Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think breastfeeding is a hassle?

414 replies

choolaboola · 13/09/2022 15:48

Apologies in advanced if this is offensive as I know some BF people feel really passionate about it - BUT - can I please ask, why do people breastfeed?

First time pregnancy here - all I read is "my BF baby won't sleep" "I can't leave them down" "I can't go to XYZ months in because Im exclusively BF" etc.

I'm genuinely wondering is it a much harder path to go down? My friends, sisters, mum and MIL have all formula fed and as far as I can see, the outcome is the same. So I'm just wondering what other people's thoughts are?

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 13/09/2022 20:00

Great post by @BertieBotts which sums up my thoughts nicely!

BertieBotts · 13/09/2022 19:57

The difference between breastmilk and formula is a different thing to the difference in outcomes between breastfed and formula fed babies.

Breastmilk is a living fluid tailored for the baby and honed by evolution to be right for our species. Formula is the reconstituted skimmed powdered milk of another mammal with the fat content added back in, usually from non-animal fats, commonly palm oil, and synthetic vitamins added. It's a completely different fluid, the fact they are both called milk is more for familiarity than anything else.

But, it doesn't really matter that much in terms of outcomes. In terms of nourishing the baby for their growth and development, modern formula does a really good job, to the point that it really IS worth weighing the convenience/mental health/preference/routine/ease/whatever other reasons somebody might prefer the idea of FF against the health benefits of breastfeeding.

Much of the benefits of breastfeeding are about the fact women want to breastfeed and see value in breastfeeding, and it ought to be protected and celebrated for that fact alone, but if an individual woman feels that the costs of breastfeeding are too much, she is probably right, the differences in outcome really are very slight. Nobody should feel guilty for preferring formula. I just also think nobody should be forced into using it before they actually want to.

Hastingsontheup · 13/09/2022 19:57

Wouldloveanother · 13/09/2022 19:51

Of course there is! What’s the noticeable difference between a FF kid and a BF kid?

Breast milk is rich in IgG antibodies, which will specifically reflect the viruses and bacteria the mother is being exposed to. It is isotonic so absorbed almost better than any other fluid and can be used topically to treat minor infections and eczema.

Formula is designed with infant nutrition in mind and is a safe and effective way to meet a baby's needs.

But (the baby's mother's) breast milk it ain't.

Wouldloveanother · 13/09/2022 19:57

JaninaDuszejko · 13/09/2022 19:15

I always thought of BFing as the 'baby reset' button, it was a crucial part of my parenting toolbox in the early days. Particularly with DC3 it was very much 'if in doubt BF'.

Baby hungry? BF
Baby thirsty? BF
Baby tired? BF
Baby cold? BF
Baby hot? BF
Baby constipated? BF
Baby needs affection? BF

Which is great. But then baby sees it as the only solution to every issue, and in the end it sort of creates a need rather than meeting one - these types of babies are often the subject of threads with very exhausted mums who are desperate to wean further down the line but can’t because their toddler screams and screams etc

I never read any books or had a parenting ‘method’ in mind, but I did find I fed roughly to a schedule - every 3 hours during the day and at night until about 3 months old, then it was every 3 hours during the day and twice at night. I didn’t just shove a boob in her mouth if she cried, I cuddled her or distracted her. I think this paid dividends when I weaned her off breastfeeding as she was good at being comforted in so many ways, I think she just saw bfing as food. And I had a lot of parenting tools in my kit when we finished.

Iamnewhere · 13/09/2022 19:55

Do what you think is best and best for your family.
I exclusively BF for 6 months, then we did one bottle of formula (expressing WAS a massive pain in the arse for me and I gave myself engorgement - not worth it).
BF for me was less hassle then bottle. I would say to anyone that you do really want to have to BF as it takes time and patience, and also it can be sore.
My baby no sleep issues, very healthy, it made me feel a close bond to him, easier then sterilising bottles and making up formula etc. But that was my preference.
When we moved to doing a bottle I often ended up still BF him so it was a bit of a waste of time

sanabria · 13/09/2022 19:53

@Oiwiththepoodlesalreadygg Ah, okay. I was going to suggest rotating/repositioning shields for lying down position but sounds like you may have already tried all of that! And to be fair, I get a fair amount of milk all over the bedsheets too..

Mine is 12 weeks and we are only just now getting off the shields so I know the struggle. But it is doable :) My HV said as babies mouths grow it can be easier to get a proper latch and it seems to be true for us and hopefully will be for you too! Best of luck!

Wouldloveanother · 13/09/2022 19:51

strawberrysea · 13/09/2022 19:41

There is absolutely not a 'small' difference between breast milk and formula milk, as some are saying. They are not comparable at all.

Your body, your choice and I would support whatever the mother wanted to do 10000%, but as facts stand no, they are not the same.

Of course there is! What’s the noticeable difference between a FF kid and a BF kid?

bakewellbride · 13/09/2022 19:46

You can't know if breastfeeding is 'hassle' unless you d experienced it. I breastfed my son until he was nearly 17 months old and it was wonderful, one of the best and most rewarding experiences of my life. Sure the first few weeks were tough / exhausting / painful but I'm so glad I stuck it out.

I'm currently breastfeeding my 5 and a half month old. She first slept through (9pm - 6:30am) at 11 weeks and I never have and never will need to buy, wash or sterilise a single bottle in my entire life. It's much more convenient for me. It's just amazing and I love it so much.

I admire those who formula feed but it's 100% not for me and I really love breastfeeding. The fact you have such a negative idea of breastfeeding before you've even had your baby just goes to show how it's depicted in society. I wish both could be shown positively.

strawberrysea · 13/09/2022 19:41

There is absolutely not a 'small' difference between breast milk and formula milk, as some are saying. They are not comparable at all.

Your body, your choice and I would support whatever the mother wanted to do 10000%, but as facts stand no, they are not the same.

89redballoons · 13/09/2022 19:30

In my experience yes, exclusive breastfeeding for six months is a hassle. It's definitely more time consuming than formula feeding and the baby relies solely on you for nutrition which can feel like a burden. If you're BFing every 2/3 hours including at night, which is pretty normal, you don't get much "you" time or much sleep. Yes you can express but that is also time consuming.

I know people say sterilising and preparing bottles is a faff but it is fairly straightforward to just wash and sterilise your stuff in the microwave once a day. You can add the powder to a few oz of hot water and then add previously cooled boiled water to cool it down (I think this is safe...?). Or use ready-made formula if out and about etc. Or lots of people use perfect prep machines.

However - I did breastfeed my eldest exclusively to 6 months, and then alongside formula and solids to 18 months. I did love the bond and it was honestly so easy to solve most cases of crying by sticking a boob in his mouth. Not sure how I'd parent a baby without breastfeeding although obviously many people can and do very well. I also found that my baby didn't get any of the bugs I picked up as I think he would have got the antibodies in my milk.

Second time round though, we started giving DS2 (now 5 months old) one bottle of formula per day aged 12 weeks or so. It does seem to help with fussy evenings, plus I can put the toddler to bed while DH does the baby sometimes which is good for our family. I had a night out with friends a couple of weeks ago and DH gave the baby one bottle of expressed milk and one of formula over about 6 hours, and he was fine. He is also really healthy generally, has never even really had the sniffles, great weight gain and meeting all the milestones.

So combi feeding seems to work really well for us. Only 1% of UK mums breastfeeding exclusively for the full 6 months and there is definitely a reason for that.

KittyEmK · 13/09/2022 19:21

I've found breastfeeding to be very convenient so far for a number of reasons - I don't ever have to worry about sterilising kit, don't have to take milk and bottles out with me and I can comfort the baby instantly. It's not without difficulties (especially at the beginning) but so worth it and has made life much easier overall.

Parker231 · 13/09/2022 19:18

Wnikat · 13/09/2022 17:29

I’m really lazy and breastfeeding was easier than all the faff with bottles.

I’m the opposite - lazy but formula meant it wasn’t me having to do every feed. Grandparents live overseas but every time they flew in they became the bottle feeders, day and night. Wonderful!

JaninaDuszejko · 13/09/2022 19:15

I always thought of BFing as the 'baby reset' button, it was a crucial part of my parenting toolbox in the early days. Particularly with DC3 it was very much 'if in doubt BF'.

Baby hungry? BF
Baby thirsty? BF
Baby tired? BF
Baby cold? BF
Baby hot? BF
Baby constipated? BF
Baby needs affection? BF

CandyLeBonBon · 13/09/2022 19:01

The thought of having to make bottles up while a baby screams if they aren't already prepared was enough to keep me going with breastfeeding. I am too lazy for all that malarky.

^^this

I bf all three of mine because I really just couldn't be arsed with all the organisation that bottle feeding seemed to entail.

But fed is best.

FreyaStorm · 13/09/2022 18:58

Oiwiththepoodlesalreadygg · 13/09/2022 18:06

I'm only ten weeks into breastfeeding so by no means an expert but for me it is quite a hassle. We have had a lot of struggles with latch and she only feeds with nipple shields so the whole feed anywhere, no equipment thing doesn't really apply here. I've also spent a fortune on feeding bras and tops, trying to find some that are vaguely supportive for my big boobs. Ended up in tears at a baby class last week because my baby was crying, she kept knocking the shields off and we both ended up soaked in my milk. We also can't feed lying down, nor do I wish to co sleep, so I'm up and feeding in the lounge each night. I'm holding out hope that my baby might develop her latch as she grows because I do like the closeness of bf (she was term but tiny) but if not I'll definitely be switching to combi feeding - bottles out and about and bf at home where I can take my time & use shields if necessary. I'm so envious of women who find bf easy but not all of us do!

Well done for persevering. You’re the second poster to mention the large boobs issue. I struggle with this too and I think breastfeeding is SO much harder for larger chested women. Thinking about it, my friends and family who struggles and sometimes ultimately failed to bf, all have very large boobs.
I think there needs to be more support, openness and conversation about bf with massive boobs as it is a logistical struggle and feeding out and about is not so much of an option.

Wouldloveanother · 13/09/2022 18:58

hewouldwouldnthe · 13/09/2022 18:55

What's convenient about sterilising, measuring, heating, cooling, washing, ensuring you have the right bottle as opposed to opening your shirt?

Other people helping with nights, or feeding in general? Being able to go out and do things knowing they won’t be starving themselves until you get back? It’s all about weighing up what’s best for your lifestyle.

Notanotherwindow · 13/09/2022 18:57

I found bottle feeding easy. Could do it with my eyes closed and it means someone else can do a few feeds while you sleep.

You can also get prepackaged, ready mixed where you literally just pull off the seal, screw the teat in and done. Again though, expensive.

Wouldloveanother · 13/09/2022 18:56

Oiwiththepoodlesalreadygg · 13/09/2022 18:06

I'm only ten weeks into breastfeeding so by no means an expert but for me it is quite a hassle. We have had a lot of struggles with latch and she only feeds with nipple shields so the whole feed anywhere, no equipment thing doesn't really apply here. I've also spent a fortune on feeding bras and tops, trying to find some that are vaguely supportive for my big boobs. Ended up in tears at a baby class last week because my baby was crying, she kept knocking the shields off and we both ended up soaked in my milk. We also can't feed lying down, nor do I wish to co sleep, so I'm up and feeding in the lounge each night. I'm holding out hope that my baby might develop her latch as she grows because I do like the closeness of bf (she was term but tiny) but if not I'll definitely be switching to combi feeding - bottles out and about and bf at home where I can take my time & use shields if necessary. I'm so envious of women who find bf easy but not all of us do!

This was basically my experience. Oversupply, milk spraying everywhere if I didn’t feed every 3 hours on the dot, soaked bedding, had to take a change of top everywhere I went. For some reason breastfeeding did something to my
hormones that made me really sweaty 😷 I lost the baby weight which was great, but just kept losing, and after about 3 months I looked pale and thin. It’s like baby was taking all my reserves and depleting me! I also felt really energy-less. When I stopped bfing I felt like I had had a power surge and my skin was amazing.

hewouldwouldnthe · 13/09/2022 18:55

Notanotherwindow · 13/09/2022 18:52

On the one hand, bottle feeding is more convenient. On the other, it costs 15 quid per tin...

What's convenient about sterilising, measuring, heating, cooling, washing, ensuring you have the right bottle as opposed to opening your shirt?

Notanotherwindow · 13/09/2022 18:52

On the one hand, bottle feeding is more convenient. On the other, it costs 15 quid per tin...

hewouldwouldnthe · 13/09/2022 18:51

Once established it's so much easier than making up/sterilising/cleaning etc bottles.
It's cheaper
It's a great way to lose weight as your body is using up calories to produce milk.
It's nature's ideal food for your baby
It changes as your baby grows to be richer and more filling
It has antibodies so is probably helpful in fighting infection
It promotes mother baby bonding

Yes it's difficult to get started first time round, and you are tied to baby for the first few months, but the pros outweigh the cons for many mothers.

Levellingdown · 13/09/2022 18:51

I would suggest combo feeding is the perfect solution. I did that. Mostly expressed milk but some formula as she got older. That way dad could do night feeds too!

Rosewaterblossom · 13/09/2022 18:47

Wouldloveanother · 13/09/2022 18:03

Yep. Breastfeeding is a tiny part of the whole picture - good food, exercise, fresh air, good mental health, education etc. My entire family have been breastfed, and sneer at formula - they think it’s really unhealthy and basically for lazy mums who don’t care. They overlook the fact most of them are obese and have chronic health issues 🤨

100% agree with this. How you feed your baby is a tiny part of a big picture. In years to come it makes 0 difference because your food, exercise and environmental habits take over how your overall health is.

KevinTheKoala · 13/09/2022 18:46

Oh and my daughter is now 3 and still usually has 1 breastfeed a day, obviously nobody has to continue that long and again it is completely down whatever works best for mum and baby but since the age of about 18 months she is perfectly happy to go for sleepovers with her nan, to nursery, days out with daddy etc. and isn't bothered at all by not having it so you do get your personal time back eventually.

KevinTheKoala · 13/09/2022 18:35

I've had 1 formula fed baby and 1 exclusively breastfed baby. The breastfed baby slept the same as the formula fed baby, but I felt better rested because while I was still being woken in the night I didn't have to get up in the night, turn the lights on, prepare a bottle, wait for it to cool while settling a screaming baby, I literally just put baby to breast and it's was calm. Going out with the baby was much easier because I could literally grab a few nappies and go, I didn't have to worry about how long I'd be out/how many bottles/where to warm them/worry about sterilising anything etc. It was free and I found it easier to settle my breastfed baby when she was poorly/teething/upset etc. Because boobs are magic apparently.

I will admit that not being able to go out was the hardest part for me. She wouldn't take a bottle at all which caused its own problems, I struggled never having time alone but in hindsight it didn't last that long at all but it felt like it at the time. It also caused problems when I was extremely unwell in hospital because she wouldn't take a bottle and so had to be with me, I discharged myself which obviously isn't ideal but I had no real choice. I was lucky to have a relatively easy breastfeeding journey physically, she latched fairly easily, gained weight as expected and only had minimal discomfort apart from 2 bouts of mastitis - caused by skipping feeds and could have been prevented if I had been more diligent with expressing.

Both breast and bottle feeding have their pros and cons, but for me personally I think if I have another I would ideally combi feed to get the best of both worlds (the benefits of baby taking a bottle and the benefits of breastfeeding) but I wouldn't rule out breastfeeding completely and if I had to choose one or the other, I'd still breastfeed. I do feel I have bonded better with my breastfed baby, but I had extremely severe PND with my eldest and so that may have nothing to do with how she was fed and more the circumstances I was in when she was born, but in terms of how they behave now - that's purely personality so no, breastfeeding doesn't give them a noticeable advantage over formula. It's whatever works best for mum and baby, any other opinion is worthless.