Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you don't usually work Monday's and now there's an extra bank holiday...

312 replies

Dressme2023 · 13/09/2022 19:23

...would you be bothered?
I'm actually not, I'm getting to see the funeral which is the important bit to me.
However many colleagues have the same day off and are now pushing for an extra half day annual leave to make up for it.
It feels a bit unnecessary and grabby to me but I'm in the minority.
Thoughts?

You're being unreasonable - you should get extra leave granted
You're not being unreasonable - everyone should just accept it for what it is and move on

OP posts:
Cervinia · 16/09/2022 18:08

This is madness, I work Tuesday, Wed, thurs. I went into work on Tuesday and there was an email Waiting confirming my leave balance had been credited with 4.8 hours.

I work 24 hours of a 36 FTE.

This is the correct and fair way.

CurrentHun · 16/09/2022 18:06

Once you’ve read the thread, you might start thinking differently. Its not about your choice of which working weekdays, legally.

elm26 · 16/09/2022 18:02

I only work Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday (my choice) and it's never occurred to me that I'm owed anything from a bank holiday Monday or Friday?

jacostajune · 16/09/2022 17:47

gatehouseoffleet · 16/09/2022 10:48

The law is very clear if full time employees are given additional leave part timers must get the pro rata equivalent

I've never quite understood why this applies to bank holidays though. If you don't work Mondays, you don't work them anyway. I did work part-time before these rules became a thing, and it never occurred to me to think I was hard done by if I missed out on a bank holiday. And you actually end up getting shafted as a part-timer as you get less holiday you can choose yourself, as you need to use so much leave for the bank holidays that you might not actually want to take. I agree the law is contradictory.

That's ridiculous.
Next week I will work four days and get paid for four days as I don't work on Mondays.
My full time colleagues will get paid for 5 days and work four days.
That is not fair.
So I will 4/5 of my daily hours added to my AL allowance to make up for it.

CurrentHun · 16/09/2022 16:05

That’s great you got paid leave of some kind Minnie, and shows it’s worth asking again.
Our HR (public sector) said that it was OK for management not give non-Monday workers the same benefit (of a paid day off) that Monday workers would get, because you can still watch the funeral for the Queen even if you’re doing so unpaid. Hmm

It’s totally beside the point- in no way is it compulsory to watch the funeral for any of our staff- paid on Monday or not. An extra bank holiday perk is being given to some staff and not to others though. That’s clearly unfair. They didn’t do this with the Jubilee bank holiday so I have no idea why they say this one is different. It’s no different.

My colleagues on mat leave are particularly upset. Every day of extra leave makes a massive difference for them. And the rest of us are always working well over our paid hours to keep the service as good as it can be after the pandemic and now staff goodwill has been undermined, pointlessly.

Princessglittery · 16/09/2022 15:10

gatehouseoffleet · 16/09/2022 10:48

The law is very clear if full time employees are given additional leave part timers must get the pro rata equivalent

I've never quite understood why this applies to bank holidays though. If you don't work Mondays, you don't work them anyway. I did work part-time before these rules became a thing, and it never occurred to me to think I was hard done by if I missed out on a bank holiday. And you actually end up getting shafted as a part-timer as you get less holiday you can choose yourself, as you need to use so much leave for the bank holidays that you might not actually want to take. I agree the law is contradictory.

The law is not contradictory.

The law gives you 5.6 weeks leave which may include BH.
The law also states an employer can specify when you take your leave. Many employers specify closed on BH so deduct these from leave allowance upfront. If you have a NWD on a BH you don’t get the leave deducted.

Remember CD, Boxing Day and NYD can fall on any day of the week.

Mummyme87 · 16/09/2022 13:38

I work in the nhs, shiftnworker, I don’t do Mondays, I’ll get 7.5hrs added to my annual leave. However, that’s how all the BH get given to us, our service is 24/7

MinnieMountain · 16/09/2022 13:29

Well I have been given time off in lieu after a discussion with our HR officer. But “we want to keep you happy” seems to have been what’s swung it. And I can’t tell anyone as she’s also had people moaning that they can’t do much with their day off.

FlippertyGibberts · 16/09/2022 12:08

gatehouseoffleet · 16/09/2022 10:48

The law is very clear if full time employees are given additional leave part timers must get the pro rata equivalent

I've never quite understood why this applies to bank holidays though. If you don't work Mondays, you don't work them anyway. I did work part-time before these rules became a thing, and it never occurred to me to think I was hard done by if I missed out on a bank holiday. And you actually end up getting shafted as a part-timer as you get less holiday you can choose yourself, as you need to use so much leave for the bank holidays that you might not actually want to take. I agree the law is contradictory.

Part-time staff aren't shafted by this at all. You're given the AL hours as extra and then take them off on bank holidays when you should be working. It's simply for AL accounting.

gatehouseoffleet · 16/09/2022 10:48

The law is very clear if full time employees are given additional leave part timers must get the pro rata equivalent

I've never quite understood why this applies to bank holidays though. If you don't work Mondays, you don't work them anyway. I did work part-time before these rules became a thing, and it never occurred to me to think I was hard done by if I missed out on a bank holiday. And you actually end up getting shafted as a part-timer as you get less holiday you can choose yourself, as you need to use so much leave for the bank holidays that you might not actually want to take. I agree the law is contradictory.

CurrentHun · 15/09/2022 18:55

www.acas.org.uk/acas-advice-for-the-queens-funeral-bank-holiday

ACAS have given some advice to employers. Unfortunately it doesn’t address the discrimination issue of this thread. Just talks about what employers should do for the individual employee.. not for fairness between employees.

Aprilx · 15/09/2022 13:02

willithappen · 15/09/2022 10:21

Also seem to be largely leaving out the fact that it's down to whether employers recognise the bank holidays in contracts

Literally nobody is ignoring that, it is perhaps you that is not reading carefully enough.

This thread is about the scenario where full time staff have been given an extra day of leave whereas part time staff have not.

Aprilx · 15/09/2022 13:00

willithappen · 15/09/2022 07:51

*"The point of this thread is that employers legally can't let those that usually work on Monday have paid leave but then not give the equivalent to those that don't work on Mondays."
*
Again that's not the case. The law on this is actually quite contradictory in places

My workplace is not giving those who don't work a Monday any extra day off for that. As it should be.

Nope that is how it shouldn’t be and if somebody challenged them in a tribunal, your employer would lose. Your employer is treating some workers less favourably if they are giving some an extra day of leave but not others.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 15/09/2022 11:36

Many of the people getting Monday off won't be watching the funeral and will be treating it like a nice day off to sleep on, do family stuff or meet up with friends.

That'll be DH!

Arbesque · 15/09/2022 10:58

Many of the people getting Monday off won't be watching the funeral and will be treating it like a nice day off to sleep on, do family stuff or meet up with friends.

I can perfectly understand people who aren't paid on Mondays to feel a bit aggrieved and expect time off in lieu.

jacostajune · 15/09/2022 10:48

Esmereldapawpatrol · 15/09/2022 10:43

In our business (small company) if you don't usually work Mondays you get an extra day off in lieu for Monday as it's classed as a bank holiday. The standard practice is to get days that are bank holidays back if you don't work them as otherwise the fulltime members of staff are benefitting and the part timers aren't.

All the reasonable people understand this, and it's the law. But there seem to be a lot of people on here who really don't understand that Monday has been declared a BH with the same legal status as all the other BHs and if you can't be at home watching the funeral and being sad then tough luck to you.

Esmereldapawpatrol · 15/09/2022 10:43

In our business (small company) if you don't usually work Mondays you get an extra day off in lieu for Monday as it's classed as a bank holiday. The standard practice is to get days that are bank holidays back if you don't work them as otherwise the fulltime members of staff are benefitting and the part timers aren't.

jacostajune · 15/09/2022 10:36

willithappen · 15/09/2022 10:21

Also seem to be largely leaving out the fact that it's down to whether employers recognise the bank holidays in contracts

Again, if they do, then all staff have to be treated equitably. If they don't, they have to treat all staff equitably.

jacostajune · 15/09/2022 10:34

willithappen · 15/09/2022 10:20

Except it's not though is it when multiple large employers are not providing it as an extra day off

Why should someone who works less hours or different days get given this as an extra day to take whenever they fancy and is suitable to them and those working on the day are forced to take it now

Either way, it's a bank holiday for one day (won't be there next year) and for the sole purpose of the queens funeral. If you are arguing to try get a day off because you are already off on the funeral then you are in fact grabby.

Because it's the law

christmas2022 · 15/09/2022 10:28

Woodsparrow · 15/09/2022 10:27

I'm the only one in my office who doesn't work a Monday. I wasn't expecting anything but my boss kindly offered to pay me for Monday next week sine everyone else would be paid for it and he wanted to be fair. I've taken his offer but not telling anyone else, while he sees it as fair te others in the office won't

No that isn't fair on the full time employees.

Pro rata payment would have been more fair.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 15/09/2022 10:27

willithappen · 15/09/2022 10:20

Except it's not though is it when multiple large employers are not providing it as an extra day off

Why should someone who works less hours or different days get given this as an extra day to take whenever they fancy and is suitable to them and those working on the day are forced to take it now

Either way, it's a bank holiday for one day (won't be there next year) and for the sole purpose of the queens funeral. If you are arguing to try get a day off because you are already off on the funeral then you are in fact grabby.

Multiple large employers not providing it as a day off doesn't mean it isn't legally identical to other bank holidays. That doesn't prove what you think it does. It simply means that either those employers don't give bank holidays as a day off anyway. And the fact that this is largely down to whether employers recognise bank holidays in contracts is entirely the point.

I'm actually on sick leave myself at the moment, so in my case the point is moot, but you appear to have confused 'fact' with 'what you think'. By all means feel it's unfair, I think bank holidays are quite inequitable generally so of course a short notice one is going to be that, but again none of this changes the fundamental point that this bank holiday has the exact same legal status as all the others and so employers can either treat it in the same way or they can break the law.

Woodsparrow · 15/09/2022 10:27

I'm the only one in my office who doesn't work a Monday. I wasn't expecting anything but my boss kindly offered to pay me for Monday next week sine everyone else would be paid for it and he wanted to be fair. I've taken his offer but not telling anyone else, while he sees it as fair te others in the office won't

christmas2022 · 15/09/2022 10:27

Clearly this discussion is only applicable to contracts where holiday plus bank holidays are recognised.

Princessglittery · 15/09/2022 10:23

willithappen · 15/09/2022 10:21

Also seem to be largely leaving out the fact that it's down to whether employers recognise the bank holidays in contracts

Correct

christmas2022 · 15/09/2022 10:23

willithappen · 15/09/2022 10:20

Except it's not though is it when multiple large employers are not providing it as an extra day off

Why should someone who works less hours or different days get given this as an extra day to take whenever they fancy and is suitable to them and those working on the day are forced to take it now

Either way, it's a bank holiday for one day (won't be there next year) and for the sole purpose of the queens funeral. If you are arguing to try get a day off because you are already off on the funeral then you are in fact grabby.

Completely disagree.

How is that fair on the people that end up with extra paid time off due to the bank holiday?

Fair and equitable treatment of all. Part time workers are not second class employees and should not be treated as such.

Grabby? Have a word with yourself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread