Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Our NEW KING paying 0% inheritance tax on £100 million estate

187 replies

bluejay5 · 13/09/2022 04:56

Am I right in thinking this is unreasonable? While the rest of us commoners are taxed to within an inch of our lives, struggling to heat our homes. A few select individuals who are innately better than any of us towns folk get to keep their wealth and see their generations become richer and richer.
Don't get me wrong I understand the need to pay taxes, to keep us in a usable society and country. They tax our income, any profit we make from any business we take the risk of setting up, our council taxes us, if we receive a dividend from any smart investment we make, if we decide to buy a new house with money that was already taxed, they tax us again ..

And finally to top it all off, after being taxed all our working lives we decided to try and build some generational wealth and help out our offspring, and even in death they tax us... on property and money that was already taxed!!!

Yet a few individuals through no skills, or talent of their own, just by virtue of their birth are deemed to be literally innately better to a point where they are exempt from the rules we live under.

Please make it make sense???

Apparently, the monarchy is exempt from income tax in order to protect the wealth of the royal family from being eroded!
While the rest of us fight for survival like crabs in a barrel.

Plus anyone heard of the ''panama papers the queen''
google it ...

this Society has class baked into it. We aren't meant to move up or aspire for greater things. It's a rigged system, you can't tell me it's not.

Sorry, rant over.

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 14/09/2022 09:46

OK so he’s not ‘giving’ money to the treasury is he? He’s paying tax like, er, everyone else. How selfless of our sovereign!

How do you know that he’s paying 45%? Did you know that despite reluctantly paying tax they get to negotiate the rates at which they pay? Have you seen his personal tax return from his ‘personal estate’ (and there are many arguments that those duchies are not their personal property at all)? Of course not, because like everything to do with royal finances, it’s shrouded in mystery.

walkingonsunshinekat · 14/09/2022 08:22

Plantstrees · 14/09/2022 07:09

He pays higher-rate income tax on the profits - 45%. Is that enough for you?

Not really, e.g 100m profit, gets to keep 55million, poor thing.

Feel sorry for the staff made redundant during the church service for the Queen, i think that shows exactly what sort of person he is.

Plantstrees · 14/09/2022 07:09

Iamthewombat · 13/09/2022 23:38

Since when has Charles given a ‘massive proportion’ of the profits of the duchy of Cornwall to the Treasury? What % are you claiming that he is handing over?

He pays higher-rate income tax on the profits - 45%. Is that enough for you?

Iamthewombat · 13/09/2022 23:38

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 13/09/2022 22:53

He can't sell any of it, and gives a massive proportion of profits to the Treasury so it wouldn't make sense to pay IHT like a 'normal' rich person anyway

Since when has Charles given a ‘massive proportion’ of the profits of the duchy of Cornwall to the Treasury? What % are you claiming that he is handing over?

allboysherebutme · 13/09/2022 23:19

None of us should have to pay it, we pay tax all our life, what we choose to do with our properties or savings after death, should not be taxed again. X

Plantstrees · 13/09/2022 23:00

I believe that a high proportion of the Queen's private wealth is jewellery. The collection would be very unique and difficult to value so all anyone can do is speculate.

The properies at Balmoral and Sandringham would probably qualify for zero Inheritance Tax anyway as they are farms and the houses, at least in part, are open to the public so would gain further exemptions.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 13/09/2022 22:53

He can't sell any of it, and gives a massive proportion of profits to the Treasury so it wouldn't make sense to pay IHT like a 'normal' rich person anyway

Plantstrees · 13/09/2022 22:50

@Wallow

I have no problem explaining what is wrong with the article but I don't want to spend my whole evening typing so here is one example from all the horribly misleading statements in the article:

"...to develop further without having to pay corporate taxes."

"..It has done so without paying corporation taxes."

It infers (no doubt intentionally) that the Duke does not pay tax on the Estate which of course he does.

The Duchy of Cornwall is not a company, its a personal Estate so why would it be liable to Corporation Tax? Instead, the Duke of Cornwall is personally liable to higher-rate income tax on the surplus made by the Estate, the rates for which are more than double the Corporation Tax rate!

This is an extract from the Duchy website for you:

"Does the Duchy pay corporation tax?

The Duchy of Cornwall estate is not a corporation and therefore not subject to Corporation tax. However, The Prince does pays income tax on the Duchy’s surplus. If the Duchy also paid corporation tax, the Prince would effectively be taxed twice on the same income. Only companies pay corporation tax; many other large organisations which are not companies pay income tax."

Iamthewombat · 13/09/2022 22:08

hummerbird · 13/09/2022 12:01

It would be nice if the OP knew what The King had inherited of his own and a few more facts like income and total tax.
Most of the land and buildings belong to us, and we have not maintained them. Buck House is about as bad as the Houses of Parliament.
Most of Duchy of whatsit goes to Crown and he gets a pension or stipend or wage.

What is ‘crown’, that ‘most of Duchy of Cornwall and Duchy of Lancaster’ is ‘going to’? Do you mean the crown estates? No. The royal family get to keep the income from both of the duchies, the crown estates (which belong to us) don’t get a look in, and guess what, the duchies don’t pay corporation tax like normal businesses. Great, eh?

I’d very much like to know ‘what the king had inherited of his own’ but we aren’t going to find out because the royal family get to keep their wills secret. Why is that, do you think? It couldn’t be because they don’t want us to know how very rich they are, could it? Especially when they are grabbing > £100m in sovereign grant this year?

mycatisannoying · 13/09/2022 13:11

YANBU. Scrap the whole fucking lot of them.

hummerbird · 13/09/2022 12:01

It would be nice if the OP knew what The King had inherited of his own and a few more facts like income and total tax.
Most of the land and buildings belong to us, and we have not maintained them. Buck House is about as bad as the Houses of Parliament.
Most of Duchy of whatsit goes to Crown and he gets a pension or stipend or wage.

Swingsarefun · 13/09/2022 11:57

DdraigGoch · 13/09/2022 11:49

The house would presumably have been worth in excess of £500k. That's still quite a windfall, even if you aren't jumping into pools of money like Scrooge McDuck. Hers was still an asset wealthy estate.

I said earlier that I'd prefer to see IHT replaced by CGT.

as someone who works in the field I would totally agree. I recently bought a property. The previous owner was a wealthy man who made a capital gain on house
price inflation that was vast. Hundreds and hundreds of thousands of pounds. Totally untaxed.

DdraigGoch · 13/09/2022 11:49

HelloDaisy · 13/09/2022 09:48

I had to pay some inheritance tax for my mum when she died.
She was certainly not wealthy but had worked bloody hard for a charity all her working life and owned her house.
We live in the SE so her house was over the threshold allowed at the time for a single person. you certainly don’t need to be wealthy to be liable, especially if you live here.

The house would presumably have been worth in excess of £500k. That's still quite a windfall, even if you aren't jumping into pools of money like Scrooge McDuck. Hers was still an asset wealthy estate.

I said earlier that I'd prefer to see IHT replaced by CGT.

blockpavingismynightmare · 13/09/2022 11:41

No holy war from me. They are dinosaurs and should not be here. The Queen was the last.
No more of this overprivileged nonsense please.
Charles is King. He has made sure of that moving very quickly after the death; didn't anyone notice how swift the transition was?
Let him have it then. Be King but only in name. No more vast wealth when people in his Islands are homeless and starving

DdraigGoch · 13/09/2022 11:37

eldora · 13/09/2022 09:40

4% is 2.7m of the current British population.

That’s not bugger all.

It is compared with the other 96%.

sorrycanthearyou · 13/09/2022 11:31

But you don't have blue blood, you are a subject. You are not as good as them, that's how they see it. If you disagree well, what can ya do?

Swingsarefun · 13/09/2022 11:19

Cognacsoft · 13/09/2022 07:26

This^^

If I build up my assets and invest wisely why should my family pay inheritance tax on an estate that has been made with previously taxed income?

The bulk of most people in the UK’s estates comes from capital gains on their main residence (house price rises), one of the few capital gains that is untaxed, so no, your estate is not made up of money from taxed income and taxed investment. It’s mostly untaxed income.

walkingonsunshinekat · 13/09/2022 11:11

Getoff · 13/09/2022 09:48

I believe farmers can pass on their farms to their children without them being subject to inheritance tax. I suppose the reason it that it's impractical and undesirable to subdivide a farm ( to pay the inheritance tax) once each generation.

I guess we could look at the royal family the same way, the family wealth exists to maintain the family, and we don't want the size of the pot to decline with time, because it needs to do its job forever.

Whether or not people agree with this argument, pointing out that farmers are exempt does show exemption from inheritance tax is not only for the royal family.

They can but not all tax free, some notable exceptions and cash is taxed, as are quotas, machinery, animals, derelict buildings & stored crops.

Funnily enough, considering her love of horse racing, stud farms are all outside of IHT.

The Royals have no such liabilities and legally avoid all tax on inheritances inc cash assets.

TitInATrance · 13/09/2022 10:51

We need a separate question to discuss the 0% tax being paid by the king as a private individual on the late Queen’s personal £500 million fortune, (estimated because we are not allowed to know, and will never be told).

The crown estates are a separate entity and a red herring.

bluejay5 · 13/09/2022 10:27

walkingonsunshinekat · 13/09/2022 09:18

Must have missed the bit where the OP is calling for a holy war on Royals ?

So KC has inherited nothing at all from his mothers passing, that he can use for his own benefit, the Duchy of Lancaster estate is purely used for sovereign duties etc ?

The only reason there is no IHT to pay is because the establishment said so.

haha if ever I wished for a like button, it would be for this 😂. I'm now an extremist hahah. This mini AIBU poll would suggest otherwise.
@walkingonsunshinekat @WhatHoJeeves

OP posts:
Drivebye · 13/09/2022 10:20

There are a few comments on this thread about them having enough to do 'their job'.

So what's enough? New outfits all the time, new car, helicopter on tap to visit people? I expect they get given a lot for free - is this donated to charities? I believe there is a list but us it everything they get?

In 2022, is it really acceptable to have multiple houses and staff? When people say they are 'working' this is a very different 'working' to the majority of the population.

TheKeatingFive · 13/09/2022 09:50

I guess we could look at the royal family the same way, the family wealth exists to maintain the family, and we don't want the size of the pot to decline with time, because it needs to do its job forever.

Thats exactly what the Duchy's and Crown Estates are for.

But the private assets are separate to that and no justification for them having special terms. Your point is answers by the other income streams.

HelloDaisy · 13/09/2022 09:48

DdraigGoch · 13/09/2022 07:49

Pretty much no one pays IHT. It's only due on estates of over £500k (£1m if belonging to a married couple, or a widower thereof), so if you are liable for IHT then you must be pretty rich yourself OP. Those with larger estates (such as the Duke of Westminster) will have other ways of avoiding the tax.

I had to pay some inheritance tax for my mum when she died.
She was certainly not wealthy but had worked bloody hard for a charity all her working life and owned her house.
We live in the SE so her house was over the threshold allowed at the time for a single person. you certainly don’t need to be wealthy to be liable, especially if you live here.

Getoff · 13/09/2022 09:48

I believe farmers can pass on their farms to their children without them being subject to inheritance tax. I suppose the reason it that it's impractical and undesirable to subdivide a farm ( to pay the inheritance tax) once each generation.

I guess we could look at the royal family the same way, the family wealth exists to maintain the family, and we don't want the size of the pot to decline with time, because it needs to do its job forever.

Whether or not people agree with this argument, pointing out that farmers are exempt does show exemption from inheritance tax is not only for the royal family.

HelloDaisy · 13/09/2022 09:42

There are plenty of other people who also don’t pay inheritance tax.

The Marquis of Westminster, Hugh Grosvenor, inherited £9 billion in 2016 but because it was all passed through trust he didn’t have to pay anything. Meanwhile my lovely mum died in an accident on holiday at the same time as his father did and I had to pay. I remember feeling then it was very unfair…

Swipe left for the next trending thread