Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do so many more adult men than adult women still live with their parents?

161 replies

Tsort · 13/09/2022 22:42

Obviously, COVID and CoL have had a severe impact on young people’s ability to leave home, regardless of gender. However, the percentage of young men at home is so much higher. These are the percentages for 2021 (according to Statista), as you’ll see, the difference starts to get quite striking in the mid-20’s.

Age Male Female
34 11% 3%
33 11%. 2%
32 13% 5%
31 14% 6%
30 15% 6%
29 19% 9%
28 25% 12%
27 30% 13%
26 36% 21%
25 43% 25%
24 56% 40%
23 56% 50%
22 65% 54%
21 67% 50%
20 64% 57%
19 81% 76%
18 92% 89%

So, what gives, do you think? Is it the old trope of useless man children who can’t cope on their own? Is it that women more likely to want their independence? Something else?

OP posts:
FloydPepper · 14/09/2022 11:23

Getoff · 14/09/2022 09:18

I copied the data into a spreadsheet and compared women with men aged three years older, instead of the same age. Only for pairs where women are aged 29 or over and men 34 or over are there more men in their parents home. At all lower ages the discrepancy vanishes.

This looks to be the answer

a lot less fun than some snippy shitty dig at men than a few posters decided to do though

KILM · 14/09/2022 10:48

This is anecdotal, but a PP touched on mental health and i find this to be a big difference between men and women suffering with mental health issues.
This is obviously not everyone, im not saying every man/woman behaves like this, just anecdotal experience (before i get jumped on)
But i find that in my personal experience the women i know with MH issues tend to still be independent and whilst they struggle, they get by and are living independently. They also tend to do more recovery work, like therapy or working on their diet/exercise/routines/relationships etc on top of or instead of medication.
The men with MH issues who are at home tend to be different. They might or might not hold down a job. They probably take anti depressents, but are not actively 'seeking' recovery or independence in the same way women do. They game, eat junk food, dont exercise, dont help around the house, take advantage of their parents financially etc.
They and their families see 'i am depressed' as a permanent thing and if im honest, sometimes an excuse for them not to do anything outside of their comfort zones.
Its really hard to get help or WANT to get help when you are suffering with poor MH, but i find it interesting the difference in the 'coping' output. We see it with marriages - men use it in 'the script' when they have been having an affair, they say they are depressed to get out of engaging in family life or leaving the family home only for it to be discovered they have been seeing someone else.
This is NOT tarring all men or people with mental health with the same brush, just a personal observation.

Alicetheowl · 14/09/2022 10:07

Four things:
Gitls tend to be worried about more by their parents in terms of getting lifts home, staying out late, meeting OLD contracts etc, so are more motivated to move out rather than be fussed over.

Single parents are prioritised for social housing, and resident parents get to stay in the family home after relationship break up, and these are proportionately more likely to be female.

I have worked in companies with a lot of Asian employees-if they can't afford their own place after marriage the norm seems to be that they stay with the husband's parents rather than the wife's.

Age gap relationships tend to be younger female, older male, so females are more likely tofind a partner who has already left home.

Tsort · 14/09/2022 10:01

June6 · 14/09/2022 09:43

In my experience it is more complicated than that, females are more skilled at masking (camouflaging signs) and as fitting into the society around you is important they tend to hone their skills and mask more. Many females with autism are underdiagnosed because in past generations there was less known about it, and the females were so good at masking that their parents and teachers did not know that there was an issue. And it is hard to diagnose or support when you don't know this. Hopefully this will begin to change, and I see this in the area I work in.

Men who are undiagnosed are in the same position as women who are undiagnosed. The reason they tend to be diagnosed earlier is because more men than women have autism and therefore it was more likely to be considered when presenting the signs (and men are less skilled at masking the signs). The higher up the spectrum you go the clearer it is how much more men than women are affected.

Sorry if I’m misunderstanding you, but I don’t think we disagree?

OP posts:
Lunar270 · 14/09/2022 09:50

Let's be honest though - a lot of fully grown men are pathetic little man babies who are happy to have their arses wiped and bills paid by another woman, whether it's Mummy or not. Mumsnet has taught me this enormously.

I think you need to get off the fence a bit and tell us what you really think!

June6 · 14/09/2022 09:43

Tsort · 14/09/2022 08:57

@SophieIsHereToday My thinking (based on the limited amount I read last night) is that men are diagnosed and receive support, but women are un/misdiagnosed and basically told to get on with it by society and their families. So, they do.

A lifetime of masking. ☹️

In my experience it is more complicated than that, females are more skilled at masking (camouflaging signs) and as fitting into the society around you is important they tend to hone their skills and mask more. Many females with autism are underdiagnosed because in past generations there was less known about it, and the females were so good at masking that their parents and teachers did not know that there was an issue. And it is hard to diagnose or support when you don't know this. Hopefully this will begin to change, and I see this in the area I work in.

Men who are undiagnosed are in the same position as women who are undiagnosed. The reason they tend to be diagnosed earlier is because more men than women have autism and therefore it was more likely to be considered when presenting the signs (and men are less skilled at masking the signs). The higher up the spectrum you go the clearer it is how much more men than women are affected.

FarmGirl78 · 14/09/2022 09:42

I would expect (but can't prove!) that young early 20s females might be more tempted to get a house or flat share with their friends, than a group of lads would be. It might not necessarily be down to relationships or purchasing houses.

AlbertaAnnie · 14/09/2022 09:41

Tsort · 13/09/2022 22:42

Obviously, COVID and CoL have had a severe impact on young people’s ability to leave home, regardless of gender. However, the percentage of young men at home is so much higher. These are the percentages for 2021 (according to Statista), as you’ll see, the difference starts to get quite striking in the mid-20’s.

Age Male Female
34 11% 3%
33 11%. 2%
32 13% 5%
31 14% 6%
30 15% 6%
29 19% 9%
28 25% 12%
27 30% 13%
26 36% 21%
25 43% 25%
24 56% 40%
23 56% 50%
22 65% 54%
21 67% 50%
20 64% 57%
19 81% 76%
18 92% 89%

So, what gives, do you think? Is it the old trope of useless man children who can’t cope on their own? Is it that women more likely to want their independence? Something else?

I think it’s more to do with reproductive responsibility. When women have their own children they usually become the primary care givers in the event of relationship breakdown- they women will maintain a independent home with the children. Also there is a theory about how young people are taking longer to grow up nowersays so staying home longer is more normal - although the discrepancy in the genders likely due to females being conditioned to be more responsible and mature. Just a guess.

SurfBox · 14/09/2022 09:37

I saw a lot of people sneer at a guy in his 50s that was living with his mum. He had been her carer for years

and yet I know many women of that age who lived with their mothers and nobody ever said anything. Double standard.

Unglamorousgranny · 14/09/2022 09:29

@OrangeFlowersAreLovely what a load of sexist claptrap. So you base your opinion of most men what you read on MN? There is the possibility that MN gives a skewed picture of how the majority of men behave.
You'll only read about the crappy husbands and partners on here as it's a problem to post about.
People are hardly likely to post about their good husbands as there is no problem that requires the advice of other MN members

Mymoneydontjigglejiggle · 14/09/2022 09:20

This is why I always roll of eyes when posters on here are disappointed to find out they are having sons because 'girls are closer to their mums'. These stats very much support my experience that men are far more likely to live at home until much older while women are more independent from earlier on. I've also noticed men are more likely to live closer to their family while women tend to move away when they do move out. Anyway, I once read girls tend to move out earlier because they are expected to do more housework and childcare of younger siblings, while boys aren't. I read that a few years ago so not sure if it's the case now.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 14/09/2022 09:20

Well my ds 28 was at home to save a massive house deposit. He’s going in 2 weeks.

Thats the only reason he was at home. He’s desperate to go!

luxxlisbon · 14/09/2022 09:20

Young women are more likely to be given a council house and middle aged and older men are more likely to have to move out of the family home following a separation.

In my experience in the young 20s bracket men are more likely to go into a trade rather than uni and so are earning much less in the early years as an apprentice. Then it takes a year or two to get on their feet enough financially to move out.

Dotjones · 14/09/2022 09:19

Lots of reasons already mentioned but my list is below. Some of these things might not be "woke" or "PC" but reality often doesn't match our expectations or desires. I think the below are true, but that doesn't automatically mean I think it's a good thing they are true.

a) Men have less reason to move out because they either have more freedom than women living with their parents, or at least care less about the restrictions.
b) Parents are more likely to let their son's partner move in with them than they are to let their daughter's partner move in. So the stats reflect the woman moving out rather than the man.
c) In a relationship breakdown the woman is more likely to remain in the previously-shared home and the man move out.
d) At younger ages women earn more than men. Obviously the average man gets paid more than the average woman, but those figures are skewed by high earning older men. In junior roles women earn more, it's only when their career progresses that men catch up and then take the lead.
e) I've always thought there's some truth in George Orwell's idea about why there are more homeless men than women, that most women are able to "attach" themselves to a man if they need to. I think this idea can be transferred to the living at home situation too. A man sees a woman with no way to support herself and seeks to protect her, a woman sees a man with no way to support himself and sees him as a failure. It's a psychological difference/patriarchal view - society sees women needing male support, but not the other way around.
f) Women have always tended to form relationships with older men (and men form relationships with younger women). Therefore a woman's partner is more likely to have their own home which they can move into than a man's partner is.
g) Women have a different view of the status in having their own home, they place more importance on it. Men place more importance on other things like cars and a big shiny new television.

These reasons generally reflect an ingrained view that women are weaker than men therefore need more protection.

Getoff · 14/09/2022 09:18

I copied the data into a spreadsheet and compared women with men aged three years older, instead of the same age. Only for pairs where women are aged 29 or over and men 34 or over are there more men in their parents home. At all lower ages the discrepancy vanishes.

Namedifferentorquestion · 14/09/2022 09:17

The adult men that I personally know that live with their parents have been shafted by divorce and cannot afford to rent or buy when ex partner has the home. Maintenance costs etc killed by brother. Ex wife took the lot and threatened to stop him from seeing kids - so many sadly use kids as a weapon to bargain with. He had to move in with parents since she took everything and solicitor costs and her threats meant he didn't pursue any part of the home he had paid for (she worked a few hours a week).

Tsort · 14/09/2022 09:15

EndTheMonacyNow · 14/09/2022 06:36

I wondered about the cultural differences too.

Are Young women are keener to start families and to 'homemake' than men?
Whereas males aren't in such a hurry?

Females are more likely to share with older males

I'd like to see the stats on young single mothers and social housing. I had a quick look but couldn't see anything

I could find anything on social housing, but my search took me to the ONS and I thought the following was interesting (it’s all from 2019, though, so I wonder to what extent things will have changed post lockdown):

Married and civil partner couple families remained the most common family type in 2019, representing two-thirds of all families (12.8 million). Cohabiting couple families were the second-largest family type at 3.5 million (18.4%), followed by 2.9 million (14.9%) lone parent families.

The number of people living alone has increased by a fifth over the last 20 years, driven mainly by increases in men aged 45 to 64 years living alone; Scotland has the highest proportion of one-person households at 35.0%, while London has the lowest (23.9%).

Lone parent mothers remained the most common type of lone parents in 2019, accounting for 86% of this family type. However, from 1999 to 2019 the number of lone parent fathers has grown by 22%, while the number of lone parent mothers also increased but at a slower rate (13.4%). These increases are both statistically significant.

Over the last decade to 2019, the number of lone parents with non-dependent children has increased by 17.5%, while the number of lone parents with dependent children has decreased by 9.8%. These changes are both statistically significant.

Reasons for the decrease in lone parent families with dependents may include:

  • more lone parents could be re-partnering
  • the number of births has been declining
  • more women have been postponing childbearing to later years
  • there have been fewer teenage pregnancies

While the increase in lone parents with non-dependent children is likely to be partly driven by the ageing of children who previously were dependents in lone parent families, it could also be as a result of increases in separation at older ages as well as an increasing trend of young adults living with parents.

OP posts:
OrangeFlowersAreLovely · 14/09/2022 09:06

I agree a lot of men have to move back "home" because ex wife has kept the family home with children. Not always but often because he's probably been a shit husband in the first place.

Let's be honest though - a lot of fully grown men are pathetic little man babies who are happy to have their arses wiped and bills paid by another woman, whether it's Mummy or not. Mumsnet has taught me this enormously.

Females in general are more mature and have higher levels of respect for themselves.

Getoff · 14/09/2022 09:05

Actually, we don't need to google statistics, if we know that average age gap in relationships. I think it's about three years?

So in the OP data, just compare woman with men three years older than them. If they're about the same, you have your answer.

For example, 25 year old female is 25%, 28 year-old male is 25%, bang on! Sounds like we have a winner.

One more: 20 year old female 57%, 23 year old male, 56%. Almost identical.

mast0650 · 14/09/2022 09:03

Often people don't move out until they find a partner. It's expensive to live alone and not everyone wants to live with friends. Men have always been older than their partners on average.

Tsort · 14/09/2022 09:01

Outwiththenorm · 14/09/2022 06:26

Aren’t women much, much more likely to be carers for their elderly/disabled parents than men? And often manage to do it while living apart and alongside a whole other household?

This is interesting! I’ll see if I can find any stats.

OP posts:
LuckyLil · 14/09/2022 08:59

I think it's more to do with the complexities of family unit dynamics. Sometimes there's a co dependency where it suits a parent to have the son at home. By brother didn't get his own place til our mum died and was probably ready to move out donkeys years ago but they were dependant on each other. He had nowhere to go and she feared she wouldn't be able to stay in the property on her own be Aude it was too big. She also felt safer having him in the house.

Getoff · 14/09/2022 08:59

If you can google some statistics about how many people are cohabiting with an opposite sex partner, broken down by age, you may be able to prove me right or wrong. (I don't care enough to do it myself.)

Tsort · 14/09/2022 08:57

@SophieIsHereToday My thinking (based on the limited amount I read last night) is that men are diagnosed and receive support, but women are un/misdiagnosed and basically told to get on with it by society and their families. So, they do.

A lifetime of masking. ☹️

OP posts:
Getoff · 14/09/2022 08:55

Haven' t read the thread.

I suspect a lot of the young woman missing from their parents homes are being supported by older, higher-earning men.

Young men are left at home because slightly older and higher-earning women apparently aren't interested in sex enough to do their bit for equality by supporting a younger man they'd like to fuck.