Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Our DDs in particular need to understand marital contracts

57 replies

autocollantes · 13/09/2022 13:45

I have a DS too and want him also to know, but given how things seem to work post kids, DDs are the priority.

When we get married we're not encouraged to think of the contract as much more than a legal document binding us together in love. Which is nice, but nonsense in the cold hard reality of life.

My DH is Catholic and we had to do a "marriage preparation" course (it wasn't that bad, just talking about what we expected in different areas of marriage). Before we have children we're encouraged to do birth preparation courses of some sort to educate ourselves and to read books to educate ourselves about baby's development.

But before we get married and sign what could be the most important document of our lives, there's NO INFORMATION.

AIBU that we need to teach our DDs - children - what a marriage contract contains, what it means for their rights during marriage and their rights in divorce? And that this needs to be done long before they're in a serious relationship.

I'd even go further and say that this education should be provided by the experts, who are divorce lawyers. In hindsight, now that I'm trying to divorce, I wish I'd been informed about all of this by someone knowledgable about what can go wrong. Knowing what it all means when everything is going well is actually useless - you don't usually need to protect yourself when everything is good!

There's sooo much I didn't know about what was involved and what the legal process itself entails. It's been an "in at the deep end" education. But for my lawyer, some if it appears to be "common sense". I absolutely agree about that, IF you know the legal system, how contracts work etc. The absolute worst way to learn about the law and your rights is via divorce.

So, anybody agree, or AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 14/09/2022 11:56

The difficulty with framing the issue as OP has is that the problem isn't limited to people who are already considering getting married. As well as some people not understanding the legal nature of the marriage contract they're contemplating, there's also an issue with lack of understanding about what not having a marriage contract means. Any process that only kicks in at the point where people are considering getting married/having a CP misses that whole cohort. Choosing to live with and have children with someone without being married to them is as potentially significant a decision as choosing to do it whilst being married.

That said, I'm not sure how far school is the answer either, for the various reasons mentioned.

Oblomov22 · 14/09/2022 11:48

It's like talking to your kids about self worth, relationships changing and ourselves changing over time, about how we all chase money but that being satisfied comes from within, pensions, mortgages.

Those conversations can be had. Easily.

Oblomov22 · 14/09/2022 11:46

Nope. I disagree entirely. All of this should be parental.
I have talked to ds1 about relationships, how it's for the long term, through thick and thin.
I also know enough about my rights to not be scared of getting divorced, god forbid my 20 year marriage ends anytime soon.

Why did you not look it up and prepare yourself? Talk to your dc about these things?

Blahblahblab · 14/09/2022 11:37

*lose out. Most definitely not love!

Blahblahblab · 14/09/2022 11:34

But OP wants the risks of getting married to be spelt out - how divorce works etc. If there is only limited time to teach things, that isn't a priority to me. The lower income earner is decently protected in a divorce. It's the higher earner who stands to love our, and that's how it should be if it has to fall one way or another.

Twizbe · 14/09/2022 11:11

I suppose it plants a seed of information. If they know there is a difference legally between cohabitation and marriage, they are more likely to go and research current law before moving in.

If they have no idea then why would they look it up.

ComtesseDeSpair · 14/09/2022 09:52

Speedweed · 13/09/2022 22:34

I agree OP, but not just marriage I think kids should be taught about cohabitation agreements, pre-nuptial agreements, wills and the effect marriage has on assets, what happens in a divorce, registering a child, maintenance etc. We focus on the relationship but not on the legal effect of what people are doing, and then wonder why people make poor choices, or put themselves into poor financial positions.

How many young people are realistically likely to recall a lesson on this back from when they were 14/15/16? And indeed, considering how the law and court view has moved in recent years regarding things like pre-nuptial agreements and divorce settlements, how likely is it that what they were taught as a teenager will even remain correct legal knowledge when they’re 45? You still see MN posters confidently advising others that a woman has a legal right to remain in the marital home until her child is 18 because this is what happened to their aunt when she divorced in the ‘80s - something which was relatively common for courts to decide back then but far less the case now.

Mumspair1 · 14/09/2022 09:40

Defaultsettings · 13/09/2022 13:50

No. You teach children about marriage and relationships by modelling good and healthy real action shops and boundaries as parents.

Exactly! And I wholeheartedly disagree that women are at some disadvantage in life and men have some secret knowledge and power over this. No. You are a grown adult entering into a marriage, do your own research and make wise decisions. The number of women who set themselves up poorly without any thought or responsibility towards themselves is shocking. There is more information easily accessible today than there ever was, so take the responsibility and accountability to do that.

Blahblahblab · 14/09/2022 09:32

autocollantes · 13/09/2022 21:43

I've been away but will try to remember the questions.

What did I learn? Well I was married abroad so I'm learning lot the hard way. Basically that in divorce both parties are only really equal if they have similar paying jobs and do childcare 50-50. Being a SAHM - through coercive control in my cane, not voluntarily - means you're hugely vulnerable for a long time. My STBX will have the life we have now, more or less, while I'll be lucky to get social housing (I probably won't).

I learned that "what's mine is yours and what's yours is mine" isn't true. There are marriage contracts that separate premarital assets from those acquired during the marriage. What's mine before marriage therefore remains mine forever and I don't ever have to spend that money or have it considered during divorce proceedings. So that there is already a division in the contract. One I happen not to have a problem with, however, it's not possible to pretend that it's a 100% Union if one party is independently wealthy and chooses to retain that wealth separate to the marriage, while the marriage financially could do with some help.

Boys need to know too. Like I said first of all. BUT until men are taking the same paternity leave as women and women don't suffer pregnancies in which they're on bed rest/signed off work for months then there's always an inherent imbalance on how both parties are likely to be able to contribute PLUS their future earning potential. That's why it's important for girls to know.

I agree btw about other contracts, especially mortgages, being incredibly important too. For those I see the need to understand as being equal between the sexes. I was posting about marriage contracts though as the post was long enough!

But in the situation given you'd be far worse off if you hadn't married. The issue isn't needing to teach about the marriage contract but that children need to understand that choosing to become a SAHparent / merging finances with another person is inherently risky. Some of your statements also aren't always correct / only apply to short marriages eg pre marital assets absolutely can be in the pot in some situations.

I don't think you need to teach that marriage is difficult to dissolve specifically. I do think there should be more education on how to ensure you are not financially vulnerable if a relationship breaks down BUT in reality I'm not sure doing one HPSE lesson on this at age 14 is going to make a difference - all this information is out there and the people who haven't accessed it on their own won't have been listening to it at school. The reality is when two people love each other all sense often goes out the window. It's hard for me to comment though because I don't remember ever having to be taught this - to me it's just obvious that relying financially on someone else is risky and you need to protect yourself. The real issue, to me anyway, is the myth of 'common law marriage'. That's what really gets people into trouble. I don't know how you fix this.

Boys also need to know the risks of having children without being married btw.

JustLyra · 14/09/2022 09:18

ArcticSkewer · 13/09/2022 21:56

I tell my sons not to get married and my daughter to get married if she is going to have kids.
That's about all that they need really

This is what I don’t understand - why tell your son not to get married?

Mine have been told/taught how vulnerable their partner would be if she gave up her job unmarried to have kids. The impact on her pension and the likes. At no point were they told “don’t get married”.

Then again mine are lucky. They’ve seen my girls Dad turn into a non paying NRP who has no relationship with his daughters, and they’ve seen his parents roundly criticise him for it and they know if they treated the mother of their children like shit I’d be exactly the same.

Speedweed · 13/09/2022 22:34

I agree OP, but not just marriage I think kids should be taught about cohabitation agreements, pre-nuptial agreements, wills and the effect marriage has on assets, what happens in a divorce, registering a child, maintenance etc. We focus on the relationship but not on the legal effect of what people are doing, and then wonder why people make poor choices, or put themselves into poor financial positions.

EndTheMonacyNow · 13/09/2022 22:23

If you are the richer high earning partner you shouldn't get married and if you are the poorer one you should. Women should avoid having kids unmarried. That's all you need to know really.

Jules198 · 13/09/2022 22:11

Yeah i agree. Taught to both boys and girls. Also the SAHP situation too and what that means for finance if you split etc.

actually i think knowing this info may mean less people get married in the first place

autocollantes · 13/09/2022 22:06

btw (sorry more!) I also agree that girls need to know the risks of having children without being married.

This is a clear example of when girls need to be taught something and boys should know it, but at the end of the day, the potential suffering caused by not knowing this is unequal between the sexes.

Anyway, my kids are some of the lucky ones, because their DM will be making sure they know all of this as they get older. Doesn't help the little girls out there who have a similar childhood and parents to me though, does it?

OP posts:
autocollantes · 13/09/2022 21:58

The relationships and divorce boards are full of people who don't know how to go about getting divorced and don't really know what their rights are in divorce, or what to expect from the legal process, or how screwed they can be as a SAHM who suddenly is expected to enter the workplace. I can guarantee they all knew the order of service for their wedding ceremony though, even if they're not regular churchgoers.

If you know all those things before getting married, then I'm pretty certain you're a lucky anomaly.

Not one of my friends who hasn't been divorced, or seen a close friend/relative go through it has any real idea of what the breaking up of the legal contract entails. I'm sure my friends aren't the anomaly in this!

OP posts:
idonotmind · 13/09/2022 21:56

But who then teaches ALL children these things?

Great question. Many answers!

I'll start with internalized misogyny.

I.E. Couple walk into a car showroom, salesman only talks to the woman.

ArcticSkewer · 13/09/2022 21:56

I tell my sons not to get married and my daughter to get married if she is going to have kids.
That's about all that they need really

idonotmind · 13/09/2022 21:55

I completely agree.

There needs to be more information regarding the financial implications of marrying.

Prince Charming is all well and good but let's face it, he ain't gonna pay the mortgage and feed the kids once you divorce

autocollantes · 13/09/2022 21:52

"Schools have enough to do"
They do. I agree. But who then teaches ALL children these things? Or is it only to be taught to the children lucky enough to be born to parents who know it all? My parents certainly didn't and I've ended up completely broken (and very likely broke) as a direct result.

"Parents should teach children about relationships and not contracts regarding marriage"
a) as above.
b) but there is a legal contract signed. Or it's not marriage. That's a religious marriage and it holds no legal weight. Again it's not actually that important while things are going well. When you start to meet (and pay for) a lawyer though due to divorce, then you'll notice that it's a legal document and the exact wording is extremely important. If everybody behaved properly in relationships and everybody was perky matched, sure, there'd be no divorces, but the reality is that there are people who lie to, cheat on, steal, and abuse their spouse as well as lovely people who are simply mismatched. For them all, teaching children to behave better in relationships is too late and also unlikely to reduce divorce in the future. Also, who teaches them? Obviously not school, so again those who were born lucky in the family department remain so and the rest are essentially scuppered.

OP posts:
autocollantes · 13/09/2022 21:43

I've been away but will try to remember the questions.

What did I learn? Well I was married abroad so I'm learning lot the hard way. Basically that in divorce both parties are only really equal if they have similar paying jobs and do childcare 50-50. Being a SAHM - through coercive control in my cane, not voluntarily - means you're hugely vulnerable for a long time. My STBX will have the life we have now, more or less, while I'll be lucky to get social housing (I probably won't).

I learned that "what's mine is yours and what's yours is mine" isn't true. There are marriage contracts that separate premarital assets from those acquired during the marriage. What's mine before marriage therefore remains mine forever and I don't ever have to spend that money or have it considered during divorce proceedings. So that there is already a division in the contract. One I happen not to have a problem with, however, it's not possible to pretend that it's a 100% Union if one party is independently wealthy and chooses to retain that wealth separate to the marriage, while the marriage financially could do with some help.

Boys need to know too. Like I said first of all. BUT until men are taking the same paternity leave as women and women don't suffer pregnancies in which they're on bed rest/signed off work for months then there's always an inherent imbalance on how both parties are likely to be able to contribute PLUS their future earning potential. That's why it's important for girls to know.

I agree btw about other contracts, especially mortgages, being incredibly important too. For those I see the need to understand as being equal between the sexes. I was posting about marriage contracts though as the post was long enough!

OP posts:
garlictwist · 13/09/2022 17:28

I think it's pretty obvious that marriage essentially means "what's mine is yours" -it's a business transaction. If you aren't prepared to do that (and I am not) don't get married (I haven't).

carefullycourageous · 13/09/2022 17:26

I think parents have to teach this to their kids, schools can't get into this as 'marriage' is a loaded topic.

Babdoc · 13/09/2022 17:25

It’s much more important to teach girls the dangers of NOT getting married - the risk of becoming homeless and penniless if their unmarried partner throws them out of the house to which they have no entitlement if it was solely in his name. The danger of being a sahm with no independent source of income. The problem of not being legally recognised as next of kin. The fact of not having inheritance tax exemption if their non married spouse dies. Etc.

Dacadactyl · 13/09/2022 17:23

I too would like to know what it is you didn't understand until recently about the legal ramifications of marriage?

LHommeRose · 13/09/2022 17:21

Definitely. You’re at risk if you have kids with him and aren’t married and don’t work. You won’t be on the mortgage either without an income. So many women think they are “common law” or “he wouldn’t do that”.