Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's time for an Australian republic

133 replies

Hairday · 12/09/2022 23:36

It's hard to defend it rationally, really, but Queen Elizabeth always seemed better than some elected person, but King Charles doesn't. What do you think?

OP posts:
DoIDareSayAnything · 13/09/2022 05:58

Funny, how it is never the right time.

felulageller · 13/09/2022 05:45

I can't see the commonwealth existing in a decade.

Australia will go as will Canada New Zealand Jamaica and the rest.

HoppingPavlova · 13/09/2022 05:36

I’m Australian and while my personal preference is a Republic, I just don’t think the time to be talking about it is right now. Staggered anyone would think it’s appropriate. We haven’t even had her Memorial Day and I think whether the preference us for a Republic or not, it’s just really disrespectful to a woman who gave her all for so many years to do this before she is even in the ground so to speak.

milkyaqua · 13/09/2022 05:33

Hairday · 13/09/2022 04:15

I'm afraid not. This is the verse I'm referring to. It was removed in the 1980s when people started thinking how great it would be to have a national anthem that was about us, rather than a different country:

When gallant Cook from Albion sail'd,
To trace wide oceans o'er,
True British courage bore him on,
Til he landed on our shore.
Then here he raised Old England's flag,
The standard of the brave;
"With all her faults we love her still"
"Britannia rules the wave."
In joyful strains then let us sing,
Advance, Australia fair.

That is fascinating! But in the whole of my life I have only ever heard the first verse sung (badly). The original, I see, was long...

DoIDareSayAnything · 13/09/2022 05:30

Yep, time to do it. We kept being told the Queen was special and we needed to wait. Well, she's dead now. Time to wrap it up and move on.

We get nothing out of it, Britain's day is over.

Referendums are expensive. If we are having one for the Indigenous Voice, then we might as well pop this in as well and get a 2 for.

StartupRepair · 13/09/2022 05:19

Gillian Triggs would be good. There is no shortage of women in Australia with gravitas and integrity.

onlythreenow · 13/09/2022 04:37

I can't stand the Australian accent. How they say "nice" as "noice" for example - it sounds so common to British ears - even when spoken from what is considered the posh Australians. There are so many hot guys out there but open their mouths and an Australian accent falls out and it's an instant turn off!

I would rather listen to an Australian accent all day than read idiotic comments from shallow people like you (who obviously has not heard many British accents in your lifetime!!).

Gremlinsateit · 13/09/2022 04:17

Hairday · 13/09/2022 04:09

Yes! Like ozgirl75 said, it has to someone bipartisan. Someone who has already contributed to the country. Not a showbiz person or journalist. Maybe Megan Davis, Donna stolzenberg, Tanya hosch? I would love our first president to be a woman. Although, I suppose we've technically had a woman head of state for 70 years. Still. It would mean a lot.

Ooh interesting choices. Joyce Clague? Rachel Perkins? Anita Heiss? Not Lidia Thorpe or Linda Burney as it shouldn’t be a past senator/MP.

Hairday · 13/09/2022 04:15

milkyaqua · 13/09/2022 03:02

That is an entirely different song that was never the Australian national anthem.

You have confused "Advance Australia Fair" with "Rule Britannia!"

I'm afraid not. This is the verse I'm referring to. It was removed in the 1980s when people started thinking how great it would be to have a national anthem that was about us, rather than a different country:

When gallant Cook from Albion sail'd,
To trace wide oceans o'er,
True British courage bore him on,
Til he landed on our shore.
Then here he raised Old England's flag,
The standard of the brave;
"With all her faults we love her still"
"Britannia rules the wave."
In joyful strains then let us sing,
Advance, Australia fair.

OP posts:
Hairday · 13/09/2022 04:09

Fullupdowntown1a1 · 13/09/2022 03:36

@Keyansier so mean and off topic! I love Australian accents, and not all English accents fill me with joy if I’m honest, but I’m glad everyone doesn’t speak the same.m- how boring would that be! One man’s meat is another man’s poison.

@Hairday absolutely time to break free I’d say, it would be great for Australia to have a head of state that would represent Australia alone around the world. They could be just a figure head, like the monarch but more Aussie. Who do you think Australians might choose?

Yes! Like ozgirl75 said, it has to someone bipartisan. Someone who has already contributed to the country. Not a showbiz person or journalist. Maybe Megan Davis, Donna stolzenberg, Tanya hosch? I would love our first president to be a woman. Although, I suppose we've technically had a woman head of state for 70 years. Still. It would mean a lot.

OP posts:
TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 13/09/2022 04:05

Absolutely agree, and the latest news suggests the possibility of corruption too. It’s just staggering to me that Hurley allowed the secret ministries, apparently without seeking advice from a constitutional QC, and “at the same time as” accepting a large financial grant for a charity that isn’t operating.

And conveniently forgot to list the appointments in his public diary. Dodgy AF, as we say.

Fullupdowntown1a1 · 13/09/2022 03:59

Ozgirl75 · 13/09/2022 03:51

God imagine having Kylie Minogue. I think we’re already seen as a bit of a lightweight country, that would just cement our airhead status 😆

@Ozgirl75 Kylie’s iconic! And she always hits her mark, in short, you should be so lucky…etc etc

Gremlinsateit · 13/09/2022 03:58

StartupRepair · 13/09/2022 03:47

Current governor general has been a complete dud.

Absolutely agree, and the latest news suggests the possibility of corruption too. It’s just staggering to me that Hurley allowed the secret ministries, apparently without seeking advice from a constitutional QC, and “at the same time as” accepting a large financial grant for a charity that isn’t operating.

I think we should be a republic and I voted for a republic, but I also think that the republican movement has done a very poor job, talking in nationalistic catchphrases instead of promoting some thought about what sort of republic we might be. Would we be a republic that respected Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people? One which wanted equality for women? Or was committed to respecting international human rights? I know why the ARM did it, but “a resident for president” just isn’t a compelling reason for change.

Also, how do we avoid a Trump-style president without ending up with one who is a captive of the govt of the day, like Hurley?

Ozgirl75 · 13/09/2022 03:51

God imagine having Kylie Minogue. I think we’re already seen as a bit of a lightweight country, that would just cement our airhead status 😆

Fullupdowntown1a1 · 13/09/2022 03:49

@Hairday kylie minogue? Geoffrey Rush? Nick Cave maybe? Cate Blanchett? Baz Luhrmann could probably do a good job at pomp and ceremony!

I think I may only know show biz types from Australia…sorry

StartupRepair · 13/09/2022 03:47

Current governor general has been a complete dud.

Pyewhacket · 13/09/2022 03:45

That would be for the Australian people to decide.

ReeseWitherfork · 13/09/2022 03:43

Keyansier · 13/09/2022 00:27

I can't stand the Australian accent. How they say "nice" as "noice" for example - it sounds so common to British ears - even when spoken from what is considered the posh Australians. There are so many hot guys out there but open their mouths and an Australian accent falls out and it's an instant turn off!

I assume Australian accents will become synonymous with “attractive and desirable man” once a woman has young children because of the association with Bandit Heeler.

Ozgirl75 · 13/09/2022 03:42

The Governor General does a lot of things so presumably we’d need someone similar to fulfil those roles. So it isn’t a political position, equally it’s much more than just a figurehead.
It probably needs someone whose been involved in charity work, or public service. Can’t be anyone who’s using it to step ahead in a career - it’s nothing like a presidential role really.
Needs to be totally separate from both political parties and not comment on political matters at all.
Or, of course, we could completely change the whole governmental system so we DO have a political President. I see little desire for that model though.

Fullupdowntown1a1 · 13/09/2022 03:36

Keyansier · 13/09/2022 00:27

I can't stand the Australian accent. How they say "nice" as "noice" for example - it sounds so common to British ears - even when spoken from what is considered the posh Australians. There are so many hot guys out there but open their mouths and an Australian accent falls out and it's an instant turn off!

@Keyansier so mean and off topic! I love Australian accents, and not all English accents fill me with joy if I’m honest, but I’m glad everyone doesn’t speak the same.m- how boring would that be! One man’s meat is another man’s poison.

@Hairday absolutely time to break free I’d say, it would be great for Australia to have a head of state that would represent Australia alone around the world. They could be just a figure head, like the monarch but more Aussie. Who do you think Australians might choose?

Chelsette · 13/09/2022 03:32

I'm a dual citizen. As a Brit I like the monarchy, but it's really not much use having a head of state that doesn't live in the country. The King/Queen meets the UK prime minister weekly, opens parliament, attends functions, opens hospitals, is up to date on the national mood and feeling, represents the UK and it's interest to the world etc etc. IS British, understands and loves their country.

It's just not possible for the King to fulfill that function for Australia as doesn't live here and isn't Australian. I question really what purpose they are serving here except for a brief tour every few years.

The Australian prime minister is already fulfilling those roles himself, so I query whether we need anyone additional. Just have the PM here and let Charles get on with being King of the UK.

Culldesack · 13/09/2022 03:30

Keyansier · 13/09/2022 00:27

I can't stand the Australian accent. How they say "nice" as "noice" for example - it sounds so common to British ears - even when spoken from what is considered the posh Australians. There are so many hot guys out there but open their mouths and an Australian accent falls out and it's an instant turn off!

I'm sure the hot Australian guys would be turned off by somebody, who is offended by harmless broadcasting, on the Queen's death.

GlorianaCervixia · 13/09/2022 03:28

I don't want anything like an American presidential system in Australia and I'd vote against any model like it. I like that our governor-general has no political power and (apart from the crisis of 1973) stays out of day-to-day politics.

Culldesack · 13/09/2022 03:27

HeddaGarbled · 13/09/2022 00:11

I’ve seen more republican threads on here in the last 2 days than you can shake a stick at. It’s not wrong to have the discussions but do we really need to have one every fucking 5 minutes so fucking soon? Could you not have waited a week? You know that some people are upset. It’s so unkind.

Hear hear

StartupRepair · 13/09/2022 03:27

I'm Australian. I'm fascinated by the Royal Family and also think we should become a republic. It's hard to function as a mature democracy when your Head of State lives on the other side of the world.
It's a generational thing.
My DC, early 20s have been astonished by the events of this week (our parliament being cancelled, Victorian politicians being resworn in, 24 hour coverage of events in the UK). My mother, in her 90s, thinks it is all right and proper. She was in a card game in 1952 when the King died and they all stopped playing for the afternoon out of respect.
Our PM will look at a republic of he has a second term.
And @Keyansier, how rude.