Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about Putin

38 replies

TarasHarp55 · 13/09/2022 15:51

Im so worried that he might just lash out in Ukraine with a nuclear weapon. Then that would be ww3. I wasn't even thinking on those lines because I don't watch the news but I heard my dh and sil discussing the possibility. I wish I hadn't heard them tbh. Now I'm worried sick. Can anyone give any reassurance? Sorry to sound so weak.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Venetiaparties · 16/11/2022 07:49

Given the state of Russian technical capabilities I guess it is also entirely possible that their nuclear weapons are defunct and rusted up anyway. It is shocking to see their troops use old 20th century weapons, clapped out tanks and not even basic provision to fight. It does not feel one with confidence.
If the efforts so far are a reflection of their nuclear ability I wouldn't be too concerned.

Venetiaparties · 16/11/2022 07:43

The biggest reason Russia is very unlikely to use chemical and nuclear weapons is the distinct possibility of mass Russian casualties as a result, they are impossible to contain and Russia couldn't guarantee or control the fall out reaching Russia, certainly it is likely to affect their troops on the ground and towns and cities on the borders. The contamination would last for years. Even Russia as angry and furious as they might be with how this war has panned out for them would know that this would indeed be the last straw on the international stage and even China, India etc would unite in condemnation. As it is Russia's global standing is hovering around the same status as Iran. If it were to unleash deadly weapons on Ukraine it would become a total basket case along the lines of North Korea, and treated as such.

At some point Russia will need an exit plan, at some point it will need to reengage with the rest of the world. Already this is defining Russia's future for the next generation and beyond, but to 'go there' with nuclear tactical weapons and knowing what the international response would be - it would be utter madness.

Laurendelaney1987 · 16/11/2022 07:36

Laurendelaney1987 · 16/11/2022 07:34

Hi, is your DH a specialist in nuclear bombs etc?

Em... just read the full thread, and he actually IS!!!!

Laurendelaney1987 · 16/11/2022 07:34

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 13/09/2022 16:25

DH says that it's the smaller ones which are more of a problem for the next door country. The big ones have a bigger blast radius on the ground but the fall out that the neighbours get is much less dangerous as it goes up higher, so takes longer to come back down, giving it more time to lose the worst of its radiation.

Hi, is your DH a specialist in nuclear bombs etc?

oakleaffy · 16/11/2022 07:08

Pixiedust1234 · 13/09/2022 16:01

This again? Go speak to your gp. You can't do anything so just let it go,

What can a GP do?
” Now then, Putin, wind your neck in, there’s good chap”
It is understandable that people are worried about escalation, but @@TarasHarp55 we are powerless against stuff like this, unfortunately.
The World has seen Nuclear threats before and come through OK.
We just have to hope it won’t come to that.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 13/09/2022 19:24

walkingonsunshinekat · 13/09/2022 19:17

Modern tactical nuclear warheads have yields up to the tens of kilotons, or potentially hundreds, several times that of the weapons used in the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki
(i'm well aware of what a tactical weapon is - from your link)

The use of depleted shells etc isn't what people are concerned about.

But if you think a missile with a similar or even bigger payload to WW2 bombs used on japan is not of concern and we'll all be ok, thats up to you.

You're scaring people with misinformation. Nuclear weapon yields are NOT linear. A bomb 100 times bigger than Hiroshima does NOT do 100 times as much damage.

walkingonsunshinekat · 13/09/2022 19:17

Levellingdown · 13/09/2022 16:14

@walkingonsunshinekat there is such a thing as a tactical / small nuclear weapon. When people have discussed Putin using nuclear weapons it’s these as there would be incredibly limited point in pretty much nuking the next door country with a massive weapon
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tactical_nuclear_weapon

Modern tactical nuclear warheads have yields up to the tens of kilotons, or potentially hundreds, several times that of the weapons used in the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki
(i'm well aware of what a tactical weapon is - from your link)

The use of depleted shells etc isn't what people are concerned about.

But if you think a missile with a similar or even bigger payload to WW2 bombs used on japan is not of concern and we'll all be ok, thats up to you.

Andante57 · 13/09/2022 17:58

Thank you FatherBuzz - that’s very interesting.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 13/09/2022 17:34

He's been humiliated by the war.
He threatened nuclear war if anyone intervened, the world has intervened massively by supplying weapons and heavy sanctions.

He would have pushed the button by now if he could.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 13/09/2022 17:30

TarasHarp55 · 13/09/2022 17:24

Thank you to everyone who's reassured me. It really does help a lot with my anxiety.

OP my info comes from my DH. He is a professor of nuclear chemistry and has been interviewed many times by media outlets all over the world on this. If you're in the UK then he's very clear that you have nothing to worry about personally even if Putin does something really stupid in Ukraine.

TarasHarp55 · 13/09/2022 17:24

Thank you to everyone who's reassured me. It really does help a lot with my anxiety.

OP posts:
BrokenFridgeDrawer · 13/09/2022 17:23

Putin can't just " push a button ".

There will be a long chain of commmand of peope involved to get to the guy who " pushes the button ", and I dare say a lot of them are intelligent thoughtful professional military people with a great deal of intelligence and morals, with their own families and their own minds. I doubt there could be blind obedient loyaltly to an order which would amount to an act of totally unprovokeed mass murder with no clear military objective other than to satisfy the demands of an out of conrrol ego. It won't happen.

LoveLarry · 13/09/2022 17:13

Derbee · 13/09/2022 16:03

I’d be surprised if their nuclear weapons work. The massively feared Russian Army have been shockingly inept. We need the world to keep arming Ukraine until this all comes to an end

Pretty much this

If psycho putin did decide to launch, he'll probably find that someone's sold the key

FatherBuzzCagney · 13/09/2022 17:02

Thanks @InconstantMoonand @MarshaBradyo !

FatherBuzzCagney · 13/09/2022 17:01

Andante57 · 13/09/2022 16:47

The massively feared Russian Army have been shockingly inept

Yes, I was very surprised by this as I’d always thought they were an incredibly powerful military force.
How long has the Russian army been in decline? Since the end of the Soviet Union? Or were all those displays of Soviet military might greatly exaggerated?

The Russian army was in a terrible state in the 1990s for lots of reasons, the Russian government kept promising serious military reform but never did it - partly because the politicians relied to various degrees on the support of the senior armed forces leadership, who were quite happy with the way things were (because they got to steal everything, basically).

The Russian army was humiliated in Chechnya in the 90s, then by things like the sinking of the Kursk submarine, then by its underperformance in its war with Georgia in 2008.

That finally forced them to start real reforms, and between 2008 and 20022 the Russian govt spent many billions of dollars modernising the armed forces. So most analysts thought the Russian armed forces - though still dealing with obvious corruption and other problems - were a serious proposition again.

Turns out they're not. The war has shown that all the old problems - corruption, lack of strategic thinking, tactical and operation ineptitude, corruption, poor unit cohesion, terrible morale, and corruption - are just as present as they were 25 years ago in Chechnya. And now the consequences are a hundred times worse for them because they aren't fighting a small group of secessionists, they're fighting a serious army that's backed by a population of 40 million and is equipped by the US. They're screwed, and it's very unlikely anyone will take them seriously again.

MarshaBradyo · 13/09/2022 17:00

Appreciate post FatherBuzz

InconstantMoon · 13/09/2022 16:58

Thanks for that great post and sharing your expert knowledge @FatherBuzzCagney

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 13/09/2022 16:49

Igotjelly · 13/09/2022 16:46

Indeed. I’m not sure our concern should be limited to those of us in the UK though….

Absolutely. I'm desperately worried for the people of Ukraine. My comment was to still the fears of those who are frightened for themselves and their children when they really don't need to be.

Andante57 · 13/09/2022 16:47

The massively feared Russian Army have been shockingly inept

Yes, I was very surprised by this as I’d always thought they were an incredibly powerful military force.
How long has the Russian army been in decline? Since the end of the Soviet Union? Or were all those displays of Soviet military might greatly exaggerated?

Igotjelly · 13/09/2022 16:46

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 13/09/2022 16:44

what is concerning is the situation son Zaphorizhzhia.

It's concerning for the Ukrainians and the people who live in the surrounding area of the plant but it poses no risk to people in western Europe.

Indeed. I’m not sure our concern should be limited to those of us in the UK though….

FatherBuzzCagney · 13/09/2022 16:45

Hi OP, FWIW I'm an academic specialising in Russian foreign/security policy. These are scary issues and so it's not surprising that you and other people are anxious. Hopefully I can explain why you don't need to worry about this particular issue very much. Tl;dr: the Russian army isn't suicidal so I don't see them using them, even if Putin wanted them to.

There are two types of nuclear weapons that people have talked about Russia potentially using during the war. The first are the missiles designed to strike western Europe, including the UK. These are the things that the fascist nutters on Russian current affairs TV have been threatening to launch at the UK and Ireland. This is delusional nonsense that no-one believes, including them no doubt. Any attempt to target a NATO state with a nuclear weapon carries the very high probability of a nuclear response, wiping out Putin, the senior Russian military leadership, their wives, mistresses, children, dachas. Putin knows this. We can never say anything with 100% certainty, but this is as close to an impossible scenario as it's possible to get in international affairs.

The second are the so-called tactical nuclear weapons, designed to be used on the battlefield. They're referred to as this because the idea is that they only have tactical application and effects - basically, they're used to achieve specific things on the battlefield. They are, in theory, different from strategic nukes (the type I mentioned above) which transform not just the battlefield, but the states involved - and the rest of the world.

The problem with the idea of tactical nukes for Russia in this scenario is that they can't, in fact, contain their effects to the battlefield alone - i.e. tactical nukes can never actually be tactical, they will provoke escalation and so will always have larger, strategic effects. This is a point made by people like Lawrence Freedman, one of the UK's most eminent scholars of war.

We can see this very clearly in the current war. In relation to the nuclear power plant currently being occupied by Russia, Western politicians have said that a deliberate release of radiation by Russia could be treated as a NATO Article 5 matter - meaning that it would provoke a direct military response from NATO (most importantly, the US). If that's the position in case of the power plant, you can be very confident that the same principle applies to any Russian use of tactical nukes. More importantly, the Russian government will know that it applies to tactical nukes.

We don't know what mental state Putin is in - it's possible he might feel the game is up and be happy to go out in a nuclear holocaust. But the men (and they are all men) around him are in power for what they can get - status, and a yacht-load of cash. Shoigu, the Russian Defence Minister is the classic example of this, but they're all the same. I can't see any circumstances in which the men around Putin would be willing to kill themselves and everyone close to them just to allow Putin to avoid defeat. They will get rid of him sooner than do that.

Another factor making tactical nuke use in Ukraine massively unlikely is the morale problem in the Russian army. There are all sorts of reports (not all verified) coming out about the state of the Russian army in Ukraine: desertions, soldiers disobeying orders, resignations, serious tensions between officers and men, fighting between the Russian army proper and the units from the Donetsk and Luhansk "peoples republics", fighting between the Russian army and the Chechen irregulars. It's clearly an absolute shitshow - as can be seen from the way the Russians collapsed in the face of the recent Ukrainian offensive. I don't see how the Russian army leadership (even if it wanted to) would persuade underpaid, underfed, mutinous troops to use tactical nukes, knowing what the response would be.

Hope this all makes sense. Happy to explain anything else Russia/NATO/war-related you have any questions about.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 13/09/2022 16:44

what is concerning is the situation son Zaphorizhzhia.

It's concerning for the Ukrainians and the people who live in the surrounding area of the plant but it poses no risk to people in western Europe.

Igotjelly · 13/09/2022 16:43

*situation in

Igotjelly · 13/09/2022 16:42

They anticipates massive retaliatory strikes following the explosions in Crimea and they never came. Considering the Kremlin still refuses to mobilise the population and economy to a war footing I think the use of tactical nuclear weapons is unlikely.

what is concerning is the situation son Zaphorizhzhia.

Huelcup · 13/09/2022 16:40

He's had months to use a nuke and hasn't yet.

You should probably be more worried about the Ukrainian nuclesr power station that appears to only be running on two AA batteries whilst Ukrainian and Russian forces both battle around it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread