Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think hotels are awful

115 replies

Hooploop · 12/09/2022 22:44

Me and DP are coming to the end of a two week holiday in Cornwall. We wanted to avoid Airbnbs because of all the housing controversy, and treated ourselves to some 4-5 star hotels that were recommended to us and have great reviews - premium rooms too. But we've been really disappointed by everywhere we've stayed. We always seem to end up getting a dud room witha broken bed, or broken windows, or the one room in the entire hotel next to the busy main road, or above the bar (when the hotel was marketed as being a 'relaxing' retreat!)

Thinking about it, I've never had a positive experience of staying in any hotel. They're always a bit weird and shabby, even the really posh ones. And people coming and going all night is annoying. What do you all think of hotels?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FettleOfKish · 13/09/2022 23:18

AnneLovesGilbert · 12/09/2022 22:46

I love them. Really properly love them.

Same as this poster. I've worked in travel for ever and I LOVE hotels. I watch all the luxury hotel shows on C5 and BBC. DH calls them my porn Blush

I'm fastidious in my research though, and not snobby about star rating (one of my favourites in Majorca is a 3*) so long as they're clean, have some character, and the service / location is good.

Hooploop · 13/09/2022 23:08

Agree with all of that@DahliaDreamer Never again!

OP posts:
Yerroblemom1923 · 13/09/2022 16:15

Having worked in the hospitality industry for a while in my youth I'm a bit wary of hotels and always do the dust test thing on top of mirrors etc. Also the idea of lying in a bed that lots of other people have slept (and more....ew) in makes me feel a bit icky. Mattress protectors and pillow protectors aren't changed regularly, only if necessaryEnvy (not envy)

EbbyEbs · 13/09/2022 15:01

Most are shite but I’ve stayed in some beautiful ones.

The Shard in London
Atlantis in Dubai
Bellagio in Las Vegas
A number of hotels in Thailand

You get what you pay for normally

AgathaX · 13/09/2022 14:59

There are some lovely hotels in the UK but also many, many poor quality ones. I think the Hilton chain must be far and away the worst chain of all.

DontBlameMe79 · 13/09/2022 14:37

HairyMcLarie · 12/09/2022 23:10

I travel for work and have stayed in some of the supposedly best hotels around the world.

All are unreservedly shite. There's always something wrong, not working or irritating and there is always, ALWAYS noise

  • tv channels that don't work
  • now where to plug a phone in near the bed
  • beds that are tucked in so tightly you untuck everything just getting in
  • crap shower pressure
  • missing hairdryers
  • terrible room service food
  • the 5 star hotel in the UK that thought removing coffee making facilities from the room and only offering hand delivered barista made coffees was a great idea. Except they a). Didn't do that service at 6am and b) I don't particularly want coffee delivered to me when I'm in my pants, chilling in bed or just out the shower.

Stupid post of the week award contender here…

SweetFannyAdamsDog · 13/09/2022 11:52

I love hotels too and I really want to know which hotel in Cornwall now! I like the look of Driftwood although I've only eaten there and I loved Hotel Tresanton in St Mawes, gorgeous place. I mostly go for for 5 star hotels though and I've mostly been happy.

I love the valet parking, friendly service, good food, comfortable beds, a mini bar, a glamourous restaurant, I could go on! I try to book suites mostly so we have a sitting area as well.

The best I've stayed in in the UK are Barnsley House in Gloucestershire, although I have a feeling it's only 4 star, it didn't feel like it though. Also like The Soho and The Haymarket in London, although I've gone off Kit Kemp hotels in the past couple of years.

The hotels I really want to try are Claridges, The Savoy and Gleneagles.

BarrelOfOtters · 13/09/2022 11:34

Honestly - unless you want a real pamper - then you can't beat a Premier Inn with a good night guarantee. The couple of times we've ended up with a dud room n a Premier Inn they've sorted us or given us our money back. They are generally quiet if utterly characterless.

I have stayed in lovely B&Bs for a really good stay. Not cheap mind.

But yes, stayed in my fair share of supposedly lovely 5 hotels - and not really up to scratch. Hotels in France that were 3 family hotels have been better.

Apart from the Corinthian in london - which was just so lovely.

zingally · 13/09/2022 11:13

I love hotels! That being said, the quality, even between hotels in the same chain, varies massively.

I think the key to success is seeing the town or city you're in as the destination, rather than the hotel.

TokyoTen · 13/09/2022 11:05

I love hotels - but I always book with a chain like Marriott or Hilton or LUX. A 4 or even 5 star that's independent I wouldn't touch.

beachcitygirl · 13/09/2022 10:46

Im cabin crew & have stayed all over the world in hotels.
In the UK hotes are generally shit. A few notable exceptions unless paying absolutely top dollar for 5*

In general we are just not that good at hospitality/service industry in the uk.

I put it down to the archaic class system & snobbishness. Its all a bit odd.

Notlosinganyweight · 13/09/2022 10:35

Not stayed in many. I usually camp, glamp or go for a SC cottage. I don't think I've stayed in a hotel for about 12 years!

They don't appeal to me, although the idea of having a pool and gym would be nice.

I think the issue is large chains buying up the larger hotels and trying to offer a luxury service on a small budget (one of the 5* hotels in my area was bought by Britania hotels and they have run it into the ground, probably through greed). The smaller ones i think is due to not having the money to invest and having weird expectations from guests, so they dont feel comfortable. You see this a lot with air b&b where the landlords expect the place to be spotless when you leave. They forget you are there for a holiday. Sadly I think it is just greed and over valuing their service a lot of the time, but I do also think it has been hard for them to compete with what is offered abroad too.

User642986540 · 13/09/2022 10:21

Don't really like them so bought a motorhome for touring and have a caravan if we want to stay somewhere a bit longer.

NeedWineNow · 13/09/2022 10:15

If we going away in this country we tend to stick to a Premier Inn or Travelodge as you know what you're getting. That said we've got a favourite family run hotel in Southampton where we always stay the night before we cruise. Yes, it could do with a refresh (which I gather the owners are in the process of at the moment) but it is clean and comfortable, in a good position for the docks and a walk into Southampton, and does a good breakfast!

DahliaDreamer · 13/09/2022 10:02

I hate them. I've stayed in some really really plush ones but I hate that you have to sit in your bedroom (unless you can afford a suite) whenever you want a private space. Plugs are always in the wrong places, towels usually too small, rarely can you open a window, aircon is noisy and difficult to get to the right temperature, air fresheners are horrible but you can't get away from them, never enough coathangers in the wardrobe and then there's the noise of housekeeping trolleys, outside deliveries, lifts, doors slamming, people playing football with a bottle in the corridor at 2am, other people snoring, other peoples' alarm clocks, TVs going on at 5am, late bars 3 floors down... the list goes on. I would never ever spend my own money on a hotel room.

OneTC · 13/09/2022 10:02

BringItBackBruno · 13/09/2022 08:26

My DH does this if a client meal in London has gone on later than expected. If they have an empty room at that time of night you can get amazing deals.

I love a good hotel - but only a good one! These days even 5 stars doesn't guarantee that.

We used to do it on holidays as well. Book a weekend trip and include Monday and Tuesday, book an okay hotel from Friday to Sunday and try walk ins for Monday and Tuesday when the rooms are in low demand. Choose the right hotel and you end up your holiday in some super luxury suite that's cheaper than the budget room you've just moved from

DancingBudgie · 13/09/2022 10:00

I love a decent quality hotel, not so much in the UK, but certainly abroad.
Although I wouldn't want to stay in the Hotel Cecil and I definitely don't fancy a drink of water there.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 13/09/2022 09:52

I used to love the Esplanade in Newquay…

whatwasIgoingtosay · 13/09/2022 09:50

I love hotels, but to avoid the bad ones I have two tips: use Trip advisor - never stay in a hotel with poor ratings AND never stay in a family-run hotel. While some may be great, most try to save money by cutting corners and have no external body overseeing standards. I always go for chains, and like many other PPs am perfectly happy with Travelodge and Premier Inn, where you know exactly what you're getting before you even arrive.

aintnothinbutagstring · 13/09/2022 09:46

Some travelers clearly don't do any research though when they book hotels though - you see bad reviews from families with young children staying in Sachas in Manchester when it's got a longstanding reputation as a party hotel. They do a great breakfast when you have a steaming hangover but you'd not take your kids there.
I've stayed in self catering cottages covered in dog hair or with bathrooms stuck in the 80s - as much as I've stayed in dodgy hotels.
The Zetter in Clerkenwell is nice - quiet and does a good breakfast.

womaninatightspot · 13/09/2022 09:44

Some hotels are fab and have a lovely feel. I like a big, old sprawling country hotel. Crieff hydro is lovely thick walls and properly fitted soft close doors, I’ve never heard another guest when in my room despite lots of excited children in corridors. Turnberry used to be lovely in the main house, extension felt a bit soulless but not been back since it was trumpified.

malmaison is quite nice as a hotel chain as tend to have good beds and interesting buildings.

lots of hotels are rubbish though and I’d default to premier inn/ travelodge for any work travel as you know what you’re getting.

VeronicaVanHoopen · 13/09/2022 09:41

I just don't understand why soft door-closers aren't fitted as standard and why there is always a gap under the door - the noise of inconsiderate people all night in the corridor drives me bonkers. Even really expensive hotels don't always have this sorted.

People increasingly don't give a shit about other people and think their stay in the hotel is the most important one. Holiday in America was the terrible for this recently but also, and maybe more surprisingly, a family ski hotel in Norway a couple of years ago. The noise in the corridors all night was ridiculous.

2Rebecca · 13/09/2022 09:34

I prefer self catering in a house/ cottage. More privacy and space and quiet and can eat when I want and what I want. Also better alcohol for the price. Hotels for 1 or 2 nights

gatehouseoffleet · 13/09/2022 09:28

I much prefer hotels and B&Bs to self-catering options and at least nobody expects you to strip the beds or take your rubbish to the local tip!

There are lots of nice hotels, you just have to choose well.

Premier Inns aren't exciting but they are ok, and do tend to be relatively quiet as well.

The worst thing about hotels is people having the TVs on loudly in the middle of the night. But you can get that in self-catering flats as well.

Appleblum · 13/09/2022 09:26

I don't mind a good b&b but nothing beats a properly good and luxurious hotel when you're on holiday. That said I've definitely stayed at some hotels that were subpar, but on the whole you do get what you pay for.