Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have different values to you

63 replies

WhatIsThisMad · 13/09/2022 14:16

AIBU to think this is the new way of saying 'i don't like you or your views and I'm better than you and my views are the only right ones, but I don't want to sound superior or that I'm putting you down or that I'm up myself'.

Feels like this is the new 'polite' (maybe woke) way of criticising someone and putting them down in a way that makes you sound superior without vocalising you think you are superior.

'we just have different values' is a term I hear alot recently (not usually directed at me, but) if directed at me it feels like a wrapped up criticism to which I have no recourse (hope that's the right spelling!)

OP posts:
ShandaLear · 13/09/2022 15:54

I don’t think it’s a superiority thing. It just means you have different beliefs/priorities/things that are important. If I prioritised sending my kids to dance classes because I believed it was good for their motor development while my DP wanted to prioritise sending them to swimming lessons because water safety was more important to him, then you could argue we have different values regarding kid’s exercise.

Cattenberg · 13/09/2022 15:52

I wouldn’t like to hear this phrase either, especially if someone was making assumptions about my values. I think it sounds patronising in a way that, “we have differing views” doesn’t.

HappyMackerel · 13/09/2022 15:51

If this affects you then could you be insecure about your own values?

SatinHeart · 13/09/2022 15:51

I've never heard anyone say this but I'd assume it was a more long winded version of "you do you"

GreenWhiteViolet · 13/09/2022 15:46

It's a phrase that I use fairly often, and when I say it I mean that we disagree but there's no sense in arguing over it because the reasons for the disagreement are value-dependent. Imagine disagreeing over a policy - I could say that I think it's a good idea because I value X over Y, but I understand why someone who values Y over X would be opposed to it. Where the values in question are liberty vs security, or individualism vs collectivism, or any other pair you like.

So yes on one level I do think my values are 'better' than the other person's - otherwise I wouldn't hold them. But what I'm usually trying to convey is that I recognise that other people do have different hierarchies of values and that's fine and it's not my place to impose my value system on others. I understand that, believing what they believe, they take the political stance they do. Agree to disagree.

It's not usually a comment on morality, because if I thought someone was morally wrong that would go beyond just 'different values'.

Getoff · 13/09/2022 15:43

NuffSaidSam · 13/09/2022 14:25

I think sometimes it's just true isn't it?

We do all have different values. Not better or worse necessarily, but different.

I don't doubt that sometimes it is used as a sly put down though. I wouldn't let it worry you.

No-one who says they have different values is saying the other person is better than them. It's phrased as if it's a neutral observation, but if it's only said by someone who thinks their way is better, it always implies criticism of the person it's addressed to.

We do all have different values. Not better or worse necessarily, but different.

If you don't think your values are any better, how did you choose them? With a flip of a coin?

I'm sure you can come up with a contrived example that is neutral, but in general "values" are moral beliefs, if someone is different to you, then by definition their belief is wrong.

The alternative is
You believe you ought to be truthful, but it's fine for other people to lie?
You believe you ought to be generous, but it's no problem if other people want to be selfish?
You're a pacifist, but if other people want to start wars, you wouldn't criticise them?
And so on.

MercurialMonday · 13/09/2022 15:38

Mmm.. in the instances I've observed, it's more the other way round. Eg.
Person A trying to 'educate' and thrust views on person
Person B, I take your views on board but not sure I agree completely
Person A, well we just have different values

So it's an updated version of we'll have to agree to disagree?

Or is person A just repeating dogma/phrases with limited understanding and can't actually argue or back up or defend what they believe so can't handle B questions so trot out this phase to stop the conversation.

I still sounds fairly polite way of stopping a potentially divisive conversation - some divisive conversation do need to be had but time and place are important.

Swingsarefun · 13/09/2022 15:36

cstaff · 13/09/2022 15:33

I've heard a slightly different phrase with a similar meaning where when they don't agree with someone's viewpoint they say "we'll just have to agree to differ". It's basically a polite way of saying you're talking bolox... 😆 or at least that's how I take it...

I think ‘agree to differ’ does not cast aspersions the other persons view in the same way ‘different values’ does. ‘Different values’ implies theirs are right and yours are wrong.

nachoavocado · 13/09/2022 15:35

It's the complete opposite. It's saying I don't agree but that's ok

cstaff · 13/09/2022 15:33

I've heard a slightly different phrase with a similar meaning where when they don't agree with someone's viewpoint they say "we'll just have to agree to differ". It's basically a polite way of saying you're talking bolox... 😆 or at least that's how I take it...

NC499 · 13/09/2022 15:31

I think it can be a criticism, a way of saying "I think your values are wrong", but said in a way that is difficult to argue against because it holds truth. I do not like statements that shut down discussion or invalidate so I would never use that term because it could be viewed in that way.

But saying that I do think I have heard it more recently as a simple statement of fact. A way of saying there is no point in having a debate about something that each person or group feels strongly about in opposing terms. There are a lot of things to talk about and it is a waste of everyone's time and energy to try and convince another person of a viewpoint that just isn't comprehensible to them or their life?

There is a benefit to us seeing this in society. And for this view just to come under a "live and let live" attitude, isn't there?

I hear a lot of opinions that I keenly disagree with and I don't often get the chance to discuss them in detail, so I have had to just let it go and think to myself "well, we have different values..." 😁

Icedlatteplease · 13/09/2022 15:24

About time people acknowledged the space within a relationship for differing opinions

WhatIsThisMad · 13/09/2022 15:16

MercurialMonday · 13/09/2022 15:09

would you rather they had said "we don't want to discuss it because you are a bunch of bullying bastards"?

I thought it might be a polite way of dealing with/heading off people who assume anyone who thinks differently needs educating - ignoring any difference in ideology culture or background - and will go on and on till other side stop talking and allow them to believe they have "won".

Mmm.. in the instances I've observed, it's more the other way round. Eg.

Person A trying to 'educate' and thrust views on person

Person B, I take your views on board but not sure I agree completely

Person A, well we just have different values

OP posts:
minipie · 13/09/2022 15:14

A friend of mine’s dad said it to her mother recently when she was commenting about my friends somewhat messy house. He wasn’t making a value judgement, he was just pointing out to his wife that a messy house bothered her, but it didn’t bother their daughter.

Ok fair.

I think I’d say “we value different things” in that context rather than “we have different values”.

To me “values” means “morals”, and so someone saying we have different values = we have different morals = definitely a criticism.

But I can see that if people are using it to mean “we value different things” that isn’t necessarily a criticism.

MercurialMonday · 13/09/2022 15:12

Said to me when apprentice left last week. Thanks for the apprenticeship it's been interesting. We clearly have different values and that's ok

Is that just he got wider experience than he's had previously.

It shouldn't really need stating people have different values and that's okay but some of the youth sub culture does seem very intolerant of differing views.

MercurialMonday · 13/09/2022 15:09

would you rather they had said "we don't want to discuss it because you are a bunch of bullying bastards"?

I thought it might be a polite way of dealing with/heading off people who assume anyone who thinks differently needs educating - ignoring any difference in ideology culture or background - and will go on and on till other side stop talking and allow them to believe they have "won".

Countingdowntodecember · 13/09/2022 15:08

I use this with various members of DH family and I definitely mean that I think they are completely wrong but can’t be bothered to argue about why I won’t follow their terrible advice.

Dalaidramailama · 13/09/2022 15:02

Well I say this about my brother because he is a drug dealer. Does this make me superior? I don’t know. It’s something I struggle with. I struggle with his choices, they’re morally wrong. Our values most certainly are different. Is it still possible for me to have a relationship with him knowing this? It is a struggle.

godmum56 · 13/09/2022 15:00

WhatIsThisMad · 13/09/2022 14:35

Nova - it's not generally said to me (except recently from my apprentice), but between students in a way that sounds like put downs (eg. In the example where one group felt they valued collectivism this was nonsense. From my view.point it seemed the other group didn't want to share ideas not because they value individualism' but because the larger group appeared quite bullying and as if they'd put them down whatever they said)

would you rather they had said "we don't want to discuss it because you are a bunch of bullying bastards"?

I have (some) different values from my best friend. Doesn't make either of us wrong.

WhatIsThisMad · 13/09/2022 14:50

Ps. Thanks this thread is actually helping me think through a few things!

OP posts:
WhatIsThisMad · 13/09/2022 14:47

AlsoknownasOther · 13/09/2022 14:42

What do you want them to say?

I don't know! Maybe 'i disagree with your view on X, y, z' and then discuss it (or not).

I think there's a difference between saying your views and opinions are different to mine Vs your values are different - especially when the implication is my views are better than yours Vs my values are better than yours.

Values somehow feel much deeper and more personal. Having my values put down or seen as less than someone else's feels more of a dig than having my opinions put down or disagreed with.

OP posts:
mamabear715 · 13/09/2022 14:47

I don't mind what people say in this context, as long as they leave it there.. I have to be seething inside (very rare) before I'll even say to someone that we'll have to agree to disagree.. it's my cue that someone's tried to browbeat me long enough, and change my views into theirs, & to stop before I have to smack them one.. ;-)

AlsoknownasOther · 13/09/2022 14:42

What do you want them to say?

scoobycute · 13/09/2022 14:42

Just as @ComtesseDeSpair has said it's a diplomatic way of saying we differ on views without trying cause offence.

I imagine it's someone trying to nip an argument or debate in the bud before it escalates..occasionally I'd say "we will just have to agree to disagree" on hot topics that I'd rather not get deep into.

Some people do hold largely differing values to each-other - so I think it's mature to identify that especially if it's relevant to a relationship or working partnership.

And yea you're right - they think their way is right...which is why they believe what they believe because it's the truth to them. But that's ok, and it's ok for some things to be left at that.

WhatIsThisMad · 13/09/2022 14:39

Ok, thanks for the replies! Good to get a different perspective on it. :)

OP posts: