Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do so many more adult men than adult women still live with their parents?

161 replies

Tsort · 13/09/2022 22:42

Obviously, COVID and CoL have had a severe impact on young people’s ability to leave home, regardless of gender. However, the percentage of young men at home is so much higher. These are the percentages for 2021 (according to Statista), as you’ll see, the difference starts to get quite striking in the mid-20’s.

Age Male Female
34 11% 3%
33 11%. 2%
32 13% 5%
31 14% 6%
30 15% 6%
29 19% 9%
28 25% 12%
27 30% 13%
26 36% 21%
25 43% 25%
24 56% 40%
23 56% 50%
22 65% 54%
21 67% 50%
20 64% 57%
19 81% 76%
18 92% 89%

So, what gives, do you think? Is it the old trope of useless man children who can’t cope on their own? Is it that women more likely to want their independence? Something else?

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 14/09/2022 01:43

I think its more to do that daughters can't live with their mothers and sons get an easy time.

worriedatthistime · 14/09/2022 01:31

Young men don't tend to keep the kids therefore not entitled to housing would play quite a big part
For example my brother ended up back home when his long term relationship filed , he hd council place but his ex kept that as she also hd kids
My db hd to move to parents as he paid for his children and that left him with not enough to save for rent etc , especially when first split as he continued to pay for bills and subscriptions they were tied into

paisley256 · 14/09/2022 01:30

The ones I have known have gone back to their parents home after relationship or marriage breakdown as they can't afford to pay for their own accommodation. The women with the children has stayed in the marital home.

It makes sense to them to go back home and be able to save up for rent or house deposit rather than renting a room for a fortune and not having space for children when they stay over.
.
The part of the country I'm form has masses of poverty and deprivation with families in temporary accommodation. A single man wouldn't get any help with housing from the council unless he was a single father. Most of the women I went to school with only moved out when they had children and got housed by the council. Hardly anyone moved out by going to uni. The other men and women stayed at home and saved for deposits for rent/mortgage and some were carers for parents or grandparents.

FangsForTheMemory · 14/09/2022 01:04

If I hadn’t moved out of my parents’ home my parents would have expected me to become their carer because I was a woman.

Lunar270 · 14/09/2022 00:58

Probably many different reasons but from my thoughts:

Judging by the number of very difficult relationships women have with their mothers, I'd imagine the motivation to fly the nest can be higher for some women. My MIL is as toxic as hell. Speaking to my wife, her brother was treated like royalty and had everything done for him. Typically for our era, he was allowed girlfriends to stay over. She was never allowed. She had the lion's share of chores to do as it was women's work. Even now, my wife can't do anything right so was no wonder she moved out at 18.

Although BIL moved out to go to university and never returned. I also moved out at 17 and never returned.

EBearhug · 14/09/2022 00:58

I know a man who lives with his mother - she's in her 80s, and broke her ankle during lockdown, so she moved into his home,because she couldn't manage alone.

Tsort · 14/09/2022 00:49

@ChiefWiggumsBoy 🤣🤣🤣

I remember when it wasn’t like this. I feel like five years ago this would have had more people who actually engaged with what was being asked and fewer ‘how dare you ATTACK AND JUDGE the menfolk?!’

I’m not sure what happened.

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 14/09/2022 00:46

My uncle (45) never left home, (well he did in his 30s and then decided it was too hard so came back) but basically he doesn’t like being by himself and he likes my grandma doing everything for him, she even runs his bath and warms his bed up for him every night and so he has got used to the lifestyle of basically being a ‘kid’ with no responsibility.

These are the kind of people (assuming no disability or SEN) who give a bad name to the many adult children co-habiting and co-operating perfectly well with their parents and sharing the running of the household.

I always remember reading an article many years ago about four men in their 50s who lived with their elderly mum, basically as if they were still children with her doing everything for them. I even remember one of the comments from one son who said "We would do housework if we had to, but it's really women's work".

I think the (usually) mums who enable this are failing as parents as well and, together, they're just really setting them(selves) up for an enormous fall. If you're completely incapable of living independently as an adult in your 50s (through laziness, not with genuine reason), with an 85yo mum, what do you expect to happen when you're in your 60s and she has died?

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 14/09/2022 00:33

@Tsort you can't have a conversation on here about statistics without loads of people getting outraged because in their personal experience it's not what you are suggesting.

Personally I don't know any men between the age of 20 and 30 so therefore I call FAKE on your post. It's definitely not because I literally don't mix with men in those age brackets....

savethebeesandthecees · 14/09/2022 00:33

TheLostNights · 13/09/2022 23:22

Yeah I did read it and the part about useless man children.
Try telling that to my 39 year old male friend who lives at home and is a carer for his disabled mum.

Oh give over.

What is with the victim mentality

NorthStarRising · 14/09/2022 00:26

I’ve got one of each, in their 20s. Boomeranged back after Uni.
The son is more laid back, easier to get on with and does his fair share of household tasks from hovering to laundry. We share a lot of interests.
The daughter is more challenging, is woke in many ways, some of which are hard to compromise on and often forgets to do her share of tasks. So of the two, I’d be keener to see her move out again. Although it’s working out fine for the most part, they’re good company and it’s a big house.
And yes, we all get tired of the comments from judgeypants.

ConsuelaHammock · 14/09/2022 00:24

Women find it harder to live with another woman? Even if that woman is her mother ?

Plenty67 · 14/09/2022 00:18

Since we are dealing in sexist tripe on this thread, what about the old Tory complaint about young / teenage single mothers getting deliberately pregnant to secure benefits and free housing giant TV's from from the social !

Well young women did intentionally get pregnant to get access to social housing and benefits (not the TV though). The thing that was seriously misrepresented in that viewpoint is how low the young woman's expectations were to make that choice in the first place. There are plenty of woman that ended up with a much more difficult and complicated life because of these choices. We should be ashamed of a society that made the option of young pregnancy so attractive, those young women were let down by society. They did not let down the society.

justasking111 · 14/09/2022 00:17

Two of mine worked abroad one part time he lived with us when home and saved up for a house. The other came home after six years and lived with us. They were no trouble did their own chores helped out around the house and garden. We never fell out.

I know mothers and daughters who fell out all the time so they moved out as I did with my own mother.
My poor dad looking back.

LorW · 14/09/2022 00:13

My uncle (45) never left home, (well he did in his 30s and then decided it was too hard so came back) but basically he doesn’t like being by himself and he likes my grandma doing everything for him, she even runs his bath and warms his bed up for him every night and so he has got used to the lifestyle of basically being a ‘kid’ with no responsibility.

Walkden · 14/09/2022 00:09

"because men need expect a woman to do their washing for them, and any other household task they find boring.
also mothers often collude with this, tolerating if not encouraging helplessness in sons but not in daughters."

Since we are dealing in sexist tripe on this thread, what about the old Tory complaint about young / teenage single mothers getting deliberately pregnant to secure benefits and free housing giant TV's from from the social !

Tsort · 14/09/2022 00:04

user1477391263 · 13/09/2022 23:53

Things like ASD are commoner in men, and often lead to guys living at home for a long time. That might push the percentage up for men.

I looked this up and have now gone deep into a rabbit hole about autism being ignored or misdiagnosed in women. It’s fascinating, so thanks!

Also totally agree that this is probably a factor.

OP posts:
user1477391263 · 13/09/2022 23:53

Things like ASD are commoner in men, and often lead to guys living at home for a long time. That might push the percentage up for men.

audeloquipalam · 13/09/2022 23:53

Those disparities in those age ranges signify that single parenthood and the associated housing arrangements are the obvious driver.

But MN and agendas.

SofiaSoFar · 13/09/2022 23:52

There won't be a single answer. It will a number of things at play.

Another one to consider is the proportion of low earning males with high earning female partners, compared to low earning females with higher earning males.

That's very much skewed towards younger/lower-earning females with older/higher-earning males, which will significantly impact the statistics.

Tsort · 13/09/2022 23:50

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll Yes, we don’t know the extent to which cultural practices are skewing the numbers. That’s a really good point.

@Overshadowed That’s super interesting, as well. And ties in with what a lot of people have said upthread about single motherhood.

OP posts:
Overshadowed · 13/09/2022 23:44

The ones I know are usually in a household with their single mother and feel guilty leaving.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/09/2022 23:43

To be honest, with the costs of housing these days and the huge difficulty in saving up for a home of your own whilst also paying rent, I think that, if you get on well and it works for everybody, it's almost foolish for a young adult who is single - male or female - not to stay living with their parents.

As we've already mentioned, the only real danger comes when the adult child continues to live/be treated like a juvenile child and not as an adult contributing properly to the running of the household.

Tsort · 13/09/2022 23:42

Unglamorousgranny · 13/09/2022 23:36

@Tsort Admittedly it does not answer your question on percentages. The answers are probably a combination of pp's replies. Why do the percentages matter to you?
I do however find questions like your op to be quite judgemental deep down of grown men still living with their parents, as I do with some of the snidey replies. There have been so many judgemental/goady posts on grown young men living with their parents, unfairly classing them as a man child, yet no one ever seems to question why a woman still lives with her parents, nor judges them.

I provided the percentages, as they are relevant to the question. Which is why so many more young men than women? There’s a massive difference and I’m wondering what about our society makes it so.

You informing me about how hardworking and sensibly saving your son is isn’t really relevant to what I’m asking. If you’re not interested in the why, that’s your prerogative, but I am.

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/09/2022 23:38

I agree that there's a massive difference between adult children who still live at home and expect to be looked after, and those who share a relatively equal co-habiting adult relationship with their parents - indeed, as has been said, the adult child might be the owner/carer and have the senior responsibility in the household - and there's absolutely no way of knowing from the stats how many fall into which group.

MN traditionally says to run from a man who still lives with his parents, but what if the roles are reversed and, to all intents and purposes, his parent(s) live with him?

As to the big difference in numbers between men and women, I wonder if this has taken into account certain Asian cultures, where the sons traditionally stay at home and their wives move in with them after marriage? Thus the DIL doesn't live with her parents, but she does live with her in-laws. That may skew it a bit.