Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Holding off potty training a 3y9m old

168 replies

AmySma1i · 13/09/2022 21:19

Hi, my DD is 3y9m old and isn't showing many signs of being potty trained yet after successful earlier attempts, we've taken a break after a long spell where we've been able to have no pants but to no avail, she recognises far too late with nothing on, and never notices until patterns change in the nappy.

We've got a trip to visit grandparents in Australia in 2 months time and I don't think we'll reliably crack potty training by then if at all. I've decided to go back to just nappies for the trip and the month away and try again when we get back. However she's going to turn 4 years old whilst away and i never thought I'd still have a 4 year old in nappies day and night. Am I making the correct decision holding off or should I give one big final push despite there not being many signs? Any advice as well as general thoughts would be amazing ❤

OP posts:
lurker69 · 14/09/2022 06:36

I'm pretty sure i just annoyed mine into doing it! i was constantly asking 'do you need the toilet?' if they answered no a few times over half an hour- and hour they would be met with 'oh well lets just try anyway!' successful use of the toilet would get a sticker or a smartie something along them lines because sometimes bribery just works!

HappyHappyHermit · 14/09/2022 05:26

It took quite a while for dd to get it, but you just have to keep going. I don't think it will help you to go back into nappies. Is the potty in the lounge? If dd sat on the potty we gave her a chocolate button. If she didn't get there in time we didt punish her or anything but did take our time to take her upstairs, wash and change her. She didn't like having to stop what she was doing to be cleaned up so that also seemed to encourage her. She was also a bit nervous of the toilet to start with so we went with just the potty, but it was one mat in the lounge with us so that it wa really convenient for her. It wasn't lovely having it around, but it needed to be in sight for her to start to get it. I wouldn't bother with any rewards that aren't instant either. She will get there.

StClare101 · 14/09/2022 04:54

Is she constipated? Long term constipation can impact bladder control. My child was 3 years, six months before we could train him for this reason (despite medical supervision for the constipation).

People telling you you are being neglectful are fuck wits who have no idea what it is like to have a child with severe gut and continence issues. Lucky them.

lovelilies · 14/09/2022 04:33

Hit the nail on the head with her being a bright girl. She's got you sussed, dancing the dolly dance of rewards etc when it's just a thing you have to do.
She doesn't want to OP, stop faffing about and negotiating, be calm, kind and firm but matter of fact.
Rip the plaster off. Don't give it much attention. DD you're not wearing nappies now, isn't that great!
If she soils, calmly hand her some clean bottoms and let her get changed , she will soon get bored of it

lovelilies · 14/09/2022 04:25

Read Oh crap potty training. My DS was heading towards 4 and we cracked it in one day (day and night) and he never once had an accident since.
MyDDs were both 2 and were 'easier' but still had accidents for years after PT.
The book is amazing takes the stress right out ( for both of you!)

Perpop · 14/09/2022 04:12

People can be so rude, you are clearly a great parent and trying your best. Keep going, she will get there.

Marvellousmadness · 14/09/2022 04:08

Ps she is way too old for a potty. Those are for babies. Let her use the toilet

Marvellousmadness · 14/09/2022 04:07

A 4 yo in nappies 🤣
Boy, you're in for a world of (rightfully so) judgement

You have 2 months to train her
Get moving
Stop giving up just cuz its hard.

Time to be a parent op

Spudina · 14/09/2022 00:45

We didn’t use a potty at all with DD2 cos nursery didn’t either and I find them grim. There’s no need with a nearly four year old. Just get her a seat and step.

lailamaria · 14/09/2022 00:37

it might seem mean but i think you might be dragging her back and i don't think you want too but you might be doing it unconsciously, it's not like a pushchair situation and you take it out anyway whether walking or not you have to be prepared for accidents but don't preempt them if you get me

MbatataOwl · 13/09/2022 23:47

Why are you using a potty and not a toilet? Pottys are for babies and toddlers, they can't be very comfortable for a 4 year old to sit on. Buy a toilet seat that has a child sized insert attached.

Nat6999 · 13/09/2022 23:34

Ds didn't totally crack it until we went on holiday with my parents, my dad who had bladder problems was going to the toilet every 15 minutes while we were out & about & ds went with him, he was totally dry in 2 days.

AmySma1i · 13/09/2022 23:28

Thank you, when we do try again after other discussions we will try every 15 mins for shorter visits. We did every hour but sat down for quite a time, we tried normal toilet and potty to see if she found one more comfortable, I wouldn't say she was anxious on either

OP posts:
AmySma1i · 13/09/2022 23:01

We want nothing more than to have her out of nappies, for our and her sake. I should add we've an older daughter as well who we trained without issue just after she turned 3 and see none of the signs.

We'll definitely schedule a call with HV, I wasn't sure as you can search and see numbers of these questions online, so I definitely hope we can find the problem to resolve it for her

OP posts:
FantasylandEnthusiast · 13/09/2022 22:54

My DS was 3 years and 8 months when he finally cracked it. We had tried continuously with no avail, and then on this particular occasion he got it straight away. He is however under investigation now for ASD so that may have played a large part in being late to grasp it.

Every hour really isn't enough - I set a timer for 15 minute intervals and sat them on the potty or toilet each time. I have found with both of my DC (nt dd trained at 2) that they both much preferred using the toilet with the seat and step contraption you can get. Both hated the potty, and were much more comfortable and happy to use the big toilet. We set a whole week aside for both of 15 min intervals and used chocolate buttons as rewards for each wee/poo. They both needed slightly different techniques, but once we found what worked for each child, ie the right type of seat, special pants, being excited to pull the flush (😅), they grasped it really quickly. Although DS was definitely late, he was dry with no accidents within 2 days once he cracked it.

It really is a case of making it your complete centre of attention. Don't plan to do anything else. Try 15 min intervals, your child may be ok with 20/30 mins, but one hour at this point is too long. Stay on it until it's done.

TheFairyCaravan · 13/09/2022 22:54

I’m not going to berate you for having an almost 4yo in nappies because if she’s not aware that she’s weeing when she’s sitting on the loo then it sounds like there’s something more going on.

If I were you, I’d give your HV a call. They can be really, really helpful with things like toilet training. It’s all well and good people saying that she should be out of nappies 🙄, I’m sure OP would like nothing more, tbh, but it doesn’t sound like the little girl is deliberately wetting herself to me. She just doesn’t know what’s happening. Not all children are the same.

momtoboys · 13/09/2022 22:53

My opinion may not too popular but here it is. I never really worked on training my sons, it just happened. Mind you, it didn't happen until they were 3 yrs 3 months all 5 of them!) but once they started using the potty they almost never had an accident again. With that being said, I would give it one more shot before you leave. I'll b et it will happen quickly this time around. Enjoy your trip.

AloysiusBear · 13/09/2022 22:43

We've picked out favourite pants and tried pantless, sat on the potty every hour, tried rewards.

She is used to peeing in a nappy with no hesitation. Try taking her more often than hourly at first.

Make sure she isnt drinking purple squash or anything with a lot of sweeteners in.

Make sure she is drinking enough to feel the sensation of needing to go.

Check she isnt mildly chronically constipated - key cause of toileting accidents as it reduces sensation.

Accept there will be accidents. Make her stop what she is doing to change wet pants, take them to the laundry and get fresh ones.

Zogthebiggestdragon · 13/09/2022 22:42

My daughter absolutely refused to go to the toilet until after her fourth birthday. She could go for hours and hours in pants but wanted a nappy on to pee in. Have to say she got so distressed when we tried to get her on the toilet that we just went with it in the end. Yes I tried bribing with sweets, tablet, tv - didn't work! Sometimes nothing does and you can't force a child to sit on the toilet.

Lots of people say their kids are toilet trained but they are actually still having accidents when you ask. There are some very harsh words on this thread about young children who just aren't ready to go to the toilet yet. Try not to worry, give them some time, they will make their own decision and forcing it does no use at all.

ConfusedDottComm · 13/09/2022 22:41

Yabu op if she is turning 4 😳

typingcake · 13/09/2022 22:41

What’s nurseries policy? We didn’t get many signs our boy was ready and every home attempt led to nothing. Then I just started sending him in on pants and trousers with up to 10 changes of clothes! Nursery were amazing about having to change him. And he got it in just over a week. The poos took about 8 weeks longer to finally conquer!

AmySma1i · 13/09/2022 22:38

Thank you it's only the first time she'll be able to properly see grandparents( was a baby the first time) so want her to be having as much time and fun as possible without lots of accidents. I'd love her to do it toilet trained but I just can't see it happening....

OP posts:
lifehappens12 · 13/09/2022 22:36

I was going to echo another poster - we used the oh crap book on my 3 1/2 year old son. We left it late as he wasn't showing any signs and nursery were even not sure when we went for it. So don't be put off by age in some ways it does help as I swear my son actually has good bladder control.

We did bare bum at home for 4 days and then jogging bottoms but no underwear. A few weeks of this before putting the pants on.

As he was older a reward chart helped massively. Not to get anything but to be allowed to pick a sticker and 3 stickers for a poo.

Yes we had accidents and still do. By focusing on the training we also learnt to watch his signals. He regressed recently at nursery and they worked out they were asking him to go to the toilet instead of telling him.

AmySma1i · 13/09/2022 22:36

Thanks again for all these replies, we really gave it everything over the summer with rewards special pants, no clothes a build a bear promise. But we kept having accident after accident and they weren't less frequent. Any toilet visit was due to chance when she was on it and she didn't realise when we cheered and gave rewards that she was successful, we might try and see if our GP has any more advice as it sounds a complete outlier, but I promise there's nothing we haven't consistently tried for 2 months straight.

We probably wouldn't have gone back without the chat with nursery , we sent her in undies but after 3 days they just said she wasn't at all ready in spite of there help and they wanted her in nappies for the ability for her to focus on learning and taking part etc. They've had others they said which they couldn't figure out but it happened like a switch one day.

She is upset by it as her friends don't wear them and is really trying her hardest

OP posts:
ChronicOverthinkr · 13/09/2022 22:29

No, I’m sorry, but at 4 and presuming NT, you don’t wait for “signs”. She is old enough to understand and learn, she just doesn’t want to. You accept that she has to go through a learning process and there will be lots of accidents, she will be uncomfortable, she will learn you’re not going to back down (again) and she’ll crack it. At that age I’d be worried about other children noticing and making fun of her for daytime nappies (nighttime totally different).