Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not (yet) understand the purpose of pronouns in emails?

217 replies

Bobby80 · 14/09/2022 17:31

I'm aware this is a sensitive topic for some but I'm looking for some education on this. I didn't want to post in the gender issues boards as I thought I might come across as very ignorant and maybe I am! I also wanted a broad 'audience'.

Pronouns in emails- what's the purpose? Should I have my pronouns in my work email signature? We have no guidance on it at work so some people do and some don't. I don't feel the need personally to have a pronoun in mine but wouldn't want to offend others. Is the purpose of it for the send ie me or for the receiver or both? Is it really meaningful or a box ticking exercise?

OP posts:
JustAWeirdoWithNoName · 15/09/2022 08:06

My friend is transgender and puts her pronouns in her email signature as she is still part-way through her transition so doesn't feel she looks fully "feminine" yet. She said she likes that a lot of people also do this now whether they are cisgender, non-binary etc because it means that her displaying her pronouns doesn't automatically out her as trans.

Also as someone who works with a lot of people from different countries with names I've never heard of and don't know the gendering of, I find it very useful to know their pronouns!

Lockheart · 15/09/2022 08:04

I won't use them because I think it's the height of masculine brutality to force a woman to refer to a man as she.

If you think that's the height of masculine brutality then I'd say you've lived a very charmed life.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 15/09/2022 08:02

Lol I’m sure the usual “you’re all nasty transphobic bigots” suspect will have reported all the actual transphobia on
this thread

knowing that sex is immutable and cannot be changed is not transphobic nor is knowing that research shows women are disadvantaged at work by drawing attention to their sex

tigger1001 · 15/09/2022 08:02

"Yes it does. I have a name that can have a masculine ending and a feminine ending. E.g: George/Georgia Alexander/Alexandra Daniel/Danielle Paul/Paula

My feminine name is clearly spelt in my email signature and I still get regretted to as a “he” “sir” “Daniel/Paul” multiple times a week. It’s annoying."

If people can't be bothered to read your name properly what makes you think they will read your pronoun correctly?

I too get a wide range of variations of my name in an email reply - and yes it's annoying. But it's annoying as it shows a lack of respect to actually be bothered to read my name. It's just plain rude.

jeaux90 · 15/09/2022 08:01

I won't use them in email because I've spent 3 decades in a male dominated industry trying to mask that I'm female by using a neutral name.

I won't use them in an email because gender identity ideology is like a religion and I don't care what religion people are.

I won't use them because I don't believe gender identity exists.

I won't use them because I think it's the height of masculine brutality to force a woman to refer to a man as she.

I will refer to people as they or by their name.

Brefugee · 15/09/2022 07:54

Got this far and have something to say. I literally don't care if people use pronouns or not. Other people can stop getting hung up on "pronouns? surely I'm just going to write Dear Name?" - it is just a way of expressing a gender identity without writing "I'M TRANS" in their sig. It may or may not be helpful (you're expecting Dave to be a guy in a suit and it turns out to be a transwoman in a dress - you're already prepared for that)

is the thinking anyway.

I have a lived experience of being a woman so am better positioned to have a view about whether this is harmful to women. I'm not trans, so my role is to listen to trans people in respect of their experiences.

I am not going to use pronouns because I am a woman and I HAVE decades of not being taken seriously in a man's world as soon as colleagues/clients/suppliers get the slightest whiff that I'm not a man. I have carefully honed letter/fax/email texts over years to "de-feminise" them (and yes, it is a thing). I sign off with Initial+Surname and always have done - until i am sure i'm not going to be sidelined for being a woman.

And i WILL NOT have anyone telling me that because they personally haven't experienced that, I've been dreaming it all. I am aware of the "if everyone uses the pronouns in their sigs, people with different gender identities to their sex won't feel isolated or singled out" and i have some sympathy with it. But basically? if you are a bearded man in a suit one day with he/him and then a bearded transwoman in a dress another day with she/her - you're already noticeable. Dave from accounts also having pronouns won't change that.

Far better than pronouns in sigs we should be looking to make workplaces more accessible, more equal, and more respectful of each other. No matter what we look like or if we have different gender identities or whatever.

sumosaussage · 15/09/2022 07:47

@Stompythedinosaur

They'll deny that's transphobic you just wait and see

The comments made on here about trans people if they were made about anyone else (women, black people, Ukrainian women, children, the list goes on) the posts would be removed and the posters banned

But MNHQ has their view on this and it's very clear they're aligned with the nasty comments as long as they're only targeting trans people.

The fact you can get a ban for calling someone the K word but not for calling a trans woman a pervert or drag queens disgusting, or saying a man in a frock is indicative of this site

Stompythedinosaur · 15/09/2022 07:41

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 15/09/2022 07:37

MN is not infamously transphobic. It is full of feminists who recognise the harm caused by pretending people can change sex. That is very different from saying that a man can't wear a frock and call himself Shirley without protection from negative outcomes. __

Mn is well known for transphobia. It is sadly the only thing most people know about mn. Obviously there is more to mn than this, but it is certainly the most well known thing to people who don't use the site.

This post is clearly transphobic. Describing a transgender woman as "a man in a frock called Shirley" is really offensive.

sumosaussage · 15/09/2022 07:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 15/09/2022 07:37

MN is not infamously transphobic. It is full of feminists who recognise the harm caused by pretending people can change sex. That is very different from saying that a man can't wear a frock and call himself Shirley without protection from negative outcomes. __

TirisfalPumpkin · 15/09/2022 07:32

It’s akin to putting your political party allegiance, ‘Go Vegan’, ‘Rejoin EU’ etc in your email signature - although worse, imo - none of those causes seek to compel your colleagues’ speech. They’re just inappropriate, rather than inappropriate, narcissistic and controlling.

people have been quietly removing them at my work following a comms about OTT messy signatures and visual/screen reader accessibility. It is an improvement and I think a lot of people are relieved.

entropynow · 15/09/2022 07:25

yetanotherusernameAgain · 14/09/2022 17:38

You might as well have posted on the Feminism boards because you're going to get the same people telling you it's a load of bollocks and virtue-signalling.

It can be helpful if you have a first name that is ambiguous (eg Sam) or unusual and people won't know if you're a man or woman.

Quite. MN is infamously transphobic and ignorant, not to mention (see replies to this thread) goady and catastrophising on this subject It's a harmless piece of information and entirely at the individual's discretion.

sumosaussage · 15/09/2022 07:21

VestofAbsurdity · 14/09/2022 21:34

I'm not trans, so my role is to listen to trans people in respect of their experiences.

Ah the submissive female socialisation in full throttle.

Do you think only women care about listening to trans experiences?

The most tolerant people I know IRL and at work are all men

Who put their pronouns on their emails without all this drama and fuss

sumosaussage · 15/09/2022 07:20

So shocked the OP hadn't returned to this thread

Said no person ever

Good job winding up the rabid MN feminists and letting them go off on one

Hope you enjoyed the entertainment OP

bellinisurge · 15/09/2022 07:18

"transgender" is not a protected characteristic. Proposing to go through the legal process of getting a gender recognition certificate, getting a gender recognition certificate and having a gender recognition certificate is a protected characteristic. So is being a natal woman. So is believing that you can't change sex.

DdraigGoch · 14/09/2022 22:16

Notjusta · 14/09/2022 20:22

Sorry haven't RTFT but wanted to share that today I received an email from someone who had put his pronoun 'declaration' in rainbow colours - each word was a different colour. A real life 'professional' person and made their email look like something out of primary school!? Also their name was unambiguously male so it was completely unnecessary.

Too busy virtue signalling to consider people with disabilities. There are plenty of people with colour vision deficiency who would struggle to read that.

OldAndTubby · 14/09/2022 22:12

FrankTheThunderbird · 14/09/2022 20:28

I think if you feel the need to declare your pronouns because you are trans/NB/ have a unisex name, then go ahead.

If you feel you want to share your pronouns to support (whatever that means) the people listed above, then go ahead.

If you don't want/ feel you need to, then don't.

Add long as no one is being forced to share theirs. I mean, imagine you've got a trans/NB colleague who isn't out yet. By forcing them to share pronouns they've either got to 'out' themselves, or misgender themselves. Neither of which is very "kind" is it.

Agree 100%

VestofAbsurdity · 14/09/2022 21:49

bellac11 · 14/09/2022 20:26

And why is it that everyone else has to do something to make someone else feel comfortable about something 'they feel the need to do'

Its not my role to make someone feel comfortable for something they feel the need to do, how controlling is that?

Agree. However according to one poster that is their role with the implication it should be every other woman's role too - aim high eh?

bellac11 · 14/09/2022 21:42

Whatsnewpussyhat · 14/09/2022 21:26

The idea is that you’re showing people who might otherwise be worried to declare their gender preference that it is completely normal

Why would anyone need to declare their preference to a particular set of sex role stereotypes?

Only people who get upset at being correctly sexed need to declare their pronouns.

Absolutely, it completely reinforces 'Im a man', call me he - look how masculine and trousered I am
or

'Im a girlie', call me she - look at my lipsticks and skirts

See Eddie Izzard for more information

VestofAbsurdity · 14/09/2022 21:34

I'm not trans, so my role is to listen to trans people in respect of their experiences.

Ah the submissive female socialisation in full throttle.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 14/09/2022 21:26

The idea is that you’re showing people who might otherwise be worried to declare their gender preference that it is completely normal

Why would anyone need to declare their preference to a particular set of sex role stereotypes?

Only people who get upset at being correctly sexed need to declare their pronouns.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 14/09/2022 21:18

Its helpful if you have a unisex name so men know to treat you worse
www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/gender-inequality-man-woman-switch-names-week-martin-schneider-nicky-knacks-pay-gap-a7622201.html

And it helps males who want to invade female single sex spaces to feel all warm and cosy about it.

If neither of those things are high priorities for you, then probably leave them off.

Atmywitsend29 · 14/09/2022 21:11

I think it's utterly pointless and bred from compelled speech, much the same as certain nurses in certain hospitals having to have their pronouns on their name badges 😑
There are people at work who put their pronouns in their email signature. I roll my eyes every time.

It can be useful when the person has a name that could be male or female, however I don't see why they don't just use their title?

thecatsthecats · 14/09/2022 21:10

Pronouns are only used when you're talking about someone behind their back.

If I'm going to control what people are allowed to say about me behind my back, then pronouns is not where I'd start.

CecilyP · 14/09/2022 21:09

Provided of course that you (Sam/Alex etc.) actually care about people knowing whether you're a man or a woman. Leaving things ambiguous could work to your advantage, given how women are discriminated against:

I have this with my signature, though my email address is my full name. Hasn’t conferred any advantage, just the occasional, ‘I thought you were a man!’