Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Flaming thank you cards

31 replies

flexiblebenefit · 13/09/2022 17:38

This has reared its head again. Happens every few years. My children are late teens. They always say thank you for birthday and Xmas grifts. When younger it was fun for them to write little cards but now at 12 16 and 18 they often say thank you via email or text. Nice texts- lengthy with punctuation as they know "old people like full stops" but an electronic thank you all the same. Sometimes for a particularly nice gift they actually call and speak to the person.

I think this is fine. They do it themselves, they're not a generation where sending cards will ever be a thing, and most importantly they are thanking the giver for the gift in a timely manner. MIL thinks that only a formal card will do, and I will no longer force then to do this or facilitate this. The older 2 have A levels and GCSEs and sport and social lives, and they are saying thank you - just not in the format prefers. Even when they call her she still expects a card!

She's grudgingly accepted that this won't happen until this week when she visited her sister. Sister is much older, in a care home. She randomly send middle child a present for their birthday. It was £5.00, a collection of the free cards and pens that you get sent unsolicited by charities and a pair of tights size L in "Barely Black" that she thought size 6 DD could use. DD was touched and realising text or email was inappropriate sent a nice little letter- in fact using a pen and the British heart foundation card from the present. MIL now fuming because, "they can do it, they just choose not to".
Thing is MIL is 20 years younger, very with it, very active online and this obsession with formal cards is just odd and I refuse to make them do it. I haven't even told them it's an issue because it's just another example of her prioritising what things look like over actually having a relationship with the children. Am I wrong?

OP posts:
flexiblebenefit · 13/09/2022 18:05

Antarcticant · 13/09/2022 17:53

They do it themselves, they're not a generation where sending cards will ever be a thing

I would ask, does this cut both ways? That is, does your MIL make an effort to buy them things they want, appropriate to their age and generation, or does she buy them a pogo stick and a space hopper because she isn't of a generation that would have bought Nike trainers or EarPods or whatever it is that is the 2022 must-have for a teen?

I would say if MIL is making the effort to buy gifts appropriate to their generation, they should thank in a way appropriate to hers. If she's not making much effort, then they shouldn't feel obliged to, either,

Great point. I think that were she otherwise an amazing Gran then I'd have mentioned it to the kids and they'd willingly do it. She's a dutiful Gran - which is fine BTW and frankly I've appreciated her hands off approach over the years- but she's pretty absent. Youngest phoned her last birthday after not seeing her for months as she'd been away and she didn't chat because the golf was on!

The kids get £50 Amazon vouchers every time. If they request (has to be via me otherwise it's "grabby") she will send a different voucher. Never cash as I think she thinks it's common. And this bit stings- she always sends the vouchers electronically TO ME so I'm having to print them out. Actually this is the killer point. I'm definitely not unreasonable

OP posts:
Antarcticant · 13/09/2022 17:53

They do it themselves, they're not a generation where sending cards will ever be a thing

I would ask, does this cut both ways? That is, does your MIL make an effort to buy them things they want, appropriate to their age and generation, or does she buy them a pogo stick and a space hopper because she isn't of a generation that would have bought Nike trainers or EarPods or whatever it is that is the 2022 must-have for a teen?

I would say if MIL is making the effort to buy gifts appropriate to their generation, they should thank in a way appropriate to hers. If she's not making much effort, then they shouldn't feel obliged to, either,

AuntieStella · 13/09/2022 17:50

I think you are both right and wrong.

You're right, because your DC are sending thanks in a timely fashion.

But it would please MIL to have a little note. So why not do that? It takes less time than a phone call, and not much longer than an email, and it would brighten someone's day enormously.

I can see why she's smarting that another person gets a handwritten version when she doesn't. Things like age and health aren't really central issues here

Royalbloo · 13/09/2022 17:43

Nope. It's fine!

Cleopatra67 · 13/09/2022 17:42

No - you’re really not. I’ve never made mine do it- still remember the misery of Boxing Day thank you cards. My step mother is still like this and mine are now adults and she still complains to me.

Onlyhuman123 · 13/09/2022 17:41

I'm with you OP. Any form of 'thank you' is perfectly sufficient, not necessary to send a hand written note. As you say, it's a fun thing to do with young kids but not teens.

And your MIL is fuming?! Good grief! 😳🙄