWord · 14/09/2022 19:29

I do it so those that want/need to can. I don't see why anyone has a problem with what another person puts on their email signature. But clearly, there are those that have issues that no one else can figure out.

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 19:27

FKATondelayo · 14/09/2022 19:22

Another good reason not to declare your pronouns is that many employers - especially those in senior positions - think they are nonsense and that the kind of people who deploy them make difficult colleagues.

Depends where you work, really.

Tbh I'm not sure that currying favour with senior staff is a good basis for making moral decisions.

InPraiseOfBacchus · 14/09/2022 19:27

It's come in handy in my office where I and three members of senior management happen to have gender neutral names.

If we'd had them in emails three years ago when I joined, it would have saved me quite a lot of embarrassing emails and awkwardness.

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 19:25

FKATondelayo · 14/09/2022 19:19

You ARE increasingly obliged to declare pronouns. DH was at a conference and he left the pronoun part of his online registration blank and it printed out he/him anyway.

Anyway there are several reasons this practice is harmful

  1. Stereotype threat as PPs have said - there is evidence that reminding others you are a woman or female increases sexual stereotyping and prejudiced treatment
  2. Compelled speech - you may be forced to call a male person 'she' especially in professions where accuracy is needed (health, crime etc)
  3. Conflict with Equality Act on belief - nobody should be compelled to believe in gender identity
  4. Indirect discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation (GNC gay men and lesbians say that they have been harassed to declare their pronouns by allegedly 'well-meaning' colleagues)

With regards to point two, there is no NHS Trust that requires you to address people by a pronoun other than the one they prefer for accuracy. I think you might have got the wrong impression about this.

The Equalities Act notes being transgender as a protected characteristic. I'm not aware of it offering any protection to people who don't believe in gender identity, though I'm happy to learn about this if I am wrong.

FKATondelayo · 14/09/2022 19:22

Another good reason not to declare your pronouns is that many employers - especially those in senior positions - think they are nonsense and that the kind of people who deploy them make difficult colleagues.

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 19:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

How is it hurting other women?

Resorting to insults doesn't make you look big or clever, by the way.

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 19:20

FOJN · 14/09/2022 19:12

I'm really not looking for a fight. I quoted your exact words, which were:

"I have a lived experience of being a woman so am better positioned to have a view about whether this is harmful to women."

I don't think I can be held responsible for thinking you were attempting to speak for all women.

I maintain that women with self respect will push back against misogyny. You keep making the mistake of asserting that women standing up for themselves are "anti trans", that is misogyny. I can defend women's rights without hate for anyone else but equally I will not stay silent if accomodating another group is done at the expense of women.

I literally said nothing to imply I spoke for other women. I said I have lived experience. I've read back my quote and not sure how you took that from what I said.

I disagree with your statement that supporting the use of pronouns makes me a misogynist. I am a feminist, just not a trans-exclusitory one. There are many beliefs which come under the heading of feminism and no one group gets to be the gatekeeper of who is a feminist.

I don't love your tone of derision for women who are not actively fighting misogyny. There are lots of reasons women aren't able to. The onus for change rests with the oppressor, not the oppressed. It is great if women feel able to fight the fight, but being critical of women who can't is misdirected in my opinion.

But, I think I do fight misogyny. I just have no interest in excluding transgender women from the group I want to fight for.

FKATondelayo · 14/09/2022 19:19

You ARE increasingly obliged to declare pronouns. DH was at a conference and he left the pronoun part of his online registration blank and it printed out he/him anyway.

Anyway there are several reasons this practice is harmful

  1. Stereotype threat as PPs have said - there is evidence that reminding others you are a woman or female increases sexual stereotyping and prejudiced treatment
  2. Compelled speech - you may be forced to call a male person 'she' especially in professions where accuracy is needed (health, crime etc)
  3. Conflict with Equality Act on belief - nobody should be compelled to believe in gender identity
  4. Indirect discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation (GNC gay men and lesbians say that they have been harassed to declare their pronouns by allegedly 'well-meaning' colleagues)
Mangogogogo · 14/09/2022 19:19

The idea is that you’re showing people who might otherwise be worried to declare their gender preference that it is completely normal.

the council here make their staff do it so I wouldn’t assume the person is some form of idiot like a pp suggested.

it doesn’t bother me either way tbh

MrsRuggles · 14/09/2022 19:16

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 18:25

I'm a little tiny bit suspicious that you have come to mn, where there is an anti-trans thread slating the use of pronouns in email signatures on at least a weekly basis, rather than google this - if you have a statement to make then just say it.

Many people disagree with putting pronouns on signatures, but the purpose is to normalise checking someone's preferred way to be addressed rather than assuming this based on gender presentation. The idea being that if everyone declares their pronouns it becomes easier for transgender people to express theirs.

It costs me nothing to tell people I use the pronouns she/her. A group who are subject to discrimination say it helps them. So I do it.

Exactly the reason I do this as well.

FlorettaB · 14/09/2022 19:15

’I maintain that women with self respect will push back against misogyny’

That’s nice. Meanwhile, in the real world,

’I work in a male-dominated field with lots of MCPs who can't get their heads around the fact that a woman could answer a technical query. I get round this by not using my name and replying as A. Smith or Kind regards, Technical Support.’