Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think breastfeeding is a hassle?

414 replies

choolaboola · 13/09/2022 15:48

Apologies in advanced if this is offensive as I know some BF people feel really passionate about it - BUT - can I please ask, why do people breastfeed?

First time pregnancy here - all I read is "my BF baby won't sleep" "I can't leave them down" "I can't go to XYZ months in because Im exclusively BF" etc.

I'm genuinely wondering is it a much harder path to go down? My friends, sisters, mum and MIL have all formula fed and as far as I can see, the outcome is the same. So I'm just wondering what other people's thoughts are?

OP posts:
siblingrevelryagain · 13/09/2022 17:46

In my opinion there is no easy option or harder option with babies - you get a hard time at some point, it's just different/delayed

If you have a vaginal birth, you have most of the pain and trauma up front, but in most cases it then gets easier once baby is out, whereas C-section seems to make the initial giving birth easier but then can be uncomfortable/painful long afterwards

Same with breastfeeding - when everyone bottle feeding seems to be skipping off into the sunset with their baby, you have a shit old time initially, but then further down the line when they're waiting for water or bottles to heat in coffee shops, you've popped baby on and have a hand free for drinking coffee, or have popped baby on boob and gone back to sleep without standing in a freezing cold kitchen

I breastfed all 3 of mine and found it full of so many lovely moments (as well as the hard)

fruitbrewhaha · 13/09/2022 17:46

Of course it's a hassle. It's all a hassle. Feeding, waking up, changing, laundry, early starts, entertaining them, getting them to places, school, homework, dinner, more laundry, sports clubs, and then the teenage years means while your up to elbows in hassle they moan and you and roll their eyes. If you want to avoid hassle, don't have kids.

Confusion101 · 13/09/2022 17:42

I have only FF. I find it reassuring to know other people can help out. I also find it great knowing how much baby is getting. I have been able to tip into town or socialise and leave baby to be minded nó hassle. Sterilising bottles is a pain but I've gotten into a routine of it now so it's easier. Do your research as you are doing then make a decision for yourself and ignore everyones opinion after that because no matter what you choose you will have people telling you you are right and wrong. Best of luck.

luxxlisbon · 13/09/2022 17:41

I did both and I agree. I don’t think people do breastfeeding any favours by pretending it’s easy, hassle free and not hard. It’s very difficult and I be the only one who can feed baby. It’s exhausting to do all the nights and feel like you can’t have more than an hour or two away for months and months in the beginning.
I also think people are so overdramatic about how complicated it is to make bottles. It’s so easy to sterilise, takes barely any time at all to make a bottle fresh and then cool in cold water. Plus you have the option of ready made.
Of course it’s easier to just whip a boob out, but equally not always. My baby hated feeding out and about and found it difficult to latch for ages.
Cost is obviously a big difference, but when I started using a bottle in the evening which meant baby would settle much easier for DH and I could go to bed, I realised I would pay almost anything for more sleep so it wasn’t a problem 😂

CastleCrasher · 13/09/2022 17:38

I found it far easier. Yes there are downsides, mainly that I'm the only one with the boobs, but if I felt strongly enough about that I could have expressed I'm sure (well, I did, but it was a faff so I stopped) or combi fed. As it was, I fed each DC for 18 months.

BF meant I always had the food the DC wanted, instantly. No sterilising, no measuring at 3am, no rooting about in a bag while baby screams the cafe down. I often went out for the day with a sling and a spare nappy& wipes tucked into the pouch - so handy!

Fififelix · 13/09/2022 17:36

I stopped at 3 months and went exclusively onto FF. I found it hard baby had to constantly be with me cluster feeding I was really sleep deprived. My nipples were flat so the latch took ages to get while I had a crying hungry baby. I looked at the statistics and decided the WHO studies were more aimed at low income countries. In my opinion it didn't make a huge amount of difference. Very happy I quit I have a happy thriving 9 year old and when I quit BF I gave DD to her dad and had a lovely 12 hour sleep with no guilt. Just see how you feel. DD also started sleeping through .

Survey99 · 13/09/2022 17:33

Parker231 · 13/09/2022 16:45

For those saying making bottles is a hassle - it’s 100% not with a perfect prep machine. By the time baby had woke up enough to start crying, a perfectly made bottle was ready.

Anyone I know who had a perfect prep (or similar) was advised by HV they are not recommended and when they looked at them online they understood why. Either due to the "hot shot" not being enough volume of hot water to adequately kill the bacteria when dispensed onto cold formula in a cold bottle effectively, or because of the reported concerns with mould build up inside the tubing inside the machine.

There are enough doubts about any formula making machine generally, or if it isn't working optimally, I personally wouldn't use them and would want to be able to see all the parts to ensure they were adequately sterilised, formula correctly prepared, and parts replace it there was any build up on them, especially for a very young baby.

mmmflakycrust81 · 13/09/2022 17:32

Cant be bothered making and washing up bottles
DD had explosive shits when she had formula
easier during the night
easy to comfort when they are upset especially when out and about
i love the bond and connection time

I am still going two years later and apart from the odd nipple lash injury its effortless now.

quiteathome · 13/09/2022 17:31

I loved breast feeding. I was lucky and I found it nice and easy,and I quite enjoyed the early morning feed as it got light outside.

I was very lucky as I didn't work when the children were babies.

I am also an exceptionally greedy person, so I was quite happy to add the extra calories to my diet.

Just do what makes you happy and keeps you and your baby healthy and alive. It is worth trying to breast feed you might love it. And you don't have to faff around with bottles.

Wnikat · 13/09/2022 17:29

I’m really lazy and breastfeeding was easier than all the faff with bottles.

Purplemoons2827 · 13/09/2022 17:28

I much prefer bf, no bottles, no sterilizing, no prep! Once I got the hang of bf I found it easy and quick, baby fed in 5-10 mins, can feed anywhere without having to worry about bringing bottles etc. Personally I found ff a hassle.

RedHelenB · 13/09/2022 17:27

You don't have to be a martyr to breastfeeding. You can always mix feed too. I bf all mine, one exclusively who also wouldn't take a dummy, bottle or cup until over a year but they all.slept for a chunk of 5+ hours by at least 4 months ( illness and teething excepted).
Give it a try ( very easy to get talked out of it as it doesn't always come naturally) I enjoyed it and felt my babies enjoyed the closeness. Most of my baby friend parents bf too, for varying lengths of time.

Superbabe64 · 13/09/2022 17:24

None of my friends or family had BF but I did and loved it.
The only thing I would say is to get the baby to also take a bottle as soon as. You can then extract milk at the same time so the baby's dad can also give bottles and you can leave baby with a babysitter. I use to freeze any surplus milk.
Good Luck...it really is not rocket science.

Mamma7576 · 13/09/2022 17:23

I did a mix of both. I can tell you that formula is a much bigger more expensive hassle. There's nothing worse than desperately trying to measure out spoonfuls of formula and cool down boiling water quickly for 3 mins at 3am while your baby is screaming in hunger.

womaninatightspot · 13/09/2022 17:22

Bf is a hassle and I say that as someone who Bf 4 dc till nearly 2 with the last lot being twins. They would take turns to feed/ sleep. It was brutal at the time but they had a milk allergy and I think I was too exhausted to do anything but plod on. That said it’s instant and convenient in lots of ways.

lots of long lasting protection from gastrointestinal problems if you bf and other health benefits. Handy if they have a blocked up nose or conjunctivitis to squirt a bit of bm on it. I think it’s good to try bf for the colostrum if nothing else. That said just feed your baby in a way that works for you.

pointythings · 13/09/2022 17:19

If BF works for you (and you have to give it some time because it's a new skill to both you and your baby) then it's incredibly easy. Much easier than the faff of bottles.

If it doesn't work for you, it's hell and you should switch to formula.

I was lucky and found it a piece of cake, would have hated to do bottles. Several of my friends had the opposite experience. It's suck it and see and don't judge what other people do.

Babyboomtastic · 13/09/2022 17:19

I did one of each - I chose to ff my first, and tried to combi feed my second, but she refused bottles, so I bf her.

If I had a third, I'm not sure which I'd choose - I'd probably try to mix feed again.

With bottles, I loved that I could (and did) share the nights. Bottle admin was shared, and sterilising was about 5m work once a day. We made up bottles for 24hrs, cooled them quickly and put them in the fridge. We either out them in a jug of hot water or a microwave to heat.

It was easy. We went away for weekends, holidays etc, and it was really not an issue. You have to be organised to ensure you don't run out, but it was very easy.

I liked that if I was ill, I could get rest. As we shared nights, I was never really tired.

I didnt like that I was feeding my baby powder, and it didnt feel very natural. I loved how my baby developed a very equal with with both of us, and I maintained a sort of social life.

Formula didnt make her a good sleeper.

My bf baby, I liked how natural it felt, and it was easy. There wasnt really any 'establishing' breastfeeding, it was just mouth to tit and go. I liked the extra flexibility we had as a pair. I missed the flexibility I lost as an individual.

She was a terrible sleeper, and very much exclusively bonded to me, which has had a longer term effect on the balance of our family.

There are pros and cons to each.

user1471523870 · 13/09/2022 17:19

I believe everyone has his own belief, history, preferences and they are all valid.

For me, breastfeeding was a natural choice as everyone around me breastfed. It felt very normal. And I absolutely loved it and still miss those times!

From a practical perspective I didn't mind getting up every 3 hours, but it was also easy as I only needed to turn to his cot, pick him up, put him on the breast few minutes, make him burp, put him back and go back to sleep.
I loved the feeling of him attached to me, to be able to provide milk for my baby. My partner was jealous I could have that special moment!

And it was super easy to go out or travel, no need to bring formula, wonder about temperature, quantities, sterilize bottles etc. I never turned down an invite because I had to breastfeed, on the contrary it was great to move around as him and me were self sufficient in a way.
But mostly it's really down to the fact it was an intimate, lovely moment and I felt like a super woman:).

ihatespeed · 13/09/2022 17:17

Organisational skills- if like me you lack them, or find them incredibly draining, then BF is often easier. It's a big job and I would ha ve struggled so much with everything that goes into formula feeding. I am also a spontaneous person and combined with my lack of organisation, I like to have the single most important thing for a baby ready on tap where it can't be forgotten.

LG93 · 13/09/2022 17:16

I'm still BF at 7 months because I formula fed my first and know how much thought went into sorting bottles to go out etc, and knew if I did that this time with 2 to get out the door I'd never leave the house.

We had a bumpy start to feeding but he sleeps as well as my first bottle fed baby did (currently 7-7 with one feed in the night, from a newborn only ever a max of 2 feeds a night) and takes a bottle so have left him on occasions with expressed milk (or now the odd bottle of formula now he's over 6 months).

I may have been lucky but having fed both ways, bf is so much easier, and I had absolutely planned to stop before now but carried on for ease so absolutely not one of the steadfast breast only mums ( not knocking those mums at all, I admire their dedication!!)

lanthanum · 13/09/2022 17:14

Mine had to be tube fed initially, and when she got the hang of things had to have formula top-ups because she didn't get enough otherwise. When she began weaning, we dropped the bottles - which tells you which we found easiest! Mine tanked up in the evenings, so I was unable to get back to my hobby until she stopped doing that, but I didn't really mind. I understand that some people might hate that.

Pros of formula:
You don't have to do every feed, so you can get more sleep or go out (assuming partner to help out).
They do sometimes sleep more after formula.

Pros of breast-feeding:
You don't have to organise taking bottles with you everywhere, sterilise them, etc. If you get held up somewhere, no problem. First thing in the morning - all you have to do is pick them up and start feeding, no having to go down to the kitchen to prepare/fetch a bottle.
It's free (possibly some unseen costs if you eat more, I guess).
There are supposedly some health benefits, but I don't think they're huge. I think they make most difference early on.

It's worth giving it a go, at least, but don't beat yourself up about it if it really doesn't work for you.

Wouldloveanother · 13/09/2022 17:13

BunsyGirl · 13/09/2022 17:11

*lid!

I was going to say, it’s the other way round Grin

BunsyGirl · 13/09/2022 17:11

*lid!

BunsyGirl · 13/09/2022 17:11

I have done both and there’s a lot on this thread about BF feeding being easier because you don’t have to get out of bed to sterilise bottles, make them up etc. However, I never got out of bed to make up a bottle. Bottles were sterilised before I went to bed and taken upstairs and I used pre-made formula in cartons at room temp. Take kid off bottle, stick milk in bottle, that’s it. DH and I used to take it in turns to give DS his bottle during the night. When I BF my other child, it was just me getting up night after night for months! Ready made formula is more expensive so you do need to be aware of that.

Herejustforthisone · 13/09/2022 17:08

No judgement

Sh’yeah. Right.

Swipe left for the next trending thread