Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think publishing the video of King Charles getting annoyed when signing a visitors book today is very unkind?

489 replies

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 13/09/2022 20:51

He has lost both parents in a short time frame, had a disagreement with his own son and taken on a very stressful job at the height of grief. AIBU to think this should not have been made public? Most people would lose their temper at a time like that in their own lives. Why publish this?

OP posts:
the80sweregreat · 14/09/2022 11:58

The costs involved. People say to me ' ahh, but if we abolish them the money saved won't go to the people anyway ' as if this makes it ok. How do they know this ?
Or it's only 50 p per person or something: I don't swallow that one at all either. Propaganda.
Agree that all this running about on jets and in cars is a tad unnecessary and then they will go on about climate change!
I was really sad that the Queen died , but she was frail and 96 and probably just tired of it all.
This funeral , the coronation next year , the jubilee pageant this year, it must run into millions ( although the jubilee did raise millions for the economy, so maybe that wasn't as bad )
It's a double edged sword , having them or not having them , but I doubt they are going anywhere for a while.
Plus having every thing done for you must be nice.
He has a temper. I'm not surprised at that.
He won't be as popular as his mum was.
I wouldn't queue up for days to see a coffin , but each to their own.

antelopevalley · 14/09/2022 11:47

It is the second time in days he has got annoyed over something minor. He does not have the temperament to be King.

SleeplessInEngland · 14/09/2022 11:47

I'm rather looking forward to him being king. They'll be so much more of this.

BirdyWoof · 14/09/2022 11:45

Septemberslooming · 14/09/2022 08:21

To say that anyone is talking out of their hole is so rude that I'll simply give the short response of saying that I highlighted how he needs to balance his visits in terms of meeting the great and good and the general public. Neither of us know the story of the elderly people who want to see their King and wait for hours in a vain attempt to do so but to see him having tantrums in a royal palace over a leaking pen and pressing the flesh with a large number of VIPs does him no favours.

It’s not rude. You’ve no qualms about being rude about Charles on here, why should I have any regarding you? You’re giving a short response because you have nothing to say.

He did speak to those at Hillsborough. There was an article yesterday about how he spoke to a lady who brought her Corgi there to see, as an example. He can’t speak to every single person in attendance- he’d be there for weeks if that was the case.

And you say no one knows the story of the elderly who await the King, but you did earlier? Apparently they’d all been waiting since 6am having been wheeled out from nursing homes? So what is it?

At the end of the day, if you’re basing your view on someone over a leaky pen then that’s your prerogative, but I think many of us, Royalist, Republican or somewhere in between, can acknowledge that sometimes humans show human emotions and small things like a leaky pen can push you over the edge a bit.

It honestly just sounds like you’re bitter that you traveled up, waited around and didn’t get a meet and greet moment to brag about to your mates afterwards.

greenhousegal · 14/09/2022 11:24

Someone with more knowledge of the Royal protocols might explain this.

Why is there a need for the new Monarch to race around the Union left right and centre to sign the documents to ascend the throne? I realise that Accession rules apply and he must sign to ascend the throne, but why could the dignitaries of the Union Parliaments or whoever needed to witness it not all come to London together and do it all in one day? I thought all the racing around by Charles was a tad unnecessary. Bring the mountain to Mohammed surely?

But as others have said, it had to be done at breakneck speed lest the peasants revolted and realised what was happening!

Sorry to say it, but the Coronation is just a pageant for the peasants isn't it?

He is King, there could be a simple ceremony in Buck House, Westminster Abbey, wherever to stick the crown on his head, but no it has to be millions more spent on a carnival of crowns and all the attendant security issues all over again.

antelopevalley · 14/09/2022 11:08

The Queen would not have behaved like this. She had decorum.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 14/09/2022 11:06

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/09/2022 10:53

he's had to hold a lot in check so yes the pen gets it!

I don't suppose anyone would comment if just the pen had "got it", but so did a number of staff who are in no position to answer back. At this rate I'd expect the staff losses a new face in the job brings to become a tsunami - and I don't just mean because the Clarence House staff may not be needed now

Worth remembering that back in Golden Jubilee year the Queen lost both her mum and sister within weeks, and did she behave like this? Did she hell ...

Perhaps she would've made a passing comment if a fountain pen had exploded over her and not for the first time.

antelopevalley · 14/09/2022 11:02

MrsFezziwig · 14/09/2022 09:54

Not especially pro- or anti-royalist (would probably be more pro-republican if we didn’t have a history of elevating idiots to high public office) but the staff redundancy terms (not “sacking”) sound pretty reasonable to me compared to some that people have to suffer in the private sector. Given the state of the Queen’s health (which staff will have been much more aware of than the general public), surely they must have seen it coming for a while?

Apart from the more than statutory redundancy money offered, everything else is legally what employers have to do. If you know private firms doing less, then they are acting illegally.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/09/2022 10:53

he's had to hold a lot in check so yes the pen gets it!

I don't suppose anyone would comment if just the pen had "got it", but so did a number of staff who are in no position to answer back. At this rate I'd expect the staff losses a new face in the job brings to become a tsunami - and I don't just mean because the Clarence House staff may not be needed now

Worth remembering that back in Golden Jubilee year the Queen lost both her mum and sister within weeks, and did she behave like this? Did she hell ...

MrsFezziwig · 14/09/2022 09:54

Not especially pro- or anti-royalist (would probably be more pro-republican if we didn’t have a history of elevating idiots to high public office) but the staff redundancy terms (not “sacking”) sound pretty reasonable to me compared to some that people have to suffer in the private sector. Given the state of the Queen’s health (which staff will have been much more aware of than the general public), surely they must have seen it coming for a while?

MrsFezziwig · 14/09/2022 09:44

LobeliaBaggins · 13/09/2022 23:27

Was the sneering comment aimed at me? I commented on that because I highly approve of separate living. I just can't afford it! Thought that was clear.

Not you @LobeliaBaggins ! There had been comments earlier in the thread.

eurochick · 14/09/2022 09:08

Fountain pens don't like air travel. It's the changes in pressure, I assume.

PugInTheHouse · 14/09/2022 08:57

People are overreacting ridiculously. He hardly said anything. He is still grieving and got a bit frustrated, many people would be the same, you just want things to go smoothly at these times. My DH was the same when he lost his mum, just got annoyed by minor things but wasn't badly behaved overall. It's silly to compared to his children when their mother died, he's hardly behaving like that whilst paying his respects, no doubt their behaviour was not good at times (which would be understandable).

I have only ever heard people saying what a lovely person he is (those who actually know him) but because of Princess Diana people have decided they know him better even though they've never met him and will f8ne any fault possible.

I'm not a massive royal family fan, I don't dislike them at all but not an avid follower but just feel people can be extremely unfair.

Novum · 14/09/2022 08:56

Septemberslooming · 13/09/2022 21:19

Terrible behaviour for a man of his age whether mourning or not.
I was at the event in Hillsborough today and I wish he'd spent more time talking with the public, many of them were elderly and had been waiting in the street for hours.

He was on a very tight timetable, I don't see how he could arbitrarily just change that around to spend more time talking. I doubt that anyone going to see him actually expected to be able to talk to him.

Novum · 14/09/2022 08:54

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 14/09/2022 08:19

Ink is a sod to wash off too, not like he can just go and wash his hands to remove it,stays on ages.

I read somewhere that he has an inflammatory condition on his hands. If that's correct, the last thing he needs is to have to scrub ink off, especially with the amount of handshaking he's having to do at the moment.

Septemberslooming · 14/09/2022 08:21

BirdyWoof · 14/09/2022 00:47

No harm but no elderly should have been brought out of nursing homes at 6am to sit and wait for him. That’s just utterly stupid.

You also didn’t have to go, either.

I’m not a fan of Charles by any stretch but you’re talking out of your hole on this one. You’re complaining about how he didn’t spend hours talking to the elderly when he is is probably the same age as those sitting waiting for him. Awful for them to be waiting for hours but totally expected for him to spend the same time waiting around talking to people?

Wise up.

To say that anyone is talking out of their hole is so rude that I'll simply give the short response of saying that I highlighted how he needs to balance his visits in terms of meeting the great and good and the general public. Neither of us know the story of the elderly people who want to see their King and wait for hours in a vain attempt to do so but to see him having tantrums in a royal palace over a leaking pen and pressing the flesh with a large number of VIPs does him no favours.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 14/09/2022 08:19

Ink is a sod to wash off too, not like he can just go and wash his hands to remove it,stays on ages.

Brefugee · 14/09/2022 08:19

I'm guessing (no evidence) that this is a fountain pen that means much to him. Probably passed down through the family? (I have one from my grandad - it leaks so much you can't use it now).
All it needs is a bit of refurbishment probably.

User287264 · 14/09/2022 08:15

Was it his staff who brought the pen with them? Or the staff at Hillsborough who gave him one of theirs?
Either way you'd think giving the King a functioning pen was a pretty basic thing to get right.
Everyone will be triple checking now if they are in charge of pen provision.

W0tnow · 14/09/2022 08:01

I haven’t rtft.

But…ballpoint?

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 14/09/2022 07:58

It was such a non event,I'd have been pissed off too. He got ink all over his hands and had to go and shake everyone's hands afterwards, would piss me off too. He had a bit of a grumble, he didn't tell or throw the pen 🙄

Brefugee · 14/09/2022 07:52

I think what a lot of people find hard to take is the enforced mourning and the absolute lack of respect for any other view than "she was an angel here on earth and poor ol' Charles just lost his mum he's doing his best"

Frankly? Someone (Camilla?) should be stepping in and saying "enough" and cutting down all the stuff he is doing. There is no reason this trip round the UK has to be such a punishing schedule for him. There should be a lot more time to think, reflect and be with his family.

The fact that this plan has been in place for decades - and periodically revised - is the problem. So he needs to suck it up and relax in the evening with a large GnT until it's all over.

The optics of what he has done to his staff - that letter should have been a face to face conversation with whoever sent it - is disgraceful. The fact that it happened to the (appalling) Queen Mother's staff should have been a lesson. They are working overtime to smooth the transition. Yes, they are well aware it's coming - but now? in that way? I hope they're in a good union (I know they aren't).

Charles is a grown man who behaves like a petulant child. He needs to get over himself because he is doing the monarchy no favours here.

Ohpaella · 14/09/2022 07:52

@montysma1 Are you okay?

Ohpaella · 14/09/2022 07:51

He wasn’t spoilt, he had a very cold stern, even cruel, upbringing. From both parents.

InWalksBarberalla · 14/09/2022 07:50

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 13/09/2022 20:51

He has lost both parents in a short time frame, had a disagreement with his own son and taken on a very stressful job at the height of grief. AIBU to think this should not have been made public? Most people would lose their temper at a time like that in their own lives. Why publish this?

Fair enough. Question though - if you saw the same sort of footage of Kim Jong-un just after his father Kim Jong-il died as he took over the very stressful job of Supreme Leader of North Korea- would you have said 'be kind' and asked for the footage not to be shown? Or would you have taken it as further evidence of what a tyrant he is.

The world is watching, and many people from many countries associate the UK royal family with the past brutal system of cololonism and dominance. Charles isn't coming across as the best person for reconciliation.