Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not (yet) understand the purpose of pronouns in emails?

217 replies

Bobby80 · 14/09/2022 17:31

I'm aware this is a sensitive topic for some but I'm looking for some education on this. I didn't want to post in the gender issues boards as I thought I might come across as very ignorant and maybe I am! I also wanted a broad 'audience'.

Pronouns in emails- what's the purpose? Should I have my pronouns in my work email signature? We have no guidance on it at work so some people do and some don't. I don't feel the need personally to have a pronoun in mine but wouldn't want to offend others. Is the purpose of it for the send ie me or for the receiver or both? Is it really meaningful or a box ticking exercise?

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 15/09/2022 10:54

sumosaussage · 15/09/2022 07:47

@Stompythedinosaur

They'll deny that's transphobic you just wait and see

The comments made on here about trans people if they were made about anyone else (women, black people, Ukrainian women, children, the list goes on) the posts would be removed and the posters banned

But MNHQ has their view on this and it's very clear they're aligned with the nasty comments as long as they're only targeting trans people.

The fact you can get a ban for calling someone the K word but not for calling a trans woman a pervert or drag queens disgusting, or saying a man in a frock is indicative of this site

Actually your comparison of th trans issue to race is shameful. If a white person got dreadlocks and wore African dress and the called themselves a black person there would and has been, ourtage. Stop trying to obfuscate what is really going on. If you have an argument based on reality, make it.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 15/09/2022 10:51

Stompythedinosaur · 15/09/2022 07:41

Mn is well known for transphobia. It is sadly the only thing most people know about mn. Obviously there is more to mn than this, but it is certainly the most well known thing to people who don't use the site.

This post is clearly transphobic. Describing a transgender woman as "a man in a frock called Shirley" is really offensive.

Feel free to give a definition of woman which makes said man other than what I've described. I, and others, have been asking for that for years and TRAs have refused to provide it. Your assertion is that wearing stereotypically female clothing and adopting sya stereotypically female name changes something other than your dress and your name. Asking how is not transphobic. Assering that this makes you a woman is an act of aggression to women.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 15/09/2022 10:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It's not transphobe just because you say so. Your evidence is women making a stand for women's rights. Which is not evidence at all of anything other than misogyny. Of course those whose privilege is threatened by women not knowing their place insult it. That's how bullies work.

TeresaCrowd · 15/09/2022 10:43

People can't spell my name right in the body text when it is also the start of my e-mail that i've just read out to them down the phone and they've just typed into the To box, so what chance do they have of managing pronouns. I think people who add them to their signatures are a bit unnecessary to be honest, along with most other corporate bullshit that goes in e-mail signatures to be fair.

DaSilvaP · 15/09/2022 10:33

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 18:25

I'm a little tiny bit suspicious that you have come to mn, where there is an anti-trans thread slating the use of pronouns in email signatures on at least a weekly basis, rather than google this - if you have a statement to make then just say it.

Many people disagree with putting pronouns on signatures, but the purpose is to normalise checking someone's preferred way to be addressed rather than assuming this based on gender presentation. The idea being that if everyone declares their pronouns it becomes easier for transgender people to express theirs.

It costs me nothing to tell people I use the pronouns she/her. A group who are subject to discrimination say it helps them. So I do it.

Have you ever paused to consider the possibility that you are in fact spreading propaganda in favour of a tiny micro-minority that acts according to the principle "if I don't like reality, too bad for reality" and wants to impose that delusion on everyone else?
Ever heard of "the road to Hell being paved with good intentions"?

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2022 10:01

It all becomes total nonsense very quickly.

This practice is predicated on pretending that pronouns reference gender not sex. Which I have a huge issue with, but for the purposes of argument, I'll park for the minute.

Hopefully no one is arguing that you can actually change sex. So this is a gender issue.

However there are hundreds of different genders apparently and a whole toy chest of pronouns to mess around with if you're so inclined. Expecting people to remember that you're e/em/eir or whatever, does feel quite self absorbed.

I've been in the workplace for 20 years and never once had an issue with any of this. So quite aside from any role it might have in muddying the waters of sex/gender understanding, it strikes me as a massive waste of everyone's time.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 15/09/2022 09:49

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2022 09:38

The Canadian Green Party are providing us with a great cautionary tale about where all this can lead ultimately.

Worth a Google if you want to see how those leading the fight against climate change are actually spending their time.

omg that is just such an embarrassment. I just googled and found an article - some journalist commented it was ‘exactly like satire’ to which the person upset by the misgendering set up a fundraiser ‘against hate’. It’s raised less than $300 and a tenner of it was donated by the journal Grin

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 15/09/2022 09:44

Brefugee · 15/09/2022 09:35

I work with a lot of colleagues who are Indian, as I’m not Indian it’s not immediately obvious sometimes if the name is male or female.

I used to work with a lot of people from Korea, China, Japan and Vietnam. As i don't speak any of the languages, or have any clue about names, i generally wrote what i thought was correct and if they were bothered by it they corrected me.

The ones who were most bothered about being addressed correctly put (Ms, Mrs or Mr) in brackets after their name, and were addressed as such. As it turned out, even Korean colleagues can't always know either, based on just a name, so i didn't let it bother me overmuch if i got it wrong.

Yep yep, completely agree.

I have an obviously female name which was also the name of a senior lead in my area of the business. Except this person was a trans woman. This was a few years ago now, and before pronouns were compelled to be in email sigs. I’m 100% certain that this particular person wouldn’t have included pronouns in an email sig, because to them, it’s obvious from their name that they’re a woman so what’s the point?

Incidentally, a couple of times people thought I must be her. Which I didn’t take offence at, as they’d clearly never met either of us and had assumed I was a lot more senior than I was. Stand us side by side and you can tell who’s male or female regardless of name or pronoun.

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2022 09:38

The Canadian Green Party are providing us with a great cautionary tale about where all this can lead ultimately.

Worth a Google if you want to see how those leading the fight against climate change are actually spending their time.

Brefugee · 15/09/2022 09:35

I work with a lot of colleagues who are Indian, as I’m not Indian it’s not immediately obvious sometimes if the name is male or female.

I used to work with a lot of people from Korea, China, Japan and Vietnam. As i don't speak any of the languages, or have any clue about names, i generally wrote what i thought was correct and if they were bothered by it they corrected me.

The ones who were most bothered about being addressed correctly put (Ms, Mrs or Mr) in brackets after their name, and were addressed as such. As it turned out, even Korean colleagues can't always know either, based on just a name, so i didn't let it bother me overmuch if i got it wrong.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/09/2022 09:25

That would be because it costs men nothing, it's a piece of piss for them to virtue signal.

There was a good thread about how pronouns on emails makes people think you are somewhat weak and gullible or "kind" (depending on your perspective) if you are a woman but for men it comes across as a dominance display.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 15/09/2022 09:23

I work with a lot of colleagues who are Indian, as I’m not Indian it’s not immediately obvious sometimes if the name is male or female.

This has genuinely never once been an issue. I don’t need to use pronouns in an email to that person, it doesn’t matter what sex they are at all. If I have a meeting with them, then it obviously becomes clear.

I’ll tell you when it’s not helpful - when some one has she/her pronouns in their sig, you invite them to a meeting and a clearly male voice dials in. Who tf is this person in my meeting? Pre-Teams, my work conferencing software didn’t announce people and you could only use a phone to dial in so you’d get numbers not names. When you’re expecting ‘Ellie’ as the accountable exec and hear a deep bass tone answer it can be disorienting.

VestofAbsurdity · 15/09/2022 09:19

sumosaussage · 15/09/2022 07:21

Do you think only women care about listening to trans experiences?

The most tolerant people I know IRL and at work are all men

Who put their pronouns on their emails without all this drama and fuss

The most tolerant people I know IRL and at work are all men
Who put their pronouns on their emails without all this drama and fuss

That would be because it costs men nothing, it's a piece of piss for them to virtue signal. It's not the language men use to describe themselves that is being enforced, not their single sex spaces, services, sports, etc., that are being threatened.

If the men you refer to were truly tolerant they would welcome gender non conforming men into all their spaces, services, sports, etc., and celebrate them as part of the rich diversity of the male sex.

thankyouforthesun · 15/09/2022 09:17

I used to work for someone called Denny who put her title in her signature. Otherwise she signed off as Denny Surname and when people wrote back to Title Surname they didn't know if she was a man or woman so she was often referred to as Mr Surname. If she'd been called Jane or Henrietta she wouldn't have had that problem.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/09/2022 09:13

The Equalities Act notes being transgender as a protected characteristic. I'm not aware of it offering any protection to people who don't believe in gender identity, though I'm happy to learn about this if I am wrong.

You are wrong, as you are wrong about the name of the Equality Act (not "Equalities") and the protected characteristic. It is "gender reassignment". After a high profile court case brought by Maya Forstater, it was confirmed in the court of Appeal that gender critical beliefs were protected under the "religion/belief" PC. It is illegal to discriminate against someone simply for disbelief in gender identity ideology.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/09/2022 09:08

If I see it in someone's email, I assume either narcissist, drone or bullied. Either way it's not a good look.

This. Glad I'm not in a physical office any more as I can't help but roll my eyes.

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 15/09/2022 09:07

I've had a couple of people email me at work (internally) with pronouns. It's a different department and they're not company compulsory but when I see them my first thought is usually they've had some sort of training and think they're being kind.

I would not, it's not being kind in my opinion, it's giving gravitas to the belief of gender ideology which I don't believe in.

If you have a unisex name as a female, there have been studies on this, if you highlighted yourself as female you'll get treated differently. Bad differently. Yes, it shouldn't be the case, but that's reality. So why would you? You're a grown up, an odd misgendering shouldn't matter. Unlike the he/she/they/zir/fae etc believers who descend into toddler tantrums, issue threats of discrimination and insists the offender gets sent off for re-education.

And if you think about it further, if there is a he/she/they/zir/fae believer (and they can believe what they want, they just can't insist I do and must show it) who isn't ready to announce a pronoun, you announcing yours in solidarity makes them feel they have to too, or lie, which could make them feel quite bad.

If you're a fervent believer, they'll be all over your email, every introduction you make, and you're probably going to try and get the team attending compulsory training anyway. Everyone will be well aware what your pronouns are. If you want to be kind, you crack on. Just leave me out of it please, and it'll be fine.

Whatsthepointofmosquitos · 15/09/2022 09:00

It’s a statement of allegiance to the ideology that believes physically male people should have access to female spaces whenever they want and females should just put up with it despite the safeguarding implications, problems for muslim women etc.

It’s a statement that you don’t think for yourself and allow others to tell you what to do.

It’s an attempt to lower the debate to “the righteous against the bigots” instead if having a rational discussion about it all.

Delabruche · 15/09/2022 08:47

user1471517900 · 14/09/2022 17:45

I definitely think THIS will be the thread that changes minds and sorts the whole thing out.

The previous 294784895 didn't do it, but I feel good about this one.

😂

I don't feel the need personally to have a pronoun in mine
So don't do it. People will be offended/oblivious/judgemental either way so you may as well do what is best for you.

StanleyStanleyStanley · 15/09/2022 08:46

JustAWeirdoWithNoName · 15/09/2022 08:06

My friend is transgender and puts her pronouns in her email signature as she is still part-way through her transition so doesn't feel she looks fully "feminine" yet. She said she likes that a lot of people also do this now whether they are cisgender, non-binary etc because it means that her displaying her pronouns doesn't automatically out her as trans.

Also as someone who works with a lot of people from different countries with names I've never heard of and don't know the gendering of, I find it very useful to know their pronouns!

It’s interesting you mentioned your friend. I have a trans woman friend (though she considers herself transsexual, not ‘transgendered’). She’s actually really offended by pronouns and absolutely hates being asked. Her thought is that she’s gone to the effort of looking feminine, changed her name to a feminine one that her pronouns should be assumed like every natal woman.

Trans people aren’t a hive mind either and I wonder if you consider other voices from the community or just the loudest?

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 15/09/2022 08:43

FlissyPaps · 14/09/2022 18:51

Yes it does. I have a name that can have a masculine ending and a feminine ending. E.g: George/Georgia Alexander/Alexandra Daniel/Danielle Paul/Paula

My feminine name is clearly spelt in my email signature and I still get regretted to as a “he” “sir” “Daniel/Paul” multiple times a week. It’s annoying.

That just shows people don't pay attention or read signatures. Putting your pronouns in an email signature won't cause someone who sees "Alexandra" and writes "Alexander" or "Alexandria" to change.

I must receive an email everyday where someone has used a similar but incorrect name for me despite my name being fully spelled out in my email address and email signature. Those similar names are all female in my case because there is no common male name that is similar but it is the same problem with Georgia/George/Georgina/Georgie/Georgiana.

bellinisurge · 15/09/2022 08:43

"Also as someone who works with a lot of people from different countries with names I've never heard of and don't know the gendering of, I find it very useful to know their pronouns!"

You realise that obliging people to say stuff isn't good.
I hope your friend has a comfortable transition and if I accidentally misgender them when I meet them, I apologise. I am not committing an act of literal violence by doing so. And telling me I am will make me think they are not a serious person.

Brefugee · 15/09/2022 08:16

She said she likes that a lot of people also do this now whether they are cisgender, non-binary etc because it means that her displaying her pronouns doesn't automatically out her as trans.

i would be very happy to refer to your trans friend as she, if that is her desire. I would be pointing out, howerver, every single occasion where upon discovering that i am not a male engineer as expected but a female and then expected to:
refer a problem to "my boss"
make the tea
take the notes
collect for someone's birthday
suddenly started communicating with my much younger male subordinate
etc ad infinitum

and then ask why she thinks i should leave myself wide open to that happening over and over. Yes, she would be more comfortable and i appreciate that. But making her comfortable puts me at a disadvantage. Why should she, newly female, get to undo all my hard work striving to head that off at the past (I've described how i do that on various posts over the years). So in that case I'd politely decline. And i would hope that would be it.

Brefugee · 15/09/2022 08:12

I don't get why you'd ask this on Mumsnet, you know the answers you're going to get here!

Well there are a wide range of answers so stick that in your pipe and smoke it.

The whole Terfnet from outside makes me laugh when i regularly see on twitter things about "sucking my lady dick death to terfs" and when it is called out as misogynistic it is dismissed as only words. But we have all seen the "literal violence" references to being misgendered by accident.

So here's the thing. I'm not a Terf. I literally want the entire universe to live their best lives without harming others. I'm quite the fan of Jeremy Bentham also, so i also belive that if you can improve the lives, even marginally, of the majority, you should be doing that.

I also believe that a society can be judged on how it treats the weakest in that society and we should treat minorities with dignity and respect.

None of that is incompatible with being a staunch feminist, a trans ally and a supporter of women's rights (including their right to sex-based services where wanted/required)

my reading of MN has shown me that outside FWR any anti-trans posts are likely to be zapped. And even on FWR they are treading a fine line (that i have, as yet, failed to identify). I watch aghast as statistics are manipulated - and how the old adage of unifying against a common enemy (who is causing most of the VAWG and transwomen and transmen? who?) has fallen by the wayside in favour of groups of people shouting (on occasion vile slurs) against other groups of people.

But one thing that is guaranteed to make me roll my eyes. "what? we don't use pronouns to talk to the person when they are present" (assuming you mean 3rd person prononuns, because you almost certainly do use pronouns). It isn't about "PRONOUNS" it is about being open about your gender identity. And/or sex. And not everyone is comfortable doing that for various reasons that are not related to anyone else. That should also be respected.

tigger1001 · 15/09/2022 08:11

"Ok, so me choosing to use pronouns might harm me, but how does it harm others?"

Turn this around - how does including your pronouns help others?

Either it's helpful to one group, but then we do have to acknowledge that it is at the expense of another, or it's not helpful at all.