Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Holding off potty training a 3y9m old

168 replies

AmySma1i · 13/09/2022 21:19

Hi, my DD is 3y9m old and isn't showing many signs of being potty trained yet after successful earlier attempts, we've taken a break after a long spell where we've been able to have no pants but to no avail, she recognises far too late with nothing on, and never notices until patterns change in the nappy.

We've got a trip to visit grandparents in Australia in 2 months time and I don't think we'll reliably crack potty training by then if at all. I've decided to go back to just nappies for the trip and the month away and try again when we get back. However she's going to turn 4 years old whilst away and i never thought I'd still have a 4 year old in nappies day and night. Am I making the correct decision holding off or should I give one big final push despite there not being many signs? Any advice as well as general thoughts would be amazing ❤

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 14/09/2022 17:01

It sounds like you've tried loads of different things and no luck. I would forget about it for now, put her in nappies and try again when you get back. No harm in starting medical investigations in the meantime. But I wouldn't want to deal with accidents on the long flight, it would be a nightmare to handle wet clothing in hand luggage, and a lot of children are anxious about new/different toilets when they are first trained.

Ignore stupid comments about it being neglectful/too old etc - there's really no huge difference between 3.9 and 4.2 and you have plenty of time to tackle it before school but after you get back.

I think yes, if you'd only given it half hearted gos before then do one more big targeted push now to give her time to go through that adjustment tricky phase before your trip, but that's not the case.

DS2 was 3.8 before he trained. It's been no issue at all. Think about what works for you and DD, not what random people will think.

zingally · 14/09/2022 16:44

I would try again. 2 months is a long time in the life of a pre-schooler, and you've still got a good chunk of time to be dry before your trip.

BlackeyedSusan · 14/09/2022 15:53

Meh, nappies or pull ups are fine. No big deal. She may get it very quickly when she is ready and be reliably dry.

Any hypermobility in the family? Or dyspraxia or autism. All three can make a kid late training as they can have poor interoception. (Bet there are other things as well.)

If she's not showing signs when she turns four see your GP and ask whether you need the enuresis clinic.

Choconut · 14/09/2022 15:47

It sounds like her brain isn't receiving the message that she needs to go - I think that should be checked out.

AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 15:08

StarlingsInTheRoof · 14/09/2022 13:41

Definitely visit the Eric website and push the doctor for a check. A lot of people are saying that a neurotypical child should be fine, but there are many other medical reasons it might not be fine. My kids were out of nappies at 2.5 for one and 4 for the other. It took a lot longer for the one that a psychological withholding issue. We had years of movicol and a lot of accidents in the first year of school still. Yet I am the same parent and did the same things for both.

Yeah we're having similar, both girls are so similar in many ways it makes no sense why training them is so different. The older one only took 2 weeks, and we've been at this for months now 🙄

OP posts:
Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/09/2022 13:45

I do think it's unusual that she can't feel when she goes, I think I would get that checked with a gp.

StarlingsInTheRoof · 14/09/2022 13:41

Definitely visit the Eric website and push the doctor for a check. A lot of people are saying that a neurotypical child should be fine, but there are many other medical reasons it might not be fine. My kids were out of nappies at 2.5 for one and 4 for the other. It took a lot longer for the one that a psychological withholding issue. We had years of movicol and a lot of accidents in the first year of school still. Yet I am the same parent and did the same things for both.

ScavengerHunt · 14/09/2022 13:31

Good luck OP. Interestingly my friend has girls who have all been very hard to train. For her it really was a case of dealing with months of accidents.
I trained all 3 of mine around their 2nd birthdays (using the Oh Crap book) and the 3rd also took months of accidents, but having trained the older two very easily at that age I was determined to crack it. It felt fairly endless at the time but when he was 2.5 and completely accident free and his wee chums at toddler groups etc then still had it all to go through, I was glad I'd stuck at it!

By the way - the big thing in the Oh Crap book is the mindset. You WILL succeed.

AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 13:29

Hugasauras · 14/09/2022 12:33

Is she verbal? What happens when you talk about it?

She's upset about it whenever we talk. There's tears and she says she's really trying bit never knows when it's happening until she sees a change in the nappy. She desperately doesn't want to need them, but understands why

OP posts:
abovedecknotbelow · 14/09/2022 13:20

I held back on Dts training at 3yo because we had to fly to America and it just seemed an added issue to switch them back into nappies for the journey / time difference etc. they were 12 weeks prem. when we got back they were reliably dry in a couple
Of days.

I think at 4 I'd persevere though. What do you mean not as developed? If it's a medical issue just stick with the nappies.

RonObvious · 14/09/2022 13:19

Bloody potty training. So much of it depends on the child, so all the advice in the world can be irrelevant at times. My son was 4.5 - I was getting very nervous about school. We tried everything. We'd always used washable nappies, so it was nothing to do with disposables, tried bare bum time, tried bribes, tried sticker charts - nothing worked. My daughter was just under 2 when she was potty trained, so I had thought we had it cracked, but nope. He would literally poo or pee himself, and then sit there in it - completely unconcerned. Then, when you pointed it out, he would try and deny it. Ugh. Anyhow, sorry for the lack of advice, just wanted to say that it isn't always as straight-forward as some posters on here would have you think! And late potty training isn't always due to "lazy parenting".

Anotherdayanotherdollar · 14/09/2022 13:19

I'd probably look a bit more into constipation and reduced sensation if she isn't even aware that she is weeing. I think 7 nappies at that age is also an awful lot. Are they saturated, or just a bit wet? Has she had any bloods done? Excessive urine production can be a sign of diabetes

Lemons1571 · 14/09/2022 13:17

DS2 never showed any signs. I gave up waiting when he was 3y 3m and went for it. It was a nightmare headfuck but we got there in the end (shudders at the memories).

DS3 was also over 3 when he learnt. Also showed none of the modern “signs”. He hated any over the top praise and bribery. It was far too overwhelming for him. One day he cracked it, the turning point was when he asked that we go away and leave him in the loo so he could relax and get on with it!! Job done.

Dinoteeth · 14/09/2022 13:11

Op I'd put her in pants and stay at home this weekend you've got a long weekend, chocolate buttons for trying the toilet or potty, extra for actually using it.

I'd really try and persevere. Lots of talk about being a big girl and using the toilet. It should click.

StClare101 · 14/09/2022 13:09

Yep my younger child was much easier to train but it still took weeks not days and was completely exhausting. Not all kids get it in two days and anyone who thinks their kids doing so is a reflection of their stellar parenting is an absolute knob!

Funnily enough no one enquires as to whether my kids toilet trained at 2 or 3.

Bunnycat101 · 14/09/2022 13:00

In many ways I think an older child can be harder to train because they’re stubborn but I do think there is a bit of a narrative of ‘my child got it in 2 days’ and people think they’re failing if they doesn’t happen. For both of mine it was a process that took weeks and months before I could just let them crack on and not worry about it. My youngest got it really quickly and then had a 6 week regression where she had loads of accidents. The staff at nursery said it was really common and expected it from the majority of children.

x2boys · 14/09/2022 12:44

NKFell · 14/09/2022 11:49

I would say to crack on and do it, if you need more help as a PP said Eric is great.

Don't worry too much, I once heard Romesh Ranganathan say something like 'you never see a 15 yr old in nappies saying 'just didn't bother learning mate''.

She'll be fine, just really focus and I'm sure she'll get there soon.

Well actually you do I have a disabled child who I got out of nappies at nine or ten and hes the only child in his class in his special school who is toilet trained so I think that comment is quite judgemental
But anyway thats not what this thread is about

x2boys · 14/09/2022 12:40

Belladonnamama · 14/09/2022 11:57

You need to make more of an effort to train her. A nearly 4 year old should not be in nappies. My friends DD is not 2 until November and she is already showing signs of being ready to potty train. I've two DDs myself and they were both trained just after they turned 2.

Well arnt you just the bees knees 🙄

x2boys · 14/09/2022 12:39

Papershade5 · 14/09/2022 11:20

This is what happens when you leave it too late, they don't want to do it. Unless she hasadditional needs it is disgraceful lazy parenting

I mean why post this ,does it make you feel better to be so nasty to a complete stranger ??
If you have nothing nice to say say nothing 🙄

Hugasauras · 14/09/2022 12:33

Is she verbal? What happens when you talk about it?

AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 12:26

5YearsLeft · 14/09/2022 12:11

@AmySma1i Yes, a lack of Vasopressin is what causes children who fully empty their bladders at night. But often the treatment is to wait and see - supplementing with Vasopressin can be difficult and usually it’s reserved for cases of bed wetting that last into the teens. You mention your youngest daughter just doesn’t seem to notice she needs to wee at all - this does sound like something to talk to the doctor about, and you said you now have an appointment in a few weeks. Combined with you saying she’s a bit small for her age but wasn’t pre-mature, and she was behind on physical milestones, it might not be a bad idea to check a few of her hormones via blood test (I know; the thought of a blood test with a 3.75 year old isn’t very pleasant). The GP who has her records and knows her full history will know best. And do check that Eric link, in particular. If your eldest daughter is actually having small wet patches, or waking up soon after weeing, it may not be related to Vasopressin. Good luck! You sound like you’re really trying and you’re nearing your wit’s end. I hope the GP, and some time to grow in the next two months, will maybe help!

Definitely we'll bring all this up, thank you so much for your time

OP posts:
5YearsLeft · 14/09/2022 12:11

@AmySma1i Yes, a lack of Vasopressin is what causes children who fully empty their bladders at night. But often the treatment is to wait and see - supplementing with Vasopressin can be difficult and usually it’s reserved for cases of bed wetting that last into the teens. You mention your youngest daughter just doesn’t seem to notice she needs to wee at all - this does sound like something to talk to the doctor about, and you said you now have an appointment in a few weeks. Combined with you saying she’s a bit small for her age but wasn’t pre-mature, and she was behind on physical milestones, it might not be a bad idea to check a few of her hormones via blood test (I know; the thought of a blood test with a 3.75 year old isn’t very pleasant). The GP who has her records and knows her full history will know best. And do check that Eric link, in particular. If your eldest daughter is actually having small wet patches, or waking up soon after weeing, it may not be related to Vasopressin. Good luck! You sound like you’re really trying and you’re nearing your wit’s end. I hope the GP, and some time to grow in the next two months, will maybe help!

Belladonnamama · 14/09/2022 11:57

You need to make more of an effort to train her. A nearly 4 year old should not be in nappies. My friends DD is not 2 until November and she is already showing signs of being ready to potty train. I've two DDs myself and they were both trained just after they turned 2.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/09/2022 11:56

In your situation I would wait. Long flights and travel without reliable potty training will be a nightmare. Wait till you are back and try again.

AmySma1i · 14/09/2022 11:54

5YearsLeft · 14/09/2022 11:27

@AmySma1i , just to answer your question, yes! There’s absolutely a genetic component. A very strong one between sisters. Women with older sisters who have urinary incontinence are 60% more likely to have urinary incontinence themselves. So your older daughter might have trained at 3, but the fact she’s still not night dry at 7 is VERY relevant. Night dryness can be so many things - they don’t make enough of the hormone to tell their kidneys to stop making wee while they sleep, or their bodies don’t wake them enough to wee, or their bladders don’t stretch enough to hold it, or… The Eric site has great information about the physical differences to tell what’s causing night wetness. Here’s that article about the genetic link:
www.webmd.com/urinary-incontinence-oab/news/20041014/urinary-incontinence-runs-in-family

And here’s that useful Eric link about types of night wetness, so you might be able to determine if both your daughters don’t have enough Vasopressin yet (if they’re both still doing huge, dilute wet wees in the bed and not waking immediately):
www.eric.org.uk/Handlers/Download.ashx?IDMF=424dac2d-352a-4e31-80c0-2e55e402fb52

Thank you so much for all this research sharing, I'll have a read through but what is said does sound like a similar situation

OP posts: