Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Holding off potty training a 3y9m old

168 replies

AmySma1i · 13/09/2022 21:19

Hi, my DD is 3y9m old and isn't showing many signs of being potty trained yet after successful earlier attempts, we've taken a break after a long spell where we've been able to have no pants but to no avail, she recognises far too late with nothing on, and never notices until patterns change in the nappy.

We've got a trip to visit grandparents in Australia in 2 months time and I don't think we'll reliably crack potty training by then if at all. I've decided to go back to just nappies for the trip and the month away and try again when we get back. However she's going to turn 4 years old whilst away and i never thought I'd still have a 4 year old in nappies day and night. Am I making the correct decision holding off or should I give one big final push despite there not being many signs? Any advice as well as general thoughts would be amazing ❤

OP posts:
AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 11:53

TheFairyCaravan · 14/09/2022 11:28

Did you miss the bit where OP said that her DD doesn't even realise she's seeing when she's on the toilet?

DS1 was dry, day and night before he was 2, DS2 was 2.5. However, I've worked in nurseries where some children need more support with toilet training because there's more going on than "they just don't want to do it."

It doesn't sound like the OP or her DD are being lazy to me. Quite the opposite in fact.

Definitely are trying every trick in the book to no avail, how did you help those slower at training in nurseries?

OP posts:
NKFell · 14/09/2022 11:49

I would say to crack on and do it, if you need more help as a PP said Eric is great.

Don't worry too much, I once heard Romesh Ranganathan say something like 'you never see a 15 yr old in nappies saying 'just didn't bother learning mate''.

She'll be fine, just really focus and I'm sure she'll get there soon.

Lakalla · 14/09/2022 11:46

You need to do it , this waiting for signs thing doesn’t happen for all children. Just take the nappy’s away stay at home a few days and put the work in she’s old enough to do it.

TheFairyCaravan · 14/09/2022 11:29

*weeing not seeing

TheFairyCaravan · 14/09/2022 11:28

Papershade5 · 14/09/2022 11:20

This is what happens when you leave it too late, they don't want to do it. Unless she hasadditional needs it is disgraceful lazy parenting

Did you miss the bit where OP said that her DD doesn't even realise she's seeing when she's on the toilet?

DS1 was dry, day and night before he was 2, DS2 was 2.5. However, I've worked in nurseries where some children need more support with toilet training because there's more going on than "they just don't want to do it."

It doesn't sound like the OP or her DD are being lazy to me. Quite the opposite in fact.

5YearsLeft · 14/09/2022 11:27

AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 10:59

Thank you, we know our final goal is to start school and thankfully have time to get there due to not being a summer child. She was also late to these at similar times, we're definitely having one more big go at pantless.

My elder daughter trained at the turn of 3 with no issues but is in night pull ups still at 7 as well so best of luck with that and sorry I can't give help for that.

It does make me wonder if there is a genetic thing causing these problems

@AmySma1i , just to answer your question, yes! There’s absolutely a genetic component. A very strong one between sisters. Women with older sisters who have urinary incontinence are 60% more likely to have urinary incontinence themselves. So your older daughter might have trained at 3, but the fact she’s still not night dry at 7 is VERY relevant. Night dryness can be so many things - they don’t make enough of the hormone to tell their kidneys to stop making wee while they sleep, or their bodies don’t wake them enough to wee, or their bladders don’t stretch enough to hold it, or… The Eric site has great information about the physical differences to tell what’s causing night wetness. Here’s that article about the genetic link:
www.webmd.com/urinary-incontinence-oab/news/20041014/urinary-incontinence-runs-in-family

And here’s that useful Eric link about types of night wetness, so you might be able to determine if both your daughters don’t have enough Vasopressin yet (if they’re both still doing huge, dilute wet wees in the bed and not waking immediately):
www.eric.org.uk/Handlers/Download.ashx?IDMF=424dac2d-352a-4e31-80c0-2e55e402fb52

sunglassesonthetable · 14/09/2022 11:22

This is what happens when you leave it too late, they don't want to do it. Unless she hasadditional needs it is disgraceful lazy parenting

please ignore this judgemental bollox OP. You sound on pins about this and have no doubt done your best. Things aren't always straightforward but it will work out in the end. Daffodil

Papershade5 · 14/09/2022 11:20

This is what happens when you leave it too late, they don't want to do it. Unless she hasadditional needs it is disgraceful lazy parenting

RubyJam · 14/09/2022 11:09

Ive trained three , all by age 2.5.

As mine were younger I had potty in the living room with a home made reward chart sellotaped to the wall behind it, so they knew the visible reward was to do with the potty.
They got a sticker after each use and a chocolate button. I kept the chocolate button packet sitting out , high up , so they could see and know there were more to get if they done more pees later.
Also big cheer and “ wow “ when anything was done.

Went cold turkey , no pull ups , just pants straight away.

As your DD is older I wouldn’t use a potty , I’d go straight to the toilet , she needs to be using an actual toilet same as at school / nursery.

Agree with all PP , it’s not about “ signs “ , you just decide to train them and go for it.
All they need is a verbal grasp to be able to say “ yes” when you say have you done a pee pee etc. They don’t need to be coming to you with a full sentence.

Bite the bullet and get it done.

Goldbar · 14/09/2022 11:01

I would crack on with training her but definitely use pull ups on the plane! You don't want an accident there - it's not fair on your DD, the other passengers and the cabin crew. And the toilets on planes can be scary for kids, busy and closed for long periods for take-off, landing and turbulence. On a recent trip, I actually put a pull up on my 4 yo who has been reliably dry for over a year because we missed our take off slot and were stuck on the tarmac for an hour with no access to the toilet and DC wasn't sure they could hold it. I'd always take a few in case of emergencies.

AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 10:59

YukoandHiro · 14/09/2022 10:49

Hi OP, don't let the comment about neglect upset you. My DD had no additional needs but was later to all physical milestones eg not walking til 21 months and jumping til age 3.5. It took me well over 9 months to train her but I had to do it because she's a summer birthday and started school a couple of weeks after she turned 4.
She did have accidents for at least the first term in school. She was scared of doing a poo for a long time and requires lots of support. But we got there.
You just need do ditch the nappies and get on with it. It will happen. It will involve a lot of washing. Take extra clothes everywhere. Bambino Mio pants can be helpful for preventing embarrassing puddles in public but also making sure they're not in pull ups. They get wet but it stops them soaking their trousers and shoes right through.
My 5yo in Year 1 is still in night pull ups though. I have no idea where to start with that. She just doesn't wake to go.

Thank you, we know our final goal is to start school and thankfully have time to get there due to not being a summer child. She was also late to these at similar times, we're definitely having one more big go at pantless.

My elder daughter trained at the turn of 3 with no issues but is in night pull ups still at 7 as well so best of luck with that and sorry I can't give help for that.

It does make me wonder if there is a genetic thing causing these problems

OP posts:
x2boys · 14/09/2022 10:52

YukoandHiro · 14/09/2022 10:49

Hi OP, don't let the comment about neglect upset you. My DD had no additional needs but was later to all physical milestones eg not walking til 21 months and jumping til age 3.5. It took me well over 9 months to train her but I had to do it because she's a summer birthday and started school a couple of weeks after she turned 4.
She did have accidents for at least the first term in school. She was scared of doing a poo for a long time and requires lots of support. But we got there.
You just need do ditch the nappies and get on with it. It will happen. It will involve a lot of washing. Take extra clothes everywhere. Bambino Mio pants can be helpful for preventing embarrassing puddles in public but also making sure they're not in pull ups. They get wet but it stops them soaking their trousers and shoes right through.
My 5yo in Year 1 is still in night pull ups though. I have no idea where to start with that. She just doesn't wake to go.

Being continent at night is not something that can be trained, it's to do with a hormone kicking in ,incidentally, my disabled child was dry at night long before he was dry during the day.

YukoandHiro · 14/09/2022 10:49

Hi OP, don't let the comment about neglect upset you. My DD had no additional needs but was later to all physical milestones eg not walking til 21 months and jumping til age 3.5. It took me well over 9 months to train her but I had to do it because she's a summer birthday and started school a couple of weeks after she turned 4.
She did have accidents for at least the first term in school. She was scared of doing a poo for a long time and requires lots of support. But we got there.
You just need do ditch the nappies and get on with it. It will happen. It will involve a lot of washing. Take extra clothes everywhere. Bambino Mio pants can be helpful for preventing embarrassing puddles in public but also making sure they're not in pull ups. They get wet but it stops them soaking their trousers and shoes right through.
My 5yo in Year 1 is still in night pull ups though. I have no idea where to start with that. She just doesn't wake to go.

AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 10:45

Geneticsbunny · 14/09/2022 10:41

Othere are right in that if she cant feel when she goes then there might be other issues going on. The most likely is constipation, which can stop kids from feeling when they need to go for a wee. The Eric continence website is brilliant and will help you work out different things to try. I would also ask for a gp refereal to continence if you try for the next 2 months and ther are still issues. They usually won't refer on until age 4 anyway.

I've managed to get on and set up another visit in a couple of weeks and we'll see if we can get a referral . I think that's the worry is that there's just no real signs to tick off that she's going to have a chance with it at the moment

OP posts:
AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 10:41

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 14/09/2022 10:36

Was DD premature, @AmySma1i? I think it's very odd to talk about age down to months post 2 yo, unless you need to explain a correction IYSWIM

Hi I didn't know what to put in the title if I'm honest, just to show that she hasn't just turned 3. She wasn't premature, only 9 days early so it's not a different developmental age which is causing her lack of readiness sadly

OP posts:
Geneticsbunny · 14/09/2022 10:41

Othere are right in that if she cant feel when she goes then there might be other issues going on. The most likely is constipation, which can stop kids from feeling when they need to go for a wee. The Eric continence website is brilliant and will help you work out different things to try. I would also ask for a gp refereal to continence if you try for the next 2 months and ther are still issues. They usually won't refer on until age 4 anyway.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 14/09/2022 10:36

Was DD premature, @AmySma1i? I think it's very odd to talk about age down to months post 2 yo, unless you need to explain a correction IYSWIM

x2boys · 14/09/2022 10:35

AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 10:04

Thank you 😊 we're going to try every 15 mins this week evenings and weekend and see where we get. Yesterday though we went through 7 nappies, 4 at nursery and then 3 in the evening at completely random times of the day, and she didn't show any signs of wanting to go before.

We left her overnight nappy on all morning and she didn't notice at all it was completely full until we asked if she'd had a wee.

We will try super encouragement and regular reminders this evening. Put after loads of accidents already this year at nursery they're going to have her in nappies so it will be confusing I worry

Every fifteen minutes is overkill ,I trained my disabled non verbal child at nine ,and we had Set times ,I would remind her regularly, and ask if she needs a wee etc ,take her to the toilet and get her used to sitting down etc ,praise her and make a big fuss of her when she has a wee on the toilet.

AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 10:24

BerriesOnTop · 14/09/2022 10:20

I wouldn't want to be changing nappies/pull ups for a child that big on a long flight

You also don’t want them to have an accident on the plane …

No matter where we get in the next two months unless we can night train it will definitely be pull ups on the plane over in case of accidents. I've avoided using nappy pants at all to avoid confusion in training so I hope that helps if we do succeed before the flight

OP posts:
BerriesOnTop · 14/09/2022 10:20

I wouldn't want to be changing nappies/pull ups for a child that big on a long flight

You also don’t want them to have an accident on the plane …

AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 10:09

BusyMum47 · 14/09/2022 08:33

I feel your pain. Our Summer born son was definitely over 3yrs old before he was reliably dry/clean. We tried several times unsuccessfully & in the end we just pushed through & made it happen, because it had to!

I'd definitely try again in the 2mths you've got before you go away. Bare bum. Towels etc everywhere. Constant trips to the loo. Loads of praise & reward. And a f*ck ton of patience!!

Good luck!!

Thank you, relieved to hear others are past 3 years, we tried all of this through moat of summer for weeks straight with no pants, but didn't get reliably anywhere.

We encourage using the toilets mainly but have potties in 3 separate places around the house as well

OP posts:
AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 10:07

StClare101 · 14/09/2022 04:54

Is she constipated? Long term constipation can impact bladder control. My child was 3 years, six months before we could train him for this reason (despite medical supervision for the constipation).

People telling you you are being neglectful are fuck wits who have no idea what it is like to have a child with severe gut and continence issues. Lucky them.

Thank you , it was three months ago we last spoke to a health professional so will set another chat up to make sure there are no issues

OP posts:
AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 10:05

lovelilies · 14/09/2022 04:25

Read Oh crap potty training. My DS was heading towards 4 and we cracked it in one day (day and night) and he never once had an accident since.
MyDDs were both 2 and were 'easier' but still had accidents for years after PT.
The book is amazing takes the stress right out ( for both of you!)

Heard loads of recommendations for this so will definitely give it a try, thank you

OP posts:
AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 10:04

Perpop · 14/09/2022 04:12

People can be so rude, you are clearly a great parent and trying your best. Keep going, she will get there.

Thank you 😊 we're going to try every 15 mins this week evenings and weekend and see where we get. Yesterday though we went through 7 nappies, 4 at nursery and then 3 in the evening at completely random times of the day, and she didn't show any signs of wanting to go before.

We left her overnight nappy on all morning and she didn't notice at all it was completely full until we asked if she'd had a wee.

We will try super encouragement and regular reminders this evening. Put after loads of accidents already this year at nursery they're going to have her in nappies so it will be confusing I worry

OP posts:
BusyMum47 · 14/09/2022 08:33

I feel your pain. Our Summer born son was definitely over 3yrs old before he was reliably dry/clean. We tried several times unsuccessfully & in the end we just pushed through & made it happen, because it had to!

I'd definitely try again in the 2mths you've got before you go away. Bare bum. Towels etc everywhere. Constant trips to the loo. Loads of praise & reward. And a f*ck ton of patience!!

Good luck!!