Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did the restaurant handle this badly?

141 replies

RestaurantMistake · 14/09/2022 14:46

I’m fully prepared to be told that I am unreasonable.

I have NCd because I have been quite open on my normal username about what village I live in.

We are frequent visitors to the Italian restaurant in our village. We are probably some of their most regular customers and know and like the team well.

The last time we visited, one of us tried a new pasta dish. It was not to our taste and most of the dish was left. We didn’t complain but it was obvious that we didn’t enjoy the dish. When the bill came the pasta dish was on the bill but at a charge if £0.00. We assumed that they’d noticed we didn’t eat it and removed it from our bill. We thought that was really nice customer service.

However, we went back in after being on holiday for a few weeks last night and they immediately produced the bill with the pasta dish circled. They said that they’d made a mistake and could we pay for the dish. Obviously I paid but I felt like they thought I had done this deliberately and then avoided visiting for a few weeks. They seemed suspicious when I said I had been away and looked me up and down saying that I wasnt very tanned.

For the sake of less than £10 I just felt a bit embarrassed in front of everyone and feel like this shouldn’t have happened.

AIBU?

Also, I completely appreciate that this is not a major problem and that there are much worse things happening!

OP posts:
LegoFiends · 14/09/2022 16:03

I wouldn’t feel like going back after that.
You could post an online review. Your tone is quite neutral and reasonable in this post so something like that would be fair enough.

RestaurantMistake · 14/09/2022 16:03

GlasgowGal82 · 14/09/2022 15:54

When they presented the bill with the pasta dish circled why didn't you just say:

"Yes we noticed that at the time, and thought you had comped the dish because we didn't eat it because it was not to our taste?"

Then you could have had a conversation with them about whether that had been their intention or whether the deduction was an unrelated admin error and come to an agreement about payment, instead of asking a bunch of people who are purely speculating.

I wish I had done but I was just a bit taken aback and I am the type of person who thinks about the best retort hours later.

I just felt like my integrity was being called into question and felt compelled to just pay it to end the situation.

OP posts:
TheHideAndSeekingHill · 14/09/2022 16:04

TwinkleChristmas · 14/09/2022 16:02

I think as they missed it then they should of just left it off and chalked it up to their mistake.

although I don’t see why you should of had it for free just because you didn’t like it.

I think it depends if it just wasn't to your taste or was poorly made. The thing I got comped was just not well made at all and inedible basically, I told the waiter that it wasn't great when he asked how the food was (I was very nice about it honestly).

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 14/09/2022 16:04

RestaurantMistake · 14/09/2022 15:34

Some kind of pasta with a name that I’ve not heard before -something like agnolotti? It was essentially like a ravioli type pasta. It was filled with a prawn paste.

Ooh, interesting!

I once ordered seafood pasta in a restaurant and it came with squid ink pasta, which wasn't mentioned on the menu. I can't stand it, so I very apologetically sent it back. Anything else and I would probably have soldiered through, but I just can't eat squid ink pasta. Was even more mortified when I heard the chef shouting about it in the kitchen, he was not happy at all.

HaveringWavering · 14/09/2022 16:05

"obviously I paid"

That was a mistake. Why on earth did you do that?

Did you not say "Oh, we thought you had seen we didn't like it and taken if off the bill"

They were utterly bonkers to think that it was worth chasing a tenner that had been under-charged by mistake.

At the very least, a good restaurant would have said at the time "Oh, was there anything wrong with the dish?".

So you live in Royston Vasey OP?

twosents · 14/09/2022 16:05

Not OK at all. They should have let it go. That's their mistake. It's really petty and poor customer service.

If they'd left it, you would have had a positive feeling about the place. Now you don't.

Not on. They messed up BIG time.

Backtobacknow · 14/09/2022 16:06

Ihatethenewlook · 14/09/2022 14:55

I’ve known this to happen a couple of times. Once to me when I didn’t like a dish and left almost all of it, though the waiters did point out to me that the cost was removed from the bill. I can see why the op might think that had happened as a goodwill gesture as it’s a local she frequents often.

Snap!

They were very rude!

HaveringWavering · 14/09/2022 16:08

Cross post OP. Did they even say it had been their mistake? If they phrased it such a way that you felt like you were being accused of pulling a fast one, that's even worse!

I really hope you won't go back.

Mannymoomin · 14/09/2022 16:08

I run a restaurant, and for anyone who doesn’t like their dish, where it’s clearly not been touched, I never ever charge, I don’t have to do that, and honestly, people don’t expect it either, so you are not unreasonable in thinking they took it off as a goodwill gesture.

Them then mentioning it to you I don’t think is unreasonable, they could have got their wires crossed.
BUT, doing it in front of other customers, and then making judgemental comments to you, was completely out of order and certainly very unprofessional, they could of and should of, mentioned it discreetly and in private.

DameHelena · 14/09/2022 16:09

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 14/09/2022 16:04

Ooh, interesting!

I once ordered seafood pasta in a restaurant and it came with squid ink pasta, which wasn't mentioned on the menu. I can't stand it, so I very apologetically sent it back. Anything else and I would probably have soldiered through, but I just can't eat squid ink pasta. Was even more mortified when I heard the chef shouting about it in the kitchen, he was not happy at all.

The chef should have been shouting at whoever left an important detail off the menu (well, they shouldn't be shouting at anyone, but you take my point). It's certainly not something for a customer to be 'mortified' about; it's an oversight by the restaurant.

Chevyimpala67 · 14/09/2022 16:10

They wouldn't be seeing me again!
Fucking cheek

RestaurantMistake · 14/09/2022 16:11

HaveringWavering · 14/09/2022 16:05

"obviously I paid"

That was a mistake. Why on earth did you do that?

Did you not say "Oh, we thought you had seen we didn't like it and taken if off the bill"

They were utterly bonkers to think that it was worth chasing a tenner that had been under-charged by mistake.

At the very least, a good restaurant would have said at the time "Oh, was there anything wrong with the dish?".

So you live in Royston Vasey OP?

Not Royston Vasey but a smallish village where the local Facebook page is full of people announcing that they’ve lived in the village all their lives and complaining about any new development etc.

I love the village - it has a great range of shops and amenities for its size. However, there are several aspects like the example above which I find a bit tiresome.

OP posts:
PaperwhiteTheGhost · 14/09/2022 16:11

Valid8me · 14/09/2022 14:50

I think you should have mentioned the charge of £0.00 at the time, you obviously spotted it. Surely no restaurant would give you something for free because you didn't happen it like it!

They do! I've had it twice, once at Wagamama and once at Cote. In both cases, when they came to ask how my meal was I admitted it wasn't what I'd expected and both times they let me order something else and didn't charge for the original meal.

I think this case is incredibly petty. You're regular customers ans the mark up on meals out is huge- they wouldn't have lost much money on jne dish. Plus, it was their mistake. If its not spotted and rectified at the time, they need to suck it up.

Wibbli · 14/09/2022 16:19

@RestaurantMistake In the same situation, I would’ve paid and then later regretted it (I have severe confrontation issues). It isn’t fair that they made you pay, especially after several weeks. They take your custom for granted. What I would do is call the manager and explain that you felt very much put on the spot, especially as this was done in front of other customers, and felt required to pay, even though it was inferred that the dish was free all those weeks ago, due to being listed on the receipt as £0. I would just vent that and that upon further consideration, you won’t be returning. See what they say - if it’s a “yeah that’s fine” then you never need to go back. If they apologise and reimburse you / give you free drinks etc, then you haven’t lost anything by complaining

LimpBiskit · 14/09/2022 16:22

Is there another Italian in the village? If so I'd be opting for that instead.

LuckySantangelo35 · 14/09/2022 16:23

They should have let it go

and interrogating you about whether or not you’d been on holiday and stuff about looking tanned way out of line

I would not go back

don’t know what they’re playing at really cos ultimately they need you more than you need them. They should be really looking after their regular customers

Midlifemusings · 14/09/2022 16:26

Could it be a case of confusion at the restaurant?The person working that night comped the pasta and then later, someone who was going through receipts saw the 0.00 charge and assumed there was an error. They may have asked around and no one rememebered comping you a meal. If the person who thinks it is an error knows you as a regular customer maybe they just thought they would mention it when you came in. Did you tell them it was comped that night?
I think this might be all a misunderstanding.

SoftwareDev · 14/09/2022 16:27

I would return or call up to explain to the manager what happened. It is unlikely that the dish was programmed into the POS system to cost zero which makes me think a thoughtful member of staff discounted it (which would make sense in the circumstances). However even if it was added to the POS system incorrectly the situation was handled very unprofessionally. The comment about your lack of tan was completely unwarranted and downright rude.

Given how it was handled I would not go back - and I'd be explaining that to them too!

Brokendaughter · 14/09/2022 16:28

If I was a regular, to the point that they recognise you weeks later & they did this to me I wouldn't be using them any more.

If you had been a random customer who had stopped in, had the same thing happen & never come back they would have lost the money, so they are taking advantage of the fact they think you are part of their 'captive audience'.

It's petty & they were the ones who chose not to charge you in the first place.

You don't sell something then a few weeks later contact a customer to tell them you changed your mind & want extra money if you want them to keep being a customer.

rookiemere · 14/09/2022 16:29

Obviously not great, but I'm somewhat impressed that they are offering prawn pasta dishes at less than £10.

poetryandwine · 14/09/2022 16:31

This was appalling customer service. Personally I would not be returning to the restaurant for some time. But it is far from unique

People can just be stupid. In a nice suburb of one of our major cities there used to be a restaurant that DH and I liked. On our second or third visit, we had booked a table for two. Unprompted, we were seated at a table for four. When we were not quite finished with our starters, the hostess came up with a party of four in tow and not very nicely asked us to move to a table for two. Of course we did, but it was quite a kerfuffle and basically ruined the evening. No compensation or even apology was offered.

After perhaps three or four nice meals there, about a year later the exact same thing happened. FWIW we eat and drink from the mid to upper part of the menu, genuinely appreciate staff and tip well, and present as acceptably if not overly stylishly middle class. So I don’t quite see how it could have been personal.

Needless to say we never went back, and I was not devastated when the restaurant was forced to close for financial reasons

Kitchenlight · 14/09/2022 16:32

RestaurantMistake · 14/09/2022 15:07

We genuinely did think that they had removed the dish as a goodwill gesture. We even thanked them about the pasta dish on our way out.

Perhaps I should have expressly checked but I just thought that they were being nice!

I think you should go in and speak to the manager. I think you should stand up for yourself. You can do it politely. You can do it and still pay for the pasta. But I'd it's your regular it's really going to sour your feelings and that's not worth it.
go on. You can do it!

AhaTopTrump · 14/09/2022 16:32

I would go back in and speak to the manager or owner face to face, presumably you know or can pint out the member of staff who ambushed you with this
Depending on the response I would either accept their apology or tell them to their face in front of people why I'd never go back

RestaurantMistake · 14/09/2022 16:32

Midlifemusings · 14/09/2022 16:26

Could it be a case of confusion at the restaurant?The person working that night comped the pasta and then later, someone who was going through receipts saw the 0.00 charge and assumed there was an error. They may have asked around and no one rememebered comping you a meal. If the person who thinks it is an error knows you as a regular customer maybe they just thought they would mention it when you came in. Did you tell them it was comped that night?
I think this might be all a misunderstanding.

The explanation I was given was that the bill had been prepared by a new member of staff who had made a mistake and accidentally not charged for the dish. The £0.00 had been circled several times and the receipt was under the till. So it looked like a deliberate decision to keep it and produce it on our next visit.

it was really awkward and uncomfortable and I just wanted the whole situation to end. So no I didn’t mention it. I might do if we go back.

OP posts:
LuckyLil · 14/09/2022 16:33

They make a point of telling you that if the make a mistake with change it can't be rectified once you leave the shop, meaning if they accidentally over charge they won't give you the difference back once you've left the shop. Well that works both ways. They shouldn't be asking you for money weeks later for their own mistake. Myself, I'd never be going back again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread