Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't want to be 'reigned over' anymore - Part 2

67 replies

vera99 · 14/09/2022 09:31

As a continuation of the thread started by @Yubgftr for a robust discussion as to the suitability or not to have a constitutional monarchy.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4631621-i-dont-want-to-be-reigned-over-anymore?page=40&reply=119985613

Even a new national anthem - why is it all about the king or queen and god saving them? Why not about the people, the nation as a whole?
That said, I also hate the idea of someone like Boris Johnson being head of state and I bet that's a role he'd go for if we were a Republic. Swings and Roundabouts!
YABU - God save the king, monarchy forever
YANBU - time to end the monarchy

OP posts:
vera99 · 14/09/2022 12:23

@felulageller agreed like Liz Truss he needs to hit the ground running with a vast swathe of reforms and use the goodwill he has obviously and rightly inherited. The late Queen got a free pass for her longevity, service and good humour she brought with almost never a crack in that noble facade. That Charles will never equal or surpass that is a given and should give monarchists a pause for thought. Just telling us to eff on and leave the country does the exact opposite.

Republicans apparently have a majority in Scotland.

OP posts:
Daftasabroom · 14/09/2022 12:20

vera99 · 14/09/2022 09:53

Well on the last thread with over 2500 votes the abolishers won by a small majority 52% to 48% so that's a lot of people leaving the country by the logic if you don't like it leave.

King Charles starts from a high point, issuing redundancy notices to his staff during the morning period is not a good start.

www.itv.com/news/2022-06-01/poll-dramatic-decline-in-support-for-monarchy-in-decade-since-diamond-jubilee

Have we learned nothing from the debacle of Brexit? Voting to abolish something without having a very clear plan of what to replace it with is a recipe for disaster.

vera99 · 14/09/2022 12:15

Thanks but your spelling mistake was a shocker for someone so well informed. 😀

OP posts:
Wallaw · 14/09/2022 12:14

User135644 · 14/09/2022 11:53

I don't like or care for the royal family but don't care about abolishing it. Is democracy all it's cracked up to be anyway when we're alwsys governed by Tories and a wretched Westminster? Who wants President Boris anyway.

In a way the monarchy is all we've got left after Brexit.

@User135644

As an American, resident in the UK for many years, I've heard this said many times, and I'm embarrassed to admit that I've never really understood this argument.

How is a PM substantively all that different from a president? They're both voted in and out, in the US, it's 8 years max (despite what the orange criminal might want), and Blair, for example, was PM for 10.

And I know they could, but would any modern monarch truly refuse to allow a government to be formed? Surely that would be the end of the monarchy? And if we elect horrors who are willing to prorogue Parliament and lie to the monarch and there's no blowback, what difference does it all really make?

Honestly not being argumentative, just looking to understand.

Legrandsophie · 14/09/2022 12:11

@vera99

10 out of 10 for being able to work Wikipedia.

vera99 · 14/09/2022 12:06

It's Bagehot for the record Bagshott is where Prince Edward and his family live. Anyway, I'm off to Central London with my partner to observe at firsthand the people and see what Bagehot's 'lower orders' are up to.

England had a ‘double set’ of institutions – the dignified ones ‘impress the many’ while the efficient ones ‘govern the many’. The dignified or ‘theatrical’ parts of the system played the essential role of winning and sustaining the loyalty and confidence of the mass of ordinary people whose political capacities were minimal or non-existent; they helped the state to gain authority and legitimacy, which the efficient institutions could then use.

Bagehot was an unashamed elitist who believed bleakly that the ‘lower orders’ and the ‘middle orders’ were ‘narrow-minded, unintelligent, incurious’. Throughout The English Constitution, there are references to ‘the coarse, dull, contracted multitude’, ‘the poor and stupid’, ‘the vacant many’, ‘the clownish mass’.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_English_Constitution

OP posts:
felulageller · 14/09/2022 12:03

If Charlie wants to save the monarchy he needs to pay inheritance tax on the private wealth he's inherited from the queen, strip everyone bar him, his DW, DC and DGCs of HRHs, have a low key coronation and donate excess castles, jewellery, art, cars, etc to charity.

They need to follow the lead of all the other surviving monarchies and live more typical lives.

ocs30 · 14/09/2022 12:02

Legrandsophie · 14/09/2022 11:53

Yes, we do. There is a book. Buy it.

Is it this? 😂

I don't want to be 'reigned over' anymore  - Part 2
Legrandsophie · 14/09/2022 11:57

The English Constitution by Bagshott is still relevant (very little has changed except for fixed term parliaments)

Does anyone here know anything about the different estates of government?

Legrandsophie · 14/09/2022 11:56

In fact there are many, many books on the U.K. constitution and hundreds of documents.

What there is not us a Ten Commandments style list so loved in the US- except when it is getting in the way of most political reforms.

Read some Bagshott and get back to me.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/09/2022 11:55

Legrandsophie · 14/09/2022 09:44

Another fact free diatribe I see.

Why not try reading our constitution rather than culling bilge from social media and newspapers?

Have you 'read' the constitution?

Which document have you read? Which aspects are of particular interest to you, and best support your desire for its continuation?

User135644 · 14/09/2022 11:53

I don't like or care for the royal family but don't care about abolishing it. Is democracy all it's cracked up to be anyway when we're alwsys governed by Tories and a wretched Westminster? Who wants President Boris anyway.

In a way the monarchy is all we've got left after Brexit.

Legrandsophie · 14/09/2022 11:53

Yes, we do. There is a book. Buy it.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 14/09/2022 11:49

We don't have a constitution you can read.

greenhousegal · 14/09/2022 11:38

TitInATrance · 14/09/2022 11:35

We don’t have a constitution in the U K.

We do, it is unwritten though, and based a lot on precedent and other tangled references.

TitInATrance · 14/09/2022 11:35

Legrandsophie · 14/09/2022 09:44

Another fact free diatribe I see.

Why not try reading our constitution rather than culling bilge from social media and newspapers?

We don’t have a constitution in the U K.

vera99 · 14/09/2022 11:30

One of the richest families in the world - fantastic benefit of tax-free privileges available to no other citizens.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/sep/14/the-sovereigns-wealth-uk-royal-familys-finances-explained?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

OP posts:
CathyorClaire · 14/09/2022 10:40

It is part of the slimming down of the royal households that everyone is so keen on

Especially Charles who touts it as a pleb pleaser while knowing his own bloated lifestyle doesn't take so much as a dent.

Otezres · 14/09/2022 10:37

@Legrandsophie redundancy situations require a consultation period. The exact time depends on numbers but many employers default to 3 months even if not legally compelled to do so (job loss isn’t over 100). Formal notice has been issued that jobs are at risk triggering that process and setting the clock ticking. That could have been delayed until after the funeral - it would have been only about a week more. Any benefit to the employee of being told now is negligible.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 14/09/2022 10:37

Yep they asked how long I was staying and who I was staying with. Like it was any of their damn business.

CathyorClaire · 14/09/2022 10:37

Andrew is a councillor of state and therefore stands in if Charles is out of the country or incapacitated.

Beatrice - she of the uncomfortable questions over sums received from an alleged fraudster- has also now been promoted to stand-in.

Scianel · 14/09/2022 10:32

I already got the third degree when I came over in the summer, despite using a British passport

OMG seriously?! The UK border force is something else, as a former holder of a different passport before naturalising it was ridiculously stressful. Whereas the EU countries even post-Brexit just say hello and stamp the damn thing.

Otezres · 14/09/2022 10:30

I have to laugh at people who support the monarchy saying ‘ooh Anne, she’s lovely, so hard working she should be Queen’ and not actually realising that this is what is at the very heart of the issue - it’s not about ability, merit, suitability, it’s about accident of birth. Ditto the people relieved Andrew isn’t ‘it’ - well here’s the thing, he could have been and you would have had no control over
that what so ever.

also the ‘poor Charles, he’s grieving and over worked’, well here’s an idea…..

Legrandsophie · 14/09/2022 10:29

@vera99 I’d imagine you would find some way to criticise him whatever he did.

What I got from the memo was that they wanted to let staff know as soon as possible out of courtesy. Damned if they do and damned if they don’t.

The double standards on this thread are ridiculous. If he’d waited until after the funeral the narrative would have been that he’d exploited them to do the change over and then moved them over. At least this way they know now and can decide where they’d like to go. Seems polite.

Can none of the ardent republicans see that they are making tits out of themselves by being caught out so often in half truths and misinformation. You lot are actually less well informed than Brexiteers. And that is saying something!

AuxArmesCitoyens · 14/09/2022 10:28

I already got the third degree when I came over in the summer, despite using a British passport. Thanks Brexit 😡

Swipe left for the next trending thread