Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's time for an Australian republic

133 replies

Hairday · 12/09/2022 23:36

It's hard to defend it rationally, really, but Queen Elizabeth always seemed better than some elected person, but King Charles doesn't. What do you think?

OP posts:
Ozgirl75 · 13/09/2022 03:25

@ManicDreamPixie the U.K. economy is the 5th largest in the world - it’s hardly only known for the monarchy.

Ozgirl75 · 13/09/2022 03:22

I tried to get a chat going about this in my exercise class this morning but all the Australians there were like “yeah don’t really mind either way” 😁
I think most Australians are fairly pragmatic sensible people who think “if it ain’t broke” but also if someone came up with a sensible model that wasn’t overly cumbersome (given that we vote on various levels of government seemingly every other week here), wouldn’t be horribly embarrassing on a world stage (so no novelty characters) and we could be proud of, they’d probably go for that.

We already have so many people to vote for here at federal, state and council level that i think a lot of the reticence to change is just thinking “surely we’ve elected everyone electable now anyway, there’s no one left” but not wanting to be left with a joke character.

ManicDreamPixie · 13/09/2022 03:21

Like the OP I have dual citizenship. I’d be in favour of a republic for Australia, although my feelings on the subject are mild. What I absolutely don’t want is a referendum, forcing people into one extreme camp or another, inviting lasting division and bitterness. More usefully, we could have discussions about how we want the country to be governed; what the role of the head of state should be; how they might come to be appointed and disposed of; and how/when any powers could be exercised. Without that the discussion doesn’t get further than ‘I don’t want an Australian head of state to be based in London’ on the one hand and ‘Yes, but I don’t want Trump’ on the other. So until then, I’ll keep the status quo. As far as the UK is concerned, Pomp & Circumstance, including the Monarchy, is it’s USP. Without that it’s just a grey damp island just off continental Europe, used by the US as a convenient unsinkable aircraft carrier. So I think we’re stuck with them.

GlorianaCervixia · 13/09/2022 03:07

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 13/09/2022 02:55

DItto re: EssentialBaby. I tried Everybump and couldn't get into it - too used to the fast pace and diversity of people and subjects on here now. Wasn't there also some drama with the fellow who started it?

Yes, they banned lots of people and are extremely restrictive about what can be posted and why. Gender critical discussion is mostly not allowed and anyone who mentions any other forum is immediately banned.

This forum was a spin-off: motherboard-forum.com . It's less restrictive but also much quieter unfortunately. It's a real shame the Essential Baby forums were closed.

Back on topic: I voted for a republic last time but I really dislike the proposed model this time around so I'm uncertain which way I would vote. From conversations with indigenous Australians, many of the older people had a very fond relationship with the Queen because they could get an audience with her when sometimes they weren't being heard by local officials. There's a diversity of thought amongst First Australians, just like with any other group.

milkyaqua · 13/09/2022 03:02

Hairday · 13/09/2022 02:35

Not any more, but it used to. They keep watering it down. Most recently they replaced "we are young and free" with "we are one and free". It turns out "young" referred to the nation and we've been belting out racist lyrics all this time. (stupidly, that never occurred to me, I thought the song writers were referring to their own youth because before that it was "australian sons let us rejoice" that got replaced with "Australians all..." ).

Basically, an ode to the British empire keeps getting nerfed to the point of meaninglessness. What does "one and free" even mean? Nobody actually meant to say that, it was just the closest non-offensive alternative. The whole anthem is like that now.

That is an entirely different song that was never the Australian national anthem.

You have confused "Advance Australia Fair" with "Rule Britannia!"

Hairday · 13/09/2022 02:56

Sadly they've never replaced "our home is girt by sea" because it's inoffensive. Australia is girt by sea all right.

OP posts:
TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 13/09/2022 02:55

Loopyloopy · 13/09/2022 02:45

I've been coming here since essential baby got shut down. Thanks pp who has just suggested every bump!

DItto re: EssentialBaby. I tried Everybump and couldn't get into it - too used to the fast pace and diversity of people and subjects on here now. Wasn't there also some drama with the fellow who started it?

Loopyloopy · 13/09/2022 02:45

Rapidtango · 13/09/2022 00:22

Do you have an Australian version of Mumsnet to which you could post your republican requirements? I'm not sure it will gain much traction on a predominantly UK site.

I've been coming here since essential baby got shut down. Thanks pp who has just suggested every bump!

Hairday · 13/09/2022 02:35

MrsFezziwig · 13/09/2022 02:02

Which national anthem contains “Britannia rules the waves” @Hairday ?

Not any more, but it used to. They keep watering it down. Most recently they replaced "we are young and free" with "we are one and free". It turns out "young" referred to the nation and we've been belting out racist lyrics all this time. (stupidly, that never occurred to me, I thought the song writers were referring to their own youth because before that it was "australian sons let us rejoice" that got replaced with "Australians all..." ).

Basically, an ode to the British empire keeps getting nerfed to the point of meaninglessness. What does "one and free" even mean? Nobody actually meant to say that, it was just the closest non-offensive alternative. The whole anthem is like that now.

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 13/09/2022 02:31

Personally I love the Australian accent. We spent a few days down in Sidney and along the East Coast and everyone was super friendly. We had a great time there.

MarshaMelrose · 13/09/2022 02:29

The Australian PM was already asked this and he said he could never rule it out but it isn't in this term's agenda because they're concentrating on the economy.

CoolerThanIceCream · 13/09/2022 02:11

Hairday · 13/09/2022 01:12

I suppose the main thing would be to update the constitution. It needs updating anyway.

For myself (and I have dual citizenship with the UK anyway) I feel that it's embarrassing. Australia is a multicultural country. We have strong ties with Asia especially and Pacific region countries. We don't really need our flag, for example, proclaiming our colonialist past. Australia day should not be the first day of occupation. Charles should not be head of state. The national anthem should not contain the line "britannia rules the waves". Cringe. I mean, sure, they're details, but also it might be better to change.

Luckily the national anthem doesn’t contain those words…..

No547 · 13/09/2022 02:04

I'm Australian and want nothing more than Australia to be a republic. I don't recognize either the queen or king as head of state.
I don't think they add anything to our way of life or represent who we are.

MrsFezziwig · 13/09/2022 02:02

Hairday · 13/09/2022 01:12

I suppose the main thing would be to update the constitution. It needs updating anyway.

For myself (and I have dual citizenship with the UK anyway) I feel that it's embarrassing. Australia is a multicultural country. We have strong ties with Asia especially and Pacific region countries. We don't really need our flag, for example, proclaiming our colonialist past. Australia day should not be the first day of occupation. Charles should not be head of state. The national anthem should not contain the line "britannia rules the waves". Cringe. I mean, sure, they're details, but also it might be better to change.

Which national anthem contains “Britannia rules the waves” @Hairday ?

CoolerThanIceCream · 13/09/2022 02:01

Keyansier · 13/09/2022 01:28

I don't care what accent a person has or where they come from either?? Just that this certain accent I don't like because I think it sounds common, to me personally.

So you’ve changed your tune to just speaking for yourself now, instead of for all British people….

No547 · 13/09/2022 01:57

Getofftheladder · 12/09/2022 23:44

They don’t seem to massively want to be a republic from what I’ve seen. Few republicans as anywhere, but no big push for it. Forgive me if I’m wrong.

@Getofftheladder, there's a lot of talk about it.....the prime minister, who was elected last year, is a huge supporter of Australia bring a republic. He wasn't pushing any agenda during his election but it's definitely building momentum. The queen's death will just fuel the discussion.

Dishh · 13/09/2022 01:55

@Keyansier

I don't care what accent a person has or where they come from either?? Just that this certain accent I don't like because I think it sounds common, to me personally.

But the fact you even mentioned negatively it on a thread that is not about accents shows you do care. You are certainly entitled to an opinion, but there really wasn't a need to share it here. Remember, too, that accents are born of circumstance: that is, the reason Australians sound they way they do is because of English colonialism.

Re: the thought of an Australian republic, this has been floated before in a referendum (25 years or so ago?) and failed. The answer might be different now. For me, I think the country is nearly ready for a new phase, but not just yet. I do believe there are some global structural changes occurring, so it would be best to wait these out at least.

MarshaMelrose · 13/09/2022 01:40

Haha. I hope so or he's going to have his spirit crushed.

CoolerThanIceCream · 13/09/2022 01:39

Keyansier · 13/09/2022 01:25

Are you Australian??

No.

Hairday · 13/09/2022 01:36

MarshaMelrose · 13/09/2022 01:32

He's only been king for 4 days! He's hardly slept and he's been here there and everywhere and you're condemning him already. Give the guy a break already.

He's far too busy to be reading threads on Mumsnet, don't worry!

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 13/09/2022 01:32

He's only been king for 4 days! He's hardly slept and he's been here there and everywhere and you're condemning him already. Give the guy a break already.

Keyansier · 13/09/2022 01:28

MermaidMummy06 · 13/09/2022 01:17

Well, us 'common' Aussies don't care what accent a person has or where they come from. It's the words that come out of their mouth that counts, and yours are extremely offensive. Please keep your rude comments to yourself.

I don't care what accent a person has or where they come from either?? Just that this certain accent I don't like because I think it sounds common, to me personally.

LINABE · 13/09/2022 01:27

HeddaGarbled · 13/09/2022 00:11

I’ve seen more republican threads on here in the last 2 days than you can shake a stick at. It’s not wrong to have the discussions but do we really need to have one every fucking 5 minutes so fucking soon? Could you not have waited a week? You know that some people are upset. It’s so unkind.

I agree with this sentiment entirely.

Keyansier · 13/09/2022 01:25

CoolerThanIceCream · 13/09/2022 01:15

Right, and so many British accents sound so much better.

People replacing ‘th’ with ‘f’. Not even being able to speak English properly (I’ve never heard other English speakers come out with the ‘I seen…, ‘I done…’ atrocities.

They sound very ‘common’ to my ears, and they’re only the tip of the iceberg.

Are you Australian??

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 13/09/2022 01:21

Wilburisagirl · 13/09/2022 01:17

I feel really mixed feelings about this. I don't want an American style republic at all. Having English, Irish and Scottish heritage, I feel a great affinity for the UK and greatly admired the Queen. And yet having listened to the thoughts and feelings of many First Nations people over these past few days, I'm starting to feel like a republic is the fresh start we need as a nation to truly come together and make up for some of the horrors of the past.

I agree, the remnants of British colonialism just don't fit well with what I see as the identity and culture of Australia, now and into the future. A change to the constitution and head of state won't change everything but it's part of what needs to change.

And I say that as a dual British citizen with a British parent and a British partner, I love the UK too but Australia's ties to it are outdated and obstructive to progress.