Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone can advise my DS on the best ways into journalism/how to become a journalist?

64 replies

Soulshinesbright · 14/09/2022 17:09

He’s 18 and looking to get into Journalism/become a journalist but he’s just not sure how to and what is best to do at university to help with this? What’s the best routes into journalism? Is anyone here a journalist and would be willing to answer some questions he has? Thank you to everyone in advance

OP posts:
WolverineBluey · 14/09/2022 21:31

Have an NCTJ qualification, as the NUJ are still a relatively closed shop

What do you mean? The NUJ is the union - anyone can join that but it won't help you get a job.

GoldenSpiral · 14/09/2022 21:29

A friend of mine has been a deputy travel editor for two national papers. He has a BA in history and a masters in journalism.

I worked in PR and I would agree with others that have said it is low paid work and that print journalism is dying out. A lot of journalists end up moving on to PR/marketing after a while due to the low pay and diminishing roles.

That being said, my friend has had a fabulous time travelling around the world for a good while now!

MrsAvocet · 14/09/2022 21:27

I've got a relative who is a reasonably successful freelance journalist - you've almost certainly read her work in big newspapers and magazines even if you wouldn't recognise her name.
She started doing work experience in local papers, various obscure magazines etc from about the age of 14. If I recall rightly her first published article was in an industry magazine about farm machinery! Basically she knocked on a lot of doors, repeatedly, and spent every school and university holiday at any publication who would have her. (As well as being vety involved in student magazines and radio.)There was a lot of coffee making and photocopying of course but it paid off and she did get credited on news reports in a major broadsheet when she was still at school. We don't have any journalists or writers in the family so no contacts which did make it harder bit she was very, very persistent. Probably a personality trait that is valued in the field I suppose!
She got good a good degree in English from an RG University and then did a Masters in Journalism in London, but I think the work experience, contacts built up and a great deal of resilience probably helped as much as the qualifications. She had some lean times at the beginning and it took years and a lot of persistence to establish herself in what is now her field of expertise. It's definitely not an easy job. I think her advice would be to start knocking on doors now, both to increase the chances of success and for your DS to learn more about the reality of the industry.

whatwouldAnnaDelveydo · 14/09/2022 21:20

Are you very rich? Journalism as a hobby, fine. If your DS plans to have a family as a journalist, that will be hard.

I used to be a science journalist. I'm early 40s and nearly all my journalist friends are working on other things. Press officers, content writers, social media managers, some are screenwriters, or enterpreneurs. There's not much to do in journalism if you want to be paid as an adult. (It's fun when you're 20 though)

In science journalism, most people in the UK studied science and then did a masters in science communication. I suggest your DS study that interests him (whatever it is) and then think about journalism later.

By the way, I think it's a shame. My skills from years of journalism are very helpful in many different jobs, but I wouldn't suggest working on this area for over 10 years to gain those skills (unless you are very rich and don't really need a career to pay the bills)

Hermione101 · 14/09/2022 21:19

Journalist here. I would dissuade him from travel journalism, there’s no money in it and it’s not a career path. He needs to get a good degree in something not journalism related (economics, history, political science). Most of our graduate hires were from oxbridge. He can also look at City University London for undergrad/graduate school to study journalism (excellent networking and opportunities right out of school).

While in school he’ll need to write for the school paper and intern. All the major broadsheets/broadcasters/magazines have internships.

If you can, I would steer him towards financial journalism (again look at City University), he can have a decent career and there are plenty of job opportunities in London. It’s much easier to have a flexible career with choice with a good degree and a level of expertise.

I wouldn’t say it’s a dying industry, I spent more than a decade at a financial broadsheet, but it is pressured and constantly changing. He’ll need a good level of stamina to compete, it’s a career that takes years to develop.

nadjasknee · 14/09/2022 21:10

I am a producer, but have worked as a reporter in the past. No family connections, just slog. I worked for free in school holidays for anyone who would give me a couple of weeks work experience. Solid degree(think history/politics) and postgrad in journalism. Both BBC and ITV have fantastic trainee programmes, so look out for them. I can't emphasise enough how important bylines and experience are when it comes to showing potential employers you are serious about the profession. FWIW I have worked for a large company for more than 20 years and earn nowhere near £150k, but it's a decent enough living if you work your way up through a good company. Best of luck!!!!

Puffykins · 14/09/2022 21:09

I'm not scraping along, I'm comfortable-ish, but I can't afford to privately educate my DCs.

But I do genuinely love what I do - which is quite significant compensation for the lack of riches. And I can afford music lessons, riding lessons etc.

TheKeatingFive · 14/09/2022 21:04

Anyone I know who stuck it out as a journo is scraping along on a pittance. It's very poorly paid these days. So my initial advice is don't do it.

Communications roles in organisations are much better paid.

Luredbyapomegranate · 14/09/2022 21:03

GemmaEdKitten · 14/09/2022 20:57

These salaries are way off

These salaries are unusual

Luredbyapomegranate · 14/09/2022 21:02

Solid academic degree from a good uni. Some post grad journalism courses (eg City University in London) have a good rep, but avoid at undergrad.

Get lots of work experience - student papers, placements in the summer - as you go.

Be aware that journalism jobs have really shrunk (I think more than halved) in the last 20 years because of so much free content and magazines folding.

There will always be news work but it’s Competitive with a capital C, and it’s also worth checking out what specialisms are buoyant (science and tech might be - dunno)

Think flexibly - there is more work in video content, and it’s mostly better paid, so learning to shoot and edit is a great idea if he leans that way.

Am not a journalist, but work with them in a media setting.

GemmaEdKitten · 14/09/2022 20:57

Curioushorse · 14/09/2022 17:27

I think the key question is what sort of journalist? If he's talking print, then for the national papers he needs to do a solid degree and then gain experience. This can be done at university by working for the university papers. But it's all experience based. Most people in print journalism I know did internships, and then got other jobs (hence the 'good degree'). I know one who was teaching and one an archivist. They wrote freelance on the side. It was a slog, but they're both now senior journalists for different papers, and after 20 years, they're both earning very good salaries (£150,000+). There is an expectation that they will both work full time, at awkward hours, and also get books published. This needs to happen to keep their names out there.

Contrary to popular opinion, neither of them had connections on papers, and were from middle class families. Internships were very short, so not expected to work for free for longer than a fortnight.

I think most of their work friends went to Oxford or Cambridge too.

These salaries are way off

UWhatNow · 14/09/2022 20:57

I think the first rule of getting into journalism is to do your own research of how to get into journalism!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 14/09/2022 20:54

And to scotch all the myths on here.

Ds did not work hard at A level
He didn’t go to Oxford or Cambridge
He’s dyslexic.

But he still did it. It’s not about any of those things. It’s about doing the right MA. They all got jobs.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 14/09/2022 20:48

My ds is a journalist at ITN.

He did a history degree at a not very good uni. He spent that time building up a student newspaper, including interviewing some local mp’s and local issues of interest.

He then did an MA in Digital Jounslism at Sheffield uni. I think Cardiff, UcL and Sheffield are the only courses credited by the NUJ. Anyway they are the top best 3 courses.

He did placements at big newspapers, and ended up freelancing. He’s busy every day.

It’s how he shows an interest in journalism that will get him on a course. So he needs to get involved with the local student newspaper and build up the readership.

Puffykins · 14/09/2022 20:48

Travel journalism is not dead. But it's true the competition is hot so you need to be very, very good. And have a point of view. And while yes, people can be taught to write for the political and news pieces etc. in a newspaper, travel comes under features, and you need to be able to write well.

Mailista · 14/09/2022 20:45

You don't need to be a genius to work out my job. I did a degree in English, and have no journalistic qualifications at all. However, I can write - and if you keep badgering the kinds of publications you want to write for, someone will spot you if you are good enough. That's my experience, anyway.

KosherDill · 14/09/2022 20:45

A) Consider if you really, truly want a poorly paid career in a dying industry. Sure it's fun the first couple of years but after a couple decades of slog, unless you become one of the highest echelon and make decent money and/or get to travel the world, it all starts to seem rather pointless.

B) if the answer is still yes, develop an expertise in a non-journalism field, be that health care, economics, motorsports, politics, etc. And I mean real expertise, as in, get a nursing degree or work for a racing team or work for an MP or be a banker or solicitor or a priest or educator or whatnot -- so that in future you'll know what you're talking about when you cover the beat.

THEN study journalism, and work on networking with editors and publications and broadcasting arms. A degree is not as necessary as connections and an authoritative take on your subject. Be an expert, thn a journalist. As my former editor used to say, "We can teach people to write; what we need is knowledge and expertise."

tinselandlights · 14/09/2022 20:44

Firstly, he needs to get a little bit more get-up-and-go than to have his mum do his research for him! But I'm sure you're just idly wondering how to help him.

I used to be a journalist (and am now a novelist). My route was that I went to a good university which is well known for turning out loads of BBC journalists and having an excellent student newspaper. There I wrote as much as I could and made contacts. This was in the late 00s.

In the university holidays I'd do work experience on local papers, for magazines and for anyone who would have me. When I temped I tried to work for newspapers/magazines/creative places to get paid yet have them on my CV - even if just telemarketing for then. There were a surprising number of jobs doing that.

Then I did an NCTJ in print journalism - the 18 week course actually has the highest pass rate as it's so intense, then I got a job straight from graduating. I already had bylines from half a dozen places then so it made starting out much easier.

I had no contacts at the start but he just has to make friends and connections. It's an industry built on who you know, so he has to get himself out there and get on people's radar. It's not well paid but it's fun, exciting and varied. I met my DH, made many best friends and had some brilliant times as a journalist.

DuckTails · 14/09/2022 20:44

Travel journalism is absolutely dead.

Best ways in are an arts degree from Oxford (English/history/PPE) or work a bit for a local paper (those that haven’t shuttered yet) and then move to a tabloid (they’re an incredible training ground) and from there go anywhere. Alternatively he could try a trade magazine (eg industry mags about law, medicine, advertising) and that’s quite a good way in.

Some papers do offer training but I imagine it’s incredibly competitive, badly paid and in London.

I would suggest looking into court journalism - it’s specialised, fascinating and excellent training. But shorthand is necessary for that.

DucklingDaisy · 14/09/2022 20:43

My husband is a national newspaper reporter, I used to work in TV and my advice is: it’s a dying industry and encourage him to consider other options.

Other than that:

  • degree in a traditional academic subject at the best university he can get into
  • try and gain work experience as a student, work on his student newspaper, possibly place a few freelance pieces
  • journalism masters at City, University of London - this is pretty much the gold standard and will really help him make connections, gain relevant experience and so on
  • try and get on a grad scheme or freelance (shift work and placing individual pieces) while applying for entry level jobs
BlackForestCake · 14/09/2022 20:38

Everyone likes travelling and eating so there are millions of wannabe travel journalists and food writers.

But can you write about local government, tax reform, washing machines, climate change, dog breeding, rugby, supply chains, latest news in the world of plumbing, new developments in dentistry? Those areas of life all have people who need or want to read about them and someone has to write the stories.

Journalism isn't writing what you want to write. It's writing what someone else wants you to write, and doing it very fast.

Puffykins · 14/09/2022 20:36

Okay - finally.... I know nothing about video editing, Tik Tok, etc, etc. - but I'm probably the last generation to have the luxury of not having to know about it. The art departments of the magazines I write for are getting training in all the bells and whistles of social media.

Puffykins · 14/09/2022 20:30

Oh - and there are people who think they want to be a travel journalist because they want to travel, or a food writer because they want to go nice restaurants. This may well not be your son at all - but crucial is to want to write and to love writing. I love writing as much as I love art. I kept a diary from the age of 10 - which I now realise was an excellent means of finding my style.

Puffykins · 14/09/2022 20:25

I am a journalist - specifically an arts journalist, writing for broadsheets and monthly magazines (good ones - the type people keep back issues of.)

I read History of Art at university, which taught me both how to think critically (which is vital) and gave me the references for much of what I write about now.

I wrote for the university paper. I did internships. I started at the bottom, writing literally anything I could for anyone (mostly they wanted me to write about fashion, then) and writing a blog on the side about what I actually wanted to write about.

I got there, eventually. I LOVE my job. At times it's still exhaustingly full on.

What I would say is that you son needs to be reading the publications he wants to write for, and he should be reading all the travel writing he can find - from Goethe's Italian Journey, through Hemmingway, Sybille Bedford etc., to the incomparable AA Gill, to now.

threegoodthings · 14/09/2022 20:02

I used to volunteer for hospital radio and quite a few have gone into broadcast journalism - both radio and TV.