Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child lost school item, school blaming me...?

190 replies

maiafawnly · 13/09/2022 17:12

Before the summer holiday, my 14 year old participated in an event for a competition where a group of student designed balloons which were sent into "space". On the balloons were recording devices logging the altitude the balloon reached and views from their balloon. The data was recorded onto a micro SD card. The data was to be analysed at the start of this term to then be submitted to the hosts of the competition.

The SD card was given to my 14 year old last day of term, and hes lost it. Micro sd cards are so small that finding it is a nigh on impossible task, and we've looked everywhere but cannot find it.

Obviously this is my childs fault, hes misplaced it, but school have called, 3 separate teachers infact have called, asking me what i intend to do about it...? What can i do? I didn't know he was being given the SD card or asked to bare any responsibility of keeping it safe for 7 weeks! And even if i had been asked, theres nothing i can do now its lost, i cant magically recreate data and images of the balloon. And tbh i think the school/teachers involved in the competition have been a bit irresponsible handing a micro sd card of data to a kid if thats the only place its stored and irretrievable if lost.

Aibu to simply ignore any further communication regarding this and have absolutely no consequences for my child at home? I dont think this is a punishable offence, my child made an accidental mistake over misplacing something he should never have been solely responsible for if it was that important?

OP posts:
LetMeSpeak · 13/09/2022 18:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

maiafawnly · 13/09/2022 18:59

user29 · 13/09/2022 18:55

so he was looking after the SD on behalf of the whole group?

He was given it, he said he didnt volunteer another girl was supposed to have it but she was absent so it was handed to my son instead. Im not sure why he was selected but i did ask him why he ended up with the card and its just because the girl wasnt there to take it

OP posts:
Tiani4 · 13/09/2022 18:58

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 13/09/2022 17:14

Tell them you’re going to give them some advice:

Do not give tiny, precious items to children. Also, don’t attach things to balloons.

This!!
They had every opportunity to back up data on it

It is tiny
I wouldn't even trust my adult colleagues with a small SD card let alone a teenager!! It'll be in his pocket and gone through the wash probably half way down you washing machine pipe
Or bottom of his bag

Same way that school say children take in expensive items to school at their own risk - even o teacher ha confiscated if and lost it- them something breaks - and it works both ways!

I would t reply other than to say you gave a tiny thing to a Child at your own risk without backing it up.

maiafawnly · 13/09/2022 18:56

LetMeSpeak · 13/09/2022 18:53

You can’t in one breath say that it’s ok your DS lost the SD card because he’s young but in the next breath say you’re not going to help him deal with it. Yabu for that. You need to help him out in the situation. Leaving him to deal with it alone isn’t far and you validating the teachers argument.

Hes apologised to the students, and the teacher(s), ive helped him look again after school, im told him he should have been more careful and made sure it was somewhere safe for the summer, but ive been understanding hes upset over the incident. Therefore i wont punish him further by making him pay for a replacement card (not that this has been asked for by any of the teachers) however if he wants to replace it ill support his choice. What else should i do for him?

OP posts:
user29 · 13/09/2022 18:55

so he was looking after the SD on behalf of the whole group?

WeepingSomnambulist · 13/09/2022 18:55

Your son could offer to replace the balloon so they can re-run the experiment. Or did the expierment have to be done at the same time country wide?

WeepingSomnambulist · 13/09/2022 18:54

Did he volunteer to take it? Why would they pick him instead of taking it themselves?

What did he do with it when they handed it to him. Surely they put it in an envelope inside it's storage case? Or did they just hand him a tiny card without a storage case?

What did he do with it? Put it in a pencil case? In his bag? All he can do is retrace his steps and see if it is still there.

I think I would have to send an email outlining the stupidity of the teachers. Being clear that this should have been backed up or kept by an adult or kept in a locked drawer in the school rather than given to a randomly selected kid.

LetMeSpeak · 13/09/2022 18:53

You can’t in one breath say that it’s ok your DS lost the SD card because he’s young but in the next breath say you’re not going to help him deal with it. Yabu for that. You need to help him out in the situation. Leaving him to deal with it alone isn’t far and you validating the teachers argument.

Antarcticant · 13/09/2022 18:50

Possibly not much help but the last time I lost an SD card, I found it by chance three months later in a tray of pens.

cstaff · 13/09/2022 18:49

It sounds like the third teacher that rang you was a little bit threatening asking what you intended to do. What exactly can you do if it doesn't turn up. I think the onus was on them and not to pass it over to a kid over the whole summer. It sounds like they don't want it coming back on them. Have a look again tonight and if it doesn't show up let them figure it out.

maiafawnly · 13/09/2022 18:47

Pixiedust1234 · 13/09/2022 18:44

okay op, let's have a think. What sort of clothes would he have worn, ie if he only has two pairs of jeans check the pockets carefully. Same with hoodie etc. Would he have been carrying a bag? Is it in his pencil case? I cant see him taking it out of anything and just leaving it on his desk....so where did he put it to take it home?

It was in a plastic wallet thingy when he got it, he took it out and viewed the data and images on his laptop with some school friends on the team first week of the holidays. He thought hed put it in his desk drawer but its not there. And its not in the laptop. I think the most likely answer is he left it on his desk, its been knocked off, and lost.

OP posts:
Pixiedust1234 · 13/09/2022 18:44

okay op, let's have a think. What sort of clothes would he have worn, ie if he only has two pairs of jeans check the pockets carefully. Same with hoodie etc. Would he have been carrying a bag? Is it in his pencil case? I cant see him taking it out of anything and just leaving it on his desk....so where did he put it to take it home?

newmum1976 · 13/09/2022 18:42

After the rudeness of the last teacher, I wouldn’t be wasting my time looking for
it 😱 what a nasty thing to say.

Peashoots · 13/09/2022 18:41

I think the teachers know they’ve fucked up and and panicking. “For his sake I hope he finds it”-what does that even mean?! Sounds threatening to me.

INeverSawAPurpleCow · 13/09/2022 18:39

I'd given them an earful on the damage done to livestock and wildlife by fucking balloons and tell them to do one.

GroggyLegs · 13/09/2022 18:38

They're panicking & trying to pass the buck for their dimwittedness and you're getting panicked on.

It was completely foreseeable. I've got 3 backups of a similar work related thing on USB because I'm well aware how easily these things can be mislaid.

I'd have one really good last look and draw a line.

Honestly though 'I hope for your son's sake...'? I'd have asked this teacher to elaborate on the consequences he foresees happening.

maiafawnly · 13/09/2022 18:37

carefullycourageous · 13/09/2022 18:34

@maiafawnly I find your position inconsistent - you say your son is too young have been given sole responsibility for the card, but also it is up to him to replace if he wants.

I think you need to pick a side - either he is old enough to have been asked to look after it, in which case he is on his own and school were right to ask him, or he is too young to look after it himself, in which case he is also too young to decide to replace it.

My feeling is the latter (14 is too young to be given sole responsibility for a group project) and the school should not have left it with him, and I also think you should replace the SD card - and if you feel it right get him to repay that money from his allowance.

The whole thing is badly thought through, what a shame!

I feel if the data was that important 3 teachers have contacted me regarding it then giving a 14 year old the sole responsibility was irresponsible on their part.

I also think that at 14 if theres an incident like this at school, its up to him to deal with it not me. I have supported him in looking, told him he should have taken better care of it, but been empathetic that it was a mistake not deliberate so wont punish him further

OP posts:
carefullycourageous · 13/09/2022 18:35

He said something along the lines of "he hopes for my sons sake i manage to find it then" What on earch does THAT mean?

I'd escalate the issue, politely, and ask a senior staff member to help. But pay for a replacement card!

carefullycourageous · 13/09/2022 18:34

@maiafawnly I find your position inconsistent - you say your son is too young have been given sole responsibility for the card, but also it is up to him to replace if he wants.

I think you need to pick a side - either he is old enough to have been asked to look after it, in which case he is on his own and school were right to ask him, or he is too young to look after it himself, in which case he is also too young to decide to replace it.

My feeling is the latter (14 is too young to be given sole responsibility for a group project) and the school should not have left it with him, and I also think you should replace the SD card - and if you feel it right get him to repay that money from his allowance.

The whole thing is badly thought through, what a shame!

maiafawnly · 13/09/2022 18:30

CantFindTheBeat · 13/09/2022 18:24

What have the teachers ACTUALLY said to you, OP?

presumably they don't really care about a £10 SD card.

Have they said 'Xs parent, could you have a thorough look and see if you can help him find it'?.

If so, that's a reasonable ask for a project they would really like to complete.

The first one called to inform me my son had the card and failed to bring it into school. I had a conversation with them and stated i will help him look this evening when he gets home.

The second started basically the same conversation, i said ive already discussed this with the 1st teacher and intend to look this eve, i said i dont have time to re-have the conversation as im on my appointment and ended it there.

The third (by this point i was a bit annoyed at them calling me) literally asked me what i intended to do about it being lost. I said ive already agreed to help him look but beyond that i cant see what i can do about the data. He said something along the lines of "he hopes for my sons sake i manage to find it then" i cant remember exactly how it was worded but i agreed and ended the call.

OP posts:
Connie2468 · 13/09/2022 18:27

Royalbloo · 13/09/2022 18:25

Erm, you/your son lost it though?

How can the OP have lost something she knew nothing about and wasn't asked to look after?

Connie2468 · 13/09/2022 18:26

This was an agreement between your son and the school.

If they ask you again, you'll have to say you don't know anything about and can't do anything about it. They need to speak to your son as he is the one they organised this with.

Royalbloo · 13/09/2022 18:25

Erm, you/your son lost it though?

CantFindTheBeat · 13/09/2022 18:24

Skolo · 13/09/2022 18:19

It doesn’t sound like they are blaming you. It sounds like they are trying to enlist your help in finding it. It has probably dawned on them that, rather than relying on a 14yr old, they might have better luck asking you to look for it.

This.

Sunnyqueen · 13/09/2022 18:24

Tell them you are happy to replace the sd card and if they have any suggestions as to how you can put the irretrievable data on to it you will happily follow their guidance.. Then request to avoid this happening again they don't give a fingernail sized piece of plastic to a 14 year old to look after for 7 weeks.

Thick as fuck some of them, hard to believe they are teachers!!