Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you don't usually work Monday's and now there's an extra bank holiday...

312 replies

Dressme2023 · 13/09/2022 19:23

...would you be bothered?
I'm actually not, I'm getting to see the funeral which is the important bit to me.
However many colleagues have the same day off and are now pushing for an extra half day annual leave to make up for it.
It feels a bit unnecessary and grabby to me but I'm in the minority.
Thoughts?

You're being unreasonable - you should get extra leave granted
You're not being unreasonable - everyone should just accept it for what it is and move on

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FlippertyGibberts · 17/09/2022 22:45

I agree with previous posters - part-time staff should have their AL awarded in hours to ensure that this is fair.

Princessglittery · 17/09/2022 22:34

@TroysMammy I thought that might be the case but it’s not as bad as you think because you work long hours on Thu & Fri. If you take all 3 days in one week it balances out. If you only take leave on a Wednesday you lose out but you gain if you only take a Thu or Fri.

The way to explain it to your HR is you are entitled to 180.75 of paid leave. If you are only paid for 5.5 hours on a Wednesday they can only deduct 5.5 hours paid leave. The opposite applies to Thu & Fri where you are paid 9.75 hours so lose 9.75 hours paid leave.

This is why the only fair way to calculate your leave is in hours.

TroysMammy · 17/09/2022 22:16

@Princessglittery but we've been taking the Wednesday half day as a full day holiday so if we take a week off we use 3 days holiday. What you said about the Wednesday, this was happening when the person I replaced started with us. A stop was put to that because that was deemed wrong as I who worked each morning 7.45am to 1.15pm was having my holidays as days (they were too) so for each half day I worked I was to take the full day as a holiday and it was decided they should too. I reckon the person I replaced left because she wasn't getting the correct holidays. The more I read into this the more undervalued and shafted I feel. There have been other occasions of unfairness that still rankles after about 4 years.

Anyway thank you for your kind assistance I now have more ammo to put my point across.

Princessglittery · 17/09/2022 21:45

@TroysMammy
Here are your calculations
Full time =

  • 5 days a week
  • 8 hours net a day
  • 40 hours net a week
  • 20 days leave x 8 hours = 160 hours
  • 8 BH x 8 hours (2023) = 64 hours
2023 = typical year
  • Total gross leave (2023) = 224 hours
  • Less 64 hours for BH
  • Total net leave (2023) = 160

2022 = unusual year

  • 10 BH x 8 hours = 80 hours 2022
  • Total gross leave =160 hours
  • Less 80 hours for BH
  • Total net leave (2022) = 160 hours
TroysMammy
  • 3 days a week
  • Wed PM = 5.5 hours
  • Thu & Fri 9.75 hours = 25 hours net per week
  • Leave 160 hours/40 x 25 = 100 hours
  • BH 64 /40 x 25 = 40 hours
2023 = typical year
  • Total Gross leave = 200 hours
  • Less BH (2023) falling on a working day
NYD Mon = 0 GF Fri = 9.75 EM Mon = 0 MD Mon = 0 SBH Mon = 0 ABH Mon = 0 CD Mon = 0 BD Tue = 0 Total = 9.75
  • Net leave (2023) 200 - 9.75 = 190.25 hours

2022 = unusual year

  • 10 BH x 8 hours = 80 hours/40 x 25 = 50 hours
  • Total Gross leave = 210 hours
  • Less BH (2023) falling on a working day
NYD Mon = 0 GF Fri = 9.75 MD Mon = 0 JD Thu = 9.75 SBH Fri = 9.75 ABH Mon = 0 CD Mon = 0 BD Tue = 0 Total = 29.25
  • Net leave (2022) 210 - 29.25 = 180.75 hours
BH NYD New Years Day GF Good Friday EM Easter Monday MD May Day SBH Spring BH ABH August BH CD Christmas Day BD Boxing Day

Each time you take a days leave on a Wednesday deduct 5.5 hours. Leave on Thursday or Friday deduct 9.75.

When a BH falls on a Wednesday deduct 5.5 hours.

TroysMammy · 17/09/2022 20:10

@Princessglittery I'm not bothered if I get less holidays if it is booked in hours. I just want it to be fair and feel more valued in the workplace.

TroysMammy · 17/09/2022 20:06

@Princessglittery work 9-6, 1 hour unpaid lunch break so 40 hours a week.

Princessglittery · 17/09/2022 18:52

@TroysMammy one last question how many net hours do full time employees work i.e. do they have 30 mins unpaid lunch so work a 7.5 hour day?

Princessglittery · 17/09/2022 18:47

@TroysMammy ues your getting it.

The only thing I would say is you work one short day and two long days. You should really have your leave calculated in hours but I’m not sure it would be in your favour to point this out.

TroysMammy · 17/09/2022 18:28

Mrs? more

TroysMammy · 17/09/2022 18:27

I think I'm sort of getting it now as I used Gov website using condensed hours. Full timer gets minimum statutory holidays 20 days including bank holidays - 28 days.
My entitlement calculated in hours would be 14 days which in line with full timer would include pro rata bank holidays. This year I had 3 so would have had 11 days to book when I please. Next year only one bank holiday on a Friday so I can book 13 days when I please. In subsequent years when bank holidays, Christmas, Boxing and New Years Days land on the days I work I'll get less holidays to book when I choose.I

I remember being told by colleague when I changed working pattern you get 14 days including bank holidays. So including pro rata bank holidays of 3 they should have been included within the 14 days entitlement and not on top as she and previous manager have interpreted. I knew I was given the shitty end of the stick again but I have also had Mrs holidays than I was entitled to but not as many as my colleague.

I've got no problem with her being off on a bank holiday as the business is closed but she should either not get it paid, work another day in the week and get paid or get paid and have the day off and get less holidays when she chooses.

coldcaff · 17/09/2022 18:04

I don't work Mondays. We close for all bank holidays and usually for those that fall on a Monday I get an extra day annual leave entitlement. I'm not for this one though, it's just tough luck. I'm not overly bothered but I do think it's not particularly fair. Those who work Mondays are being paid as usual for the day off. We don't get to choose our working pattern, it's about the needs of the business, so doesn't seem fair for some of us to lose out.

TroysMammy · 17/09/2022 17:58

@Princessglittery Wednesday 5 1/2 hours, Thursday and Friday 9 3/4 hours both days.

TroysMammy · 17/09/2022 17:53

@Princessglittery no full timer 5 days a week, 40 hours gets 20 days holiday and 8 days Bank Holiday a year. I've told her with her length of service what she could get but she's not bothered!. Other part timer works every morning, 26 1/4 hours a week also gets 20 days and 8 days Bank Holiday. I don't know who they used for HR but it must have been a Mickey Mouse company. I think new Manager is going to do things differently next year but there will be no recompense. So what's done is done.

raffegiraffe · 17/09/2022 16:43

I don't work Mondays so I have all Monday bhols added to my leave as they are paid days off. I am actually working this one so will get an extra day in lieu

MinnieMountain · 17/09/2022 15:30

@roarfeckingroarr how many people do you think are actually going to use it to watch the funeral? Quite rightly nobody can be made to, hence it has to be a statutory bank holiday.

I know not all my colleagues who work Monday-Friday will be watching.

Princessglittery · 17/09/2022 12:45

@roarfeckingroarr how would you feel if your employer said to all staff - if Monday is your normal working day we will pay you a one of bonus of £150, if it is your non-working day you will get £0. Is it grabby for those whose non-working day is a Monday to ask for the same?

jacostajune · 17/09/2022 12:35

roarfeckingroarr · 17/09/2022 12:21

@jacostajune not what I meant. If it's your legal entitlement then sure. In principle, I don't see why anyone who isn't at work should have an extra day off for what isn't a standard BH but a day given for a specific purpose

It is a standard bank holiday. The .gov.uk website makes it clear that it should be treated like every other BH. It's very clear.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 17/09/2022 12:31

roarfeckingroarr · 17/09/2022 12:21

@jacostajune not what I meant. If it's your legal entitlement then sure. In principle, I don't see why anyone who isn't at work should have an extra day off for what isn't a standard BH but a day given for a specific purpose

It is a standard BH.

If people want to argue that it should be treated differently to other bank holidays, that's fine, but that means arguing that it shouldn't have been a bank holiday at all.

roarfeckingroarr · 17/09/2022 12:21

@jacostajune not what I meant. If it's your legal entitlement then sure. In principle, I don't see why anyone who isn't at work should have an extra day off for what isn't a standard BH but a day given for a specific purpose

jacostajune · 17/09/2022 11:57

@roarfeckingroarr nothing grabby about wanting your legal rights to be upheld.

roarfeckingroarr · 17/09/2022 11:53

I think it's grabby when the point of the day is to enable people to watch the funeral if they wish. If you're not working anyway, there's no need for you to have additional time off.

jacostajune · 17/09/2022 10:26

LittlePet · 17/09/2022 10:00

No, definitely I wouldn't ask for time off in lieu (I work a half day on Monday but even if it was my full day off I wouldn't).
In this instance it is a day off to watch the funeral and reflect if you wish to - you have that opportunity whether you are paid or not.

Whatever the reason for it it's an official bank holiday and must be treated as such as had been explained over and over again. It makes no difference AT ALL if people watch the funeral / paint their house / watch Netflix all day, everyone is entitled to be treated the same re BH leave / pay!!!

Aprilx · 17/09/2022 10:13

TroysMammy · 17/09/2022 09:28

@Aprilx both work 25 hours a week
Colleague Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday morning 14 days leave, pro rata bank holidays 3. As bank holidays Monday and Tuesday gets those days off as well. Good Friday and Jubilee Bank Holidays rostered off not paid. Therefore in total this year 21 days off paid.
Me Wednesday pm, Thursday, Friday. 14 days leave, pro rata bank holidays 3 days taken Good Friday, Jubilee Bank Holiday. Other Bank Holidays rostered off but not paid. Therefore in total this year 17 days off paid.

This has been the case for a couple of years when I switched my part time working pattern from 5 mornings to 2 1/2 days. No contract given with regard to the switch.

I think to get better clarity in your own mind you need to look at it slightly differently.

So first step, consider bank holidays and leave all in one leave pot. You are entitled to 50% of what a full time worker in the same role receives. So if they receive, let’s say 24 days plus 8 bank holidays, that is a pot of 32 days and it means you are entitled to 16 days, as is your colleague that works 50% same as you.

As a second step, now bring the bank holidays into it. Employers are allowed to tell staff when they can take their leave. So for the full time workers they are saying, you need to use up 8 days of your 32 day leave pot on the bank holidays.

For the part time workers, the employer can also tell them to use up some of the leave pot on bank holidays. So a PT worker that works Mon - Wed needs to use up some of their 16 days of leave (per my example) on bank holidays same as the full time workers do. A PT that does not work on Mondays does not need to allocate their leave to BHs because they don’t work that day anyway. So that person ends up with more freedom as to when to use their leave, but still gets the exact amount of leave as somebody that works Mondays.

I am a part time worker too, 60% and I don’t work Mondays. My leave entitlement for next year is 20 days (calculated as 60% of 25+8BHs). Only one of my working days next year falls on a bank holiday, Good Friday, so I have to use one of my 20 days for that and the other 19 I get to choose. On another year, I might only get to pick and choose say, 16 days because more bank holidays fall on my working days. That is why it needs to be worked out via the two step approach above, rather than as a %.

LittlePet · 17/09/2022 10:00

No, definitely I wouldn't ask for time off in lieu (I work a half day on Monday but even if it was my full day off I wouldn't).
In this instance it is a day off to watch the funeral and reflect if you wish to - you have that opportunity whether you are paid or not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread