Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think breastfeeding is a hassle?

414 replies

choolaboola · 13/09/2022 15:48

Apologies in advanced if this is offensive as I know some BF people feel really passionate about it - BUT - can I please ask, why do people breastfeed?

First time pregnancy here - all I read is "my BF baby won't sleep" "I can't leave them down" "I can't go to XYZ months in because Im exclusively BF" etc.

I'm genuinely wondering is it a much harder path to go down? My friends, sisters, mum and MIL have all formula fed and as far as I can see, the outcome is the same. So I'm just wondering what other people's thoughts are?

OP posts:
Xmasbaby11 · 14/09/2022 09:28

I did mixed feeding with both my dd. I had low supply (found out later it was probably linked to my underactive thyroid) so couldn't fully breastfeed and so did breast and bottle at every feed for 6 months. In a way, the worst of both worlds! It worked for us, anyway. I enjoyed breastfeeding and doing both meant that dd was versatile and if I left her over a feed, she would just have a bottle.

I wish there had been more advice about mixed feeding as no midwives or the support from La Leche League could give me any info or advice which made me feel like a total anomaly - but surely must happen to other mums. This was 8 and 10 years ago so maybe things have improved!

DappledThings · 14/09/2022 09:25

Having had one child ebf who I spent ages trying to get to take a bottle as well which was really hard work I then couldn't be arsed with DC2 and just breastfed. No way could I be bothered with the hassle of bottle feeding.

bedtimestories · 14/09/2022 09:24

I breast fed my 2 with no problems. Both good sleepers

YukoandHiro · 14/09/2022 09:22

When it's working well it's so much less hassle - zero prep, zero cost, always available.

Obvs if your working before 9-12 months or have planned separation periods before they're settled on solids then pumping to prepare and avoiding blocks is a faff. But I didn't have any lengthy separation time til they were older so no matter.

With rising formula prices personally I think knowing there always a food source for your baby is v low stress

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 09:20

@Wouldloveanother thank you for that answer and for not getting the arse with me for asking!! And yes to be fair once DD was 6 months old, crawling around and licking the doormat I'd have been a lot less worried!!! 😆 It's at that newborn stage when you just worry all the time... Having a paediatric nurse give one the go ahead would definitely have been reassuring. I did ask my midwives what I was supposed to do and they referred to the official guidance (which I suppose they should and must, but it just made it seem so utterly impossible to formula feed as newborns feed all over the place and I just couldn't stand the idea of her screaming with hunger while I naffed around cooling fresh boiled water to x degrees etc etc). I'm a bit of a rule follower, so I would have needed someone "official" to give me that permission I guess, rather than just the "I've raised 5 children" brigade.

Change123today · 14/09/2022 09:19

I’ve done both

BF is hard at first but once it clicks it’s all good. Had a good sleeping baby and could be put down in own cot. Much easier past 6 weeks than ff - could go anywhere without worrying about bottles etc much more free.

FF - colicky baby, threw up a lot, was tough time and yes easier at beginning as partner could help , but trying to make up a bottle with screaming baby and all the other things. She co-slept till she was nearly 2. I was lucky if she slept more than an hour !

Hassle isn’t down to how you feed the baby but whether the baby is a unsettled one or not.

NovaDeltas · 14/09/2022 09:18

I was lucky, I think, but it was incredibly easy. No crying or trouble sleeping, no weight issues, no colic. Fed anywhere, anytime, and no washing up or sterilising. I honestly found it second nature. BUT yes some people have difficulties and it you do, sack it off. Life's too short. But it can go really well and be really easy.

Parker231 · 14/09/2022 09:16

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen - my DC’s only ever had formula. No concerns as to it’s safety. It’s an amazing product. They didn’t get sick - no stomach problems or allergies.

People say bottle feeding is a hassle - it’s straightforward, easy, quick and everyone can help with it.

Wouldloveanother · 14/09/2022 09:15

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen well for me, I made them up the ‘official’ way until an NHS paediatric nurse told me ‘nobody really does that, just use a hot shot then top up with pre-boiled cooled water. It’s not official guidance, but..’
But DD was a robust 8mo, I think I would’ve been more nervous if she had been a newborn.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 09:12

@ebri91

Fuck off yourself. It's a genuine question. It's the thing that made FF impossible for me and pumping the easier option as I could not find any officially endorsed guidance about pre-prepping formula that would make it less of a ballache than making it up fresh every time. Yeah various folk would say to me "I just do this [insert time saving measure here]" but when I tried to find guidance on how to do this safely it was nowhere to be found. And in the same way I wouldn't give my baby honey before 1year just because my granny said I had LOADS on my baby porridge and it didn't do me any harm, I wouldn't prep my baby's food in a way that no official source could confirm to me was safe. I'm not being an arsehole, it's a genuine question!!

ebri91 · 14/09/2022 09:01

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 08:55

The thing I don't get about formula feeding is how people "decide" what is "safe enough" for them, because it seems like no-one who does it as their main feeding method actually makes up each bottle fresh as per the package instructions and the NHS guidance (unsurprisingly because that would be SO hard to manage in normal life with a normal baby who doesn't get hungry every 4 hours on the clock). How do you decide "it's ok to just make them up in the morning and warm up", or "it's fine to use a Perfect Prep machine" when there is no official guidance that supports that? Don't you worry?

My baby was only on formula for a day so could afford the ready made stuff - but by GOD it's expensive compared to the powdered (which is also expensive!!). So I understand why these choices get made, I just don't know how people arrive at what they're comfortable with and how they deal with the worry of not following the package/NHS guidance.

oh do fuck off!

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 08:55

The thing I don't get about formula feeding is how people "decide" what is "safe enough" for them, because it seems like no-one who does it as their main feeding method actually makes up each bottle fresh as per the package instructions and the NHS guidance (unsurprisingly because that would be SO hard to manage in normal life with a normal baby who doesn't get hungry every 4 hours on the clock). How do you decide "it's ok to just make them up in the morning and warm up", or "it's fine to use a Perfect Prep machine" when there is no official guidance that supports that? Don't you worry?

My baby was only on formula for a day so could afford the ready made stuff - but by GOD it's expensive compared to the powdered (which is also expensive!!). So I understand why these choices get made, I just don't know how people arrive at what they're comfortable with and how they deal with the worry of not following the package/NHS guidance.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 08:50

I have done both (bottle and breastfed) and for my money bf is easier (long term, can be tough to initiate and settle in no question), cheaper, an so much more versatile. It is so much more than a feeding method, it's a parenting tool. Baby hurts themselves? Breastfeed and it floods them with both pain relieving and comforting hormones. Teething? Instant pain relief and comfort. Baby sick and refusing solids, only wants to cuddle? Bf. Baby vomiting and struggling to hold down fluids? Bf is easy on their tummy and if they do chuck it back up, doesn't stink nearly so badly as formula puke (plus you haven't just 'wasted' a load of time and money on making up a bottle). Baby refusing to sleep at bedtime? Bf until they zonk out 😆 Gone out and forgot to pack snacks/cup, or get stuck out longer than you planned for? Food and drink on tap. Baby bored and being a pest while you try to talk to a friend? Whack em on the boob!

ALL THAT BEING SAID: my first baby had an awful latch and CMPA an ripped my nipples to shreds. It was no joke and it did not "come naturally" - took us about 6 very VERY painful weeks to find our groove. Also because of her bad latch she wasn't getting much on board so woke up every 20 minutes in the early weeks which nearly killed me dead before I learned to feed lying down. La Leche League and an online support forum helped so much. If I hadn't been so (possibly unhealthily) fixated on breastfeeding due to unwanted c section related birth trauma I could easily have given up at that point.

My second baby I was much more prepared - but then she just wouldn't feed AT ALL, flat out wouldn't latch on. Screamed when I tried. Was squeezing out colostrum into a little syringe and squeezing it onto her tongue. It was awful. Midwife visited and saw what a state I was in, saw that the baby was giving signs of low blood sugar and recommended formula to tide her over and she guzzled it down from a newborn bottle - it was such a relief to have her fed. Made me realise what an amazing invention it is, possibly for the first time. I then got a pump and from the next day she was on exclusively pumped bottles (I was lucky that I had little trouble with supply). I found pumping and bottle washing etc a total admin ballache though and hated it, so persisted with bf (mostly at night when she was sleepy enough to be relaxed about giving it a go). By 6 months we were "mixed" breast and bottle, by 10 months she sacked off the bottles herself and was exclusively breastfed. Still going now at 19 months.

I would say the convenience of bottle feeding (if there is any) is in the bottle, rather than the formula, and if I wanted to bottle-feed for whatever reason I would pump for it. Once I discovered in-bra hands free pumping it changed my life, before that pumping was such a nuisance, afterwards it was just so so easy.

I guess my point is it depends what you want out of it. For me, bf solves a bunch of problems an doesn't cause any past the initial weeks or establishing. Bottle feeding caused a lot of issues. But for me, I didnt have to or want to be away from my babies when they were small - if I had needed to, pumped bottles of breast milk would have been my solution.

fantasmasgoria1 · 14/09/2022 08:02

I didn't want to breastfeed. I just did not like the thought of my baby sucking from my breasts several times a day. I know it's a natural thing etc but the thought genuinely made me feel anxious. Perhaps subconsciously the thought of breastfeeding around others was a factor. I also wanted others to be able to feed my baby such as my exh and my mum. Six bottles were made up at the beginning of the day and warmed as soon as DS began to stir.

Wouldloveanother · 14/09/2022 08:00

I also never got the ‘nice hormones’ from breastfeeding, I just felt incredibly thirsty and sweaty. It’s like my body just doesn’t ‘enjoy’ the process of pregnancy and bfing! I can see how it’s much more appealing if it does, and I wish that was me.

Wouldloveanother · 14/09/2022 07:46

BertieBotts · 14/09/2022 07:33

Its like your body isn’t ever really your own when you’re breastfeeding and after being pregnant for nearly ten months I really wanted my body back! Don’t think that’s too much to ask tbh

Defo not too much to ask. This must just be so personal though, because I remember people on my NCT course saying they "wanted their body back", and I remember talking to younger women before I had kids saying they would never breastfeed because they didn't want to share their boobs, but I have never felt like this, not once in 7.5 total years of breastfeeding plus three pregnancies. I don't really get it. I don't feel like my body isn't mine.

I think it's really interesting the way we experience this thing differently.

Absolutely. I didn’t think I would feel that way - I’m not generally hung up over how I look etc, but I really did. I think having difficult pregnancies has something to do with it - you’re going into life with a newborn having already experienced months of pain/fatigue/nausea etc.
I have hyperemesis at the moment and I have never felt so unwell, for so long, in my life - I feel like I’ve been poisoned. Currently vomiting 5 times a day, and up at least once in the night to vomit. Constant nausea, stomach pain from the endless retching.
I don’t know if or when it will ease off, I imagine if it doesn’t then the prospect of DH sharing the feeding responsibilities after the baby is born, to let me get my strength back, will be very appealing. As I said in a previous post, breastfeeding saps my energy and makes me lose weight very quickly, weight I can’t afford as I’m naturally very slim and I’ve already lost 10lb from the vomiting.
Sorry didn’t mean to bang on about vomiting 😂 just trying to explain why it’s not always superficial Barbie mums who ‘want their body back’.

Twizbe · 14/09/2022 07:42

Nowyouwillfeel · 14/09/2022 06:45

@Twizbe but how would your DH know if he’s missing out when he never gave a bottle before so doesn’t know what that’s like? My DH was very sad when we moved away from formula as he loved the experience of feeding baby. He gives the two bottles we do give now and it’s lovely for him.

You might have missed it in earlier posts of mine.

We combi fed our eldest so he had given bottles to him.

He doesn't feel like he missed any bonding time or anything with our daughter just because she was breastfed.

BertieBotts · 14/09/2022 07:33

Its like your body isn’t ever really your own when you’re breastfeeding and after being pregnant for nearly ten months I really wanted my body back! Don’t think that’s too much to ask tbh

Defo not too much to ask. This must just be so personal though, because I remember people on my NCT course saying they "wanted their body back", and I remember talking to younger women before I had kids saying they would never breastfeed because they didn't want to share their boobs, but I have never felt like this, not once in 7.5 total years of breastfeeding plus three pregnancies. I don't really get it. I don't feel like my body isn't mine.

I think it's really interesting the way we experience this thing differently.

arthurfowlermood · 14/09/2022 07:29

Tried it. Hated it. Couldn’t do it. Put myself through hell for a week. Son was suffering and had dry nappies. I was at breaking point.

Gave him a bottle and never looked back.

He was fed and my mental health steadily improved. It just wasn’t for me and that’s ok.

WhatNoRaisins · 14/09/2022 07:15

I can see how the pros and cons can be different for different people. The anyone being able to feed bottles didn't apply to me as much as it would someone who had the baby's grandparents regularly visit and give bottles for example.

From what I've read it seems there is evidence that breast milk is better but what I'm less convinced of is that it's "better" enough to be worth all the guilt the NHS piles on new mothers about it.

Anothernamechangeplease · 14/09/2022 07:11

I'm lazy so bf suited me much better. Bottle feeding looks like a monumental hassle to me. Having to get up in the night to make up a bottle, all that sterilising, not being able to go out without thinking about how many bottles you might need. Each to their own but that wasn't for me!

Giggorata · 14/09/2022 07:11

I was a young mother and remember how surprised and delighted midwives and HVs were when I said I was breastfeeding, as it was unusual for younger mothers at the time.
But to be honest, a lot of my motivation was due to laziness. As someone said upthread, tit > gob.

Perhaps I was lucky, but it was no hassle for me. I don't think I could have borne all the faffing about with sterilisers, bottles, etc.
It didn’t stop me going out and about, to festivals, etc.
I didn't have to pack all that equipment, just needed one bag for nappies and changes of clothes.

And it was great actually!
Bonding and natural and convenience, all in one.

clpsmum · 14/09/2022 06:58

Because the health benefits are better for baby and better for mum

Nowyouwillfeel · 14/09/2022 06:45

@Twizbe but how would your DH know if he’s missing out when he never gave a bottle before so doesn’t know what that’s like? My DH was very sad when we moved away from formula as he loved the experience of feeding baby. He gives the two bottles we do give now and it’s lovely for him.

Twizbe · 14/09/2022 06:38

Marvellousmadness · 14/09/2022 04:29

A formula fed baby is a baby that sleeps
through the night. And a mum that is able to drink a few glasses of red.

breastfeeding equals sleepless nights for at least a year. And saggy boobs...

No thanks.

🤦‍♀️ right there a ton of myths about breastfeeding.

How you feed has not impact on whether baby sleeps lots or not

You can drink alcohol while breastfeeding

Saggy boobs are from pregnancy not breastfeeding.

I asked my DH if he feels he missed out by not being able to give DD a bottle. His response was 'nope'.