Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not (yet) understand the purpose of pronouns in emails?

217 replies

Bobby80 · 14/09/2022 17:31

I'm aware this is a sensitive topic for some but I'm looking for some education on this. I didn't want to post in the gender issues boards as I thought I might come across as very ignorant and maybe I am! I also wanted a broad 'audience'.

Pronouns in emails- what's the purpose? Should I have my pronouns in my work email signature? We have no guidance on it at work so some people do and some don't. I don't feel the need personally to have a pronoun in mine but wouldn't want to offend others. Is the purpose of it for the send ie me or for the receiver or both? Is it really meaningful or a box ticking exercise?

OP posts:
stayinghometoday · 15/09/2022 13:08

I don't state my pronouns. Besides, people can't even reply to an email which clearly spells my name without misspelling it. I doubt that they'd check my pronoun. I'm also not offended if they get my pronoun wrong.

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/09/2022 13:07

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 15/09/2022 13:00

I have a name that can be male or female. It helps prevent the idiots who like to argue whether I am male or female.
I also had a close colleague who is a trans man. It helped support him.
I had contact with around 100 people a week. A good amount of the time I couldn't tell from their name whether they were male or female. I would often have reason to mention them in other communications. Knowing their pronoun helps with this. I can't remember hundreds of peoples pronouns, but I can quickly check an email.

How does it help though. Communication can only take place of everyone is aware of the meanings of the words. If sone are working from the basis that pronouns are sex based and some are working from the basis they are gender based then people are working from different pages.

You could refer to Sam as him but the email couod go to someone who knows Sam and knows they are female so how does it remotely help.

If you had to go to the fifth floor to hand deliver a letter to Sam he/him from accounting you would still l quite possibly have no idea if you were looking fir a man ir a woman.

Renders the whole thing pointless.

I have a unisex name too. I dont care if people think I'm a bloke. Why wouod it matter to me.

FKATondelayo · 15/09/2022 13:04

MagpiePi · 15/09/2022 13:00

I wish I could send an annonymous link of this thread to one of the associate directors where I work who is a man (I used to work i the same office, so I know he is a man) with a traditional man's name but feels the need to put he/him in his email signature.

Cringe

My DC's headteacher literally has 'Mr.' in his email address and yet still puts he/him in his sign off.

He/him wasn't very happy when I sent him the Sex Matters schools document.

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 15/09/2022 13:03

Oh, and I am a very inclusive feminist. I await the childish MN name calling.

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 15/09/2022 13:00

I have a name that can be male or female. It helps prevent the idiots who like to argue whether I am male or female.
I also had a close colleague who is a trans man. It helped support him.
I had contact with around 100 people a week. A good amount of the time I couldn't tell from their name whether they were male or female. I would often have reason to mention them in other communications. Knowing their pronoun helps with this. I can't remember hundreds of peoples pronouns, but I can quickly check an email.

MagpiePi · 15/09/2022 13:00

I wish I could send an annonymous link of this thread to one of the associate directors where I work who is a man (I used to work i the same office, so I know he is a man) with a traditional man's name but feels the need to put he/him in his email signature.

Cringe

YouSetTheTone · 15/09/2022 12:56

Using pronouns is basically the same as putting a little gif of a Stonewall trans/ pride flag in your email. It shows credence to gender ideology and signals that the emailer doesn’t care about the drive to make women’s prisons/ sports/ rape crisis centres/ single sex spaces mixed sex. It signals the emailer doesn’t think women should have boundaries and suggests they lack critical thinking skills.

I have, over the course of my career, encountered many colleagues etc who have unisex names. I can’t think of any occasion where I actually needed to know for sure what their sex was when communicating re our work.

Usually only difference between male Sam and female Sam in a professional environment is that male Sam inexplicably gets paid more.

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2022 12:54

To even suggest such a word is meaningful and needed by the approximately half of the population that is, well, female-bodied is apparently an act of despicable hate. I wonder why that should be?

Its a great puzzlement alright

DadOnIce · 15/09/2022 12:49

The well-known story of the two workers in Philadelphia, Martin and Nicole, who (accidentally at first and then deliberately as an experiment) swapped email identities a few years ago is very instructive, as I think it is used by pronoun zealots to support their case. And yet it shows the very opposite of what they're trying to point out.

As soon as people thought they were dealing with a woman, they behaved differently -- more obstructively and more patronisingly. For a lot of women, it is positively disadvantageous in non-face-to-face work interactions to reveal their sex if they don't have to.

And if by chance this is the first time you've ever heard this story, you automatically know Martin is the fella and Nicole is the woman, without my having to tell you.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 15/09/2022 12:32

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2022 12:22

Surely another term could have been created

oh don't worry they've created lots of terms 😉

Yet weirdly not one that sinply means "female bodied". To even suggest such a word is meaningful and needed by the approximately half of the population that is, well, female-bodied is apparently an act of despicable hate. I wonder why that should be?

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2022 12:22

Surely another term could have been created

oh don't worry they've created lots of terms 😉

Marvellousmadness · 15/09/2022 12:20

Oh hell no

If people WANT TO they should
Dont force allothers to follow suit just because of wokeness.

My name is "bella"
People would know i am a she /her

If i wanted people to think I was an it
I would add 'they/them' to my email

Whilst on the topic
Who on earth came up with They Them. Jezus. Surely another term could have been created....

FlirtsWithRhinos · 15/09/2022 11:37

Stompythedinosaur · 14/09/2022 18:40

How is me adding pronouns to my email signature harming you?

I have a lived experience of being a woman so am better positioned to have a view about whether this is harmful to women. I'm not trans, so my role is to listen to trans people in respect of their experiences.

Hi @Stompythedinosaur

I can't speak for the poster you replied to but for myself:

When people add pronouns to "support trans people" they are supporting the belief that the difference between men and women is mental rather than physical, and therefore they are supporting the reallocation of resources set up to help the female-bodied thrive in a sexist society from those female-bodied people to those with a "female mind", whatever that is, and the undefining of female-bodied people as a social group with their own rights, concerns, priorities deserving of a political voice.

As a female-bodied person, it harms me to lose those resources and that political voice, an it harms me to be redefined as a person with a female mind when that is not something I identify as, simply because the words I have always used, and society has always used, for the female bodied have been redefined without my consent.

I am very happy to listen to trans people with respect to their experiences, so I know trans people do not speak with one voice. I find it sad and strange that the people who wish to appropriate female words and spaces do not feel any need to respect my needs and experience, and that of the many, many women like me.

I hope you realise that I am not telling you whether to put pronouns in your email or not. That is up to you. I am simply making sure you are clear that it is harmful to people like me who understand ourselves to be female but do not have this "female brain". What you do with that knowledge is up to you.

HTH.

QuinkWashable · 15/09/2022 11:29

but on mumsnet saying you don’t think pronouns are that big of a deal marks you out as a enemy to your sex or some shit. If you aren’t frothing at the mouth at the very idea you aren’t doing it right

I think you missed the memo - we're old and baffled by modern ways now, not frothing and angry

Or perhaps I'm out of date and we've moved back again - I've seen some ridiculous stuff about how violent and dangerous us middle aged women are about various issues recently

0live · 15/09/2022 11:19

yetanotherusernameAgain · 14/09/2022 17:38

You might as well have posted on the Feminism boards because you're going to get the same people telling you it's a load of bollocks and virtue-signalling.

It can be helpful if you have a first name that is ambiguous (eg Sam) or unusual and people won't know if you're a man or woman.

I have a first name which is unisex. People who only deal with me by email often don’t know what sex I am and in the early days of my career they always assumed that I was a man.

It didn’t bother me as they always treated me better when they thought I was male.

Even now, women are disadvantaged in the workplace when they are compelled to disclose their sex. Many senior women use their initials to avoid this eg Dr J S Smith.

bellinisurge · 15/09/2022 11:17

If you think speaking up about the erosion of language about women and the erosion of single sex protections is anti-trans, then you are admitting there is a clash of rights. Which means we should talk about it.

To coin a phrase, the people with the power are the people you aren't allowed to challenge.

JustAWeirdoWithNoName · 15/09/2022 11:16

StanleyStanleyStanley · 15/09/2022 08:46

It’s interesting you mentioned your friend. I have a trans woman friend (though she considers herself transsexual, not ‘transgendered’). She’s actually really offended by pronouns and absolutely hates being asked. Her thought is that she’s gone to the effort of looking feminine, changed her name to a feminine one that her pronouns should be assumed like every natal woman.

Trans people aren’t a hive mind either and I wonder if you consider other voices from the community or just the loudest?

Wow I can't believe the responses I'm getting on this. I never said in my post that my friend speaks for all trans people - I was just giving one viewpoint.
I also never said that she thinks EVERYONE should do it - just that she likes it when people does as she feels more comfortable sharing her own pronouns.

I completely understand why some people (particularly women in male-dominated industries) prefer not to advertise that their gender.

I was simply trying to give a viewpoint from someone who is quietly trying to live their life as a transwoman in order to give an alternative viewpoint in the GC echo chamber - not all transwoman are militant TRAs just like not all GC people are militant TERFs.

midgetastic · 15/09/2022 11:15

PassMeASpork · 15/09/2022 11:10

I also think they're another Woke addition, however there is ONE valid "email" scenario where I can see they may be handy.

If I'm replying to an email and copying in someone else ("Lucy", for example), then I might say something like "when I spoke to Lucy the other day, she said"...

Yes, the sentence structure could change ("Lucy said xxxxxxx when we spoke the other day"), but it just doesn't feel "natural".

I guess a pronoun might help in that case...

You could say "they said "

You could assume she wouldn't actually care if you accidentally got it wrong

Lots of alternatives

Brefugee · 15/09/2022 11:15

It costs me nothing to tell people I use the pronouns she/her. A group who are subject to discrimination say it helps them. So I do it.

But what if another group says it contributes to discrimination against them? And ask you not to? And that group have historically - since time immemorial been discriminated against. And are paid less, and have a harder time getting promotion and are mitigating against some of that by appearing to be "not women" in their emails?

It is fine to put pronouns in mails, especially if you are forced to. (not that it is ok to force people to do this) but it is equally fine not to.

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/09/2022 11:13

I dont go to work to be a prop in someone's game. Someone's gender identity is theirs and theirs alone I am under no obligation to believe it or play along with it. Anyone who sends an email with pronouns is reducing me to nothing but a collection of feelings inside someone's head. Its offensive. I automatically think." knobhead" when I see it.

PassMeASpork · 15/09/2022 11:10

I also think they're another Woke addition, however there is ONE valid "email" scenario where I can see they may be handy.

If I'm replying to an email and copying in someone else ("Lucy", for example), then I might say something like "when I spoke to Lucy the other day, she said"...

Yes, the sentence structure could change ("Lucy said xxxxxxx when we spoke the other day"), but it just doesn't feel "natural".

I guess a pronoun might help in that case...

SouthernFashionista · 15/09/2022 11:08

Absolutely bloody ridiculous. Over my dead body will I do it.

YouHaveAnArse · 15/09/2022 11:07

If you want to, then yes.

I have a name that's not obviously feminine if you aren't a native English speaker. I have a colleague who has a name from another culture that is more commonly a woman's name in the UK. Aside from anything to do with trans issues, it's useful then.

PeloFondo · 15/09/2022 11:04

At this point I'm just happy if people get my name right. I have a name that is the feminine version, there is a masculine version (samuel, Samantha type)
The past 4 years I have never been called samuel so much in my life
I'll go for an appointment and they'll shout "Miss Samuel Pelo" and I'm Confused "the clue is on the fuckin paper in front of you"
My name is not samuel Angry and I would put pronouns if it helps but miss/Mrs doesn't so...

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2022 10:55

Because it's one of the few sites that allow some people to say the shit they want about trans people with impunity

Mumsnet says very little about Transpeople actually.

But a lot about the importance of preserving sex specific spaces for women who need them. I have to wonder why that wouldn't be important to you?