Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think breastfeeding is a hassle?

414 replies

choolaboola · 13/09/2022 15:48

Apologies in advanced if this is offensive as I know some BF people feel really passionate about it - BUT - can I please ask, why do people breastfeed?

First time pregnancy here - all I read is "my BF baby won't sleep" "I can't leave them down" "I can't go to XYZ months in because Im exclusively BF" etc.

I'm genuinely wondering is it a much harder path to go down? My friends, sisters, mum and MIL have all formula fed and as far as I can see, the outcome is the same. So I'm just wondering what other people's thoughts are?

OP posts:
MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 10:54

And frankly, I'll take a better, safer night's sleep for me and my daughter over your 'sympathy' /approval any day of the week :)

BertieBotts · 14/09/2022 10:53

Wouldloveanother · 14/09/2022 07:46

Absolutely. I didn’t think I would feel that way - I’m not generally hung up over how I look etc, but I really did. I think having difficult pregnancies has something to do with it - you’re going into life with a newborn having already experienced months of pain/fatigue/nausea etc.
I have hyperemesis at the moment and I have never felt so unwell, for so long, in my life - I feel like I’ve been poisoned. Currently vomiting 5 times a day, and up at least once in the night to vomit. Constant nausea, stomach pain from the endless retching.
I don’t know if or when it will ease off, I imagine if it doesn’t then the prospect of DH sharing the feeding responsibilities after the baby is born, to let me get my strength back, will be very appealing. As I said in a previous post, breastfeeding saps my energy and makes me lose weight very quickly, weight I can’t afford as I’m naturally very slim and I’ve already lost 10lb from the vomiting.
Sorry didn’t mean to bang on about vomiting 😂 just trying to explain why it’s not always superficial Barbie mums who ‘want their body back’.

Oh gosh, no, not at all, I didn't think the "want my body back" was a superficial thing. It must be really visceral. I had fairly easy/enjoyable pregnancies (the third was a bit of a drag towards the end) so you're possibly onto something with that idea.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 10:53

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 10:48

Actually I sympathise with those who attempt to get the baby in a basket first before resorting to bedsharing as a last resort. Those who don't even bother and are proud of it I don't. I wonder which group you fall in?

Baby 1 I was group A, baby 2 I was wholeheartedly group B. Know better, do better.

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 10:48

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 10:37

You do love to just chuck a non seqitur don't you?

It's not survivor bias, it's a fact then when done correctly (safe sleep surface, clear of bedding, breastfeeding non-smoking non-drinking non-medicated parent) there is no increased risk. The problem is people are blanket told 'don't sleep with your baby, put them in a cot', and then that doesn't work (many small babies prefer contact when they sleep), and parents then become exhausted and 'emergency' bedshare without planning/preparing/researching how to do it safely.

Actually I sympathise with those who attempt to get the baby in a basket first before resorting to bedsharing as a last resort. Those who don't even bother and are proud of it I don't. I wonder which group you fall in?

Lachimolala · 14/09/2022 10:46

BF is so much easier if you can get it established, I think there’s not enough education around it being a skill you need to learn. I naively thought it would just happen, so when it didn’t and we ended up back in hospital repeatedly making the switch to formula was the easiest thing.

I’ve had 3 children and managed to get it to work for just one, it was easier as it was convenient and free but in the end FF isn’t such a chore. The ready made milks and a clean bottle is all you need.

Comparatively I found I was more comfortable and happier with FF but if I was to have another child I would attempt to persevere with the BF for the health benefits.

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 10:44

KevinTheKoala · 14/09/2022 10:31

But a cuddle doesn't sooth a teething baby as well as breastfeeding does, a cuddle doesn't contain antibodies to sickness like breastmilk does, breastmilk is easier on the stomach than formula and so easier to keep down if a baby is vomiting, and it IS food and drink on tap which is better than letting a young child end up hungry and miserable. A cuddle wouldn't solve any of those things, and plenty of parents have comfort items for their babies too like dummies and special blankets.

With my formula fed baby I had weeks of sleepless nights when she was teething, going through Ashton and parsons powders, calpol and any other solution I could find just to give her a bit of relief, with my breastfed baby, I just had to breastfeed her and she'd settle down in no time at all, when my formula fed baby needed to go into hospital and have IVs put it and MRIs and other scary tests, it was a horrific experience of having to listen to her screaming, when my breastfed baby had a severe infection I could feed her while they put the IVs in and drew blood and yes she cried, but it was sorted much faster and while it was still heartbreaking to have to experience, it wasn't quite as difficult as with my eldest. Formula and bottles are great but they alone can't replace the comfort breastfeeding can bring.

Depending on your feelings for them I often find dummies good for teething. Mind you I was lucky with my first with teething. Waiting to see about my second.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 10:37

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 10:28

Survivor bias.

You do love to just chuck a non seqitur don't you?

It's not survivor bias, it's a fact then when done correctly (safe sleep surface, clear of bedding, breastfeeding non-smoking non-drinking non-medicated parent) there is no increased risk. The problem is people are blanket told 'don't sleep with your baby, put them in a cot', and then that doesn't work (many small babies prefer contact when they sleep), and parents then become exhausted and 'emergency' bedshare without planning/preparing/researching how to do it safely.

KevinTheKoala · 14/09/2022 10:31

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 10:13

I don't get why in every one of those scenarios you would just pop a boob in when a cuddle could suffice? Enough hormones in there to sooth. Not nessarily aimed at you but I see so many moaning that they want independence and then do that. It is just odd.

Obviously this is aimed at older babies and not newborns. *

But a cuddle doesn't sooth a teething baby as well as breastfeeding does, a cuddle doesn't contain antibodies to sickness like breastmilk does, breastmilk is easier on the stomach than formula and so easier to keep down if a baby is vomiting, and it IS food and drink on tap which is better than letting a young child end up hungry and miserable. A cuddle wouldn't solve any of those things, and plenty of parents have comfort items for their babies too like dummies and special blankets.

With my formula fed baby I had weeks of sleepless nights when she was teething, going through Ashton and parsons powders, calpol and any other solution I could find just to give her a bit of relief, with my breastfed baby, I just had to breastfeed her and she'd settle down in no time at all, when my formula fed baby needed to go into hospital and have IVs put it and MRIs and other scary tests, it was a horrific experience of having to listen to her screaming, when my breastfed baby had a severe infection I could feed her while they put the IVs in and drew blood and yes she cried, but it was sorted much faster and while it was still heartbreaking to have to experience, it wasn't quite as difficult as with my eldest. Formula and bottles are great but they alone can't replace the comfort breastfeeding can bring.

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 10:28

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 10:12

Bed sharing is perfectly safe if done properly. As anyone who has read even a tiny amount of research on the subject would know. Sleeping with infants is done worldwide and is completely normal for mammals.

Survivor bias.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 10:26

@ebri91

And you're an angry, aggressive little so and so. I've reported you.

ebri91 · 14/09/2022 10:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Blossom45 · 14/09/2022 10:20

My baby simply wouldn’t latch properly (no tongue tie) and on the rare occasion when she did she’d fall asleep so wouldn’t get enough milk. I so wish I could breastfeed because of its convenience (no sterilising, no making up bottles etc) but it’s not for us. Ultimately though, everything with a baby takes a million times longer and every baby is different, some will be champion sleepers, others won’t be. You just have to do what’s right for you and baby. I also don’t think you can make a firm decision until baby has arrived.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 10:20

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 10:13

I don't get why in every one of those scenarios you would just pop a boob in when a cuddle could suffice? Enough hormones in there to sooth. Not nessarily aimed at you but I see so many moaning that they want independence and then do that. It is just odd.

Obviously this is aimed at older babies and not newborns. *

Well even assuming a cuddle would suffice, it does me no harm to pop the boob in, does the baby some good (oxytocin, nutrition, hydration, pain relief), and does me some good (length of breastfeeding correlates with lower breast cancer rates, oxytocin). Plus we both still get the cuddle. So not so much "why?" as "why not?" really. No rod!

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 10:13

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 10:09

I must be ferociously hard of thinking but I have literally no idea what you mean by that catty little non sequitur. Want to elaborate, or leave me in suspense?

I don't get why in every one of those scenarios you would just pop a boob in when a cuddle could suffice? Enough hormones in there to sooth. Not nessarily aimed at you but I see so many moaning that they want independence and then do that. It is just odd.

Obviously this is aimed at older babies and not newborns. *

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 10:12

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 05:30

Why is not getting out of bed to feed seen as a bonus of BF? Baby should be in a safe place like cot or moses basket.

Bed sharing is perfectly safe if done properly. As anyone who has read even a tiny amount of research on the subject would know. Sleeping with infants is done worldwide and is completely normal for mammals.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 10:09

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 10:02

A rod for your own back springs to mind.

I must be ferociously hard of thinking but I have literally no idea what you mean by that catty little non sequitur. Want to elaborate, or leave me in suspense?

Beigefoods · 14/09/2022 10:07

i think I know one woman who found breastfeeding easy! It is hard at first. With my ds, I hated it and couldn’t wait to give up and stopped at 6 months and moved to formula. Main reasons were a huge hungry baby and hourly wake ups for feeds and not having a day off from feeding. With my dd this time, I’ve been used to no social life so the impact on my independence etc isn’t noticeable haha. I also accepted it would hurt and be hard at first after experiencing that with dd. I’m now at 11 months and still going and will continue when back at work.
I saw a poster in the maternity ward and it made me determined to bf, I didn’t realise all the benefits to be honest. If you google them, it’s amazing. Your boobs even detect from your baby’s saliva what mix of milk the baby needs. So if baby is sick, it prepares the correct antibodies. I’m not adverse to formula at all, I use it at night now but I’m a big advocate of bf having learnt of the benefits and that powered me through the beginning when, for most women, it’s quite hard and you want to give up constantly.

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 10:05

Mamai90 · 14/09/2022 09:36

I breastfed the first day in hospital and then went on to formula feed which was always my plan. But I really regretted not sticking with BF, before you have a baby you can't even begin to imagine the love and the bond you'll feel. I just wanted her close to me skin to skin and you realise then why so many women love breastfeeding, because it's an intimate bonding experience between mother and child and a real sense of closeness.

I really didn't fully 'get it' until it was too late but I'd definitely like to try with baby number 2.

If it is any consolation you can still have a lovely bond with a formula fed baby. My 7 month old only wants me most of the time! Don't swallow all the "only have a amazing bond if you breast feed". Same goes for myvolder child too!

procrastinator8 · 14/09/2022 10:02

Perfect prep machines and safety etc:

elht.nhs.uk/application/files/4915/5533/6985/Statement_on_formula_preparation_machines_Nov_2016.pdf

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 10:02

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 08:50

I have done both (bottle and breastfed) and for my money bf is easier (long term, can be tough to initiate and settle in no question), cheaper, an so much more versatile. It is so much more than a feeding method, it's a parenting tool. Baby hurts themselves? Breastfeed and it floods them with both pain relieving and comforting hormones. Teething? Instant pain relief and comfort. Baby sick and refusing solids, only wants to cuddle? Bf. Baby vomiting and struggling to hold down fluids? Bf is easy on their tummy and if they do chuck it back up, doesn't stink nearly so badly as formula puke (plus you haven't just 'wasted' a load of time and money on making up a bottle). Baby refusing to sleep at bedtime? Bf until they zonk out 😆 Gone out and forgot to pack snacks/cup, or get stuck out longer than you planned for? Food and drink on tap. Baby bored and being a pest while you try to talk to a friend? Whack em on the boob!

ALL THAT BEING SAID: my first baby had an awful latch and CMPA an ripped my nipples to shreds. It was no joke and it did not "come naturally" - took us about 6 very VERY painful weeks to find our groove. Also because of her bad latch she wasn't getting much on board so woke up every 20 minutes in the early weeks which nearly killed me dead before I learned to feed lying down. La Leche League and an online support forum helped so much. If I hadn't been so (possibly unhealthily) fixated on breastfeeding due to unwanted c section related birth trauma I could easily have given up at that point.

My second baby I was much more prepared - but then she just wouldn't feed AT ALL, flat out wouldn't latch on. Screamed when I tried. Was squeezing out colostrum into a little syringe and squeezing it onto her tongue. It was awful. Midwife visited and saw what a state I was in, saw that the baby was giving signs of low blood sugar and recommended formula to tide her over and she guzzled it down from a newborn bottle - it was such a relief to have her fed. Made me realise what an amazing invention it is, possibly for the first time. I then got a pump and from the next day she was on exclusively pumped bottles (I was lucky that I had little trouble with supply). I found pumping and bottle washing etc a total admin ballache though and hated it, so persisted with bf (mostly at night when she was sleepy enough to be relaxed about giving it a go). By 6 months we were "mixed" breast and bottle, by 10 months she sacked off the bottles herself and was exclusively breastfed. Still going now at 19 months.

I would say the convenience of bottle feeding (if there is any) is in the bottle, rather than the formula, and if I wanted to bottle-feed for whatever reason I would pump for it. Once I discovered in-bra hands free pumping it changed my life, before that pumping was such a nuisance, afterwards it was just so so easy.

I guess my point is it depends what you want out of it. For me, bf solves a bunch of problems an doesn't cause any past the initial weeks or establishing. Bottle feeding caused a lot of issues. But for me, I didnt have to or want to be away from my babies when they were small - if I had needed to, pumped bottles of breast milk would have been my solution.

A rod for your own back springs to mind.

WhatNoRaisins · 14/09/2022 09:45

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen

I think that's another thing that muddies the water here, FF isn't this one universal thing, practices change a lot.

I can see advantages to the older ways, making up in advance without worrying about bacteria, only feeding every 4 hours and the formulas being heavier and settling babies for longer periods. It's completely different to having to boil a kettle and make fresh every time whilst FF on demand. You could end up with a baby who eats small amounts every 2 hours day and night, worst of both worlds.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 09:36

@Parker231 well that's your experience. As I say I bottle-fed for months and found it an amazing faff Vs breastfeeding! All that sterilising and scrubbing and making sure you had everything when you went out, finding the right size teat, knowing when you had to size up... And then there was the time I managed to pump ahead three bottles and then left them all in the fridge of the holiday home two counties away and only realised when we got home 😭

As I say no concerns about formula when it's prepared according to guidance, I just don't know how people in general find the confidence to go "off piste" to make it more manageable. I couldn't do it which is one of the reasons I pumped as you can have BM in the fridge and just warm it straight up (or if you're out, pump and feed directly). But then you still have to wash and sterilise the bloody pumps!!!

Can't argue with the other people helping bit though (as long as they actually do). Somehow I still ended up doing all the nights even when baby was bottle fed!! Side eyes partner but it was great in the day time to not ALWAYS be the one who had to drop everything and feed.

Mamai90 · 14/09/2022 09:36

I breastfed the first day in hospital and then went on to formula feed which was always my plan. But I really regretted not sticking with BF, before you have a baby you can't even begin to imagine the love and the bond you'll feel. I just wanted her close to me skin to skin and you realise then why so many women love breastfeeding, because it's an intimate bonding experience between mother and child and a real sense of closeness.

I really didn't fully 'get it' until it was too late but I'd definitely like to try with baby number 2.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/09/2022 09:35

Going to take this at face value.

After the first couple of weeks BF is a doddle. No getting up in the middle of the night to make bottles, no making bottles in general, no worrying about bringing formula out and about. No matter where you you have milk for your baby. Generally you also don't have a "target" when bfing, the amount of time my FF friends stressing over how many ounces baby was drinking was incredible.

Your baby is sick and refusing to eat/ take a bottle? Or it's hot and you are worried about dehydration? Chances are they will BF as its comforting to them and triggers a pain relief response. Same if they ar hurt or upset, feeding is like instant comfort.

[disclaimer to FF who will no doubt get offended by this - it's just my experience and is not to in any way dimish your relationshup with your baby] I also found it an incredible bonding experience with my baby - some of my favoutie moments with my babies are BFing them, it's like a long close cuddle (sometimes). I am not saying that you can't achieve the bond or feeling in otherways, but that was my experience. Also I found it awsome to see my babies my babies grow and knowing that was all coming from me.

I lost a lot of weight BFing, but it helps your uterus contract after birth.

All that is before you even start on the clever things like sharing immune responses with your baby to help them get over illness quicker, the fact the miulk adjusts to different times of day etc etc.

Also, I know lots of FF babies who don't sleep well. Unfortunately FF isn't some magic sleep pill. Babies wake up at night, that's what they do.

Franticbutterfly · 14/09/2022 09:30

I bf all mine. You're right it's not easy - in fact I found it harder bfing than I ever did being pg - but neither is standing in front of a hob cooking a meal for over an hour each evening. It was about nutrition for me. For me, most things that are worth doing take a bit of effort.

That said, I have no issues with ff, I just chose not to do it. It's all a personal choice.