Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone can advise my DS on the best ways into journalism/how to become a journalist?

64 replies

Soulshinesbright · 14/09/2022 17:09

He’s 18 and looking to get into Journalism/become a journalist but he’s just not sure how to and what is best to do at university to help with this? What’s the best routes into journalism? Is anyone here a journalist and would be willing to answer some questions he has? Thank you to everyone in advance

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ExHack · 17/09/2022 14:01

PinkHeadphones · 15/09/2022 16:35

About what to study at university - I don't think it matters really. I did English literature, like many journalists, and it helped in the sense that it taught me to extract information very quickly from large amounts of text, but so would most degrees. I think if you have an "extra" bit of knowledge as a journalist - science, maths, history, politics - that can only be a good thing. I did a three month postgrad journalism course. I also was involved in the university newspaper, did work experience on the local paper and wrote music reviews for magazines while at uni.

Potential journalists often don't consider trade journalism - the kinds of magazines that are mocked on Have I Got News For you - but they can be good training grounds, you get a lot of responsibility very quickly and often a lot of travel. There are trade travel magazines/ outlets, focusing on business travel, conferences etc. I used to sit next to one, and the reporters were always jetting off to stay in lovely hotels and write about them.

PPs are correct about the salary though. I am still a journalist because I like it, but earn about a fourth of the salary of most of my university friends.

That is a good point — and the trade magazines also pay very well, or at least they did in my day! Some of them are subscription-only so they have a guaranteed revenue unlike the newsstand mags.

SmugglersHaunt · 15/09/2022 18:23

I would encourage him to do a blog, a vlog or anything else that will get him out there and will show any potential recruiter that he’s already doing stuff. Also contact Press Association as they do a training course and are pretty much the gold standard. And work experience is always good

toffeechai · 15/09/2022 18:20

PinkHeadphones · 15/09/2022 16:35

About what to study at university - I don't think it matters really. I did English literature, like many journalists, and it helped in the sense that it taught me to extract information very quickly from large amounts of text, but so would most degrees. I think if you have an "extra" bit of knowledge as a journalist - science, maths, history, politics - that can only be a good thing. I did a three month postgrad journalism course. I also was involved in the university newspaper, did work experience on the local paper and wrote music reviews for magazines while at uni.

Potential journalists often don't consider trade journalism - the kinds of magazines that are mocked on Have I Got News For you - but they can be good training grounds, you get a lot of responsibility very quickly and often a lot of travel. There are trade travel magazines/ outlets, focusing on business travel, conferences etc. I used to sit next to one, and the reporters were always jetting off to stay in lovely hotels and write about them.

PPs are correct about the salary though. I am still a journalist because I like it, but earn about a fourth of the salary of most of my university friends.

I honestly hugely regret going into journalism, partly because it meant years of terrible pay. I think you’d be hard pushed to find anyone who’d recommend it as a career these days.

PinkHeadphones · 15/09/2022 16:35

About what to study at university - I don't think it matters really. I did English literature, like many journalists, and it helped in the sense that it taught me to extract information very quickly from large amounts of text, but so would most degrees. I think if you have an "extra" bit of knowledge as a journalist - science, maths, history, politics - that can only be a good thing. I did a three month postgrad journalism course. I also was involved in the university newspaper, did work experience on the local paper and wrote music reviews for magazines while at uni.

Potential journalists often don't consider trade journalism - the kinds of magazines that are mocked on Have I Got News For you - but they can be good training grounds, you get a lot of responsibility very quickly and often a lot of travel. There are trade travel magazines/ outlets, focusing on business travel, conferences etc. I used to sit next to one, and the reporters were always jetting off to stay in lovely hotels and write about them.

PPs are correct about the salary though. I am still a journalist because I like it, but earn about a fourth of the salary of most of my university friends.

SeptemberPumpkin · 15/09/2022 16:26

Your son really does need to do his own research and it's a not a good sign that you're doing it for him. Many journalists have to come up with their own ideas or at least research the story they've been told to write about-whether that's a company that's just won an award, a celebrity or someone whispering to horses.
He will also have to write quickly and not be precious when some one tells him to cut it in half. It is very competitive, despite the pay not being great.

ExHack · 15/09/2022 13:03

toffeechai · 15/09/2022 09:33

Ex-journalist here wanting to offer a bit of advice I’ve not seen on the thread yet: he needs to read as well as write. He needs to be able to talk about publications and writers that interest him. I remember I’d meet a lot of wannabe journalists who were not interested in reading others’ work and learning from them and it was an issue (eg in interviews)

One of my best journalism teachers (Goldsmiths College) used to say "the writing's just the bit you do at the end".

drspouse · 15/09/2022 09:46

I am not a journalist but as a student I wrote for the Uni newspaper (mainly arts but also really interesting things like interviewing the VC). I then did two sets of work experience - one in the UK in the local newspaper, and one while I was volunteering overseas after Uni on the national newspaper there. I had a place to go and do a postgrad journalism course. I realised while doing the work experience that I wasn't interested enough in news - I had wanted to move into science or arts journalism - but I could see that the daily grind of local politics etc. would bore me to tears.
There weren't any blogs etc. then (I am ancient) though I did write the odd letter to the papers/New Scientist.
(The end of this story is that I went on to do a PhD and do a lot of technical writing for my job and that volume of writing means I don't really do that much non-work, fun writing any more except on Mumsnet!)

toffeechai · 15/09/2022 09:33

Ex-journalist here wanting to offer a bit of advice I’ve not seen on the thread yet: he needs to read as well as write. He needs to be able to talk about publications and writers that interest him. I remember I’d meet a lot of wannabe journalists who were not interested in reading others’ work and learning from them and it was an issue (eg in interviews)

MaChienEstUnDick · 15/09/2022 09:29

Get interested in the world.
Learn how to do your own research.
Do a 'good' degree in a subject that you love that brings something to the table - see the arts journalist above who did history of art, politics is a good one, science/tech subjects aren't thought of as 'traditional' routes into journalism but give you a viewpoint and a niche. Someone who can write credibly with authority about AI, for example, is going to find work.

Be prepared to work for little money and fill the holidays with relevant experience. For example, if you want to write about arts you need to be in Edinburgh working for very little money covering the festivals in August because that's how you meet people and get great clips.

Then think about a further qualification, if only because it's a way to make connections.

Think broadly - if you want to work in travel then actually print probably isn't the way to go. So is it travel or writing? What about lifestyle stuff? I know someone who did a very niche post grad and is now travelling Scotland writing about tourism stuff. It's all freelance so it's a slog, but she's having the time of her life.

PeekAtYou · 15/09/2022 09:17

I know a 19yo who wants to be a journalist and she's currently studying a degree but also spends a lot of time writing on her blogs so that she can practice writing as well as improve her digital skills. She has multiple blogs because they cover different interests so are written in different styles.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 15/09/2022 09:11

But the 3 post grads l mentioned have excellent connections.

Cardiff
Sheffield
UCL

Bingbangbongbash · 15/09/2022 08:39

Echo the above - really good degree in non-journalism / broadcast subject (arts, humanities, science) from top university - Oxbridge, London etc - then a masters from City (or equally prestigious post grad - there are some niche ones for science communication, for example). All the time writing for the best publications you can - uni newspaper, local paper etc. - to build up a body of work you can use as a portfolio.

The best journalists are highly paid and influential, but they are few and far between. That said, there are lots of related industries that can offer interesting and fulfilling careers. Lots of journalists end up in PR or as comms people in big companies for example.

If it’s the travel he likes, TV can be a good one to try - although equally competitive.

WolverineBluey · 15/09/2022 08:28

Nowadays any semi-literate with a smartphone calls themselves a journalist.

This - for all the talk on this thread about needing to be an excellent writer with critical thinking skills, some of this advice seems a bit out of date (and I say that as someone out of date myself!), in regional media at least, standards are absolutely woeful these days (except for sports writers who need a bit more about them). It really is all about the clicks and getting things out at breakneck speed.

Do the nationals still do trainee courses these days? Incredibly competitive but a brilliant way in for the lucky ones.

KosherDill · 15/09/2022 02:04

whatwouldAnnaDelveydo · 14/09/2022 21:20

Are you very rich? Journalism as a hobby, fine. If your DS plans to have a family as a journalist, that will be hard.

I used to be a science journalist. I'm early 40s and nearly all my journalist friends are working on other things. Press officers, content writers, social media managers, some are screenwriters, or enterpreneurs. There's not much to do in journalism if you want to be paid as an adult. (It's fun when you're 20 though)

In science journalism, most people in the UK studied science and then did a masters in science communication. I suggest your DS study that interests him (whatever it is) and then think about journalism later.

By the way, I think it's a shame. My skills from years of journalism are very helpful in many different jobs, but I wouldn't suggest working on this area for over 10 years to gain those skills (unless you are very rich and don't really need a career to pay the bills)

Same here. Journalist friends now working none too happily in PR, marketing etc to support their families.

It's not as it's romanticized to be.

KosherDill · 15/09/2022 02:01

AloysiusBear · 14/09/2022 22:13

Have someone in the family who's already a journalist. Have a rich family he can rely on to do unpaid internships. Have an NCTJ qualification, as the NUJ are still a relatively closed shop.

This but honestly? I would dissuade him with every ounce of my being. It's a terribly paid job, notorious for being a closed shop where who you know matters, anything remotely paid is dominated by those from public schools.

To even consider it I'd expect him to be/have the following:

  • an excellent writer. Eg winning school prizes, writing for local publications
  • loves writing. Probably keeps diaries and blogs, does the school paper and if it hasnt got one, tried to start one. Has sought out many opportunities to write outside of school - writing the sports match reports, reviewing things online.
  • has looked for & got work experience - local papers, interest magazines - anything.

Do not do a journalism degree. They are generally offered by lower ranked universities with poorer academic standards and less connections.

Do a degree involving a lot of writing (english, history, law) at a well regarded university & move on to something NCTJ afterwards

Exactly.

I've been more fortunate than most and yet if i could go back to my younger self there are 100 career paths I'd advise in lieu of journalism. If not 1,000.

It's an honorable trade but it's a thankless slog with little job security. And i say that as one of the "lucky" ones.

Nowadays any semi-literate with a smartphone calls themselves a journalist. It's not worth it unless one has a private income on the side.

ExHack · 15/09/2022 01:31

Retired magazine editor here. "In my day" the London College of Printing (now renamed "University of the Arts London") did highly respected courses that were pretty much guaranteed to get you a job. Their standards are very high.

janeseymour78 · 14/09/2022 23:44

Please disregard my awful typos and don't judge my institution based on them - Im both tired and under the weather!

janeseymour78 · 14/09/2022 23:43

I'm a grad of literature and journalism, erote for the uni paper and every decent site or mag I could get my hands on. I was a travel journalist for a couple of years after uni but now I work in PR like most of my peers. But I .also a published fiction writer and doubt I would be if it wasn't for the course.

Not solely studying Journalism was a good move - I'd suggest he does a dual course with another subject.

Like others have said it is very difficult to get into.

IdisagreeMrHochhauser · 14/09/2022 23:33

Both Chris Mason and Adam Fleming studied geography, one at Oxford and the other at Cambridge.

AloysiusBear · 14/09/2022 22:13

Have someone in the family who's already a journalist. Have a rich family he can rely on to do unpaid internships. Have an NCTJ qualification, as the NUJ are still a relatively closed shop.

This but honestly? I would dissuade him with every ounce of my being. It's a terribly paid job, notorious for being a closed shop where who you know matters, anything remotely paid is dominated by those from public schools.

To even consider it I'd expect him to be/have the following:

  • an excellent writer. Eg winning school prizes, writing for local publications
  • loves writing. Probably keeps diaries and blogs, does the school paper and if it hasnt got one, tried to start one. Has sought out many opportunities to write outside of school - writing the sports match reports, reviewing things online.
  • has looked for & got work experience - local papers, interest magazines - anything.

Do not do a journalism degree. They are generally offered by lower ranked universities with poorer academic standards and less connections.

Do a degree involving a lot of writing (english, history, law) at a well regarded university & move on to something NCTJ afterwards

Butterflymosaic · 14/09/2022 22:01

I have two journalist friends. One was an A* student who read English at Oxford. More importantly, she wrote, wrote and wrote. She ran the yearbook, the school mag and had countless articles published from about age 13/14. It’s her life and always has been. She’s not well paid but is employed rather than self employed now in her early 40s.

second one read English Lit at Edinburgh then a masters in publishing. Again, she reads and writes constantly. Sometimes she is so into her writing she stays in all weekend. She worked lots of random jobs such as in an optician, bars etc whilst writing for peanuts (or her blog for free). She has been a ghost writer numerous times also. She’s late 30s and not a high earlier but loves her work. She is a great all rounder who can research and write quickly.

So as far as I can see basically: he needs to love writing and words, to live and breathe them and to be happy to write a lot. Oh and deadlines! Sometimes they have peaks and troughs of work which can mean lots of all nighters.

And perhaps have a back up plan for part time work alongside.

AragornsGirl · 14/09/2022 21:51

My friend is a journalist. She studied English at uni, and while we were there she also wrote for the uni newspaper (not sure if such a thing exists now!) which gave her lots of great experience

Puffykins · 14/09/2022 21:43

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow it's great how well your DS has done - and evidently he worked super hard at university - but the journalists I know who went to Oxford/ Cambridge/ St. Andrew's etc. didn't go on to do further degrees, we went straight into journalism. So maybe the route is either an excellent university- or a post grad at one of the universities you mention.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 14/09/2022 21:40

Im a journalist. I did an apprenticeship at a paper, they paid for my NCTJ and I've been in the biz ever since. I already had a degree in English before that.

Im also a travel journalist and I have to warn him it's extremely tough to get into. I side stepped from a diff dept. The pay is shit as well... but i do travel the world!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 14/09/2022 21:36

Yet again…. Oxbridge….

There we’re about 50 people on ds’s course. I think about 4 went to Oxbridge.

Yet all of them got jobs🤔

Swipe left for the next trending thread