Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Period of mourning has sent some people batshit?

237 replies

LimpBiskit · 13/09/2022 17:45

I've noticed a ramping up of crazy on here over the last few days with some odd threads. Also more fratchy interactions on more balanced ones. AIBU that the queen's death has destabilised things a bit?

OP posts:
LucilleDarlingtonUnexpectedly · 15/09/2022 23:46

She’s been a constant presence in most people’s lives. It does feel like a loss for a lot of people.
Also if the Queen can die, we can all die. It’s confronting people with the reality of the finiteness of their own lives. Even if it’s subconscious.

gnilliwdog · 15/09/2022 23:45

@Diverseopinions That's interesting to hear. I suppose I do think of mothers I have met who skip meals so their children can eat. Or have no money on the meter for electricity for several days. Or go to foodbanks. I am sure they would get the spirit of the queen's passing, but perhaps not have much spare energy to be overcome by grief or tears. I am not thinking it's only the well off who can afford to mourn, more that the truly desperate maybe cannot. There are more and more of those people in our society now. I think you are probably right that the older generations have a longer memory of the queen that would include her more active years, so they are likely to feel more deeply.

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/09/2022 23:43

@lightisnotwhite

I also think it’s fine to go “batshit” if that’s what this is. It’s quiet, respectful and hurts no one.

Well... up to a point. But not if you require everyone else in an island of 68 million people also to go equally batshit or risk being accused of sedition. Which is kind of how it feels if you're not totally bought into all this...

lightisnotwhite · 15/09/2022 23:40

Diverseopinions · 15/09/2022 23:06

I think it's like watching a play - you have to buy into the symbolism and emotionally connect to it in order to be moved. You know, from your seat on the balcony, that you are looking at props, actors saying lines and understanding a context which stands for something greater. With royal events, you suspend cynicism.

You can say after a play: "But that was a plasterboard wall which somebody wheeled off, and it was that man from 'Killing Eve'," but it's actually perfectly possible to enjoy theatre, if you have seen a few live plays, when at school and got into the hang of it.

Sure, for some the theatre experience may be alien. But it's disingenuous to express that it's inconceivable how vast numbers of people can join in official mourning for a monarch who played a symbolic role for 70 years.

Even the Christmas Day message was meaningful. Royalty visited Grenfall and, before that, Aberfan. They did connect events to meaningful reflection and they did mark what was spiritually important to people.

We have so much celebration and fuss over sportspeople and their achievement, that it's obviously within the human psyche to go a bit wild on occasions: it's within the range of normal, rather than being batshit.

yeah this.
I also think it’s fine to go “batshit” if that’s what this is. It’s quiet, respectful and hurts no one.

Diverseopinions · 15/09/2022 23:31

Whether you mourn might depend on your age. Older people might feel that the Queen has been with the population through some hard times and they might get a sense of royalty caring, based on what their memory tells them. A lot have people have expressed that their feelings are to do with the Queen always having been there, throughout their lives.

I also thinking mourning is a strange word. People probably feel sad in spurts. I don't think what they feel will be deep and continuous grief. Also, a funeral and the build up is a celebration of a life. People who queue up might want to celebrate a life.

I don't think you'd go and queue up for thirty hours if you had pressing problems at home. I certainly wouldn't be spending hours in a queue, although I can understand how some people will.

I suppose the circumstance of not eating anything at all for days must be an occasional one, as you would usually have to eat something to live . I certainly know what it is like not to have been able to have put the heating on in winter, some days, and to have felt very cold, sometimes, when living on my own, and I can still say that I appreciate the Queen - and so I don't think it is just the comfortably off who get the spirit of the last week.

Endlesssummer2022 · 15/09/2022 23:30

The same people who insist we must all wear black, mourn and have no fun are the same who enjoyed the Covid restrictions and never wanted the schools to reopen. They are really lucky this year because they can roll straight from this into their November role as the Poppy police.

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/09/2022 23:22

The hysteria and the polarisation is starting to disturb me a bit.

I'm not a royalist nor a hardline Republican. I have a pragmatic tolerance of the Royal Family, although I was a fan of the Queen as an individual I instinctively feel that its not a progressive institution and would be fine if it was phased out. So I'm pretty on the fence about the whole thing but I am REALLY tired of not being able to read about anything else in the papers, and of being told not to say anything that questions the validity of the institution.

I was taken aside at work earlier today because I expressed this view (in pretty mild and inoffensive language).

It does genuinely disturb me that in a constitutional democracy no discussion about the merits of the Royal Family is brooked because of this "period of mourning".

I absolutely respect that some people feel genuinely bereaved and I respect their right to mourn as they see fit. I wouldn't personally go down to queue to see the coffin but I'm very happy for others to and I would never be openly disrespectful or scornful of this. But when people tell me I'm not allowed to question the validity of the Royal Family in a public setting it does give me the heeby jeebies. I will be glad when this is all over.

Roxy69 · 15/09/2022 23:18

You are right, it is too late. No going back now to any kind of normal, rational behaviours.

gnilliwdog · 15/09/2022 23:10

I wonder if the people who can afford to mourn are those who are not worried about their immediate survival? Are you more likely to be crying if you know you have a warm home and dinner than if you are unable to pay your bills and have not eaten for a few days so you could feed your children instead?

Diverseopinions · 15/09/2022 23:06

I think it's like watching a play - you have to buy into the symbolism and emotionally connect to it in order to be moved. You know, from your seat on the balcony, that you are looking at props, actors saying lines and understanding a context which stands for something greater. With royal events, you suspend cynicism.

You can say after a play: "But that was a plasterboard wall which somebody wheeled off, and it was that man from 'Killing Eve'," but it's actually perfectly possible to enjoy theatre, if you have seen a few live plays, when at school and got into the hang of it.

Sure, for some the theatre experience may be alien. But it's disingenuous to express that it's inconceivable how vast numbers of people can join in official mourning for a monarch who played a symbolic role for 70 years.

Even the Christmas Day message was meaningful. Royalty visited Grenfall and, before that, Aberfan. They did connect events to meaningful reflection and they did mark what was spiritually important to people.

We have so much celebration and fuss over sportspeople and their achievement, that it's obviously within the human psyche to go a bit wild on occasions: it's within the range of normal, rather than being batshit.

user1499128287 · 15/09/2022 22:47

The media are all so far up establishment arse that they can't breathe! Total sycophancy making us all look batshit bonkers. Thanks a lot, BBC idiots.

Booklover3 · 15/09/2022 22:29

RedheadIreland · 15/09/2022 21:23

Not English so this is all quite interesting to observe from a relative distance, over the water, but I am finding it a bit hard to understand the need of so many people to grieve or mourn for someone they have never met, I can't really work out how she has impacted the day to day lives ofost people. yes it's sad that someone has died but really is it going to impact a normal family in some massive way? Genuinely intrigued by it all, was trying to work out if we would have an equivalent reaction for someone and came up empty 🤔 it is interesting to see the drama of it all with the family etc

I think it's more that she’s just always been there… it’s the symbolism. Literally the only constant thing I can think of from my birth till her death. She did the vast majority of speeches and visits etc. When I think of the monarchy I think of her… I don’t think of the new King or the extended royals. Her picture / symbolism is everywhere. On our money, stamps, old post boxes… and probably more I’ve forgotten.

I’m not a royalist but I did respect her mostly. I don’t respect any of the other royals particularly. I don’t think they will ever be able to live up to her if I’m honest. She was very devoted. I’ve not had to sing the national anthem since she passed and I don’t know how I’ll feel about that… “God save the King…” just doesn’t feel right.

I’m not crying into my coffee or depressed over it. Just a bit sad.

RedheadIreland · 15/09/2022 21:23

Not English so this is all quite interesting to observe from a relative distance, over the water, but I am finding it a bit hard to understand the need of so many people to grieve or mourn for someone they have never met, I can't really work out how she has impacted the day to day lives ofost people. yes it's sad that someone has died but really is it going to impact a normal family in some massive way? Genuinely intrigued by it all, was trying to work out if we would have an equivalent reaction for someone and came up empty 🤔 it is interesting to see the drama of it all with the family etc

Diverseopinions · 15/09/2022 19:41

The Royal Family set a good example of not being pushed over the edge. They soldier on. I read about Prince Philip's childhood and it wasn't an easy one. I feel that thinking of the Queen doing her duty and seeing the other royals doing the job with courage and stoicism tends to make people decide not to haywire, when problems loom.

The continuity and constancy of this week's ceremonies tend to affirm the quiet power of 'keeping calm and carrying on'. We read a lot about the wartime spirit. Well Princess Elizabeth was there - in London. Her death reminds people of that. My parents were in London during WW2. They'd see atrocities, but carried on. I find that times like these bring about a sense of calm and renewed determination to do one's best.

Some people find the Queen an inspiration and a strength.

xmaswiththeinlaws · 15/09/2022 13:13

Last week I was initially slightly concerned as to how things might pan out with people's reactions. I was a bit worried some people might start rioting objecting to a new King. I'm pleased that hasn't happened so far. I do find other people's extreme reactions difficult to get my head round sometimes, like queuing for hours on end. haven't people got jobs and other commitments to attend to?

somewhereovertherain · 15/09/2022 11:50

Hopefully, by the end of Charles's reign, we will have an Independent Scotland and United Ireland.

somewhereovertherain · 15/09/2022 11:47

Same as when Diana died, it's nuts but probably also explains why the UK is as fucked up as it is.

Maybe Charles can dissolve parliament and we can get rid of the current system.

Ti

VerbenaGirl · 15/09/2022 11:43

It's yet another thing to add to all that the last two and a half years (plus) has thrown at us - Brexit, Covid, Government breakdown, NHS shortfalls, funding squeeze on education, energy cost rises, cost of living crisis... Inevitable that it will push some people over the edge.

LoveLifeBeHappy · 15/09/2022 10:58

I think it's time the Monarchy let go of the commonwealth nations. It's time to move away from our horrible colonial past which no one ever talks about. In 2022, something like that shouldn't exist anymore. Time to move on.

RIP the Queen, she tried her best to make amends.

Diverseopinions · 15/09/2022 09:51

I think there has to be originality involved for it to be possible to say there is a genuine wish to show off our pageantry. The mourning services simply follow an age old formula and pattern. This is what people in other countries find so fascinating about our royal rituals - we continue with what went before.

To read in to this a kind of intention, desire to compensate and a self-consciousness is equal, in my estimation, to saying army drills and marches on celebration days are like the army/navy realising they are, numerically, a reduced force and wanting to compensate by going out on horseback with extra shiny buttons and big plumed hats.

I think an analogy between royalty and armed forces is an apt one. Both have no real say, in where they are deployed and in which cause. Governments decide the actions of Britain overseas, for instance. For me, the answer if you don't like things, is to get politically involved and help your local party to garner support and then change some policies in the country. There is division in Britain, and inequality, but I look to politicians to reduce it - not the monarch.

Hagpie · 15/09/2022 09:41

I feel like some people will be upset as with any celebrity dies but to pass it off as national mourning? To cancel people’s medical appointments and other people’s funerals? How dare they! It’s not a tragedy she was 96 fgs!

Normally quite apathetic, it makes me think about how she was seen an harmless old lady but really she sat at the head of one of the most evil families to have ever lived. Even if she didn’t personally order people murdered she wore her blood diamonds and other stolen items with pride! Disgraceful! I’m afraid you can’t discuss the end of an era or the history of a family and only take the good bits and shoving it down our throats is making some of us think about all of it. Her son (not the nonce she defended, the other one) Charles isn’t going to quite charm people like his mum when he has a reputation for beating up his staff when things don’t go his way and for throwing temper tantrums. I don’t think republicans have much work to do. I say let the man baby King show us what royalty has always been, reverse the pretend OTT mourning and give people their appointments back and try to keep a straight face when we see these weirdos on TV spend 30 hours waiting to view a stranger’s coffin. We have lost our minds.

venus7 · 15/09/2022 09:11

Bukhara · 13/09/2022 18:31

Yes, a definite strain of royal demise-inspired lunacy has emerged, but seems also to be in some vague way related to end of empire and to Brexit — sort of ‘Yes, we may no longer have an empire, have voted to make our country increasingly irrelevant and isolated off the back of an internal Tory squabble, and be governed by the venal, unqualified and incompetent, but by God, we do royal death ceremonial well!’

Well put, and completely correct. It all seems a disconnect from reality, a loss of self respect giving way to showing off instead.

LaDamaDeElche · 15/09/2022 07:53

It was the same when Diana died, possibly worse, and more worldwide. I think these things trigger something in a lot of people and really strong emotions just take over. I don't care one way or another about the Royal family and spend zero time thinking about them normally, but I felt a bit upset when I heard the news, even got sucked in to watching the same loop of stuff on the news for a good few hours. I have no idea why I felt like that - maybe homesick because I live abroad, possibly stirred up feelings about the people I've lost in my own life or could be a sense of losing something that had just always been there during my lifetime...not sure really. For people who actually love the Queen and all the pomp an pageantry, it must feel like a big loss. I can only compare it in my mind to when River Phoenix died, I was a young teen and absolutely devastated! Cried for days!

happychops · 15/09/2022 07:31

i’m glad we are all different, it makes the world
a more interesting place. What’s wrong with people being who they want to be and wanting to express their grief/queue for 30 hours? It’s not for me but good luck to those who want to. Tolerance and kindness towards others costs us nothing.

countrygirl99 · 15/09/2022 05:45

Flossatops · 14/09/2022 22:27

How are you helping the situation by belittling someone who is expressing an opinion? Is that no longer allowed? Perhaps 'LetMeSpeak' has a point.

Exceptshe has a very different point of view on another thread do either this post was made in jesr but backfired or she's been converted since.

Swipe left for the next trending thread