Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘Single parent’ status misrepresenting reality

284 replies

Rainycitydweller · 12/09/2022 22:29

AIBU to be so infuriated by so called ‘single mums’ who actually co parent their child/children with a responsible ex partner , have more independence and less responsibility than cohabiting parents and a reliable maintenance payment every month but who wear their status when it suits to suggest they are someone how disadvantaged? Not only is it insulting and disrespectful to the invisible on SM etc co-parent, playing up to the connotation they are a bit shit or neglectful, but it also totally undermines actual lone parents (and their children)genuinely struggling to survive parenthood completely unsupported as well as any parents who have responsibility for their kids 24/7 with no weekends off etc ?
I appreciate co-parenting is not easy but it’s totally different to having sole responsibility in every way for your children.

OP posts:
XmasElf10 · 13/09/2022 06:54

Where do you draw the line? My ex takes DD EOW. He doesn’t pay maintenance (but I’m not broke). He doesn’t buy her any vlothes, take her to any appointments, organise any single thing for her. He just has her over on those weekends. Does that make me a semi single semi Co parent? He sure as shit isn’t an equal parenting partner!

SudocremOnEverything · 13/09/2022 06:54

how is it helpful to go around deciding who is a ‘real’ single mother/lone parent and who is not?

If you are a single person and a mother, you fit the criteria - whether you’re rich, poor or whatever; whatever your contact pattern for the children; however small or large (or absent) the maintenance payment is; whether you have an army of supporters or have to do everything yourself; however effectively you are able to parent with/alongside/despite your ex.

There will always be variation in circumstances. Insisting others aren’t proper single parents because they don’t fit a stereotype of a woman abandoned with the children, struggling to eat and with no support, is ridiculous.

Some women who are now single will be in much better situations than some married women. Many will be in worse. insisting women whose exes aren’t useless call themselves coparents instead just increases the prejudice associated with lone/single parent in unhelpful ways.

Pleaseaddcaffine · 13/09/2022 06:52

This is a goady op post tbh.
Lone parent is how I would discribe my friend who has no support form child's dad and she has it hard.
Im a single parent as every single day it's on me, I buy all the clothes, food, school drop offs and pay for wrap around care to work. I get 1 or 2 weekends off a month as he sees his dad.
But I assure you the 70 quid a month I get in maintenance obviously covers the shortfall of having another earner in the house and makes up for the evenings trapped inside as no other adult so can't even go for a run or pop to shops if need milk.
Seriously STOP competitive parenting, everyone has it hard in some ways and society is quite judgy towards single parnets as per Katherine Ryan's earlier comedy stand up shows

Zippedydoo123 · 13/09/2022 06:50

I have only rarely met co parents in 17 years of lone parenting. It is very rare.

Sunnyqueen · 13/09/2022 06:49

I get what you are saying, definitely but there are just too many variables to police. Like if there is no help from the dad but lots of help from family e.g.one night a week at one nans and all weekend at the others, does that make her a single parent or coparenting with relatives?

Where do you draw the line and who gets to decide what that looks like?
Me personally I get 24hrs a week where they go to their dads. There are lots of things I don't like about his set up (I wouldnt call him responsible at all) and 24 hours is long enough. I get absolutely no maintenance and little-to-no help with other things like uniform, clothes and clubs. He makes no parenting decisions, does no life admin or appointments or anything.
So interested to know what would I be?

vroom321 · 13/09/2022 06:48

I understand OP.

It's a huge difference having every weekend or other to yourself. Having someone help with their care.

What about dads in the military?

"shared responsibility for education, health and well-being of children". He wouldn't know his to make a doctors appointment and I don't tell him when I apply for school places. It only affects me and them.

Dd best friend sees her dad Friday night-Monday morning every week. I'm married / in a relationship with my dds father. He sees them every other weekend but often not for 4/5/6 months at a time.

violetcuriosity · 13/09/2022 06:48

But every situation is completely different and it's all such a grey area... you have no idea what peoples situations are and how alone people feel. My situation is that my daughter lives with me and her dad has her every other weekend on a Saturday afternoon and overnight, he also pays a small amount of maintenance. So, on paper, do I co-parent?

My reality is that my ex actually has a serious traumatic brain injury and relies on his parents for care. He is unable to offer any support and we definitely do not co-parent. When DD is with him she has to stay at her GPs with him and finds the whole situation very upsetting.

You just don't know other peoples situations.

Givenuptotally · 13/09/2022 06:47

there are always single parents on tv / radio about lack of finances but there's no explanation of where the other biological parent is

why is it the parent who stayed who should somehow have to explain the absence of the other?

jeaux90 · 13/09/2022 06:46

I always say lone parent now.
No maintenance, raised DD13 completely on my own since she was two.

Pisses me off too when co parents say they are single parents so I've changed my language.

Quincythequince · 13/09/2022 06:46

Andromachehadabadday · 13/09/2022 06:41

Where in the post I quoted did you ever say you had, at any point being a single parent?

You said I wasn’t a single parent and could never have come close to understanding the struggles of someone who actually was,

The you said you have never thought of yourself as a single parent.

But ok, now you clocked what I was saying you are. Ok then.

I was, as is clear in my post, referring to the time when my husband was working away for months in months on end, during. Which other people used to say to me in some way or another ‘you’re just like a single parent’

Of course I wasn’t - I corrected them on that, at that time.

It’s all there in black and white you swivel-eyes fool.

You making absolutely no sense at all, and your posts to me are deluded at best.

TheClitterati · 13/09/2022 06:43

I am a single parent.
Ex is around and I get EOW to myself.

I get zero family support. Zero. No family at all.
I am not in competition with anyone.

Is that ok with you?

Givenuptotally · 13/09/2022 06:42

People are allowed to define their own lives and their own situations. I consider myself a single parent, have been for nearly 15 years now. Ex is reliable with contact and always has been but has never paid maintenance, one of my teens chooses to live with him. It is fraught and unpleasant and we have never co-parented. I have had people along the way tell me I’m not single parent because he’s around.

Like I say, I will define my parenting status how I see fit.

Andromachehadabadday · 13/09/2022 06:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Where in the post I quoted did you ever say you had, at any point being a single parent?

You said I wasn’t a single parent and could never have come close to understanding the struggles of someone who actually was,

The you said you have never thought of yourself as a single parent.

But ok, now you clocked what I was saying you are. Ok then.

womaninatightspot · 13/09/2022 06:38

Eeksteek · 12/09/2022 23:53

It drops an iron girder across the conversation, doesn’t it? It makes everything VERY awkward. Especially if it’s just a casual conversation (or worse a transaction) and you just want to move it along. In those situations I say ‘I’m on my own’ and people can infer what they like.

There is as much difference between a separated parent and a widowed parent as there is between separated parents and cohabiting couples.

If I were unconscious, there is no one who could legitimately leave work early and step in. NO ONE! Sure friends and neighbours would, if it’s convenient, but they can also say no, they’re too tired this evening, sorry. It’s all my responsibility, all of the time, everything. That’s what people with back up won’t get. Even crappy back up will turn out if you’re in ICU. I don’t have that. Social services will have to figure something out in that case (fortunately I have managed to stay upright so far) and that’s what lone parenting means to me.

Money is an issue, too. No benefits for widows after 18 months now (bloody Tory’s) and even if you do earn enough for two, no tax breaks, either. If I earn as much as two people, I’m still taxed on it as one. Any income from my husband’s investments is still taxed as my income - I can’t use his tax free allowance - or if assessed for benefits, it isn’t discounted as maintenance is. You don’t get married persons tax perks. Which is fair enough, as you aren’t married, but they didn’t replace it with anything. Widowed parents have been fucking shafted. Make sure you have good life insurance, is my advice.

In France, I’m sure in other places too, you get taxed as a family unit so children have a 50% adult tax allowance. If you have two children as a single parent you’d effectively have a double tax allowance.

I think it sounds much fairer.

itsgettingweird · 13/09/2022 06:31

I understand what you're saying.

But I don't find it's the term essentially but rather than other single/lone parents not being understanding of each other's situations and being supportive.

I've raised my ds alone since he was 1. He is disabled. I get no maintenance and his dad lived abroad and disappeared when he was young.

I had other single parent friends with totally the opposite situation. 50:50 care. Good maintenance and some even were SAHP due to family finances during the relationship.

I had to pull back when they couldn't understand why a night away in a hotel wasn't possible for me to have a girly night out.

I was plagued with suggestions of getting a babysitter, don't sorry about the weekend being away means I can't food shop, do the washing etc. forget the fact I couldn't afford or even justify a few hundred pounds for a weekend away.

The name doesn't matter. The lack of empathy for someone's situation being different - does.

Sova · 13/09/2022 06:28

So I’m a mum whose ex sees my kids 3 days a week but only after school (not for the night), only while I’m at work and never at the weekends. Also gives me some maintenance but usually £100-200 a month and I can’t contest much despite his fairly reasonable income as he is self
employed. I don’t have support nearby except for some friends and paid babysitter which I rarely use these days due to cost. I work full time. . How would you call me? Am I a co-parent? If so it feels like a pretty crappy co-parenting where I do 80-90 % of everything with hardly any respite. And so I have to explain myself to every person and even is this anyone’s business how I call myself? There will always be people who have it worse or have it better but this is rarely a choice and it’s rarely a privileged situation. Single mums have always been criticised so dividing us feels counterintuitive tbh.

Quincythequince · 13/09/2022 06:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EntertainingandFactual · 13/09/2022 06:23

shared responsibility for education, health and well-being of children and financial and residential security
How lovely that sounds.
You can be a ‘lone parent’ even when the husband/partner/father lives with you all.

Andromachehadabadday · 13/09/2022 06:23

Quincythequince · 13/09/2022 06:15

Did you read my post???

I have clearly said it wasn’t similar at all, and that I used to correct other people when they called me that.

I never thought of myself as a single parent at all.

Your attention to detail is non-existent.

How are you that dense?

You said you were no variation on a single parent. I know, I mentioned that in my post. Or was it too long for you to read.?

You then decide that you know which single parents must have it harder and what people in a position you have never been in, should call themselves. My point was since you weren’t a single parent, you actually have no clue. Many peoples lives are made harder by some involvement from their ex. Some people who have no contact with their ex have lots of family support. All situations are different and no one set up of single parent household is always easier.

But as you weren’t a single parent, you wouldn’t know that.

alilstressed · 13/09/2022 06:20

OP, YANBU, I get it. I was raised in a single/lone parent family with zero financial, emotional and physical support from my father. I'm raising my children within a two parent family but if we were to split up, I would have financial and physical support from their father.
I don't see this thread as a race to the bottom , more like highlighting the nuances of parenting.

JMKid · 13/09/2022 06:20

I class myself as a single parent. Ex sees DC 1 night every other weekend. Apart from that, where his parents actually do most of the things for DC, he does nothing else, no maintenance, never once turned up to parents evening, events, etc.

ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps · 13/09/2022 06:20

I used to work with someone who had a standing arrangement that he got first pick of school holiday time off because he was a single parent... He wasn't the resident parent, he had his son every other weekend and half the school holidays! Baffled me why that gave him priority over parents with more and younger children than him who were still together...

I agree with those saying "lone parent" indicates someone who doesn't have a co-parent and really is doing all the parenting completely alone - single parent just means a parent who isn't in a committed relationship.

Quincythequince · 13/09/2022 06:15

Andromachehadabadday · 13/09/2022 06:10

That’s not even similar. You were with the kids dad.

You weren’t any variation on a single parent so it was incorrect?

Thats not what the op is comparing.

and since you weren’t a single parent of any sort, you have no idea how all variations of single parents, have difficulties. As you said, you haven’t been close to any variation.

Did you read my post???

I have clearly said it wasn’t similar at all, and that I used to correct other people when they called me that.

I never thought of myself as a single parent at all.

Your attention to detail is non-existent.

Quincythequince · 13/09/2022 06:14

shared responsibility for education, health and well-being of children and financial and residential security

But you have no idea that just because their other parent is ‘on the scene’ in some capacity, if this is true or not though do you?

This isn’t true in many cohabiting couples homes FGS. Ever heard of the mental burden of motherhood.

I understood your first post, but tbh, I think you’re being a bit ridiculous now.

And what on earth are privileged circumstances?

StridTheKiller · 13/09/2022 06:12

I'm not a fan of labels full stop. Real lives rarely fit in the perfectly neat square boxes we try to stuff them into, yet we persist to try.