Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Our NEW KING paying 0% inheritance tax on £100 million estate

187 replies

bluejay5 · 13/09/2022 04:56

Am I right in thinking this is unreasonable? While the rest of us commoners are taxed to within an inch of our lives, struggling to heat our homes. A few select individuals who are innately better than any of us towns folk get to keep their wealth and see their generations become richer and richer.
Don't get me wrong I understand the need to pay taxes, to keep us in a usable society and country. They tax our income, any profit we make from any business we take the risk of setting up, our council taxes us, if we receive a dividend from any smart investment we make, if we decide to buy a new house with money that was already taxed, they tax us again ..

And finally to top it all off, after being taxed all our working lives we decided to try and build some generational wealth and help out our offspring, and even in death they tax us... on property and money that was already taxed!!!

Yet a few individuals through no skills, or talent of their own, just by virtue of their birth are deemed to be literally innately better to a point where they are exempt from the rules we live under.

Please make it make sense???

Apparently, the monarchy is exempt from income tax in order to protect the wealth of the royal family from being eroded!
While the rest of us fight for survival like crabs in a barrel.

Plus anyone heard of the ''panama papers the queen''
google it ...

this Society has class baked into it. We aren't meant to move up or aspire for greater things. It's a rigged system, you can't tell me it's not.

Sorry, rant over.

OP posts:
Wallaw · 13/09/2022 08:45

SavingsThreads · 13/09/2022 07:54

@bluejay5 did you do any research on this before you posted?

We've had a hundred threads about this in the last week which all go the same way. People being shouty capitals incensed by it, and people explaining they've gotten the facts wrong. It's tiresome.

@SavingsThreads

Except that a lot of the people who believe they have got the facts correct have not. In case you want to do a little research.

www.nytimes.com/2022/09/13/world/europe/king-charles-wealth.html?smtyp=cur&smid=tw-nytimes

bluejay5 · 13/09/2022 08:44

The tide is shifting on the monarchy, as the demographics of this country change age-wise. So to will support, times are getting harder for the rest of us, while a select few ''virtuous'' individuals who have been venerated to God-like status for no real reason are kept in place by fanatics and a broken system.

OP posts:
Sally090807 · 13/09/2022 08:42

DdraigGoch · 13/09/2022 08:35

Not incorrect at all. Tax-free threshold of £325k, plus residence nil-rate band of £175k. Double it for a couple, who if married can transfer their allowances across.

www.moneysavingexpert.com/family/inheritance-tax-planning-iht/

£325k if you’re single and the nil rate band of £175k only applies if you pass on a main residence to your children or grandchildren, not nieces and nephews. So in my aunts case, anything over £325k was at 40%

Mothership4two · 13/09/2022 08:37

There is Crown wealth and personal wealth - posters are confusing them

If the Queen has passed on her personal wealth (£365m according to the Sunday Times but who knows? @cakeorwine) to Charles he will not have to pay any inheritance tax. I agree with the OP it is unfair and unreasonable.

Obviously assets held by the reigning monarch in right of the Crown aren’t subject to inheritance tax such as official residences and the Royal Collection of paintings and other works of art.

The Duchy of Cornwall with an annual income of about £21million has been passed on to William as per tradition, but likewise the Duchy of Lancaster has been passed on to Charles with a net income of about £24 million per year. So he hasn't exactly lost out

DdraigGoch · 13/09/2022 08:37

cakeorwine · 13/09/2022 07:52

4% of deaths result in IHT being paid

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/inheritance-tax-statistics-commentary/inheritance-tax-statistics-commentary

IHT receipts received by HMRC during the financial year 2021 to 2022 were £6.1 billion. This was an increase of 14% (£729 million) on the financial year 2020 to 2021, and is the largest single-year rise in IHT receipts since the 2015 to 2016 financial year, when receipts rose by 22% (£848 million)

Proves my point, 4% is next to bugger all, and those who do pay it are well-off.

Autumndays123 · 13/09/2022 08:36

bluejay5 · 13/09/2022 08:31

You are talking nonsense @Autumndays123

go and read this then come back and write an informed post

britishheritage.com/royals/royal-family-cost-british-taxpayer

Hahaha OP that link has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with what I wrote? Are you just firing off things you've found on Google to people to 'support' your own narrative without actually reading what they are saying?

Tax avoidance is legal and pretty much every member of society do it one way or another. It's almost certain that you avoid tax, your husband, your parents/siblings etc and so on. Just because the media don't thrust it in your face or spoon feed that information to you, it doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

Yes, the wealthier you are the more extensive the tax planning but the principle is no different to what you are your family do through paying a pension etc, it's just on a larger scale because more money is involved. Are you saying it's acceptable for you to avoid tax through the various methods listed but it's not ok for others?

I would strongly recommend you improve your knowledge of tax and tax planning, if only to pass that knowledge onto your children and future generations within your family.

DdraigGoch · 13/09/2022 08:35

Sally090807 · 13/09/2022 08:00

That’s incorrect, it’s 40% on assets over £325k or £500k if you’re married.

Not incorrect at all. Tax-free threshold of £325k, plus residence nil-rate band of £175k. Double it for a couple, who if married can transfer their allowances across.

www.moneysavingexpert.com/family/inheritance-tax-planning-iht/

GingerGloucester · 13/09/2022 08:32

Inheritance tax isn’t money that is “taxed twice”

whenever money/assets changes hands there is typically a tax in this country.

e.g VAT when I buy something in a shop, when I cash in investments and pay CGT

by your logic of only taxing assets/money once, I should argue I shouldn’t pay income tax before VAT has already been paid on the money I earn.

I also don’t understand the big deal with inheritance tax, when my parents die me and my brother will get a decent enough chunk after inheritance tax.

Plantstrees · 13/09/2022 08:32

bluejay5 · 13/09/2022 08:26

What a ridiculous response @Plantstrees . Other people do it so it's ok...no it's not ok, it's irrelevant what other wealthy people do. We are talking about the royal family, human beings that are intrinsically better than any of us. Had they been born in any other country or class, they would have inevitably all risen to the same stature and level because they are 'ROYAL'

So everyone paying into a pension out of their monthly salary is now classed as wealthy? I think it is you that is being ridiculous.

Pension and other investments are generally made through investment managers or pension funds. The individuals whose pension or funds are being invested very rarely understand the details. Are you telling me that you pay into a pension? If not, I guess maybe you are dependent on the state or will be when you retire - how is this better that working all your life and taking advantage of a few legal tax breaks?

SmallSoupcon · 13/09/2022 08:31

Seriously, if you don't talk about this when it's actually happening, ie during the succession, then when on earth do you?!

If you look into the public vs private status of the duchies, it gets very muddy. If these estates are public assets, why do we see none of the £millions of profits they generate? Why doesn't this go to the treasury? If they're private assets, why don't they pay corporation tax or capital gains tax? And why do they invest so much of their profits offshore which is of no benefit to us at all? It's extremely murky. When Parliament has scrutinised why the duchy of Cornwall is exempt from tax, the reason is pretty much "because it is". They even audit their own accounts!

Btw I suggest everyone reads "and what do you do?" by Norman Baker for an insight into Royal finances. It's an education.

bluejay5 · 13/09/2022 08:31

Autumndays123 · 13/09/2022 08:21

It's really frustrating that individuals keep posting about this topic having conducted absolutely zero research. It's also concerning how little the OP and general public understand about tax and 'tax avoidance'

Firstly OP, you have to understand that the Royal family are somewhat at a disadvantage to the rest of society as they cannot work or trade. As they can't trade, there are only minimal ways they can increase their family income.

I understand that 'disadvantaged' might be a poor choice of word to use, but you have to understand that the Royal family require some element of wealth in order to be maintained for the next potentially hundreds of years. If the RF paid IHT each time the monarch died, their wealth would evaporate quite quickly.

In addition, as others have said on this thread, HRH and now H(is)RH pay IT and CG voluntarily and have done for decades. Charles has also given up his personal wealth in order to tax the role.

Finally, you clearly have a very basic (or less) understanding of tax planning and tax avoidance. If you pay into an ISA, you are avoiding tax. If you pay into a pension, you are engaged in tax avoidance. And that's the the start. Just because you don't read in the paper how you and your family are avoiding tax, it doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

You are talking nonsense @Autumndays123

go and read this then come back and write an informed post

britishheritage.com/royals/royal-family-cost-british-taxpayer

OP posts:
BloodyHellKen · 13/09/2022 08:31

As I said a couple of days ago on the previous post about the royal family and inheritance tax I don't think anyone should pay inheritance tax.

You are being taxed on money that has already been taxed. Good for him he's found a way round it and so would I if I could.

I should add I am in favour of higher taxes in general to maintain a better standard of living for everyone, but not inheritance tax because I think it is unfair.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 13/09/2022 08:29

Userg1234 · 13/09/2022 06:42

The is always the right to discuss the monarchy but right now? People are upset.
Also the very next post is someone kicking off like a loon!
It is clear that there is no appetite for a Republic. The sheer numbers of people that are attending, the response to her death ... Sorry but people need to accept we have a king

Biscuit
RiftGibbon · 13/09/2022 08:28

lemmein · 13/09/2022 06:55

The is always the right to discuss the monarchy but right now? People are upset.

It's getting a bit boring being dictated to of what we can discuss because the flag-shaggers are 'upset' tbh.

If words on a screen, about people you don't know, is too upsetting maybe the internet isn't for you?

Also, some people are upset. That's fine.
But not everyone is. Some people just want to get on with their every day lives. Many or which are affected by inequality. It feels as though there is never a 'good time to discuss these things.
It also seems that during such times, when the general public is distracted (directed into distraction, the cynical might say), subtle changes to laws around human rights and environmental issues are slipped through.

bluejay5 · 13/09/2022 08:26

Plantstrees · 13/09/2022 08:19

If you have a non-state pension then indirectly I imagine there are offshore elements within it. It is all perfectly legal and a very sensible investment strategy. The Panama Papers were just the media stirring up trouble - nothing much came of it because most people weren't doing anything wrong. There are always a few tax evaders at every level of wealth.

What a ridiculous response @Plantstrees . Other people do it so it's ok...no it's not ok, it's irrelevant what other wealthy people do. We are talking about the royal family, human beings that are intrinsically better than any of us. Had they been born in any other country or class, they would have inevitably all risen to the same stature and level because they are 'ROYAL'

OP posts:
TarasHarp55 · 13/09/2022 08:26

cakeorwine · 13/09/2022 08:15

You can see how popular the monarchy is recent days, it seems to have overwhelming support

Funny. I remember a million people marching for a second referendum - yet we all know that Brexit had more support.

Which just means you are only seeing the people who support the Monarchy or those who are interested.

You aren't seeing the other people. #survivorbias

Those are the people who obviously haven't read the book by Norman Baker.....there's also millions who are indifferent.

sleepwouldbenice · 13/09/2022 08:23

I am sure I saw this same discussion couple days ago. This and the republic talk getting boring now

Autumndays123 · 13/09/2022 08:21

It's really frustrating that individuals keep posting about this topic having conducted absolutely zero research. It's also concerning how little the OP and general public understand about tax and 'tax avoidance'

Firstly OP, you have to understand that the Royal family are somewhat at a disadvantage to the rest of society as they cannot work or trade. As they can't trade, there are only minimal ways they can increase their family income.

I understand that 'disadvantaged' might be a poor choice of word to use, but you have to understand that the Royal family require some element of wealth in order to be maintained for the next potentially hundreds of years. If the RF paid IHT each time the monarch died, their wealth would evaporate quite quickly.

In addition, as others have said on this thread, HRH and now H(is)RH pay IT and CG voluntarily and have done for decades. Charles has also given up his personal wealth in order to tax the role.

Finally, you clearly have a very basic (or less) understanding of tax planning and tax avoidance. If you pay into an ISA, you are avoiding tax. If you pay into a pension, you are engaged in tax avoidance. And that's the the start. Just because you don't read in the paper how you and your family are avoiding tax, it doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 13/09/2022 08:21

You are not unreasonable but Charles isn't a sole exception - loads of wealthy families have very similar structures in place to avoid inheritance tax and if those structures are abolished for all the other multimillionaires and billionaires then the same legislation should also apply for the crown, which is exactly the reason why the option won't be abolished.

Any family, noble or otherwise, can set up a holiding body which is the "actual" owner of all the assets, and which makes grants to family members according to specific criteria. In the case ofvthe royal family the assets are owned by "the crown" which isn't quite the same entity as the mortal human being currently wearing the crown. In the case of a non-royal family it would be a family trust. These entities are immortal so never pay inheritance tax. They cost a lot to run so it's not worth the effort if you aren't stupidly wealthy.

If a means can be found to close this loophole and make all wealthy estates stop hiding their assets from inheritance tax then the Crown shouldn't be an exception, but neither should it be singled out as the only family trust excluded from the loophole when it's something that happens all the time for thousands of families in the top 1%

TarasHarp55 · 13/09/2022 08:20

sst1234 · 13/09/2022 07:44

If you are going to be angry about something or protest, at least make the effort to think beyond the latest headline. As others said, a monarch cannot sell his/her palaces to retire to the Costa del Sol.

Maybe question why the country is in a mess? Why health people were locked up at home for two years and £450bn was printed to pay for the lockdown disaster. Or maybe why for 25 years, govts refused to invest in nuclear power, leaving us with an energy crisis. Or why we continue to import cheap labour rather than raise the minimum wage and grow productivity through encouraging companies to invest. But never mind all that, it’s too much like hard work to think beyond the what you see when you switch on the tv today.

The Op is rightfully outraged and is entirely to speak about it. Why bring up other issues, she's talking about this one. By that reasoning if there was a thread about the government's failure to invest in nuclear power, we could say "but what about the government allowing the royals to dodge taxes".....are we supposed to be outraged about everything in one go? Let's talk about the subject in hand please, no mind trying to overshadow/minimise it with things that you get het up about.

Plantstrees · 13/09/2022 08:19

bluejay5 · 13/09/2022 08:03

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/paradise-papers-tax-haven-secrets-the-queen-appleby-law-firm-offshore-finance-a8039041.html

moral or immoral?
or does it not matter as it was only £10 million. Maybe I can store some of my money offshore to avoid tax?

If you have a non-state pension then indirectly I imagine there are offshore elements within it. It is all perfectly legal and a very sensible investment strategy. The Panama Papers were just the media stirring up trouble - nothing much came of it because most people weren't doing anything wrong. There are always a few tax evaders at every level of wealth.

TheKeatingFive · 13/09/2022 08:18

These types of institutions are treated differently by the tax system

Well no. We're talking about their private wealth here, not the public funding.

They're keen to stress that this wealth is private and should be treated as such when it suits them, so on what grounds should IHT be waived?

bluejay5 · 13/09/2022 08:17

cakeorwine · 13/09/2022 08:15

You can see how popular the monarchy is recent days, it seems to have overwhelming support

Funny. I remember a million people marching for a second referendum - yet we all know that Brexit had more support.

Which just means you are only seeing the people who support the Monarchy or those who are interested.

You aren't seeing the other people. #survivorbias

This exactly!

OP posts:
Plantstrees · 13/09/2022 08:15

Sally090807 · 13/09/2022 08:00

That’s incorrect, it’s 40% on assets over £325k or £500k if you’re married.

@DdraigGoch is correct. It is up to £1m for a married couple if you take into account the property exemption.

cakeorwine · 13/09/2022 08:15

You can see how popular the monarchy is recent days, it seems to have overwhelming support

Funny. I remember a million people marching for a second referendum - yet we all know that Brexit had more support.

Which just means you are only seeing the people who support the Monarchy or those who are interested.

You aren't seeing the other people. #survivorbias