Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't want to be 'reigned over' anymore - Part 2

67 replies

vera99 · 14/09/2022 09:31

As a continuation of the thread started by @Yubgftr for a robust discussion as to the suitability or not to have a constitutional monarchy.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4631621-i-dont-want-to-be-reigned-over-anymore?page=40&reply=119985613

Even a new national anthem - why is it all about the king or queen and god saving them? Why not about the people, the nation as a whole?
That said, I also hate the idea of someone like Boris Johnson being head of state and I bet that's a role he'd go for if we were a Republic. Swings and Roundabouts!
YABU - God save the king, monarchy forever
YANBU - time to end the monarchy

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DownNative · 15/09/2022 12:57

greenhousegal · 14/09/2022 11:38

We do, it is unwritten though, and based a lot on precedent and other tangled references.

Common misconception!

The UK does have a WRITTEN constitution. It's just found in different sources of writing, e.g. Acts Of Parliament, Case Law, etc. This means we have an UNCODIFIED constitution.

Even then, a good amount of the UK Constitution is codified, e.g. Belfast Agreement, EU treaties, Withdrawal Agreement, etc.

Lord Norton is a globally renowned expert on the UK Constitution:

nortonview.wordpress.com/2019/09/20/do-we-need-a-written-constitution/

vera99 · 15/09/2022 12:14

TBH I don't see the Monarchy lasting beyond Charles III. There is no justification for a hereditary Head of State in a modern democracy and an elected alternative works in other countries. Young people are in favour of abolition and I don't think Charles or William have the qualities required to make the Monarchy relevant.

William is especially underwhelming. I don't see him creating the mystique required of a Monarch which is the main justification put forward by W Bagehot as a unifying force for a nation. In the near term, Charles has already made too many mistakes such as not supporting M&H, not allowing H to wear his uniform to the lying in state of the Queen, and starting the redundancy round of his and the Queen's employees during the service for the Queen, displaying his short temper and unpreparedness while signing a document (not knowing the date IMO is not acceptable, can you imagine the Queen not being prepared) then blaming his pen ... this does not create mystique...

Roll on Tuesday so we can get back to some sort of business as usual.

OP posts:
UsernameIsCopied · 15/09/2022 11:56

hariseldonscalculator · 14/09/2022 15:51

I think I saw this referred to on the Sky News website but can’t believe it hasn’t been mentioned here.

www.nbcnews.com/video/king-charles-iii-angry-with-leaking-pen-at-hillsborough-castle-book-signing-148334661797?cid=referral_taboolafeed

This happened yesterday.

He sounds so unpleasant in this video, like a really horrible man. For now, I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt and assuming he's just stressed.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/09/2022 17:29

Daftasabroom · 14/09/2022 17:26

@MarieIVanArkleStinks talk to me about "green politics".

@Daftasabroom: No. It's off the topic of this thread. You have access to Google, educate yourself instead of expecting others to do it for you.

HTH

Daftasabroom · 14/09/2022 17:26

@MarieIVanArkleStinks talk to me about "green politics".

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/09/2022 17:19

Well I've learned something amazing today. Professor Yaffle was based on Bertrand Russell! Brilliant pisstake, too.

And yes, I do vaguely remember that buffoon Charles making those comments about people expecting immediate success to fall into their laps without working for it. Says the bloke who had every imaginable expensive educational advantage at his disposal and only emerged from university with a mediocre 2.2.

Ironic indeed. But this is the bloke preaching green politics to the population - who he reckons should adjust their behaviour and be more responsible - whilst belching carbon into the air from his fleet of helicopters, gas guzzlers, private jets and massive estates. These people are so completely lacking in self-awareness, they're beyond parody.

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 14/09/2022 16:48

What is wrong with people nowadays? Why do they all seem to think they are qualified to do things far above their capabilities?" the heir to the throne exclaims
Oh great, my irony meter just exploded.

AclowncalledAlice · 14/09/2022 16:46

Dotjones · 14/09/2022 09:44

If you don't want to live in a country ruled by a monarch, the beauty of Britain is that you're free to leave and find a country where you'll be happier.

On a practical day to day level I don't see what benefit abolishing the monarchy would bring. Anyone could become head of state, so bloody what? Look at countries where there is an elected head of state, how many people actually manage to get into that position? Even somewhere with a high turnover you'd be looking at the leader changing every year or two.

If the monarchy is abolished, feel free to move somewhere where there is one. 🙄

Wallaw · 14/09/2022 16:04

vera99 · 14/09/2022 15:58

Wow quite a find one of the richest men in the country supports a hierarchical class system shock.

I don't disagree, but it's rare (and not particularly refreshing) to see it expressed so blatantly. And I find it particularly galling now, considering how many of his 'subjects' seem genuinely devastated by the death of his mother, to recall his contempt for them.

vera99 · 14/09/2022 15:58

Wow quite a find one of the richest men in the country supports a hierarchical class system shock.

OP posts:
hariseldonscalculator · 14/09/2022 15:51

I think I saw this referred to on the Sky News website but can’t believe it hasn’t been mentioned here.

www.nbcnews.com/video/king-charles-iii-angry-with-leaking-pen-at-hillsborough-castle-book-signing-148334661797?cid=referral_taboolafeed

This happened yesterday.

Pilipalapal · 14/09/2022 15:47

Wallaw · 14/09/2022 15:32

Does anyone else remember this, Charles complaining about people trying to, I guess, level up? He denied it afterwards, but it was pretty convincing. Hope he's moderated his views.

people rising above their stations

Thanks for posting this - I’ve no memory of it (I’ve always tended to avoid reading ‘news’ involving the royal family).

What an arsehole.

Wallaw · 14/09/2022 15:32

Does anyone else remember this, Charles complaining about people trying to, I guess, level up? He denied it afterwards, but it was pretty convincing. Hope he's moderated his views.

people rising above their stations

ClaudineClare · 14/09/2022 15:00

Or are we going for a more French revolution style with all rich families being beheaded?

Now that issomething I would queue up to see 😅🪓

AuxArmesCitoyens · 14/09/2022 14:54

^^tell me you'vr not bothered reading the arguments without telling me you've not bothered reading the arguments

PrincessMarsh · 14/09/2022 13:41

I would like to be reigned over by the Royal Family because :

  1. I don't want an elected head of state. I really don't want a political figure as head of state. I think the person has potential to be divisive, will be driven by the short term need for votes, not for the long term benefit of the country and its how countries end up with far right leaders. The RF are not political. They have a power to bring people together - it's like we all share this same distant family and is a talking point, did you see the wedding, did you see the dress, how cute are the kids etc.

  2. I see the RF as a part of living history. They are a link to the past. All the tourists who visit the palaces and historic sites - they are made more attractive and more real because its not something that happened long ago - its something which is happening now. Comparing the UK visitors to, for example, French palaces - there is a real difference.

  3. Leverage on the world stage. We as an island aren't particularly interesting other than our traditions and our history. It's our unique selling point on the world stage. I sincerely doubt that the world's attention would be on us if a normally elected head of state had passed. The US president would not be flying in for the funeral. There have been instances where the Queen has been able to do things due to her status and her long relationships with countries that a prime minister has been unable to do behind the scenes.

  4. for many in the military the Queen (and now King) is incredibly important to them.

I don't understand where the notion of plebs comes from. The Royal Family spend their entire lives in service to the country. Being told what to do, where to go, who to meet. They are trapped in a gilded cage. I've never heard of a story of the Queen ever treating anyone with anything other than respect and kindness. I've never got the impression the RF have ever felt or made anyone in real life, only people's own projections.

There are plenty wealthy families in the world. The RF is a family who spend their lives doing charitable work and trying to improve the lives of others.

Or are we going for a more French revolution style with all rich families being beheaded?

vera99 · 14/09/2022 13:13

@MarieIVanArkleStinks brilliant stuff thanks for taking the trouble to write such an elegant and illuminating piece also for mentioning Bagpuss - apparently Professor Yaffle was based on the philosopher Bertrand Russell.

OP posts:
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/09/2022 13:00

WillPowerLite · 14/09/2022 12:48

In my head, I'm hearing Bagpuss. Clearly I am one of the lower orders. 😀

Well I'm lower-order too, because I think Bagpuss rocks. He was really the clever one. Yaffle the one who thought he was smart but was really a bit gormless. Imagine a dusty old academic being trolled by a gaggle of blue-collar workers (mice) who at one point even rebel against him and go on all-out strike!

(starting to sing under my breath 'as soon as this pub closes, the revolution starts ...)

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/09/2022 12:55

There is no document setting out the detailed principles of a UK constitution. None. There are plenty of books chewing the fat over whether or otherwise there even IS a British constitution, and if so how we might interpret that term considering how nebulous a concept it's become as the 20th century progressed. As to the extensive constitutional reforms brought in by Tony Blair's government - the most radical since WWI, the manifesto on which they were elected - judge for yourself how well those turned out. And I'm still none the wiser as to what those posters continually telling others to 'read the constitution' 😂would like them to take out of this process, or how they anticipate this will change their position and make them ardent supporters of the monarchy. Are there any takers?

As a counter-argument, I could just as easily urge you to look up the term 'elective dictatorship' or to read the Irish Constitution (unlike the British one you can read it in full, including all articles and amendments), especially those relating to the sovereignty of the republic, separation of powers, and rights of the Irish people. As a system of liberal democracy it's an effective model. Curious as to how these points might compare to the issues with British one you are claiming to know all about.

It's not only the Windsors, who are a small aspect if an influential figurehead of a dying system, around which questions are being asked about a UK constitution pretty much in its decline. To the extent that we do have a set of rules around which government is based, we have constitution (for what it's worth). But even academics are divided over its meaning. The traditional principles of state and national identity - that 1000 years of 'history' monarchists bang on about - is pretty much redundant given every government seems to lack faith in its own principles and seek to 'modernize' it at every given opportunity. And now we've even seen fit to remove the checks and balances afforded us by the EU a radical reform of the whole system is even more urgent.

As well as '1000 years of history have worked perfectly well, it provides stability' [it doesn't, for above reasons; that is a comforting illusion], monarchists like the argument that it would be a terrible idea to overthrow the system without complete clarity as to what its benefits would be, and the exact structure of what replaces it. I agree completely. It needs a gradual transition and careful consideration, not an idealist revolution. That's a discussion which was always going to begin with the death of Elizabeth II. And those questions are starting as of now.

WillPowerLite · 14/09/2022 12:48

AuxArmesCitoyens · 14/09/2022 12:34

I wondered who Bagshott was but am too polite to say so 😇

In my head, I'm hearing Bagpuss. Clearly I am one of the lower orders. 😀

Stopandlook · 14/09/2022 12:48

Why on earth should I leave Britain? I don’t have to believe that someone can rule over me because of their family history to live here. Neither do I have to believe a human should be born with their life mapped out for them.
i just live with the fact that quite a lot of the country believe otherwise for reasons I’ll never understand.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 14/09/2022 12:34

I wondered who Bagshott was but am too polite to say so 😇

countrygirl99 · 14/09/2022 12:31

I studied Bagehot as part of the British Government module at university. Got a 1st in that module too.Am I allowed to have an opinion?

Novella4 · 14/09/2022 12:30

@LakieLady
Another poster says there is a bill underway to remove him from line of succession

The point being , we shouldn't be in this position in the 21st century

The other thing I wonder about is Andrew may not be the only issue

LakieLady · 14/09/2022 12:23

Novella4 · 14/09/2022 09:41

Thank you for new thread

I have just mentioned on another thread that in Robert Preston's Twitter he's pointing out that Andrew is a councillor of state and therefore stands in if Charles is out of the country or incapacitated.

The royalists are frothing ' it's protocol , it's nonsense '

The fact is it will take an act of parliament to remove him
This is why the royals need removed
Ludicrous

I think this is the first step of the RF's efforts to rehabilitate the (alleged) sex criminal.

Swipe left for the next trending thread