Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Holding off potty training a 3y9m old

168 replies

AmySma1i · 13/09/2022 21:19

Hi, my DD is 3y9m old and isn't showing many signs of being potty trained yet after successful earlier attempts, we've taken a break after a long spell where we've been able to have no pants but to no avail, she recognises far too late with nothing on, and never notices until patterns change in the nappy.

We've got a trip to visit grandparents in Australia in 2 months time and I don't think we'll reliably crack potty training by then if at all. I've decided to go back to just nappies for the trip and the month away and try again when we get back. However she's going to turn 4 years old whilst away and i never thought I'd still have a 4 year old in nappies day and night. Am I making the correct decision holding off or should I give one big final push despite there not being many signs? Any advice as well as general thoughts would be amazing ❤

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
keiley7899 · 30/09/2022 20:28

Goldbar · 14/09/2022 11:01

I would crack on with training her but definitely use pull ups on the plane! You don't want an accident there - it's not fair on your DD, the other passengers and the cabin crew. And the toilets on planes can be scary for kids, busy and closed for long periods for take-off, landing and turbulence. On a recent trip, I actually put a pull up on my 4 yo who has been reliably dry for over a year because we missed our take off slot and were stuck on the tarmac for an hour with no access to the toilet and DC wasn't sure they could hold it. I'd always take a few in case of emergencies.

was your DD/DS alright with you putting a pull up on them on the plane ? my son is 4 and wears a nappy to bed and on long car journeys but gets embarassed being changed infront of others.

JudgeJ · 27/09/2022 19:10

I'm not talking rubbish ,a school cannot refuse to take a child who isn't toilet trained it's illegal

Who should deal with this then? Parents shoild be on the end of the phone and willing to come into school very quickly to deal with their child.

AmySma1i · 27/09/2022 18:35

Hi all, a bit further to these comments we tried the oh crap book that weekend.

We have also tried for longer periods than 3 days we eyed up the summer holiday to no avail, we spent 2 and a half weeks, pantless completely naked whilst it was warm enough but we had no success in doing this, anything that happened on the potty /toilet was purely coincidental and very rare. I wouldn't have questioned it if I felt I hadn't exhausted every option.

We will visit the GP next week, and hopefully this might give some progress in seeing if there is a reason behind this. She is already one of only a few in her nursery class in nappies and I do feel self conscious for her.

We've always tried to make sure she's as developed as possible mentally and physically, she was slower to the physical goals but as sharp as anything with learning so its not a mental block I don't think. We wanted her out by 3 not still in at nearly 4, this definitely isn't the cheap or easy option

OP posts:
maddiemookins16mum · 23/09/2022 12:45

You’ve basically trained your nearly 4 year old to sit in her own waste.
I don’t get the reluctance on MN to keep wains in nappies until well past 3, I bet they’re not in cots, highchairs, sucking from bottles at that age.
Someone on another thread mentioned their goal (for a NT child) was to be potty trained by the day before they started school! Shocking really.

Penguinfeather781 · 23/09/2022 11:52

Quincythequince · 22/09/2022 21:15

No one laughed at him or “got the ick”, anymore than they laughed/were allowed to laugh at the child with spectacles or the one with a walking frame

You have no idea what went on during the day in that class. Bigger kids wee more. A larger volume, and still quite often.

Kids will be able to smell this. Don’t kid yourself that you don’t know what this child (or children) went through. Kids are blunt and unkind and a kid at school in nappies would generally be noticed.

Anyway, how are you privy to this info regarding other kids anyway!

Because he’s a friend of my child and I’m friends with his Mum. My child has disabilities too, we have been known to talk about how school accommodates them. And because when I’m in school for eg assembly or I see him mixing with his peers at birthday parties I use my eyes. How else would I know - you think I set up a spy cam or hide in my kid’s bookbag to observe or something?!

That child is a lovely boy, funny and popular and I genuinely don’t think he’s been bullied because of his disability. His Mum doesn’t think he has. But if he was, that would have been unacceptable. Honestly the person coming across as unkind here is you.

Even if the OPs child has no reason not to be toilet trained (and I have no idea where you get that op only trained for a three day weekend, her previous posts say she’s tried several times before) do you honestly think your posts are helpful or appropriate? Do you think the parent of a child who uses nappies for medical reasons needs to read you pontificating that other kids think their child is icky or smelly?!

Ludwig1 · 23/09/2022 11:09

2 of my kids decided they'd do it when they turned 4. They got it pretty much straight away and there was no issues, just a happy content child with no stress. Follow your child's lead. They will let you know x

Sherrystrull · 23/09/2022 11:04

I agree that you need to try longer than a weekend. We allocated a week and just resigned ourself to the fact we would be carrying a potty everywhere plus a bag with 7 or 8 changes of clothes in. We never did pull ups and our dc learnt over that week that being soiled or wet felt horrible and it was better to use the toilet. Trying then stopping and trying later is not helping. Throw the nappies and pull ups away and just go for it.

Quincythequince · 23/09/2022 09:41

*providing disability aids for children who can’t see properly

Quincythequince · 23/09/2022 09:40

x2boys · 23/09/2022 06:59

I'm not talking rubbish ,a school cannot refuse to take a child who isn't toilet trained it's illegal

No it’s not.
Parent has to be able to prove its a disability, as defined by the Equality act 2010.

Not toilet training a child because you just haven’t done it yet, doesn’t meet that criteria I’m afraid, and will be the case for most kids who aren’t continent yet in mainstream school (rather than those who attend a special needs school).

I was a primary governor for years and am very familiar with this.

It’s amazing how many incontinent kids whose parents wish them to start reception, suddenly became trained when they realise this.

It’s like asking for proving disability did children who can’t see properly, because the parent can’t be arsed to get them glasses!

x2boys · 23/09/2022 06:59

Quincythequince · 22/09/2022 21:08

Yes. Neglect by the parent who hasn’t bothered! Don’t use an extreme example of what a school may be faced with, with what they can/can’t do.

They can say they can’t accommodate such a child due to lack of resources, inadequate facilities etc and there would be nothing anyone could do about it. Except of course train your own child at home and send them in when they won’t suffer the ill effects of incontinence.

Again, this is not applicable to kids with additional needs but mainstream schools aren’t broadbrush expected to manage incontinent children, stop talking rubbish.

I'm not talking rubbish ,a school cannot refuse to take a child who isn't toilet trained it's illegal

Quincythequince · 22/09/2022 22:41

*So is it not spending the time or nerve difficulties

‘DD - no more nappies ok! This is how it’s going to be. Big girl pants and toilet use only. It takes as long as it takes, and mistakes are ok, but the nappies are gone’

Watch this child suddenly be trained in the very near future.

Quincythequince · 22/09/2022 22:39

Dinoteeth · 22/09/2022 22:32

How do you know that the child who hasn't been toilet trained doesn't have other issues like nerve damage?

That's what the mum needs to be sure of that there is no other reason.

I have repeatedly said, barring difficulties. If this child has a problem it’s, fair enough.

But OP gave up after a weekend. Three days! So is not spending the time and helping make it happen, or nerve difficulties 🙄

Three days. Give me a break. I’ve taken longer to break in new shoes.

Dinoteeth · 22/09/2022 22:32

Quincythequince · 22/09/2022 21:16

And Don’t compare glasses, or a disabled child to one who hasn’t been toilet trained.

Really!

How do you know that the child who hasn't been toilet trained doesn't have other issues like nerve damage?

That's what the mum needs to be sure of that there is no other reason.

Quincythequince · 22/09/2022 21:16

And Don’t compare glasses, or a disabled child to one who hasn’t been toilet trained.

Really!

Quincythequince · 22/09/2022 21:15

No one laughed at him or “got the ick”, anymore than they laughed/were allowed to laugh at the child with spectacles or the one with a walking frame

You have no idea what went on during the day in that class. Bigger kids wee more. A larger volume, and still quite often.

Kids will be able to smell this. Don’t kid yourself that you don’t know what this child (or children) went through. Kids are blunt and unkind and a kid at school in nappies would generally be noticed.

Anyway, how are you privy to this info regarding other kids anyway!

Quincythequince · 22/09/2022 21:08

x2boys · 22/09/2022 18:31

Again it's neglect to leave a child wet and or soiled ,so somebody would have to change them
I really dont think there are hordes of children going to school in nappies, it makes no sense assuming ,the child has no medical / disabilities, that they would prefer to be in nappies at 5+

Yes. Neglect by the parent who hasn’t bothered! Don’t use an extreme example of what a school may be faced with, with what they can/can’t do.

They can say they can’t accommodate such a child due to lack of resources, inadequate facilities etc and there would be nothing anyone could do about it. Except of course train your own child at home and send them in when they won’t suffer the ill effects of incontinence.

Again, this is not applicable to kids with additional needs but mainstream schools aren’t broadbrush expected to manage incontinent children, stop talking rubbish.

toddlingtortoise · 22/09/2022 19:21

AmySma1i · 22/09/2022 08:54

Sadly not, we tried all weekend but didn't get anywhere, we've got a GP appointment in 2 weeks and will see if anything comes from that

3 days isn’t enough. You need to be prepared to give it at least a week and expect a gazillion accidents.

Snowpaw · 22/09/2022 19:01

By "try" what do you mean - like describe the weekend and what happened. It might help readers understand the technique you're using and help identify any changes you could make.

Penguinfeather781 · 22/09/2022 18:51

Dinoteeth · 22/09/2022 18:26

Who in a mainstream school should change a child?
And how many schools actually have changing facilities suitable for children (and I don't mean I tiny baby change)

Well in my child’s class there were two in nappies in reception, one still was a couple of years later. No one laughed at him or “got the ick”, anymore than they laughed/were allowed to laugh at the child with spectacles or the one with a walking frame. A TA helped that (neurotypical but with other medical issues) child change his pull up at lunchtime in the disabled toilet. That toilet also has a child - not toddler - changing bench that I know has been used for other children in the past. Not every school will have that obviously but it’s not unheard of!

The answer to who in mainstream school should change a child is a member of staff - teachers can’t be compelled to do it but it’s not uncommon to have it in a TA job description. I’m not arguing it’s easy to accommodate for schools, but it is necessary.

It’s not acceptable to not toilet train your child out of laziness, but it is very possible to have a child age 3 with as yet unknown/undiagnosed medical or disability issues that mean they still need nappies. There’s no need to try and scare/shame the OP about something her child is 11 months away from and in any case the school should accommodate. There is absolutely no way her child is going to get a special school place on continence issues alone, even if OP wanted it, much less if she didn’t. Neither can her child be refused a school place.

YukoandHiro · 22/09/2022 18:45

OP I think you're going to have to commit it a good couple of weeks if you want to make progress. IMO all this "they can do it in a day or two if they're ready" is absolutely bullshit. You've just got to prepared to clean up a lot to w couple of months or more. It's part of the process

x2boys · 22/09/2022 18:31

Dinoteeth · 22/09/2022 18:26

Who in a mainstream school should change a child?
And how many schools actually have changing facilities suitable for children (and I don't mean I tiny baby change)

Again it's neglect to leave a child wet and or soiled ,so somebody would have to change them
I really dont think there are hordes of children going to school in nappies, it makes no sense assuming ,the child has no medical / disabilities, that they would prefer to be in nappies at 5+

Sundayrain · 22/09/2022 18:29

My DC potty trained at 3y3m and I honestly think if we hadn't pressed it then he would have been in nappies by 4. He never did get to the point of wanting to do it, but I didn't want him to be at pre-school in nappies and actually once we did it he was done in 2 weeks, day and night.

Dinoteeth · 22/09/2022 18:26

Who in a mainstream school should change a child?
And how many schools actually have changing facilities suitable for children (and I don't mean I tiny baby change)

Quincythequince · 22/09/2022 16:18

And you think reception kids won’t work out really quickly who is still ‘in nappies’

Why would anybody subject their kid to that, rather than persevere with it simply and clean up for as long as it takes at home.

Quincythequince · 22/09/2022 16:16

Nowhere have I said it’s ok to discriminate against a a child.
So please don’t post as if I’m doubling down on a point I never made.

More and more children are showing up to school unable to hold a knife and fork, who cannot scribble and who are not toilet trained so it is becoming more and more of a problem.

Parents should be doing the hard work - not leaving it to teachers to manage which whilst not taking long of an in itself. can take away five mins for the other 29 kids in a class, multiple times a day. How many teaching/learning minutes collectively are lost because of that?!

That is not ok.

Swipe left for the next trending thread