Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think breastfeeding is a hassle?

414 replies

choolaboola · 13/09/2022 15:48

Apologies in advanced if this is offensive as I know some BF people feel really passionate about it - BUT - can I please ask, why do people breastfeed?

First time pregnancy here - all I read is "my BF baby won't sleep" "I can't leave them down" "I can't go to XYZ months in because Im exclusively BF" etc.

I'm genuinely wondering is it a much harder path to go down? My friends, sisters, mum and MIL have all formula fed and as far as I can see, the outcome is the same. So I'm just wondering what other people's thoughts are?

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 14/09/2022 11:36

Haven't RTFT.

For me:
I felt strongly that I wanted to BF for all the well documented reasons.

I was returning to work and felt that BF was the one thing that only I could do and it would help strengthen our bond. To reconnect in such a physical way became very important to me, and also helped cope with the night wakings (which increased when I returned to work).

I didn't have to worry about forgetting things when out and about. As long as I had my boobs, I was able to sort out anything else.

I never FF, but do have the feeling that BF (once established) was far less hassle, especially during the night. I co-slept so just had to roll over and BF, barely awake.

Breast milk is magic - it helped clear up sticky eyes, small scratches.

Most of my peers and family BF so I felt fully supported.

olderthanyouthink · 14/09/2022 11:34

I am far to lazy to wash bottles and far to disorganised to have formula in all the time and remember to bring the stuff 😂 go to take my boobs everywhere anyway

DC1 was a pain in the arse, couldn't leave her, needed feeding all the time, shitty shorty sleeper.

DC2 I can leave just fine, not all day when he was under 1 but for several hours sure, sleep is pretty good.

D1 continues to be more work than other kids and she's no longer BFing and having spoken to MANY people and professionals we put it down to it's just how she is. The idea of having to have bottle fed her through her baby hood is exhausting.

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:33

Twizbe · 14/09/2022 11:31

@IhateHermioneGranger in short yes.

So formula is a great thing. Life saving in many cases. However, formula companies do not make it out of the goodness of their hearts.

There have been cases all over the world of babies being very sick and dying for incorrectly made formula, unclean water used, watering down due to expense and contamination.

Not that long ago there was a black market trade in baby formula in China because of contamination. People were going to HK with suitcases to buy as much Australian / European produced formula as they could. We saw the signs in the shops limiting how much 1 person could buy.

Nestlee are being boycotted at the moment by many people due to poor practices surrounding baby formula.

The vast majority of babies in the UK will be ok with formula not made up per instructions as we have clean water to start with.

I can totally see though how maternal anxiety around that would put people off bottle feeding though. Just like maternal anxiety can put women off breastfeeding because you don't know how much they've had.

To be fair I was coming from the point of view of babies dying in the western world. Obviously I am aware of Nestle.

Twizbe · 14/09/2022 11:31

@IhateHermioneGranger in short yes.

So formula is a great thing. Life saving in many cases. However, formula companies do not make it out of the goodness of their hearts.

There have been cases all over the world of babies being very sick and dying for incorrectly made formula, unclean water used, watering down due to expense and contamination.

Not that long ago there was a black market trade in baby formula in China because of contamination. People were going to HK with suitcases to buy as much Australian / European produced formula as they could. We saw the signs in the shops limiting how much 1 person could buy.

Nestlee are being boycotted at the moment by many people due to poor practices surrounding baby formula.

The vast majority of babies in the UK will be ok with formula not made up per instructions as we have clean water to start with.

I can totally see though how maternal anxiety around that would put people off bottle feeding though. Just like maternal anxiety can put women off breastfeeding because you don't know how much they've had.

BertieBotts · 14/09/2022 11:28

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:18

Have any babies died from incorrectly prepared formula? Obviously I know it is a risk but it is a lot less risky than bedsharing. I don't think it is comparable.

Anyway got to give the baby attention. 😂

Yes, very rarely there are incidences of formula contamination. Recently in the US and a few years ago in France are the two examples I can think of offhand. In both the US and France there is no official recommendation to use just-boiled water, so most people use room temperature water to prepare formula (in the US even tap water can be used). Nine babies died in the US contamination incident and 128 babies were made ill. Investigations are ongoing as to whether the deaths were directly caused by that outbreak. 35 babies became ill in the French outbreak, none of them died.

It is a known risk that formula powder can become contaminated with everyday bacteria such as e-coli, cronobacter and salmonella and this is particularly a risk for babies under four weeks old. In the US where boiling water is not advised, they do advise ready-to-feed formula for newborns.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/09/2022 11:23

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:18

Have any babies died from incorrectly prepared formula? Obviously I know it is a risk but it is a lot less risky than bedsharing. I don't think it is comparable.

Anyway got to give the baby attention. 😂

It's probably not exactly the same no.

It was more a nudge to the pp who said they didn't prepare uit correct and accepted the very small risk.

Becuase, factually and statistically, that is what bed sharing is. A very small risk. Particularly if you ensure safe practices.

(I coslept with our second, after being petrified to do so with DD due to overinflated warnings about how cosleeping is basically a sure fire way to murder babies. IOverall, it was DEFINITELY much safer for the baby second time around. With DD I spent half the first year in a dangerous state of bad sleep. I did many dangerous things as a result. Second time around we had a next to be type crib and would be fleixble with bedsharing if required. DH was out the room, I didn't drink or smoke and bedding was kept safe and to a minimum. I BF which, as others point out, also reduce any risk (whether cosleeping or not). I felt happy with the informed risk assessment we made there. Interestingly NHS advice has changed too now and safe cosleeping is not discouraged)

Worldgonecrazy · 14/09/2022 11:20

Breastfeeding was very hard to begin with but once established it was a doddle, even when I went back to work full time at 12 weeks, I could express enough to maintain supply. We put her cot, side down, next to the bed, filing the small gap between with a rolled blanket, so I didn’t need to get up to feed her. When she was older she would just help herself without waking me.

No need to sterilise bottles or teats, (breast milk is self sterilising) instant comfort, easy to leave the house with just a nappy and wipes, plenty of sleep for both of us. She was never poorly (remarked upon by our GP) and teething was no issue. As I was expressing as well as breast feeding, others got to help with feeds too.

I do recognise that I was blessed with an easy baby and good sleeper, but how much of that was due to luck, and how much due to parenting, I will never know. I was also blessed with great family support and two lovely health visitors who were experts in breast feeding.

Babyboomtastic · 14/09/2022 11:19

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen
I think the other factor, is you mention how you worry about everything when they are newborn. This isn't a universal thing, or at least the worry varies in intensity.

There are many things I worry about too much in life, but presumably, newborns never made me anxious. Like you, I thought of animal parents and babies interacting, with no guidelines, internet, etc, just acting on instinct, and thought that maybe we overthink things.

Hugasauras · 14/09/2022 11:18

Also strange that the same people who get in such a lather about risks of bedsharing are also very blase about the benefits of breastfeeding, even though it halves the risk of SIDs

Yes I always find that interesting, but of course people get up in arms when you point that out!

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:18

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/09/2022 11:15

It's not a big risk. It's risk, yes. But statistically a small one.

Perhaps like preparing formula incorrectly.

Have any babies died from incorrectly prepared formula? Obviously I know it is a risk but it is a lot less risky than bedsharing. I don't think it is comparable.

Anyway got to give the baby attention. 😂

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 11:17

Thank you @Hugasauras for posting the evidence, I love that sheet as it is incredibly realistic and reassuring about the statistics. WHat would be great would be a straight comparison between cot in own room/cot in same room as mother/safe bedsharing with mother. Doesn't seem quite possible to tease that out from these stats but I think it would be interesting.

Also strange that the same people who get in such a lather about risks of bedsharing are also very blase about the benefits of breastfeeding, even though it halves the risk of SIDS.

nameisnotimportant · 14/09/2022 11:15

Very hard for the first six to eight weeks, then I found it very very very easy and I could eat more. I found bottles much more of a faff

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/09/2022 11:15

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:05

Just accept and acknowledgement you are taking a big risk. 🤷‍♀️

It's not a big risk. It's risk, yes. But statistically a small one.

Perhaps like preparing formula incorrectly.

Hugasauras · 14/09/2022 11:14

This has good info in it and is endorsed by Lullaby Trust Smile

www.unicef.org.uk/babyfriendly/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2016/07/Co-sleeping-and-SIDS-A-Guide-for-Health-Professionals.pdf

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 11:12

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:05

Just accept and acknowledgement you are taking a big risk. 🤷‍♀️

Nope. Because I'm not. As I've said, when you remove the risk factors of FF, drugs/drink, smoking or unsafe bedding, there isn't an increased risk to bedsharing vs sleeping in a cot. And the rates of SIDS/suffocation are vanishingly tiny anyway, so even if i was being more slack than i am (which I would never advocate) it isn't a big risk by any definition.

Hugasauras · 14/09/2022 11:12

I've coslept with both of mine, although I did put DD1 in a crib for the first few months but honestly found it a bit of a hassle and especially once she moved to her own room but still had night feeds so we ended up cosleeping till she moved to her own room of her own accord.

DD2 is 12wo and we've coslept since birth, which has been lovely and easy and we've had lots of sleep and it's helped breastfeeding a lot. I feed her lying down, which I find much less disruptive and I've never had that newborn fug of sleep deprivation. She just unlatches herself when done and because we are already in a safe sleep position she doesn't have to be moved.

I don't believe there is an increased risk for a full term breastfed baby and a safe cosleeping environment and position. Statistics generally don't differentiate between safe cosleeping and people accidentally falling asleep on sofa or while sitting up (which ironically tends to happen when people have had the fear of God put into them about sleeping in the same bed!)

But anyway we all find our own comfort levels with risk and as long as we have the relevant information and are making an informed choice, then it's an individual thing. That goes for breastfeeding as well as cosleeping.

PolkaDotShoes · 14/09/2022 11:10

DawnBreaks · 13/09/2022 15:53

I loved breastfeeding and consider it one of the most rewarding, amazing experiences of my life. It was hard at first but ultimately became as easy as breathing. I did it because I felt it gave my babies the best start in life. However, we are all different and you should do what you feel is best for you.

Same here.
I also loved that I didn't have to buy any bulky equipment - nothing cluttering up the kitchen, and that it was essentially free and always on tap.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 11:10

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:08

If this is me you are referring to I have never done "cry it out". Why do you need to go from one extreme to the other?

I'm not referring to 'cry it out' (which is just walking out of the room and leaving child to scream). I'm referring to what is known as 'gentle sleep training' with the put down and pat, or gradual retreating chair stuff. All the things basically between 'cry it out' and 'when your baby cries, pick it up'.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 11:08

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:04

So you preach about the dangers of perfect prep but happily share a bed in which it is well known that babies can and do die?

Okay...

I didn't preach. I asked a question as to how others made their peace with it as it wasn't something I personally could get my head around, which made bottle feeding much more difficult for me. I've had some enlightening answers. Everyone has their thing they worry about. To me it makes perfect sense that mammals sleep with their babies, and very little sense that this would result in an increased risk of death if done in the way most mammals do it (as in breastfeeding mother sharing with infant, no drugs no booze no fags no bed paraphenalia). The evidence supports this view.

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:08

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 11:02

First baby I definitely got into some dangerous situations due to sleep deprivation as she would not sleep in the cot for more than 40 minutes. Ever. and it took forever to settle her in it. Even without bedsharing, walking her round and round the room to get her off when I was dead on my feet and banging into walls but didn't dare sit down with her as I knew I'd fall asleep on her; lying down on the floor with her simply because I was too tired to do anything else and she wouldn't go to sleep without touching me; eventually sleeping with her between me and my partner because I hadn't planned to bedshare so had no safe sleep surface. Now THAT was dangerous.

Baby 2? I didn't even get the cot out of the attic. Since the day she came home from the hospital she has slept with me on a beddingless double mattress on a futon frame on the floor. As it so happens she is a different baby, and would actually settle quite nicely for her dad or after a feed and sleep for a decent length of time - sod's law :P but I was not prepared to go through what we went through with baby 1 and end up at risk, so I planned for what actually worked for me as a parent and her as an infant.

Your next bit will be to tell me i was too lazy to 'train' baby 1 and i should have just let her cry in her cot whilst 'patting' her or 'retreating' or some such thing. At which point I will say at the point you need to completely ignore all your parenting instincts to soothe and comfort, and all your tiny baby's instincts to seek safety and comfort from its primary caregiver, to make your system work, thats the point you have to wonder if it's a workable system.

If this is me you are referring to I have never done "cry it out". Why do you need to go from one extreme to the other?

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:05

Just accept and acknowledgement you are taking a big risk. 🤷‍♀️

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 11:04

Babyboomtastic · 14/09/2022 10:58

I didn't worry.

We take risks every day, without even thinking about them. I've never heard of a baby dying through incorrectly made formula in the uk, but many die in car accidents/collisions with cars.

But how many parents with up whether that car journey is REALLY essential, when deciding to take it, or the safety of taking baby out in the pram for a walk. Both of which have resulted in more tragic deaths of babies than advance making milk or a perfect prep.

The guidelines are so strict because:

  1. there is no incentive from the NHS to make it workable, as that would detract from their push for breastfeeding.

  2. companies are always going to cover their backs. That's why some shampoos even, suggest checking with your doctor before use. It's not about proportionality, but about minimising the risk of litigation.

I didn't worry because making in advance is endorsed as a safe (albiet not the 'ideal' method) by the WHO, I've not known personally any babies become ill using that method, and because frankly, it's a commonly used method and if it were that dangerous, there's be reported of babies becoming ill and dying in the news.

I accept that is a tiny risk, but so is walking up the stairs, riding a bike. Even breastfeeding has it very tiny risks (undiagnosed HIV or other transmissible illnesses, the occasional baby that suffocates on a boob etc). Life is a risk, nothing is 100% safe, and theres a balance to be struck between safety and practicality.

Thank you for this answer, it makes perfect sense to me. All of parenting is a balance of risks as you say, and letting perfect be the enemy of good is never the way forward!

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:04

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 10:54

And frankly, I'll take a better, safer night's sleep for me and my daughter over your 'sympathy' /approval any day of the week :)

So you preach about the dangers of perfect prep but happily share a bed in which it is well known that babies can and do die?

Okay...

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 11:02

First baby I definitely got into some dangerous situations due to sleep deprivation as she would not sleep in the cot for more than 40 minutes. Ever. and it took forever to settle her in it. Even without bedsharing, walking her round and round the room to get her off when I was dead on my feet and banging into walls but didn't dare sit down with her as I knew I'd fall asleep on her; lying down on the floor with her simply because I was too tired to do anything else and she wouldn't go to sleep without touching me; eventually sleeping with her between me and my partner because I hadn't planned to bedshare so had no safe sleep surface. Now THAT was dangerous.

Baby 2? I didn't even get the cot out of the attic. Since the day she came home from the hospital she has slept with me on a beddingless double mattress on a futon frame on the floor. As it so happens she is a different baby, and would actually settle quite nicely for her dad or after a feed and sleep for a decent length of time - sod's law :P but I was not prepared to go through what we went through with baby 1 and end up at risk, so I planned for what actually worked for me as a parent and her as an infant.

Your next bit will be to tell me i was too lazy to 'train' baby 1 and i should have just let her cry in her cot whilst 'patting' her or 'retreating' or some such thing. At which point I will say at the point you need to completely ignore all your parenting instincts to soothe and comfort, and all your tiny baby's instincts to seek safety and comfort from its primary caregiver, to make your system work, thats the point you have to wonder if it's a workable system.

Babyboomtastic · 14/09/2022 10:58

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 08:55

The thing I don't get about formula feeding is how people "decide" what is "safe enough" for them, because it seems like no-one who does it as their main feeding method actually makes up each bottle fresh as per the package instructions and the NHS guidance (unsurprisingly because that would be SO hard to manage in normal life with a normal baby who doesn't get hungry every 4 hours on the clock). How do you decide "it's ok to just make them up in the morning and warm up", or "it's fine to use a Perfect Prep machine" when there is no official guidance that supports that? Don't you worry?

My baby was only on formula for a day so could afford the ready made stuff - but by GOD it's expensive compared to the powdered (which is also expensive!!). So I understand why these choices get made, I just don't know how people arrive at what they're comfortable with and how they deal with the worry of not following the package/NHS guidance.

I didn't worry.

We take risks every day, without even thinking about them. I've never heard of a baby dying through incorrectly made formula in the uk, but many die in car accidents/collisions with cars.

But how many parents with up whether that car journey is REALLY essential, when deciding to take it, or the safety of taking baby out in the pram for a walk. Both of which have resulted in more tragic deaths of babies than advance making milk or a perfect prep.

The guidelines are so strict because:

  1. there is no incentive from the NHS to make it workable, as that would detract from their push for breastfeeding.

  2. companies are always going to cover their backs. That's why some shampoos even, suggest checking with your doctor before use. It's not about proportionality, but about minimising the risk of litigation.

I didn't worry because making in advance is endorsed as a safe (albiet not the 'ideal' method) by the WHO, I've not known personally any babies become ill using that method, and because frankly, it's a commonly used method and if it were that dangerous, there's be reported of babies becoming ill and dying in the news.

I accept that is a tiny risk, but so is walking up the stairs, riding a bike. Even breastfeeding has it very tiny risks (undiagnosed HIV or other transmissible illnesses, the occasional baby that suffocates on a boob etc). Life is a risk, nothing is 100% safe, and theres a balance to be struck between safety and practicality.