Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Our NEW KING paying 0% inheritance tax on £100 million estate

187 replies

bluejay5 · 13/09/2022 04:56

Am I right in thinking this is unreasonable? While the rest of us commoners are taxed to within an inch of our lives, struggling to heat our homes. A few select individuals who are innately better than any of us towns folk get to keep their wealth and see their generations become richer and richer.
Don't get me wrong I understand the need to pay taxes, to keep us in a usable society and country. They tax our income, any profit we make from any business we take the risk of setting up, our council taxes us, if we receive a dividend from any smart investment we make, if we decide to buy a new house with money that was already taxed, they tax us again ..

And finally to top it all off, after being taxed all our working lives we decided to try and build some generational wealth and help out our offspring, and even in death they tax us... on property and money that was already taxed!!!

Yet a few individuals through no skills, or talent of their own, just by virtue of their birth are deemed to be literally innately better to a point where they are exempt from the rules we live under.

Please make it make sense???

Apparently, the monarchy is exempt from income tax in order to protect the wealth of the royal family from being eroded!
While the rest of us fight for survival like crabs in a barrel.

Plus anyone heard of the ''panama papers the queen''
google it ...

this Society has class baked into it. We aren't meant to move up or aspire for greater things. It's a rigged system, you can't tell me it's not.

Sorry, rant over.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DownNative · 16/09/2022 08:06

Iamthewombat · 14/09/2022 13:27

Oh well, if it is public knowledge that Charles pays tax at 45% then it must be true, eh? How did the public acquire that knowledge? They can’t, because the evidence isn’t available to view.

Re the Duchy of Cornwall accounts: would it surprise you to learn that I am a chartered accountant and finance director? Thus well qualified to look at annual reports, having had many years’ experience of sticking them together and reviewing them. Have you looked at the 2022 ‘integrated annual report’? I have. Show me the tax line in the group revenue statement. Oh, you can’t. Because the tax payable by this ‘private estate’ isn’t mentioned in the P&L account. That is what I’d call a mystery.

The ‘trade and other payables’ note gives a liability of £0.3m for ‘Social security and other taxes’. When you strip out PAYE and NI for employees, which is always paid in arrears, it doesn’t leave much for other taxes, does it? On revenue of 45m and a ‘surplus’ of £25m?

You can see from the group cash flow statement that ‘HRH’ (the accounts actually call him that) managed to extract £21m for the year to 31 March 2022 and £20.2m for the previous year. Not bad, eh?

The UK Government maintained Prince of Wales website states:

"The Prince pays Income Tax voluntarily on the surplus of the Duchy of Cornwall, after official expenditure has been deducted at the highest rate, which was 45 per cent in 2016-17, resulting in a total of £4.8million (including an element of VAT)."

So....do you have any evidence the PoW doesn't pay 45% income tax?

fyn · 16/09/2022 07:59

@Mothership4two yes, but there are numerous ways to reduce that liability. I am an Estate Manager and have worked for families far wealthier than the Queen. Tax planning is a big part of the role and taken into consideration with almost every decision that is made.

StoneofDestiny · 16/09/2022 07:29

The financial privileges the monarchy has are scandalous. Don't forget the queen was forced to pay tax fairly recently - following pressure from the media. Her husbands will was sealed (not a privilege non royals have) and so will her will be. This family are independently wealthy multi millionaires - yet we taxpayers end up paying for their weddings, funerals and just about everything else they can screw us for. If people are dumb enough to believe they 'bring in more than they cost', we probably deserve to be screwed over by them.

When your local school comes begging for money, when you can't find an NHS dentist in your area, when you cannot get up the hospital waiting list or get a local police officer to investigate your burglary etc...........then think of the billions of pounds spaffed up the wall on an old woman's funeral that is lasting weeks (because she wanted it too!)

BakeOffIsBack · 16/09/2022 07:13

Why does the "Crown" own the seabed around the UK?

Just on this one point - I’m kinda pleased they do else the government would have sold it off by now. Misses point of thread.

littlespeckledfrog · 16/09/2022 06:49

How do you know the Queen's estate passes to Charles? She has other children and her will won't be published. It seems likely he will receive a share, but it would be very surprising if he's her sole beneficiary.

Mothership4two · 16/09/2022 06:29

@WhatHoJeeves ·

"extremism" because you don't agree with them? Our new king WILL be paying 0% inheritance tax on £100+ million estate - factually correct

And I couldn't care less

You couldn't care less that you accuse someone who is being factually correct of extremism? Not sure I would come on to a public forum to admit that. Bit OTT

Mothership4two · 16/09/2022 05:17

Her wealth has been estimated at £430 million @fyn although it's all pretty secret, it's not just Balmoral and Sandringham

Mothership4two · 16/09/2022 05:11

The Crown Estates provide the income @Tiani4 not the RF or the Monarch. It's technically owned by the reigning monarch but not literally ie he cannot sell off any part of it or take the revenue and is not managed by him,

fyn · 16/09/2022 04:55

Even if IHT was due on balmoral and Sandringham it would be minimal. They’d get APR (Agricultural Property Relief) on a good majority of it which is 0%. A lot of the remaining estate and parkland would qualify as national heritage assets and qualify for tax relief - these schemes are open to anybody who qualifies.

BambinaJAS · 16/09/2022 04:32

LuftBalloons · 13/09/2022 07:39

I agree @bluejay5 The level of deference and exceptionalism for a mediocre person who’s lucked out on his accident of birth, is distasteful.

If you do not have a background in finance, most people generally have no idea how much they are all being fleeced by the Royal Family.

They have no idea about "Queens Consent"

They have no idea that the Duchy blocked leaseholders from buying the freeholds to their properties.

Thats how they maintain control now. Not via military power, but via economic power.

Specifically property.

Why does the "Crown" own the seabed around the UK?

Its completely ludicrous. There is no other Royal family in the democratic western world like this. None.

And when people say "70% goes to the people and 30% to the Sovereign Grant"..

That is the textbook definition of a rentier.

The Royal Family do nothing productive. They just sit in the middle absorbing 30% of the income.

In reality, 100% should go to the public purse.

The entire country is beeing fleeced slowly as the Royals absorb more and more land, while the "Royalists" cheer them on.

You honestly cannot make it up.

MarshaMelrose · 16/09/2022 04:04

Mothership4two · 16/09/2022 03:59

Look up Crown Estates @Tiani4 - I think you have that backwards. Also how do you calculate how much RF bring in in the way of tourism? Counties without monarchies seem to do OK

It's my experience that those who support the monarchy will happily believe the figures. And those who don't will call the figures rubbish.
It hardly seems worth presenting the figures because you've all judged what the figures should be already.

Mothership4two · 16/09/2022 03:59

Look up Crown Estates @Tiani4 - I think you have that backwards. Also how do you calculate how much RF bring in in the way of tourism? Counties without monarchies seem to do OK

Tiani4 · 15/09/2022 16:07

Whoops saved too soon by accident so there is a net profit to government of £240 million a year from Royals just from their Crown estate of the Monarch. That's £1 billion wveey 4 years money give up to government - ie we people- let alone the economy boost from tourism revenue to others that they bring in as our Royal family (with a crown estate) - calculated at at least £500 million a year up to £1.6 billion a year to our economy according to Forbes

They ain't so shabby at all, the Royal family being in far more than they cost us

LovingTheseAutumnSnippets · 15/09/2022 16:06

I love people who make grand statements like this, but haven’t googled first.

lol

Ifailed · 15/09/2022 16:04

I'm unsure of the arrangements of any private wealth

If you bothered to read the thread, you'd know that the Queen's private wealth is passed down without paying any IT, it specially exempt, unlike the rest of us.

Tiani4 · 15/09/2022 16:03

Plantstrees · 15/09/2022 15:51

@Iamthewombat Clearly you can't read properly. I did not state that at all - please check what I said!

These are my previous posts - nowhere do I say the income tax is recorded in the accounts:

  1. He pays higher-rate income tax on the profits - 45%. Is that enough for you?
  2. It is public knowledge and on record that he pays 45% on his income. I think it is recorded in Hansard but am not going to [find] spend hours searching for it.
  3. The Duchy accounts are also in the public domain and available to anyone on their website if care to look. No mystery involved.
  4. If you really are a Chartered Accountant you should understand that the accounts for an Estate or any other unicorporated entity never show the owner's private income tax liability! Only Corporate accounts will do that.

Public knowledge just means that the information is in the public domain - not that everyone has it in their possession. You really are being obtuse. I said that the tax rate was declared in Hansard, not in the accounts where it would not be appropriate.

Well said ^^

People also moaning about how much sovereign grant the royals get also ignore the fact that it mmm the royals give £313 million revunue rayed by the crown from palace/ crown estates and revenue and are given a slice back £83 million as the grant! £83 million in 2020- so there's a net profit to government even after "we pay for Royals costs!" (We don't pay they do and they get 1/4 back!!)

gogohmm · 15/09/2022 15:58

The Queen's wealth was mostly the crown estates, it can't be sold so can't be treated the same as a normal inheritance. I'm unsure of the arrangements of any private wealth

Plantstrees · 15/09/2022 15:51

@Iamthewombat Clearly you can't read properly. I did not state that at all - please check what I said!

These are my previous posts - nowhere do I say the income tax is recorded in the accounts:

  1. He pays higher-rate income tax on the profits - 45%. Is that enough for you?
  2. It is public knowledge and on record that he pays 45% on his income. I think it is recorded in Hansard but am not going to [find] spend hours searching for it.
  3. The Duchy accounts are also in the public domain and available to anyone on their website if care to look. No mystery involved.
  4. If you really are a Chartered Accountant you should understand that the accounts for an Estate or any other unicorporated entity never show the owner's private income tax liability! Only Corporate accounts will do that.

Public knowledge just means that the information is in the public domain - not that everyone has it in their possession. You really are being obtuse. I said that the tax rate was declared in Hansard, not in the accounts where it would not be appropriate.

Tumbleweed101 · 14/09/2022 22:47

I see their wealth the wealth of our nations history.

It doesn't mean to say I think paying tax on things already taxed is fair. I think inheritance tax is awful (even though it means nothing to me as I wont ever inherit anything of value).

Iamthewombat · 14/09/2022 22:21

Make your mind up. On the subject of tax, you claimed that Prince Charles’ tax liabilities relating to the Duchy of Cornwall were not a mystery because anyone could look at the accounts for the Duchy, them being in the public domain and all.

Unfortunately for you, you forgot to look first. If you had, you’d see that there is no mention of tax in those accounts.

Plantstrees · 14/09/2022 17:05

Iamthewombat · 14/09/2022 13:27

Oh well, if it is public knowledge that Charles pays tax at 45% then it must be true, eh? How did the public acquire that knowledge? They can’t, because the evidence isn’t available to view.

Re the Duchy of Cornwall accounts: would it surprise you to learn that I am a chartered accountant and finance director? Thus well qualified to look at annual reports, having had many years’ experience of sticking them together and reviewing them. Have you looked at the 2022 ‘integrated annual report’? I have. Show me the tax line in the group revenue statement. Oh, you can’t. Because the tax payable by this ‘private estate’ isn’t mentioned in the P&L account. That is what I’d call a mystery.

The ‘trade and other payables’ note gives a liability of £0.3m for ‘Social security and other taxes’. When you strip out PAYE and NI for employees, which is always paid in arrears, it doesn’t leave much for other taxes, does it? On revenue of 45m and a ‘surplus’ of £25m?

You can see from the group cash flow statement that ‘HRH’ (the accounts actually call him that) managed to extract £21m for the year to 31 March 2022 and £20.2m for the previous year. Not bad, eh?

If you really are a Chartered Accountant you should understand that the accounts for an Estate or any other unicorporated entity never show the owner's private income tax liability! Only Corporate accounts will do that.

Public knowledge just means that the information is in the public domain - not that everyone has it in their possession. You really are being obtuse. I said that the tax rate was declared in Hansard, not in the accounts where it would not be appropriate.

Iamthewombat · 14/09/2022 13:27

Oh well, if it is public knowledge that Charles pays tax at 45% then it must be true, eh? How did the public acquire that knowledge? They can’t, because the evidence isn’t available to view.

Re the Duchy of Cornwall accounts: would it surprise you to learn that I am a chartered accountant and finance director? Thus well qualified to look at annual reports, having had many years’ experience of sticking them together and reviewing them. Have you looked at the 2022 ‘integrated annual report’? I have. Show me the tax line in the group revenue statement. Oh, you can’t. Because the tax payable by this ‘private estate’ isn’t mentioned in the P&L account. That is what I’d call a mystery.

The ‘trade and other payables’ note gives a liability of £0.3m for ‘Social security and other taxes’. When you strip out PAYE and NI for employees, which is always paid in arrears, it doesn’t leave much for other taxes, does it? On revenue of 45m and a ‘surplus’ of £25m?

You can see from the group cash flow statement that ‘HRH’ (the accounts actually call him that) managed to extract £21m for the year to 31 March 2022 and £20.2m for the previous year. Not bad, eh?

Plantstrees · 14/09/2022 12:56

@Iamthewombat The Duchy accounts are also in the public domain and available to anyone on their website if care to look. No mystery involved.

Plantstrees · 14/09/2022 12:54

@Iamthewombat It is public knowledge and on record that he pays 45% on his income. I think it is recorded in Hansard but am not going to find hours searching for it.

FinallyHere · 14/09/2022 12:07

It how it works.

Remember that especially when ever you hear a politician saying we 'can't afford' to house the homeless or feed the hungry.