Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘Single parent’ status misrepresenting reality

284 replies

Rainycitydweller · 12/09/2022 22:29

AIBU to be so infuriated by so called ‘single mums’ who actually co parent their child/children with a responsible ex partner , have more independence and less responsibility than cohabiting parents and a reliable maintenance payment every month but who wear their status when it suits to suggest they are someone how disadvantaged? Not only is it insulting and disrespectful to the invisible on SM etc co-parent, playing up to the connotation they are a bit shit or neglectful, but it also totally undermines actual lone parents (and their children)genuinely struggling to survive parenthood completely unsupported as well as any parents who have responsibility for their kids 24/7 with no weekends off etc ?
I appreciate co-parenting is not easy but it’s totally different to having sole responsibility in every way for your children.

OP posts:
MinervaTerrathorn · 13/09/2022 06:11

This is my sister and I do not begrudge her the term. She has close to sole responsibility a bit over half the time, little responsibility a bit under half the time. It's very different to being in a two parent family and very different to being alone parent. I am a lone parent and use that term. I have sole responsibility all of the time but no stress of coparenting.

Andromachehadabadday · 13/09/2022 06:10

Quincythequince · 13/09/2022 06:04

I get you OP.
I used to get referred to as a single parent.
14 years ago, my husband worked away and I had the sole responsibility for our threee boys from Sunday afternoon to Friday afternoon. For a year (give or take). I had a five year old, a two year old and a baby.

However, I had secure accommodation, enough money not to worry about it, I wasn’t working at the time, and he came home at weekends.

I wasn’t a single parent and could never have come close to understanding the struggles of someone who actually was, and used to actually say this by way of response.

YADNBU.

That’s not even similar. You were with the kids dad.

You weren’t any variation on a single parent so it was incorrect?

Thats not what the op is comparing.

and since you weren’t a single parent of any sort, you have no idea how all variations of single parents, have difficulties. As you said, you haven’t been close to any variation.

HPandTheNeverEndingBedtime · 13/09/2022 06:10

As far as I'm concerned I'm a single parent, I'm single and a mum.

DDs dad sees her one day a week, does no actual parenting or decision making and pays his minimum £178 a month, his one day is more glorified babysitting than anything. Yes, I get a day off a week but I need that for my sanity, to catch up on sleep as I'm the one getting up in the night (at least when she was little), catching up on house work because I'm the only one doing it, catching up on 'me' time as my evenings are spent taxiing DD around to activities, catching up on shopping because theres only me to do no ringing a partner to ask if they can just pop to the shop and pick up some milk or Calpol.

OP you've been a lone parent for half your childrens lived, I've had the above arrangement since she was 2 and before that I did everything myself with no involvement from him. So where do I rank on the lone parent / co-parent/ single parent list???

It is far easier to use the term single parent.

felulageller · 13/09/2022 06:07

Yes I get pissed off at this too.

I was an actual lone/ single parent. Never had contact or a penny of maintenance. But mums that co parent think they've had the same experience as me!

Quincythequince · 13/09/2022 06:04

Rainycitydweller · 12/09/2022 22:29

AIBU to be so infuriated by so called ‘single mums’ who actually co parent their child/children with a responsible ex partner , have more independence and less responsibility than cohabiting parents and a reliable maintenance payment every month but who wear their status when it suits to suggest they are someone how disadvantaged? Not only is it insulting and disrespectful to the invisible on SM etc co-parent, playing up to the connotation they are a bit shit or neglectful, but it also totally undermines actual lone parents (and their children)genuinely struggling to survive parenthood completely unsupported as well as any parents who have responsibility for their kids 24/7 with no weekends off etc ?
I appreciate co-parenting is not easy but it’s totally different to having sole responsibility in every way for your children.

I get you OP.
I used to get referred to as a single parent.
14 years ago, my husband worked away and I had the sole responsibility for our threee boys from Sunday afternoon to Friday afternoon. For a year (give or take). I had a five year old, a two year old and a baby.

However, I had secure accommodation, enough money not to worry about it, I wasn’t working at the time, and he came home at weekends.

I wasn’t a single parent and could never have come close to understanding the struggles of someone who actually was, and used to actually say this by way of response.

YADNBU.

Day20 · 13/09/2022 06:04

Rainycitydweller · 12/09/2022 22:31

Co-parent.

I've co parented ever since me and DS dad split apart from 11 months where he refused to see his child because I wanted him to change from a night job to a day job. He used to collect his Son twice a week at 6pm. (Our Son would sleep the majority of the co parenting time). He also did one Saturday night stay once a month 🙄

I think you should not worry about others situation UNLESS you know the exact details and the full picture.

SpeckofDustUponMySoul · 13/09/2022 05:55

I'm what you might call a 'lone parent', @Rainycitydweller. And, zero family to help.
However, I think people can define themselves however they like.
It might grip your shit, but there's not much you can do about it. You sound resentful and jealous.

Hyacinth2 · 13/09/2022 05:50

I wish people would be more explicit - there are always single parents on tv / radio about lack of finances but there's no explanation of where the other biological parent is. It seems as a society we fully accept one parent disappearing and not contributing.

If instead of accepting this the interviewee said 'due to other parent moving abroad/ not paying support etc'someone in Gov might think of changing the rules to increase payments.

TheOriginalEmu · 13/09/2022 05:50

YABU because every single persons set up is different and what you’re talking about is somehow having to earn the badge of single parent by having it ‘worse’ which is both time consuming and harmful to living a good life.
my ex sees my kids every other weekend, but he doesn’t pay me a penny, doesn’t involve himself in the day to day of dentists and hairdressers and doctors and specialists and school runs etc, none of the grind of parenting. So am I allowed? Are you going to be the arbiter of who is allowed which name

Andromachehadabadday · 13/09/2022 05:36

I think single parent is fine. It’s a household with one single parent in it.

I have been a single parent and a lone parent.

’Co-parent’ doesn’t work because couples also Co-parent.

Quite frankly my life is easier without the EX involved. I don’t agree with the narrative that single parents with the ex involved always have it easier.

Exh had ds 3 nights a week. Ds became anxious about school because exh would drop him late. Uniform, trainers, clothes, toys etc would go missing at my exhs house all the time and he wouldn’t replace them, so it was up to me. There was always problems with his latest girlfriends that upset both my kids. My eldest stopped seeing him early on after he tried to tell her she had to treat his new girlfriends children like brothers and sisters, 6 months after he had split with another woman whose kids were to be considered her brothers and sisters.

He caused the kids all sorts of emotional problems. I had to pay for counselling. There was no Child support payment as he was self employed and his income is officially low.

I still had to pay all my own bills, run the house, organise the kids (even if things were happening on his time), sort Christmas presents, birthday party presents etc but trying to do it with someone who is determined to make it more difficult is soul destroying. The fact that I often got 3 nights a week on my own, mostly which were at the weekend, meant that I spent those 3 days working then catching up on everything I could to make life easier when ds came home.

Since his involvement has reduced to an occasional couple of hours visit, it’s been loads easier. Dd went to uni, with the only input from him being a box of food that was mainly beans. There’s been no dramas, no issues and so much easier that he wasn’t involved. Me and dd have sorted it all between us.

The term lone parent isn’t always accurate. I know people who have no involvement from their ex, but loads of family support. Weekly sleep overs for several nights. Babysitting when they need, free child care, help with the bill. In some cases the lone parents, parents take the place of the absent parent.

The point I am making is that all situations where you parent alone, have situations where it’s easier or harder. Some co parent with and ex and it’s harder than doing it alone. Some do it without their ex but have it fairly easy because of their family. Some people who are entirely alone, find that easier.

Squabbling over what people call themselves because you view them as not having a hard enough life, isn’t helpful to anyone and no one label will encapsulate their own situation, exactly.

Bouledeneige · 13/09/2022 05:22

I was a lone parent from the time my DC were 5 and 7. I got child maintenance but not spousal maintenance and although I got every other weekend off I didn't have any support from grandparents and worked full time. I organised everything for the kids. I wasn't in the same boat as single parents but my DC now say I was one because they know how much I did on my own two feet with no help.

Vikinga · 13/09/2022 04:46

I was more a single parent when I was with my ex than I am now. Because we were together I did everything.

Since we have split, he has them so i get some respite.

However, I would have preferred to have been a lone parent as they're my kids and I miss them when they're not with me. But I think it is better for them to have both parents in their lives.

2 of my friends are widows and I feel for them and their kids.

Tiani4 · 13/09/2022 04:38

I agree with the gist of your point OP

I say I'm a single parent but really I'm a (entirely) lone parent. I'd love a second parent to help make those difficult decisions or to pay me anything to help bring up my DCs, rather than the absent dad we had/ have.

So people who have their DCs 50% shared care or even 70:30 etc aren't in same boat as me.

Louie314 · 13/09/2022 00:33

I think I know what you're getting at OP. Nothing can describe the grinding exhaustion of my life.
I have my kids 24/7, work full time in a demanding job in an enormously male oriented profession, and they have supervised visits with their father an hour's drive away once a fortnight which I am court ordered to support despite this being a permanent situation. If anything were to happen to me my kids would be in care. One of my kids has special needs and I am on the go from 7am until 11:30pm all day every day. It is relentless. I have lived this life for well over 2 years now and am unsure how I can survive the next 6 years of this, and it's certainly not comparable to most of the 'oh it's so hard being a single parent' scenarios you are referring to

MissMaple82 · 13/09/2022 00:25

That should read NOT a single parent *

MissMaple82 · 13/09/2022 00:25

Whst grinds me more are ones who are in a committed relationships and still call themselves single parents - no you are both a single parent! I am a lone parent, I do understand where your coming from but as long as they are single amd getting no support from a partner involved in their family dynamics I take no issue

Boreded · 13/09/2022 00:25

I hate it, you are a parent who is single, totally different (still really hard) from a single parent who is the only carer for the child.

zzzexhaustedzzz · 13/09/2022 00:20

I wouldn’t get bothered about it. Why does it really bother you OP?
I describe myself as a single parent.
Some people might get maintenance from an ex and that’s it. In my view, the money is worth less than real caring engagement with the children and time.
It annoys me a bit when people in caring, supportive parenting relationships flippantly claim to be like single mums. They have never experienced the absolute loneliness that can involve… or if they have (and ok some have) they really need to end their relationships.

Eeksteek · 13/09/2022 00:20

I don’t want it to be a competitive thing. All parenting is hard. Single parenting is really hard. True lone parenting is hard in a way I don’t think anyone who hasn’t done it is even capable of conceiving. It’s the huge, unending, total responsibility for every damn thing, all the time. It’s the little things like having to train your three year old to dial 999 or which neighbours to go to for help if you fall and don’t get up again, just in case, because no one would report you missing or come and check on you. Or having no one to mull over which school to go to, or when to allow your tween to stay home alone. It’s never, ever, ever being off duty. Never being alone. Always having to drive, everywhere, every time (and navigate and dole out snacks etc). Always having to carry the bag and the baby. And only being able to do one thing at a time. No ‘you start dinner and I’ll run their bath’. Or ‘you check the map for a better route round the accident while I drive’ It’s needing to do favours for people, even though you have no spare capacity, so you feel comfortable asking for them when you need them (because you will). Having to accept that people knock you back for small favours, because for them, they are no big deal, but for you it’s a massive issue (how do I drop the car in to have a new clutch fitted, just how?!). It’s having to learn to be good at everything, even things you don’t like or haven’t felt were your thing (car maintenance. Running after wobbly bikes. Wrestling. Surreptitiously inventing a reason to go shopping and mentioning Mother’s Day so your little kid ‘remembers’ and gets you something (and doesn’t feel bad later when they find out). Having to rock up at school plays alone and look like an idiot during the interval with your tea and biscuit. It being able to host friends for dinner, because it’s really, REALLY hard to cook a dinner, fend off a clingy child, get people drinks and chat. Needing a babysitter to do anything at all without them, so even a run isn’t really possible, let alone an evening class or a local community thing. Social life is pretty hard to maintain, too.

Being two people is, unsurprisingly, pretty taxing. And yet people think it isn’t a big deal, and it’s absolutely the same if you are two people some of the week or for years on end. There’s a world of difference. A world.

Speedweed · 13/09/2022 00:17

Totally agree - 'single parent' is outdated and pejorative.

You're a co parent if your ex partner is at all involved, you're a solo parent if there is no one else eg widowed or solo parent by choice.

Lone parent always seems a bit drearily sad, like you've been abandoned, but understand why people use it.

TheFormidableMrsC · 13/09/2022 00:09

I'm a lone parent, ex has chosen to cease contact with DS. Pays £15 a week maintenance as he can get away with it. My lovely friend is also on her own, but does have EOW and gets decent maintenance. I don't see much difference between us. She's still doing the lions share of the work while her ex does a bit of Disney Dadding. He does exactly nothing to support their every day lives and she's absolutely exhausted in the same way I am. It isn't a race to the bottom.

OverTheRubicon · 13/09/2022 00:06

I think that's why it's important to separate lone parenting from single parenting.

Other than that, why would you want to cause even more division in a group that already has it harder than average? There's loads of evidence that women who are single parents - co-parenting or not - take a huge financial hit Vs women in relationships.

Even among 'coparenting' friends, it's rare that it isn't one parent (usually the mum, who has them the most, who ends up sorting the uniform and doctor appointments etc), and also taking the bigger earning hit because of the need to be around for more dropoffs and pickups. CMS, even when it's paid in full, is a pittance Vs what the less-resident or non resident parent is taking home.

And 2 nights 'off' a week isn't exactly a cakewalk when you knew that you split up because he was abusive, or didn't want the hassle of parenting, so you're afraid of what might happen or alternatively that he will use money and guilt to ensure he's the hero. Not many women split up with wonderful men when there are young kids in the picture, so most exes were bad in the day to day, or cheated and left. Most are left financially worse off, and still having to take sole responsibility for the house and financial stability just as you are.

None of it's equal. I have a coparent but there are some huge issues with that, and our families are overseas. My friend is a lone parent but with involved parents who do weekly childcare and help with money. Neither of us is 'winning', it's bloody hard

Save all the anger you want for married women who say 'its like I'm a single mum ' when their husband is away for work, or for a government that doesn't do enough for truly lone parents struggling on solo. But beyond that, think about why you're picking on another struggling group instead of the more privileged.

sandgrown · 13/09/2022 00:01

I knew a single parent whose ex contributed in every way and if she ran out of money or food or needed a babysitter she ran to her parents . She also had a business her parents helped her set up . She posted on Facebook about how hard it was being a single parent with no support!

Eeksteek · 12/09/2022 23:53

HilarityEnsues · 12/09/2022 22:40

@tunnocksreturns2019 I'm also a widow but I don't tend to announce this as people feel the need then to tell you how sorry they are or carry on mentioning it, so I tend to say single parent unless someone asks directly.

It drops an iron girder across the conversation, doesn’t it? It makes everything VERY awkward. Especially if it’s just a casual conversation (or worse a transaction) and you just want to move it along. In those situations I say ‘I’m on my own’ and people can infer what they like.

There is as much difference between a separated parent and a widowed parent as there is between separated parents and cohabiting couples.

If I were unconscious, there is no one who could legitimately leave work early and step in. NO ONE! Sure friends and neighbours would, if it’s convenient, but they can also say no, they’re too tired this evening, sorry. It’s all my responsibility, all of the time, everything. That’s what people with back up won’t get. Even crappy back up will turn out if you’re in ICU. I don’t have that. Social services will have to figure something out in that case (fortunately I have managed to stay upright so far) and that’s what lone parenting means to me.

Money is an issue, too. No benefits for widows after 18 months now (bloody Tory’s) and even if you do earn enough for two, no tax breaks, either. If I earn as much as two people, I’m still taxed on it as one. Any income from my husband’s investments is still taxed as my income - I can’t use his tax free allowance - or if assessed for benefits, it isn’t discounted as maintenance is. You don’t get married persons tax perks. Which is fair enough, as you aren’t married, but they didn’t replace it with anything. Widowed parents have been fucking shafted. Make sure you have good life insurance, is my advice.

Isaidnoalready · 12/09/2022 23:46

People who are "quite lucky?"

Nope not buying this its the same old divisive shite you can't call yourself a single parent unless xyz has been achieved

Bollocks