Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

24 Yr old ss - maintenance

56 replies

ChateauQueen · 12/09/2022 22:21

Name change for post. 24 Yr ss mostly lives with mum - roughly 2 days a week with dh and I. Had a few pt jobs while at uni - none longer than 3 months. Doesn't like working Christmas and holidays. Just been backpacking round Asia for 6 months (funded by money given by us and mum's family) DH has continued to pay maintenance during this time, and has said he will do until dss is settled with a job. We have 3 older kids between us and 2 younger together. We both work and I also look after 2 grandkids 3 days a week for my dd and my other dss. Aibu to think he shouldn't be paying maintenance for a 24 Yr old?!?

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 13/09/2022 04:41

I think this depends on how much money you all have and how much is expected of (all) the children.

Lots of parents fund their children living at home, not charging rent, covering bills and food, many of the same expenses they had when the kids were minors for years after they turn 18. The “failure to launch” brigade are almost all living at home supported by parents. I think it’s admirable if your DH recognises that the burden shouldn’t fall mainly on his ex just because she ended up being the default carer.

But there’s also the question of whether they are enabling SS, harming his chances of a successful adulthood, and putting more resources into him than is reasonable given all the other demands on the families’ purses. The tales of him swanning off on trips does rather sound like it, but from his age it sounds like he probably finished Uni just as Covid hit? Which will have disrupted all sorts of things so I think there’s room for some slack there, if finances allow.

Also, I think one of the benefits that rich families can give their children is the opportunity to find something that they’ll actually enjoy rather than feeling pressured into getting whatever career is available. So, again, if finance not so much of an issue, then it’s not so unreasonable.

Tiani4 · 13/09/2022 04:24

I agree with this
Your husband (and his ex) need to stop this. They are effectively infantilising their 24 year old, keeping him in a childish / dependant / responsibility-free environment. They are stopping him from growing up by rewarding his slacker lifestyle with no-strings-attached funding,

DSS is now 24 years old. Well into adulthood and it's time he behaves like an adult. His mum should be charging him rent and he should have chores to do.

I can see how it would have been easy to continue initially as he was a new adult until he hit 20-21 but without a clear end to it after then, this young man has settled into a slacker lifestyle.

Maintenance should stop now. This adult man should be making his own way in travel if he wants to visit you. Gosh my DCs as teenagers catch train up to London to visit their dad.

Why is DH collecting him for "contact" like he's still a child?! He's not even a uni student and he's a grown ass man choosing not to get a full time job, any job ...

I'd be saying maintenance stops in one months time. The only thing is be buying after then is a loan for bus travel pass for first month to get to work and a couple cheap shirts and cheap trousers for your first job. I got my dS's shirts for £15 for two in asda and a £14 pair of smart work trousers and that was for a temp job whilst he was home from uni, so I have every reason to help him out. He paid for his travel and still does chores when he gets home after leaving at 7am and returning home 6pm. He takes his turn in cooking does his own laundry and carries my shopping etc He hoovers and cleans (just not the toilet Grin) and puts the bins out.

Your DSS can sign on to a recruitment agency and get a data entry job or any job really (many supermarkets are recruiting).

CircleofWillis · 13/09/2022 03:58

The money is mad but the living with mum 5 days and dad 2 days a week is beyond ridiculous.

Why don't you get him to babysit your grandchildren in exchange for the money? That way you have some free time and you and his dad will be getting some value for money.

Boxowine · 13/09/2022 03:32

.

TheTeenageYears · 13/09/2022 01:29

It's fine for DC to move back home after uni and also fine if they have no idea what comes next but I think as long as they have a roof over their head and food to eat plus the very basic of shared toiletries they can fund everything else themselves. In your situation if you don't have room to permanently house then subsidising that minimum at Mum’s seems reasonable almost regardless of if she can afford fully on her own - just on the basis it's a shared child. Both parents need to stop funding anything beyond the absolute basics (no mobile, no toiletry requests, no transport, no nights out, no holidays, no takeaways and no special food requests) to incentivise their DS to work in some way shape or form and move on with their life.

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 13/09/2022 01:18

Pixiedust1234 · 12/09/2022 23:51

Again, what happens if ss never gets a job? What will your dh do then? Keep supporting him dh dies? Then how will ss cope? Or will dh give ss the house and his pensions so you end up with nothing?

Seriously, these questions need to be asked.

Can I be this first to ask your dh to adopt me please? He obviously has money to spare.

This.

Seriously, when does it end?

My aunt funds my cousin’s partying and travelling lifestyle while my cousin (mid thirties) has part-time, sporadic work in the (legal) cannabis industry. My cousin does a lot of “product testing”, shall we say…

My aunt now unfortunately has terminal cancer, and has to stop work very suddenly and unexpectedly. It’s very unclear how her DD will continue to pay rent, let alone keep up the other elements of her lifestyle.

Sometimes cutting the apron strings (and the purse strings!) is a kindness, while you are around to be a safety net if things go seriously amiss.

knackeredagain · 13/09/2022 01:17

Wow.. I don’t believe in just cutting off the oxygen supply on their 18th birthday, but how is he ever going to be independent? At first I thought the mum must be struggling with money and relies on dad to pay ‘board’ but it doesn’t sound like this is the case?

WhereYouLeftIt · 13/09/2022 01:09

Your husband (and his ex) need to stop this. They are effectively infantilising their 24 year old, keeping him in a childish / dependant / responsibility-free environment. They are stopping him from growing up by rewarding his slacker lifestyle with no-strings-attached funding,

I think their enabling of his arrested development is really quite cruel. At what point will he be encouraged (allowed?) to be an adult? 30? 40? On the death of his misguided parents?

Notatallanamechange · 13/09/2022 00:27

Whaaaaaaaaaat?

Kate0902900908 · 13/09/2022 00:23

24 years old and he's paying maintenance to mum? . . . Is this a joke? (I'm being serious is this a joke?)

That is outrageous! He's a grown arse man, when is her going to grow up? Make his own money pay his own way? If dad is paying mum money to keep him? I would give both mum and son 1 months notice it's over! He has to get a job and work for what he wants not let mummy and daddy keep him. In 6 short years he will be 30 years old!?!

Boreded · 13/09/2022 00:22

Yeah that needs to stop. Give a date, 6m or something and then there is ample time to find work

Ponderingwindow · 13/09/2022 00:09

Maybe if Covid had prevented him getting a job after finishing university, I could see continuing maintenance for a bit. I know that was an issue for some graduates. Lockdowns are over and hiring has started in earnest again so I would be be expecting any extended support to be over.

caringcarer · 13/09/2022 00:02

If your DSS can't manage to get a job and deal with his finances it is both the parents fault for indulging him. He sounds just like Prince Harry expecting his father to pay for him and his family too. Many students not only study at University but also work 20 hours a week as well. Your DH is not aiding his son he is setting him up to be a failure in life.

Cats23 · 12/09/2022 23:55

How embarrassing.
His parents have completely enabled their adult child to be this way.
Weird he splits his time between his parents still too.
Your Dh needs to stop paying for him.

Audioslaw · 12/09/2022 23:52

What have I just read. You are enabling this ADULT to be completely shit at life. Pathetic.

I was a parent by this age.

Bloody hell imagine if he gets a gf/wife. Poor her

Pixiedust1234 · 12/09/2022 23:51

Again, what happens if ss never gets a job? What will your dh do then? Keep supporting him dh dies? Then how will ss cope? Or will dh give ss the house and his pensions so you end up with nothing?

Seriously, these questions need to be asked.

Can I be this first to ask your dh to adopt me please? He obviously has money to spare.

ChateauQueen · 12/09/2022 23:45

The travel support was for mental health/covid. But realistally now there is no reason for supporting this . Although Dh is still facilitating travel/picking up DSS from his mums even tho its only 2 miles away on a bus and train route. I can't get my head round it .

OP posts:
Pixiedust1234 · 12/09/2022 23:40

What happens if ss never settles or gets a job? Why would you if you have stupid parents willing to fund your travels?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 12/09/2022 23:38

Maintenance for a 24 yo who could and should be working? Ridiculous! And what 24 yo goes back and forward between parents for “contact” like a child?

ChateauQueen · 12/09/2022 23:32

Yes he doesn't buy toiletries etc that's parents job 🙄 doesn't do any "jobs" in our house eg laundry in the basket, dishes in the dishwasher etc.

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 12/09/2022 22:46

This sounds daft, both parents are letting him waste their money (I’m guessing his Mum pays for things for him as well). Time to grow and start supporting himself.

FuckOffff · 12/09/2022 22:39

Yes its weird, yes he needs to stop.

What on earth would be the incentive for your step son to fund his own lifestyle if he's being bankrolled by mum and dad at 24 years old. He's not in education anymore so that's shameful honestly. He can find a job to pay for his nights out like plenty others do.

Georgeskitchen · 12/09/2022 22:39

Is this a joke? This waster needs to get off his arse and work for a living. Sounds like he's been pandered to all his life
Christ on a bike he's f*ing 24!!!

ChateauQueen · 12/09/2022 22:37

No disabilities. Payment straight to mum. Tbh she is not relying on the money (we all get on) but ss has been spoiled and is quite happy making plans for nights out with friends, weekends away etc etc rather than looking for a job. They just seem to have this sense of importance that they should be supported until THEY decide otherwise, and mum and dad go along with it! Drives me mad!

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 12/09/2022 22:37

Is he going to give all the other DC the same amount? How much are we talking?

He’s an adult man, he needs to get a proper fucking job and support himself. You’re enabling him.