Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to contact my first love's widow

283 replies

KitsilanoBeach · 13/09/2022 12:16

I had my first proper boyfriend/first kiss/first love when I was 14/15. I’m fairly sure I was his first girlfriend and first kiss too.

It only lasted a few months but I was besotted and we used to write each other love letters (no emails/texting back then, and we went to different schools in the same town but lived quite far from each other).

He then dumped me - I don’t think I ever knew why, he was a nice guy and not a player - and broke my heart. Our paths didn’t really cross again, although he did send me a letter when I was about 17 apologising for what happened (a friend of mine had bumped into him and told him “Kitsilano hates you!” which wasn’t true, but anyway – teens, eh?).

I have from time to time wondered what happened to him and had idly googled him but without any success – he has a reasonably common name. It was only recently that I thought to google him and the name of the small village he grew up in and I immediately came across an obituary for him, reporting that he had died in 2019 after a long battle with cancer. He was quite successful in his chosen career so there were a couple of obituaries in national publications, and in addition his wife (now widow) is a professional writer who has written at length about his illness and her subsequent bereavement.

Even though I hadn’t seen or heard from him in decades I have felt quite affected by his death, both because of what he meant to me for a brief time but also I suppose because it is always hard to think about people dying so young.

I am tempted to reach out to his widow to offer my condolences, but I just can’t work out if this would be inappropriate and not welcomed by her. Both because it is now a number of years since he died, but also because she may not want to hear from an ex-girlfriend, even though it was just a teen romance from many years before they met.

I also suspect that she will have been contacted by many other people who have been bereaved/widowed young and who could relate to what she has written and wanted to share their own experiences with her, and perhaps it is all a bit much for her. She may also now be in a different place (although from her more recent writing online I do not get the impression she has found anyone else, although she may just have chosen not to write about it).

But on the other hand, she might like to hear from someone else who has fond memories of her late husband and at the end of the day we both loved him, (albeit I'm not of course comparing my relationship with hers).

I don’t think there is a right answer but am really torn, and would welcome views particularly from anyone who has suffered a similar bereavement if you feel able to share them.

YABU – do not contact the widow, leave her be
YANBU – it’s fine to contact the widow to offer condolences

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Slutdrop · 23/09/2022 10:56

ShandaLear · 13/09/2022 13:07

If you could frame it as:

’I recently found out about x passing away. I was so sorry to hear the news. We dated briefly as young teenagers and I have fond memories of dancing/eating/hanging out (throw in an amusing anecdote)…

Yours sincerely,

xxx’

That would be ok - and I think quite nice for the widow.

Please don't. Absolutely not.

sue20 · 19/09/2022 14:30

mam0918 · 14/09/2022 19:48

What about the litrally dozens of other women on here also in the same situation that have said catagorically DON'T do this and how upset they where that people did try to do this.

Your enjoyment doesnt top their pain, if theres any chance this may hurt the woman (and theres a good chance it might) you obviously DON'T do it.

Your experiance is totally valid to your life but NOT to blanket the situation and you are not the woman in question.

I’m firmly with Minpin. All this over sensitivity why on earth would it hurt widow who especially wants to think deeply into memory and publicises it. Quite honestly the romance at that age barely needs mentioning just fond memories of a young friendship which is what it basically was. Something a bit weird about people focusing on the sexual aspect of a 14 year old relationship and giving it the same weight as an older one.

Pinkdelight3 · 19/09/2022 14:20

Why on earth wouldn’t widow want to hear from people who remember him fondly?

Um, for the many reasons that other widows have expressed clearly on this thread. Experiences vary. Not that hard to comprehend and empathise.

ShaneTwane · 19/09/2022 14:19

sue20 · 19/09/2022 14:15

Why on earth wouldn’t widow want to hear from people who remember him fondly? The best people attending my father then mothers funeral were those from the past. Letters of condolence the same.

Maybe because the op doesnt know him or anything about him. She very briefly knew him as a 14 year old when he broke it off and decided he didnt want to see her again. She knew nothing about who he was what he liked as an adult who he became, absolutely nothing.

She is a stranger who didnt know him wanting to insert herself into the widows grief. Imagine if everyone did that for people they very briefly knew as children? The point is the ops memories have no baring on the widow at all.

sue20 · 19/09/2022 14:15

SpicePearl · 13/09/2022 12:20

I would only get in touch if you had something to share that might benefit her. A nice story about him when he was younger or something like that. A condolences card isn’t going to mean too much at this stage and she doesn’t want to hear about your emotions around his death. if it is about processing your own reaction then I think you need to find another way to do this.

Why on earth wouldn’t widow want to hear from people who remember him fondly? The best people attending my father then mothers funeral were those from the past. Letters of condolence the same.

sue20 · 19/09/2022 14:05

Time wise having just lost my mother the most comforting contact was from her old workplace it felt lovely to get information about parts of her life I knew nothing about and know she had been much valued by colleagues. Relationship wise I can’t believe people taking a viewpoint that somehow your teen romance is inappropriate to mention. This is a man who has had a full life with a wife who is happy to make public her feelings and his last days. You haven’t been obsessed by him. We all have people we wonder how they are. Completely appropriate that you send a message to his widow given it’s your heartfelt memory. She’s adult we all have a past. If I was her I’d be delighted.

KaitK · 18/09/2022 17:29

I would have said no but as she has written about this, made his death and her grief public, then I don't think you are being unreasonable. Make it about him, though, not you.

MumThyme · 18/09/2022 16:36

I chose YABU not because you shouldn't contact her but because you are deluded to think she'd care about someone who went out with her husband for a few months as teenagers. You are over thinking your impact on each others lives. She wouldn't care either way, she was his wife, in comparison to that you were nothing.

FurnitureUpcyler · 15/09/2022 22:35

Good God, please don't! This feels wrong on so many levels. My first thoughts on reading your post were that it was really all about you with little thought for the feelings of his grieving widow.
Hold on to your dignity & find another way to deal with it please!

MigsandTiggs · 15/09/2022 20:54

Kellymumto2 · 14/09/2022 23:15

You would be doing it for you. Not her. But why shouldn’t you do it for you?
you say it’s been a while so she is probably not still caught up in the throes of grief. Send the letter, say what you need to. If she replies great. If she doesn’t, fine. You do you and let her do her. You don’t know this women, nor do we, you can preempt what she may or may not feel, if she will reflect upon it positively or not. You can only do what you feel and see what happens. Good luck with whatever you decide.

Seriously? The grief never goes away, it just fluctuates. It can be awful some days, even years later. Even now, if I was contacted by someone like the OP, I'll be asking our friends who the hell it is and think her a bit cray cray anyway.
As other pp have said, it's about the OP getting closure, so write a letter but don't send it.

loislovesstewie · 15/09/2022 20:37

@AllThreeWays my DH of over 40 years died early this year. I had 2 previous girlfriends of his 'reminiscing' on social media. I found it very distressing. I didn't want that shoved in my face. You might be happy with contact from former lovers, but I wasn't . The point is just that, when in doubt, don't.

TokidokiBarbie · 15/09/2022 20:30

ReneBumsWombats · 15/09/2022 19:38

Did you really have to make a comparison like that?

Sorry, it was a bit crass. But I was hoping to get across the idea that the OPs feelings in this are not in anyway comparative to that of the widow who did have more than a brief fling and did know him in his adult life. I can understand paying respects but contacting the widow is far too much and you'd have to be very self important to even consider risking upsetting her over your own feelings.

AllThreeWays · 15/09/2022 19:47

I lost my partner 4 years ago. I would have loved to hear from you and heard about him in high school.
However, try not to make it about you I don't think a 4 mth high school romance equals your statement " we both loved him".
Send flowers, explain you knew him in high school and only just found out he was gone, share some suitable anecdotes.
Some many opinions on here saying no, from people who haven't experienced losing their partner. Everyone thinks you should pussyfoot around death and not talk about it. I disagree, we should be far more open.
Especially a few years on when she probably feels that everyone has forgotten him and he is never talked about anymore.

ReneBumsWombats · 15/09/2022 19:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Did you really have to make a comparison like that?

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 15/09/2022 19:36

YABU and it sounds a bit stalkerish. Leave the poor woman in peace. You say it was ‘decades ago’ and you were 14/15, he wasn’t the love of your life. It was just a few snogs that you look back on fondly. Have you ever found true love?

Banana2079 · 15/09/2022 19:33

You could write her a letter and say that you were a childhood friend And that you give your condolences you could even share time where you did something fun
Or you could write him a letter and read it out loud I am a believer in the afterlife and he will hear your letter If you want him to.

TokidokiBarbie · 15/09/2022 18:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MessyBunPersonified · 15/09/2022 18:09

Autumn61 · 15/09/2022 17:50

Of course you can contact her. You’re thinking to much about it , write a card ,say exactly what you want to say. It will give you closure too. You are not being malicious, you are bing thoughtful. You were never a threat to her . I’m so surprised at some of the responses on here.

His death isn't about op though.

Why write to a complete stranger, who is the one who actually suffered a loss, to trauma dump about your feelings about a boyfriend of a couple of months from decades ago?

Op doesn't need closure, he wasn't a part of her life.

Mumspair1 · 15/09/2022 17:59

Don't do it. What would you ever have to say that would be for her benefit. In fact I would think you a bit unhinged writing about your teenage romance decades later. She might even question what your motive is for doing this and her late dh as well. Just don't.

Autumn61 · 15/09/2022 17:50

Of course you can contact her. You’re thinking to much about it , write a card ,say exactly what you want to say. It will give you closure too. You are not being malicious, you are bing thoughtful. You were never a threat to her . I’m so surprised at some of the responses on here.

Celestialmoonface · 15/09/2022 17:19

Do not contact her

loislovesstewie · 15/09/2022 15:11

To all of you saying 'yes, do it' , how would you feel if you caused distress to the widow? Would you think, 'oh well' , or what? Because you can't rectify that, can you?

milkywithsixsugars · 15/09/2022 14:27

I don’t think I’d contact her tbh. I had a first relationship (15-22), with my ex, who decided to be a massive knob, and broke up with me after pretty much ghosting me for 2 months. Turns out he was cheating beforehand (they’re still together now with a secondary school age child) and saying he was busy with a new job etc. Afterwards, I didn’t hear a word from any of his family, even though we’d been quite close before.
This is obviously a different scenario to yours, but I found out not long ago that his mum passed away. I was a bit sad, but never gave any thought to contacting him 20 years after we last spoke. I’m married with kids now, happy with how my life has gone, and I wouldn’t have my family if I was still with him.
I think, a donation in his name would be better than a letter out of the blue, unless you are able to make a letter not about you and your first love - more we were friends as kids, and I’ve just heard about your loss.

TokidokiBarbie · 15/09/2022 14:21

messymonkey1074 · 15/09/2022 14:19

I’m so surprised to see all the “absolutely nots”
If the same thing happened to me I would love to hear from his first love sharing childhood experiences and would be really touched you’d taken the time to write.
Im genuinely shocked everyone is so against it. Do what you feel is best. I would be very surprised if your letter upset her.

The posters on this thread who've lost their husbands seem to largely disagree.

messymonkey1074 · 15/09/2022 14:19

I’m so surprised to see all the “absolutely nots”
If the same thing happened to me I would love to hear from his first love sharing childhood experiences and would be really touched you’d taken the time to write.
Im genuinely shocked everyone is so against it. Do what you feel is best. I would be very surprised if your letter upset her.