Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘Single parent’ status misrepresenting reality

284 replies

Rainycitydweller · 12/09/2022 22:29

AIBU to be so infuriated by so called ‘single mums’ who actually co parent their child/children with a responsible ex partner , have more independence and less responsibility than cohabiting parents and a reliable maintenance payment every month but who wear their status when it suits to suggest they are someone how disadvantaged? Not only is it insulting and disrespectful to the invisible on SM etc co-parent, playing up to the connotation they are a bit shit or neglectful, but it also totally undermines actual lone parents (and their children)genuinely struggling to survive parenthood completely unsupported as well as any parents who have responsibility for their kids 24/7 with no weekends off etc ?
I appreciate co-parenting is not easy but it’s totally different to having sole responsibility in every way for your children.

OP posts:
Eeksteek · 14/09/2022 11:01

To clarify my point slightly, I have no issue with the use of single parent, at all. If you don’t live with a partner, you’re a single parent, even if you have good support, and it’s hard.

What I am saying is that lone parenting is another level. That you can’t understand it unless you have done it. And what I am seeing confirms that. People who have no ‘apart from’ get it. People who have support want to minimise it, and expect the same from lone parents as single parents, and that’s unfair. It is it not the same. As a rule (and there are overlaps and exceptions) I have fewer resources. Even the smallest ‘apart from’ is something to hold out for. It’s like being rich. Even if you try, you can’t really experience poverty, because you know that this isn’t for ever. That’s the difference. The ‘apart from’ means it’s not for ever. There is, however small, some respite.

I am not saying it’s the hardest thing in the world, it’s not. There are plenty of people who have it harder than me. And I can acknowledge that and feel for those people - declare them worthy of sympathy, validation and help - without comparing them to my own challenges, whether better or worse. There are also of plenty of people better off than me, who still have valid problems. When single parents have problems, I try to help if I can. If I can’t, I try to listen and empathise. I don’t invalidate them by saying ‘plenty of people manage’ or ‘at least your husband didn’t die’ or ‘some people in your situation have more/more disabled children than you, you know’. Despite that sort of thing being repeatedly expressed to me, as a lone parent either directly or (more often) by holding me to same standards and expectations as single parent, and finding me wanting when they are more challenging for me. It’s frustrating to be expected by society to participate at the same level as people with more resources, and to thought weak in character when you don’t.

I also sincerely hope that people who don’t get it because they haven’t experienced it, don’t have it happen to them. I just wish they’d acknowledge that their experience isn’t mine, and they don’t get it

CatchersAndDreams · 14/09/2022 10:28

@SpinningFloppa yup. I'm not a lone parent. My dc spend 98% of their time with me (although in the past they have done eow but they're older now and have their own lives) I get adhoc money for school uniforms or college clothes. They get birthday, Christmas presents and they go for days out. Usually the cinema so he doesn't have to actively engage with them. I do all of the parenting and thinking around them. But I'm not a lone parent. In an emergency he would be there. Lone parents don't have any of that.

georgarina · 14/09/2022 10:21

Beezknees · 14/09/2022 08:40

I'm a lone parent, he does pay maintenance through cms but has no contact with DC. I don't find it insulting. I don't get why it bothers people so much, it's not a race to the bottom.

Totally agree...it makes no sense because they ARE single parents and no one's situation is exactly the same anyway. You don't have to be all alone in a dark room with only a crust of bread to be defined as a single parent.

As for the 'I'm basically a single parent' comments - yes, those are definitely annoying!

But not all parents in relationships have it easier - there are partners who don't help and are like a second child, or even those who are unpleasant/abusive.

Equally, some on this thread seem to be imagining that when the dads are involved they are good-naturedly providing all required maintenance and nights off - when it reality it can be abusive texts, constant arguments, threats, court involvement, not paying, refusing to see the kids on a planned schedule/not showing up, etc etc.

From my experience of both having the dad involved and doing it completely on my own inc no maintenance, doing it on my own has so far been MUCH more pleasant and less stressful.

forinborin · 14/09/2022 10:18

I think a "single parent" is also a very socially loaded term in the UK. I had people telling me that I am not a single parent because I have a degree, a good job and a mortgage, I am just a divorced mother.

CandyLeBonBon · 14/09/2022 10:10

Beezknees · 14/09/2022 08:40

I'm a lone parent, he does pay maintenance through cms but has no contact with DC. I don't find it insulting. I don't get why it bothers people so much, it's not a race to the bottom.

^^this. Same boat. I do everything - always have. Even when he did see them for a Saturday/Sunday eow he never actually parented. Just took them out for trips etc. Any idiot can do that!

Beezknees · 14/09/2022 08:40

I'm a lone parent, he does pay maintenance through cms but has no contact with DC. I don't find it insulting. I don't get why it bothers people so much, it's not a race to the bottom.

SpinningFloppa · 14/09/2022 08:25

CatchersAndDreams · 14/09/2022 08:05

If you're single parenting with an eow weekend ex and cm (no matter how small) you aren't lone parenting and I can see how fustrating it is for lone parents when SP say this as it's hard AF without the - I'm a lone parent apart from. It's also hard when your dc are upset about not having a dad.

If your sharing your dc and they have a shit weekend Disney dad it's also hard AF but it is a different hard to lone parenting. You might wish your ex wasn't in the picture. He may be actively damaging your dc and there isn't a lot you can do about it. It's hard but comparing yourself to a lone parent isn't any different to lone parents then army wives who compare themselves to single parents.

My best friend has a Disney dad ex. She gets frustrated about the dc being spoilt rotten by him. They don't want to go to bed at a reasonable time/eat vegetables etc and say things like - my daddy doesn't make me do this, he lets me stay up till he goes to bed. My daddy loves me more than you do, I want to live with daddy. They say this because their dad gives them everything they want and it takes a few days to go back to normal after their weekend. A horrible position to be in for anyone but it's not lone parenting. It's a different challenge.

I’m so glad someone said this, as a lone parent who hasn’t had one single night to myself in 6 years it’s annoying to read “I only get eow off so I’m basically a lone parent” erm no you’re not! I would give my right arm for regular weekends to myself my dc are also very upset about not having a father involved and it’s really been hard for my dd who feels abandoned imagine your parent wanting nothing to do with you? So whilst a Disney dad might be annoying it’s not the same at all.

OverTheRubicon · 14/09/2022 08:17

@Paigeycakey Since when did CMS become the equivalent of paying for all the school lunches, extra activities and make up for the lack of social life?

46% of UK single mother families are living in poverty, more than twice the rate of 2 parent families -and many more are close to poverty, or might have tipped in with the current cost of living crisis. That's lone parents, but also a lot of 'coparents'.

Yet these threads are always full of women talking about their current partner's or lovely brother's evil/ grasping/ ungrateful ex. I wonder how they'd feel if the situation were switched, or if they actually had the full context.

I'd rather believe that most of these women are underinformed rather than just selfish enough to resent even the proportionally small amount of child support asked by CMS.

CatchersAndDreams · 14/09/2022 08:05

If you're single parenting with an eow weekend ex and cm (no matter how small) you aren't lone parenting and I can see how fustrating it is for lone parents when SP say this as it's hard AF without the - I'm a lone parent apart from. It's also hard when your dc are upset about not having a dad.

If your sharing your dc and they have a shit weekend Disney dad it's also hard AF but it is a different hard to lone parenting. You might wish your ex wasn't in the picture. He may be actively damaging your dc and there isn't a lot you can do about it. It's hard but comparing yourself to a lone parent isn't any different to lone parents then army wives who compare themselves to single parents.

My best friend has a Disney dad ex. She gets frustrated about the dc being spoilt rotten by him. They don't want to go to bed at a reasonable time/eat vegetables etc and say things like - my daddy doesn't make me do this, he lets me stay up till he goes to bed. My daddy loves me more than you do, I want to live with daddy. They say this because their dad gives them everything they want and it takes a few days to go back to normal after their weekend. A horrible position to be in for anyone but it's not lone parenting. It's a different challenge.

CousinKrispy · 14/09/2022 07:12

*if not is dammit

CousinKrispy · 14/09/2022 07:12

What is you have to keep co-parenting with an ex-partner who uses it as a continued opportunity to abuse and manipulate you? Does that count as enviable privilege?

I do agree that language on this could be more precise, and that lone parenting is incredibly tough, you have my sympathy!

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 14/09/2022 07:06

Apologies, I've not read all of the thread, only the first and last pages but has anyone also mentioned that even if it eow and CMS, in many, certainly my case, it's the lack of involvement in day to day parenting, the juggling of work, school run, activities with 2 or 3 DCs and one of you. It's the having to work out on your own how to approach the school about this or that problem , or how to handle a behaviour issue, or pick their secondary school. How to deal with the sibling issues, the teenage hormone twattyness. That's ALL on me and it's exhausting. He judges from afar but doesnt actually offer any help or input, even when directly asked. That's hard. There will be degrees of support in every family, single, coupled, blended. I'm not sure it's remotely helpful to start a competition about trying to grade who has it worst.

Andromachehadabadday · 14/09/2022 06:55

And also Couples who are together ‘co-parent’ so that’s in an inaccurate term as well.

Andromachehadabadday · 14/09/2022 06:54

OverTheRubicon · 14/09/2022 00:28

@Eeksteek I really hate competitive misery, and I completely agree it isn’t fair to put neat labels on people, but conflating actual lone parenting with single parenting of any level really invalidates lone parents.

That's the thing, you can be a single parent without being a lone parent. They're different challenges, but even 3 nights a week (which most certainly don't have) still doesn't save you from knowing that you alone are responsible for the rent, the dishwasher, your pension.

Otherwise it absolutely does become competitive misery. You mention being a lone parent but to one child.
What about someone who has 3 children, and has eow 'off', but spends it feeling sick with worry about what will happen if he loses his temper again? Or who has a 'co parent' who does 3 nights a week, and is paying his CMS, but it's £7 a week because he works sporadically and cash in hand - and uses the rich weeks to treat the kids to Legoland, and never to school shoes? Or one who immediately shacks up with their mistress and soon has 2 new DCs and a stepmum who says there's no space so the older kids now spend their night/s on blow up mattresses in the living room?

In the competitive misery stakes, these 'single parents' and their children are not necessarily better off than lone parents of one or two children without medical issues and with family support, or enough money to buy help.

Generally speaking, parenting in even a two parent family is too much pressure compared with traditional larger family structures. Doing it outside of a couple is another level of hard, and division only plays into the hands of people dying to talk about "welfare queens" and the deserving poor, instead of acknowledging and supporting families and children in tough circumstances.

100% agreeZ

I know a ‘solo’ parent whose own parents are heavily involved and have the kids sleep at their house between 4 and 8 nights every 4 weeks.

Thats more ‘nights off’ than some single parents, whose ex sees them EOW. They also pay for quite a lot for her because they can afford it. Again, more than a lot of people get in CMS.

So the term solo parent would technically be correct. It doesn’t communicate that she is the same as a solo parent who has no support at all. Even in solo parent there’s variations.

A label does not reflect how hard or easy someone has it and all set ups have their upsides and downsides.

Paigeycakey · 14/09/2022 06:49

justusandmoo · 13/09/2022 20:36

Yes you are right. I'd never refer to myself as a single mum as I co-parent with my ExH and it's totally 50/50. I'd always say that I co parent.

My partners ex wife always refers to herself as a single parent even though their dad is very involved and they spend huge amounts of time with us. I find it quite strange and a bit of an insult to the parents who do actually parent completely alone x

Single parent is a term used though. It's not optional it's the correct term despite those that co parent they ARE a single parent. You will be asked on certain forms are you a single parent.....ect.

People on this thread are projecting their own situation even going as far to speak on CMS? Really ladies?

Since when did CMS become the equivalent of paying for all the school lunches, extra activities and make up for the lack of social life?

A big part of raising a child is dependent on your support network it isn't necessarily about the dad's as such. Some grandparents are a huge help. Does this make you not a single parent also?

There's some very narrow minded views and it's shocking even for MN.

Hesma · 14/09/2022 06:38

I parent my kids single handedly 12days/14. Yes they see Dad 2 days a fortnight but I have no other help. My parents live 100 miles away so yes, I consider myself a single parent OP, sorry not sorry if that pisses you off

BigYellowElephant · 14/09/2022 00:36

OverTheRubicon · 14/09/2022 00:28

@Eeksteek I really hate competitive misery, and I completely agree it isn’t fair to put neat labels on people, but conflating actual lone parenting with single parenting of any level really invalidates lone parents.

That's the thing, you can be a single parent without being a lone parent. They're different challenges, but even 3 nights a week (which most certainly don't have) still doesn't save you from knowing that you alone are responsible for the rent, the dishwasher, your pension.

Otherwise it absolutely does become competitive misery. You mention being a lone parent but to one child.
What about someone who has 3 children, and has eow 'off', but spends it feeling sick with worry about what will happen if he loses his temper again? Or who has a 'co parent' who does 3 nights a week, and is paying his CMS, but it's £7 a week because he works sporadically and cash in hand - and uses the rich weeks to treat the kids to Legoland, and never to school shoes? Or one who immediately shacks up with their mistress and soon has 2 new DCs and a stepmum who says there's no space so the older kids now spend their night/s on blow up mattresses in the living room?

In the competitive misery stakes, these 'single parents' and their children are not necessarily better off than lone parents of one or two children without medical issues and with family support, or enough money to buy help.

Generally speaking, parenting in even a two parent family is too much pressure compared with traditional larger family structures. Doing it outside of a couple is another level of hard, and division only plays into the hands of people dying to talk about "welfare queens" and the deserving poor, instead of acknowledging and supporting families and children in tough circumstances.

Agree with all of this

OverTheRubicon · 14/09/2022 00:28

@Eeksteek I really hate competitive misery, and I completely agree it isn’t fair to put neat labels on people, but conflating actual lone parenting with single parenting of any level really invalidates lone parents.

That's the thing, you can be a single parent without being a lone parent. They're different challenges, but even 3 nights a week (which most certainly don't have) still doesn't save you from knowing that you alone are responsible for the rent, the dishwasher, your pension.

Otherwise it absolutely does become competitive misery. You mention being a lone parent but to one child.
What about someone who has 3 children, and has eow 'off', but spends it feeling sick with worry about what will happen if he loses his temper again? Or who has a 'co parent' who does 3 nights a week, and is paying his CMS, but it's £7 a week because he works sporadically and cash in hand - and uses the rich weeks to treat the kids to Legoland, and never to school shoes? Or one who immediately shacks up with their mistress and soon has 2 new DCs and a stepmum who says there's no space so the older kids now spend their night/s on blow up mattresses in the living room?

In the competitive misery stakes, these 'single parents' and their children are not necessarily better off than lone parents of one or two children without medical issues and with family support, or enough money to buy help.

Generally speaking, parenting in even a two parent family is too much pressure compared with traditional larger family structures. Doing it outside of a couple is another level of hard, and division only plays into the hands of people dying to talk about "welfare queens" and the deserving poor, instead of acknowledging and supporting families and children in tough circumstances.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 13/09/2022 21:17

*cms

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 13/09/2022 21:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

That's not co parenting, that's throwing a bit of money at a situation. Usually because they've been caught by cos so have no choice

Givenuptotally · 13/09/2022 21:14

@User354354 no problem. I just couldn’t understand what you were getting at!

User354354 · 13/09/2022 20:49

Givenuptotally · 13/09/2022 19:57

Yes. I this was aimed at you.EOW is roughy 4 nights a months, depending on how many weeks in a month. It's hardly father of the year material is it

why? I think you might mean someone else, I have been a single parent for nearly 15 years.

@Givenuptotally

Gosh I am so so sorry. You quoted someone, I quoted you, thinking you were the original poster.

I was referring to the poster who's DH has his kids EOW and said the mum was claiming to be a single parent.

Once again I am really sorry, completely my mistake for not reading properly!

TitInATrance · 13/09/2022 20:39

Also dislike the term ‘single parent’. I was a solo parent (only living parent). I wasn’t single throughout DC childhood but I was most definitely their only parent, and no XH wasn’t useful.

justusandmoo · 13/09/2022 20:36

Yes you are right. I'd never refer to myself as a single mum as I co-parent with my ExH and it's totally 50/50. I'd always say that I co parent.

My partners ex wife always refers to herself as a single parent even though their dad is very involved and they spend huge amounts of time with us. I find it quite strange and a bit of an insult to the parents who do actually parent completely alone x

MinervaTerrathorn · 13/09/2022 20:27

If a single parent is receiving regular money from the other parent they are surely co-parenting?
Disagree. I receive regular money from tax credits but I am not coparenting with the government.
If the other parent sees their children 5 days a fortnight they are most definitely co-parenting.
Definitely agree there. I don't see EOW or less as coparenting though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread