Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The angels brought you

34 replies

Shelovestosingthatsong · 12/09/2022 23:15

I waited years to have Dd, now 4, she was an ivf baby after many losses and was a miracle really.
When she was a bit younger, she was interested in when she was in my tummy etc, as they are. She asked how I got there and I said that mummy and daddy waited for a long time for her and wished for her and the angels brought her. I was probably speaking emotionally at the time and it seemed a simple, sweet way to explain it.
My Dm and Dh have since acted like I shouldn’t have said it, when she’s sort of asked again, I’ve said when a mummy and daddy love each other, they wish for a baby and if they are lucky, they have one…that sort of thing. She prefers to say the angels brought her and smiles when she says it…is it ok I said that? 🤷🏻‍♀️I’m being made to geek it kind of isn’t…obviously as she gets older it will become more age appropriate etc.
My mum also seems to want to go into more detail about death when Dd brings up her grandad dying (Dh’s dad-she never met him but he tells her about him fairly often) whereas if she asks I keep it simpler and she seems quite happy with the response and moves on to the next thing. Do we really need my dm trying to give more detailed explanations? I actively said to her to please not to and she said along the lines of I’m too soft and need to prelate her for life…yes, but at 4?! Can’t we keep them innocent as long as possible, is there anything wrong with that 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PaperwhiteTheGhost · 13/09/2022 04:59

I generally go with an age appropriate truth policy rather than totally making stuff up.

For example, my niece knows her baby brother came out of mummy's tummy via her "nunny" but she also thinks that mummy and daddy decided to have a baby and so they did.

I don't think you need to outright lie, especially as she'll surely meet pregnant women at some point.

Josette77 · 13/09/2022 04:57

Some of our kids already lost their dad's by 4. I think being honest about death makes it easier when confronted with it.

notanothertakeaway · 13/09/2022 04:21

Shelovestosingthatsong · 13/09/2022 00:05

She also said ‘I wonder how he died’ and I said he got older and sick and she said ‘One day daddy will get older and sick and die’ 😢I mean, what do you say to that? She wasn’t upset, just sort of stating it matter of factly

I would say that some people are ill for a while, some die suddenly, you have a healthy lifestyle because you want to be around for as long as possible and most people are grown ups by the time their parents die

Best to be honest, and age appropriate

PurpleMarie · 13/09/2022 04:16

Posting to get spam off front page.

howoriginal · 13/09/2022 00:36

I don't think there's anything wrong with the angel story, but I personally prefer to be direct with my child and give him age appropriate info on the birds and the bees. He's 7 and gets on the school bus with 15 yr olds so he's going to hear stuff - I'd rather he heard it from me than heard it from an older kid and misunderstand it all. We didn't have IVF but a friend did to conceive her child, so we talked about that with him and about how gay and lesbian couples can have babies using IVF/adoption etc. He found it quite interesting but hasn't mentioned it or asked about it since. We also bought him Adam Kay's kids book about the human body and read that with him, it explains a lot.
With regards to death, I think you have to talk to them about it because at some point in their childhood they are probably going to lose a pet or older family member. I lost my mum at a young age so I've always raised him talking about his 'other nanny' and every now and then he asks questions about her but he doesn't seem to be upset about it all. I think making things like sex and death seem so secretive and taboo to children might make it more scary and strange for them.

Marvellousmadness · 13/09/2022 00:29

Be open about the way she was conceived. Make it normal for her

Saying the angels brought her is rediculous. And saying that if mommys and daddys wish for a baby, that if they are lucky (?) They get a baby???also rediculous

Tell them that normally a baby grows in the womb (or say tummy but I find that weird as i like to call it as is) and that she was conceived in a different way.
Make it normal to her and for her.
You are just going to make it weird for her when she is 12 and found out she came from a tube in a lab.
Dont shelter her. Educate her. Otherise it could backfire later in life

And tell her about death ESPECIALLY now with the Queen and all. You wont take away her innocence by explaining life and death. Death is normal.

Shelovestosingthatsong · 13/09/2022 00:26

Just to clarify, I had said it to Dd as in the angels put her in my tummy etc, not that they’d literally delivered her in a box outside the door 😅

OP posts:
Chickmad · 13/09/2022 00:23

@Shelovestosingthatsong my Dad (who has been gone a year now...hopefully driving the Angels mad with his bad jokes) used to tell me that I was the baby waving my comforter, my Boo-boo, at them when they went to chose a baby at the hospital....I was adopted at 10 days old. In fact he drew me a cartoon book of the whole thing that I thought I had imagined until finding it in my teens.

Then years later he told me that I had been conceived in a moment of passion on a beach on New Year's Eve but that unfortunately my birth mother couldn't keep me. (NYE is summertime in SA where I was born).

Of course whether either of these stories are true...who knows lol....but they worked for me at the time. And I suffered no ill effects. And most importantly they remind me of what an imaginative and caring parent he was now that he has gone and I smile remembering the tales he spun me as a child.

When your DD came to you I bet you believed that the Angels HAD delivered her. They don't need to be religiously accurate Angels. They are your very own special ones!

StillWeRise · 13/09/2022 00:22

many adults don't understand what a metaphor is so I don't think you can expect a 4 yo to

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 13/09/2022 00:21

Or Mrs X, sorry to female consultants!

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 13/09/2022 00:20

I don't think being heaven-sent is that rare a metaphor is it?

As long as she knows that she grew in your tummy from a mixture of you and her daddy (with some help from Mr X and the nurses at the hospital if you want to start adding that) and doesn't think she literally got dropped off by an angel then I don't see there's much harm in it.

saraclara · 13/09/2022 00:17

When mine were that age I just said I pushed them out of my tummy and they came out between my legs.

At two, my eldest asked those questions when her baby sister came along. It was pretty simple to give those same answers and she was perfectly comfortable with them.
I'd like to think that these days we can be ope and matter of fact stright from the off. Toddler science is much preferable to storks and angels imo.

saraclara · 13/09/2022 00:13

Stuff about angels makes me cringe I'm afraid.

My kids knew this stuff early because they kept picking up the age appropriate body books when we went to the library and demanding I read them! It made the whole thing so much easier with a really good book available to them in the same way that their other story and non-fiction books are. (Calre Rayner's Body Book anyone?!)

Stage 1 is for her to know a bit about where babies come from, and at some later point you can go into how she was made in a very special and different way. but she needs to know about the mormal way first.

I'm sure there are now loads of good boooks about bodies and babies these days. Back when mine were little, Clare Rayner's was all we had (and some of my friends looked at me askance when I got them for my eldest at four or five back then). Fortunately three decades later, it's standard stuff.

Luredbyapomegranate · 13/09/2022 00:12

whingewhinge · 12/09/2022 23:51

@Luredbyapomegranate - why do you feel the child needs to know about the IVF?

Because it’s the story of how she came to be, same as if she were adopted/surrogate etc (but happily much less fraught, just cool.)

Luredbyapomegranate · 13/09/2022 00:10

Shelovestosingthatsong · 13/09/2022 00:05

She also said ‘I wonder how he died’ and I said he got older and sick and she said ‘One day daddy will get older and sick and die’ 😢I mean, what do you say to that? She wasn’t upset, just sort of stating it matter of factly

Well she’s right isn’t she?!

So you just say - yes darling but not for years and years till you are grown up And probably have children of your own, to head off any worries.

Testina · 13/09/2022 00:10

Shelovestosingthatsong · 13/09/2022 00:05

She also said ‘I wonder how he died’ and I said he got older and sick and she said ‘One day daddy will get older and sick and die’ 😢I mean, what do you say to that? She wasn’t upset, just sort of stating it matter of factly

You say, “actually most people don’t get sick - they die peacefully at a very old age, much older than you, much older than mummy and daddy, after a long life of fun. When they die we don’t get to see them any more, but we keep them with us by remembering all our lovely memories of them.”
Just meet it head on. She’s 4 and does - so you as an adult can too!

Testina · 13/09/2022 00:07

I think the truth about how our bodies work - at whatever age appropriate level - is far more interesting than random stuff about angels.
Does she still bring it up?
I’d explain it properly, you can always say that having extra help made it feel like angels brought her. (though I’d be dropping the angels but myself)

UndertheCedartree · 13/09/2022 00:06

Shelovestosingthatsong · 13/09/2022 00:01

@UndertheCedartree Yes, this is my worry, I said it when younger and as a sort of emotional response, but I worry about others and her adamantly believing it/saying it to others…how to I gently move it on but not denying that, if that makes sense

Well, I'd probably explain that the angels put her into your tummy and then when she was big enough you gave birth to her. When mine were that age I just said I pushed them out of my tummy and they came out between my legs.

Shelovestosingthatsong · 13/09/2022 00:05

She also said ‘I wonder how he died’ and I said he got older and sick and she said ‘One day daddy will get older and sick and die’ 😢I mean, what do you say to that? She wasn’t upset, just sort of stating it matter of factly

OP posts:
Testina · 13/09/2022 00:03

whingewhinge · 12/09/2022 23:51

@Luredbyapomegranate - why do you feel the child needs to know about the IVF?

Why not? When my IVFer started asking how babies are made, it all got talked about at the same time. This is the “natural” way, but daddy has funny shaped and slow sperm and mummy didn’t have many good quality eggs - so this is how we got some help... it’s fascinating stuff! We used to joke that she was so independent because the first 5 days of her “life” she was just growing away in a dish in a hospital down the road… she loved hearing about it.

Shelovestosingthatsong · 13/09/2022 00:02

@StillWeRise That we go to heaven…to be fair, she hasn’t probed lots about this and this was in the car and I had to think quickly. So hard what to say without scaring/upsetting her

OP posts:
Shelovestosingthatsong · 13/09/2022 00:01

@UndertheCedartree Yes, this is my worry, I said it when younger and as a sort of emotional response, but I worry about others and her adamantly believing it/saying it to others…how to I gently move it on but not denying that, if that makes sense

OP posts:
StillWeRise · 12/09/2022 23:56

Do you have a coherent theology around this OP? Because when you start making stuff up you will quickly hit inconsistencies - I'm sure there are religious people who have a clear line on what angels do and don't do- but if you don't have any actual substance to your storytelling it will quickly fall apart when your DD asks more questions (or hears a different lot of stories about angels) and she will wonder why you are lying to her.
What have you said to her about death? I do hope you didn't talk about falling asleep.

UndertheCedartree · 12/09/2022 23:56

Well, I think it is up to you. But I didn't realise people still said things like that. Does she know you actually gave birth to her or think angels just delivered her to your house? I'd just be worried other DC might laugh at that idea at school and unintentionally upset her. You can tell them the truth in an age appropriate way, it doesn't equal 'the loss of innocence'.

whingewhinge · 12/09/2022 23:51

@Luredbyapomegranate - why do you feel the child needs to know about the IVF?