Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think breastfeeding is a hassle?

414 replies

choolaboola · 13/09/2022 15:48

Apologies in advanced if this is offensive as I know some BF people feel really passionate about it - BUT - can I please ask, why do people breastfeed?

First time pregnancy here - all I read is "my BF baby won't sleep" "I can't leave them down" "I can't go to XYZ months in because Im exclusively BF" etc.

I'm genuinely wondering is it a much harder path to go down? My friends, sisters, mum and MIL have all formula fed and as far as I can see, the outcome is the same. So I'm just wondering what other people's thoughts are?

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 14/09/2022 12:43

Tort · 14/09/2022 12:40

Awww that gave me such a clear memory of hugging and rolling to swap boobs. Mine could help himself to upper one eventually but I think he was over six months at least.

Ha ha, yes! I was thinking about smaller babies. Once they get to a certain size it's a different story entirely!
They're 23 and 13 now and I do treasure these very personal and intimate times.

Tort · 14/09/2022 12:40

TheOrigRights · 14/09/2022 12:17

No flopping here. I have tiny breasts. I've read how women can BF flat on their backs, or feeding from the upper breast when lying on their side.
I could never do that, but did perfect the bed roll - baby attached to breast, hold them close, roll over and seamlessly move baby to the other breast.

Awww that gave me such a clear memory of hugging and rolling to swap boobs. Mine could help himself to upper one eventually but I think he was over six months at least.

Sniffypete · 14/09/2022 12:37

Surely just whipping a boob out is easier and most importantly free?
I never produced any milk so had to ff and it was such a faff!

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/09/2022 12:33

noclothesinbed · 14/09/2022 12:09

The outcome is definitely the same. As someone who did bf for one baby and bottle for another I can honestly say the bottle fed baby got way less coughs and colds actually and is healthier all round (now grown up). It's personal choice but if I had my time again I would hundred percent bottle feed. I love the routine of every four hour feeds and seeing how much they had taken. Went straight down for nap after feed and to be honest I was constantly sodding around all night with breast feeding !!

But that's just 100% percent anecdotal. Both mine were BF and one is loads more succeptible to illness than the other who barely blinks no matter what germs are throw at her. Your anecdotal comparison, kindly, proves nothing.

Teenytinyfeet · 14/09/2022 12:29

LemonPledge555 · 13/09/2022 20:39

@LuckySantangelo35

For mums there is an increased risk of premenopausal breast cancer, ovarian cancer, type 2 diabetes, heart attack, osteoporosis and rheumatoid arthritis.

For babies there is an increased risk of infections (lung, GI tract, ear infections, lower respiratory), type 1 and 2 diabetes, childhood cancer, SIDS, asthma, skin allergies…

All sorts of risks. But generally we speak about the benefits.

Not meant to be judgy. More for information!

Can you show your sources for this information please with actual statistics as to how much it lessens the risk of these things? I have done a fair amount of research into this and the numbers were tiny. Something like it reduces the risk of breast cancer by 4% but that’s only if you breast feed for 12 months.

Likewise, it drops the risk of getting an ear infection and the like in the first year, but those risks are low anyway, the statistics were something like it drops it down from 6% to 3%. So the risk is low anyway.

Can we actually start linking to proper research (of which there isn’t much) and statistics before making these bold claims and scaring women who can’t/ don’t want to breastfeed that they’re going to get cancer because of this and their babies are going to be ill/ die or SIDS 🙄

TheOrigRights · 14/09/2022 12:17

workiskillingme · 14/09/2022 11:55

Just a question regarding breastfeeding - why is it everyone 'flops' a boob out?

No flopping here. I have tiny breasts. I've read how women can BF flat on their backs, or feeding from the upper breast when lying on their side.
I could never do that, but did perfect the bed roll - baby attached to breast, hold them close, roll over and seamlessly move baby to the other breast.

Wouldloveanother · 14/09/2022 12:16

noclothesinbed · 14/09/2022 12:09

The outcome is definitely the same. As someone who did bf for one baby and bottle for another I can honestly say the bottle fed baby got way less coughs and colds actually and is healthier all round (now grown up). It's personal choice but if I had my time again I would hundred percent bottle feed. I love the routine of every four hour feeds and seeing how much they had taken. Went straight down for nap after feed and to be honest I was constantly sodding around all night with breast feeding !!

I’m really not doing breastfeeding down but I’m always a bit baffled by how amazing the benefits are on paper vs how little effect they seem to have in real life? On paper they’re incredible, but in real life the healthiest kids I know were bottle fed. 8 months of breast milk didn’t seem to do much for my daughter who caught every bug going, but her bottle fed cousins never get sick and seem to have the constitutions of an ox. I would be genuinely interested to know why.

LuckySantangelo35 · 14/09/2022 12:15

I don’t think wanting your body back is superficial at all

lets not pretend - we all want to look and feel nice in our clothes etc

its not selfish or shallow

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 12:10

Worst thing about bottle feeding actually is it got me out of the habit of wearing boob accessible clothes... now toddler is quite keen and will march up to me when i get home from work and demand it, there's me on the sofa with my smart high-necked office dress rucked up round my armpits, tights gusset on display to poor old DP when he comes in 😳Flopping a boob out of a stretchy top would be considerably more dignified!

noclothesinbed · 14/09/2022 12:09

The outcome is definitely the same. As someone who did bf for one baby and bottle for another I can honestly say the bottle fed baby got way less coughs and colds actually and is healthier all round (now grown up). It's personal choice but if I had my time again I would hundred percent bottle feed. I love the routine of every four hour feeds and seeing how much they had taken. Went straight down for nap after feed and to be honest I was constantly sodding around all night with breast feeding !!

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 11:59

workiskillingme · 14/09/2022 11:55

Just a question regarding breastfeeding - why is it everyone 'flops' a boob out?

Because being engorged with milk makes them feel pretty 'floppy' 😉As does pregnancy come to that.... I suppose depending on what I was wearing sometimes I 'winkled a boob out' or 'slipped a boob out'. but tbh, flopping was standard!

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 11:57

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11189463/Abbott-Labs-hid-lawyers-YEARS-recalling-powdered-formula-shutting-factory.html

This just a recent reminder though that while formula is amazing and lifesaving stuff, formula companies - not so much. Like so much that is essential I feel the profit motive is not something that should really be involved, and would be happy to hear of more initiatives by governments or non-profits to ensure a safe, affordable, sustainable offer to all parents who need formula. I also think their advertising practices, despite the rafts of regulation they are having to weasel around, are pretty egregious tbh.

Sorry about the fail link, in a rush and it was the first news report that came up!

olderthanyouthink · 14/09/2022 11:57

Because it sounds funny?

I don't flop one out technically because my boobs aren't the right size and shape for flopping 🙃 whip one out maybe?

Somethingsnappy · 14/09/2022 11:55

JaninaDuszejko · 13/09/2022 19:15

I always thought of BFing as the 'baby reset' button, it was a crucial part of my parenting toolbox in the early days. Particularly with DC3 it was very much 'if in doubt BF'.

Baby hungry? BF
Baby thirsty? BF
Baby tired? BF
Baby cold? BF
Baby hot? BF
Baby constipated? BF
Baby needs affection? BF

Love this! Baby reset button 😎😍

workiskillingme · 14/09/2022 11:55

Just a question regarding breastfeeding - why is it everyone 'flops' a boob out?

Msloverlover · 14/09/2022 11:48

Wouldloveanother · 13/09/2022 15:58

Ooooh we don’t talk about that on here OP 😉

I’ve done both, breastfed for 8 months (it was more mix feeding for the last month or so) then a few months of formula at the end.

Breastfeeding is both convenient and a faff. Convenient in the early days, when you’re not going anywhere anyway, and no sterilising etc to do. Possibly less convenient after 6m when you want to do the odd thing independently and no
more sterilisation is required just regular washing of bottles.

Health wise, there’s virtually no difference between a breastfed baby and a formula fed baby. There’s a small benefit to breastfeeding, but it’s only seen if you record the health data of hundreds of thousands of babies. My family are very very strong advocates of breastfeeding, yet the unhealthiest bunch of people I know - weight issues, allergies, immune conditions. Everyone has something wrong. DH’s family are of the 70s formula feeding vintage, and healthy as horses, strong constitutions etc.

Sleeping wise DD slept through from 4 or 5 months, so can’t comment there.

So really, it all boils down to whatever works for you. And you’re completely entitled to query this by the way - if people have issues with you doing so it’s because they feel it undermines the effort they put into breastfeeding, to point out it has strengths and weaknesses like anything else.

I’d say the opposite in my case. Beginning was a faff (well actually just painful) and cluster feeding (at the time) I thought was a pain. After a couple of months though it was the easiest thing in the world. Flop out a boob, feed, done.

Im pregnant again and actually now really looking forward to cluster feeding eg sitting on the sofa eating chocolate, watching Netflix, completely exempt from childcare duties!

Babyboomtastic · 14/09/2022 11:47

BertieBotts · 14/09/2022 11:28

Yes, very rarely there are incidences of formula contamination. Recently in the US and a few years ago in France are the two examples I can think of offhand. In both the US and France there is no official recommendation to use just-boiled water, so most people use room temperature water to prepare formula (in the US even tap water can be used). Nine babies died in the US contamination incident and 128 babies were made ill. Investigations are ongoing as to whether the deaths were directly caused by that outbreak. 35 babies became ill in the French outbreak, none of them died.

It is a known risk that formula powder can become contaminated with everyday bacteria such as e-coli, cronobacter and salmonella and this is particularly a risk for babies under four weeks old. In the US where boiling water is not advised, they do advise ready-to-feed formula for newborns.

The 9 cases, over 15m, equates to about a 1 in 500,000 chance of it killing a baby. That was during an outbreak. In the uk, the risks are far lower than that.

The risk of sids is 1:1700

Even during an outbreak of contaminated milk, the risk is lower than being struck by lightening.

Formula is really, good really safe

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 11:47

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:37

Many people actively choose to bedshare whereas I did attempt twice to try to breastfeed. It didn't work out. Such is life. Baby won't die from the lack of breast milk. Also the benefits of the lower risk of breast cancer in my case would be cancelled out by the extensive fertility treatment which increases the risk!

Well this is just it. Statistics are there to guide our overall approach, and then individual experience and real life gets in the way! The important thing is that babies are healthy and safe and loved (and mothers, actually!). We all get there our own way but most of us get there. I think making peace with that is harder for some than for others.

I think experience helps, and i don't think anyone on their second baby isn't a ton more relaxed and confident about their choices, and indeed those things where choice doesn't come into it. I was brokenhearted when I had to have an EMCS with my first baby; when my planned VBAC with baby 2 started going the same way as the first, it was a much much easier decision to let that dream go and do what was easiest and safest for me and my baby.

I feel like we've both got a bit onto our high horses here actually, it's easily done when talking parenting choices as it's so close to our hearts and it's easy to feel attacked. I think we're extremely lucky to live in a modern first world country with access to clean water, formula, free healthcare, reasonable maternity policies, and a wealth of good advice and education to understand how to interpret that advice and tell the good from the bad. We really couldn't be luckier. So people like us arguing over this choice or that choice is utterly daft really, as we both have every opportunity to have healthy, happy, well-looked after babies however we go about it. So sorry! :)

Ringmaster27 · 14/09/2022 11:45

Honestly?
The biggest factor in it for me was convenience!
We are a bedsharing family, so no getting up in the night - just flop a Boob out, and job done.
No washing or sterilising bottles.
No packing all the feeding stuff when going out and then being stuck if I forgot something - can’t forget my boobs at home 🤷🏻‍♀️😂
No paying for formula or bottles or sterilising equipment.
And it became the most effective tool in my parenting Arsenal when we entered the toddler years. If the toddler is hurt, upset, tired etc, a boob became the most effective solution to all of those things.
Don’t get me wrong, getting started was hard all 3 times. As much as people say it’s the most natural thing in the world….it’s really not. It’s a skill that you and your baby both have to learn. Once you’ve passed the initial hurdles though, I found it easy. Until the point arrived to stop. Weaning a toddler off the boob can also be really challenging!

Sunnytwobridges · 14/09/2022 11:44

FlounderingFruitcake · 13/09/2022 16:07

I found bottles pretty easy tbh. Run them through the diswasher and then the microwave. Barely more work than any other type of drinking cup. Perfect prep machine at home does a drinking temp bottle in minutes, used ready made out of the house which you just throw in your bag with a bottle and pour when a feed is due. Feed times were always predictable at every 4 hours during the day so I could plan according. Both of mine slept well- never more than 1 night feed from birth and an 8 hour stretch from 4-6 weeks. I don’t think I can credit that to formula, more a combo of a good routine and an awful lot of luck. But even of yours isn’t a great sleeper then as long as you have a partner and they’re not completely out useless then it’s not all on you and you can do proper overnight shifts and have a night off when you need it.

It’s about what works best for you and your family but for me that was definitely formula.

This. It was pretty easy.

Also my dd was never sick and completed school at the top of her class. So I didn’t see any benefits of breast feeding.

workiskillingme · 14/09/2022 11:37

Yes massively
But so is a lot of parenting

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/09/2022 11:37

Babyboomtastic · 14/09/2022 11:19

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen
I think the other factor, is you mention how you worry about everything when they are newborn. This isn't a universal thing, or at least the worry varies in intensity.

There are many things I worry about too much in life, but presumably, newborns never made me anxious. Like you, I thought of animal parents and babies interacting, with no guidelines, internet, etc, just acting on instinct, and thought that maybe we overthink things.

Very fair point!! I guess this was and is what guides me as a parent - I listen to what my instincts are telling me about my babies and what they and I need. Being a librarian I then also research to make sure I'm not wrong! 😆But by and large the things that make me most anxious tend to be the things that take me away from those natural instincts, and for the most part doing what 'feels' right has been in accordance with the evidence. So for e.g. when my 2nd wouldn't feed from the breast, it felt bloody fantastic to feed her formula because she was starving and then she was fed, which every instinct in me was screaming at me she needed. So it's not an appeal to 'nature above all else' (unmediated nature has a pretty catastrophic wastage rate for human babies!). But to follow the instincts we have as mothers to protect and care, and to follow the baby's instinct to seek closeness and bond to us in every way possible, seems like the most logical, least stressful and least risky way to go in most cases.

IhateHermioneGranger · 14/09/2022 11:37

Hugasauras · 14/09/2022 11:18

Also strange that the same people who get in such a lather about risks of bedsharing are also very blase about the benefits of breastfeeding, even though it halves the risk of SIDs

Yes I always find that interesting, but of course people get up in arms when you point that out!

Many people actively choose to bedshare whereas I did attempt twice to try to breastfeed. It didn't work out. Such is life. Baby won't die from the lack of breast milk. Also the benefits of the lower risk of breast cancer in my case would be cancelled out by the extensive fertility treatment which increases the risk!