Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to contact my first love's widow

283 replies

KitsilanoBeach · 13/09/2022 12:16

I had my first proper boyfriend/first kiss/first love when I was 14/15. I’m fairly sure I was his first girlfriend and first kiss too.

It only lasted a few months but I was besotted and we used to write each other love letters (no emails/texting back then, and we went to different schools in the same town but lived quite far from each other).

He then dumped me - I don’t think I ever knew why, he was a nice guy and not a player - and broke my heart. Our paths didn’t really cross again, although he did send me a letter when I was about 17 apologising for what happened (a friend of mine had bumped into him and told him “Kitsilano hates you!” which wasn’t true, but anyway – teens, eh?).

I have from time to time wondered what happened to him and had idly googled him but without any success – he has a reasonably common name. It was only recently that I thought to google him and the name of the small village he grew up in and I immediately came across an obituary for him, reporting that he had died in 2019 after a long battle with cancer. He was quite successful in his chosen career so there were a couple of obituaries in national publications, and in addition his wife (now widow) is a professional writer who has written at length about his illness and her subsequent bereavement.

Even though I hadn’t seen or heard from him in decades I have felt quite affected by his death, both because of what he meant to me for a brief time but also I suppose because it is always hard to think about people dying so young.

I am tempted to reach out to his widow to offer my condolences, but I just can’t work out if this would be inappropriate and not welcomed by her. Both because it is now a number of years since he died, but also because she may not want to hear from an ex-girlfriend, even though it was just a teen romance from many years before they met.

I also suspect that she will have been contacted by many other people who have been bereaved/widowed young and who could relate to what she has written and wanted to share their own experiences with her, and perhaps it is all a bit much for her. She may also now be in a different place (although from her more recent writing online I do not get the impression she has found anyone else, although she may just have chosen not to write about it).

But on the other hand, she might like to hear from someone else who has fond memories of her late husband and at the end of the day we both loved him, (albeit I'm not of course comparing my relationship with hers).

I don’t think there is a right answer but am really torn, and would welcome views particularly from anyone who has suffered a similar bereavement if you feel able to share them.

YABU – do not contact the widow, leave her be
YANBU – it’s fine to contact the widow to offer condolences

OP posts:
WarmChocolateFudgeCake · 13/09/2022 14:52

What exactly is the reason behind contacting her? Is it to make her feel better or for you to share your grief with her? I'd find it rather odd if a gf of 30 seconds from when my husband was a teen contacted me telling me about HER grief. Leave the woman be.

TheSpringyGuyAndTheCheeseEater · 13/09/2022 14:49

TwigTheWonderKid · 13/09/2022 12:23

Omg absolutely no. I totally get why you feel the way you do, you never forget your first love and also his death creates a bit of an existential crisis in you too; you mourn your the loss of carefree self, all the possible alternative lives you might have had etc.

But this has got nothing to do with his widow who actually lived a life with him and had her future with him snatched away and you contacting her will not be consoling.

This.

TheSpringyGuyAndTheCheeseEater · 13/09/2022 14:48

No offence meant OP but this seems hugely self-indulgent. Of course this wouldn't be a comfort to his widow, hearing from a teenage girlfriend. I'm shocked you think this would be appropriate or welcomed.

I understand you're upset but this woman lost her husband, not somebody she kissed a few times as a teenager. Leave her alone to grieve.

BobDear · 13/09/2022 14:46

OP I am going to tell you a story that might help you.

My mum lived and studied abroad (European country) for the whole of her twenties in the 1960s. For nine years she dated and was engaged to a local man and they were very much in love. He proposed to her and she wanted to marry him but in the end decided that for various reasons (more traditional culture/expectations of a wife) it wouldn't work for her. They were both heartbroken and she returned to the Uk and eventually met and married my dad. She always carried a candle for this man and although the marriage to my dad was long and happy, I know she thought of him often and wondered what he was up to. She returned the place she had lived a couple of times a year for the rest of her life (because she loved the place) but never sought him out.

In her early seventies, the girl she had shared an apartment with during her life in this place, tracked her down. They had been very close and this (now woman) girl had dated my mum's boyfriend's friend at the time for a short while. She shared an obituary with my mum of her ex boyfriend and it turned out that he had died in a motorbike accident in his mid thirties - only a few years after my mother left. The shock to my mum of realising that all the times she had wondered what he was up to, he was actually dead, was actually huge to her. We think the small stroke she suffered a couple of weeks later was because of this news.

It turned out that he had just married and when he died, his wife was pregnant with their first child.

That summer, my mum went to the place as she always did in the summer and this time, sought out his widow. She wanted to tell her how sorry she was and perhaps share a few memories with her. I kept asking if it was a good idea but she insisted it was.

It wasn't

Widow was upset
Mum was upset
Widow said Mum should have left her alone - why would she want to hear from his ex?
Mum told her that she meant to be kind and thought she'd like to talk
Widow said 'no you didn't. You wanted to burden me with your pain. I have friends to talk to'. It was awful and uncomfortable.

And after that Mum started reducing her visits to her favourite place in the word because she felt she had overstepped and was no longer welcome there which was desperately sad.

I know it's not the same, and in my mum's case, she was actually with this man longer than his wife, but this woman was his wife and the mother of his child. She took him on for life and she was left alone. It was her loss to mourn and not my mothers.

Sometimes, we just have to hold our pain quietly inside and mourn with dignity in the privacy of our own lives. I would say your situation is one of those times. I'm sorry for your loss.

coconuthead · 13/09/2022 14:38

God, no.

FantasylandEnthusiast · 13/09/2022 14:34

"At the end of the day we both loved him"

No, you didn't. You were infatuated aged 14, and kissed him once.

She was his wife ffs - do not contact her, and please stop.

Luredbyapomegranate · 13/09/2022 14:34

MolliciousIntent · 13/09/2022 12:17

Write her a letter, and don't send it.

Yes this.

She doesn’t want or need to hear from you, especially 3 years after his death. No one wants to hear about their late partners exes.

But also in your case OP you aren’t his first love, you went out for 5 minutes when you were kids. So whatever this is, it isn’t about him.

Write and chuck the letter to get it out of your system and then spend some figuring out why you are obsessing about him

stuffnthings · 13/09/2022 14:33

Tricky one. Also a young widower, but my late DW and I had been together for a long time and have DC, so a lot of life shared, but cut brutally short.

Even though the rational side of me knows it shouldn't bother me, I would find it a bit unnerving having a letter or some form of contact from someone who had had some intimate interaction with my DW, especially out of the blue and from someone I didn't really know.

It's hard OP and your feelings about it are completely understandable, but I would try to navigate them personally and not engage with his DW.

diddl · 13/09/2022 14:30

She probably has already heard from people who have fond memories of her husband-those who he kept in touch with & were close enough to know when he actually died!

ittakes2 · 13/09/2022 14:28

I am sorry this appears more about you wanting to process your feelings rather than helping her. She’s lost her husband and his first kiss wants to offer condolences? Sorry please let her be.

Lavendersummer · 13/09/2022 14:22

This is for you. So leave some flowers at his grave. No need for a note.

Rosehugger · 13/09/2022 14:21

Yes, that's a really nice post, @Reallyreallyborednow great advice.

But be prepared for her to write about it!

CCC2 · 13/09/2022 14:21

As a widow myself it's a definite no from me. I would hate to receive a letter like that.

notanothertakeaway · 13/09/2022 14:16

Reallyreallyborednow · 13/09/2022 12:34

Do you know what, I don’t think it’s a bad idea.

cut out the first love shit and simply say you knew him from school, he was a lovely lad in your friendship group and you were very sad to hear about his illness and death. You hope their times together were happy and that she is doing ok.

when I lost a close family member some of the hardest times were/are in the months and years after when it seems like everyone else has moved on, life is back to normal and no one brings it up anymore. Probably for fear of opening old wounds but it feels like your loss is forgotten.

i occasionally google my relative in the stupid hope that someone somewhere has remembered- his work, church, distant friends and relatives.

a distant friend of his posted his wife a card for years on his anniversary- I know that was very comforting to her.

so yes, send a message or card. Say you’ll think of them and you know how hard it is even years later, and you just wanted her to know that he had an impact on someone he knew for a relatively short time.

I agree with @Reallyreallyborednow

HotWashCycle · 13/09/2022 14:13

Hoping you do not send this letter to her, OP. It would be more for you than for her, wouldn't it? There is no point in bringing up her former husband's past. I feel it would be quite unkind, in fact. It is not as though you were a colleague of his, or a distant family member. So please don't do it.

HilarityEnsues · 13/09/2022 14:12

I am a widow and this wouldn't bother me personally, because I met my husband in my thirties, so realise he had a life before me and indeed know about some of his exes. A couple of them were very distraught by his death, as was a colleague I always suspected had a soft spot for him, I felt fine with this as he wasn't owned by me and had people in his life who loved him in different ways. I would not contact her though, as not everyone would feel the same. You aren't doing it to help her, you would be doing it to get closure for yourself and to process this significant (to you) death. You need to find a way to do that on your own I think, perhaps with friends from that time. If you send anything, a neutral thoughtful message is all.

TokyoTen · 13/09/2022 14:09

I would just leave it and not contact her. There is nothing for her to gain from your comms, it's just for you. But sorry for the loss.

MelodyPondsMum · 13/09/2022 14:02

I don't think you should write. My concern would be that you don't need to write because if the Daily Mail recognise your description of them and pick this up, an article will cover it for you.

DadOfTheMoment · 13/09/2022 13:59

Leave her alone

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 13/09/2022 13:57

I'd definitely say don't contact her.

If you do more as friends than first loves and don't make it into a big teenage love affair.

Having said that, a few years ago (10 maybe?) I looked online (Google not FB) and found out that an ex-SO I'd had in my 20s for 2 years had ended his life. It was a lot more complex than that as he also had HIV/AIDs and had also moved abroad and got married and had DC and was divorced. I worked out from translating articles what had happened and was shocked by the HIV/AIDS and also wondered re timelines if I had AIDS/HIV from him (I'd had an AIDS test after I knew him but not for this reason) but this wasn't possible due to timelines. I contacted his widow and she kindly spoke to me and reassured me and actually told me he'd spoken a lot about me, shared memories and photos and she wanted to meet me in London (I didn't, she lived in Europe). But we shared a few memories and photos and she seemed happy enough to explain to me what had happened (all very sad, he didn't have lots of girlfriends). But I did this either the year or just a year or so after he'd died, so quite soon and not 3 years later.

ancientgran · 13/09/2022 13:55

I think it is almost impossible to give advice as people vary so much, she might be offended/horrified/touched by it.

My father's exfiancee turned up at his funeral. My mother was very kind and welcoming and they chatted but I'm not sure all widows would be the same. My husband's ex from when he was 16/17 sometimes phones, I say hello and pass the phone to him. I'm pretty sure if he died before me I'd get a call from her, I think she's a bit odd but she loved him 60 years ago, maybe she still does, so I wouldn't be upset.

economicervix · 13/09/2022 13:50

@JinglingHellsBells nah.
she wouldn’t word it like that but that’s exactly what she’d be doing, and it would be completely unhinged, actually creepy. Don’t bother quoting me again, I could not be less interested.

Lovetogarden2022 · 13/09/2022 13:50

I think it's a nice thing to do - I have a few close family members and friends that have passed away and one of the nicest things was hearing from the people who knew them in the past (who we may never have heard of) with funny stories or memories. People like "oh we lived with them in halls at uni and I'll always remember when..." - we've even had some years later and found it very comforting that they were thinking about that person.
I guess it depends how it's done - if it's like "I'm really glad he found happiness etc" and a nice memory from the past - lovely. If it's in any way negative or whatever - not so lovely.

Kilofoxtrot99 · 13/09/2022 13:50

In this same situation with a friend. Her husband passed suddenly and young. I think a card and a nice memory of how lovely he was is ok, it’s a comfort to know your loved one who is no longer with you was remembered (as a friend though wouldn’t go into the whole teenage romance bit…) If it’s for her as a kind gesture then think it’s ok.

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 13/09/2022 13:47

If I got a letter like this after my DH died (he is still v.much alive Thankfully) I would actually find it quite offensive and think you were unhinged.

Swipe left for the next trending thread