Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s my ILs…. Again. Serious advice needed

159 replies

Lillonely · 12/09/2022 20:20

So you may remember me from my previous threads and my almost farcical situation with my IL. Feel free to search my UN to pull them up, can’t work out how to link them…

but we’ve got another one now…

brief overview DH is British Pakistani, I’m the ‘wrong kind’ of Asian. 3 kids. FIL has 2 ‘wives’ islamically, in legal terms one wife (mil) and one mistress/ side chick or whatever SMIL. Long and short is, never wanted to marry MIL, married her, knocked her up, and dumped her here. Paid her pitance to live on, and made DH when he was 16 financially provide for her and the household. She speaks no English and has made no effort to. There’s a lot of backstory but she’s not as innocent as my synopsis makes her seem and has been very very cruel to me for years. FIL has now refused to pay for MIL, DH can’t as it’s an extra £700 pcm. She now signs on, that in itself was a battle. She has all her faculties. The house was bought cheap at auction (15k in the 90s) is in quite a bad state of repair but is habitable, (for now) I’m sorry there’s probably more detail but it’s in the other threads.

so the issue now is, dh goes around, we had covid so he’s not visited for 2 weeks and she’s just let the house go in to a state of ruin apparently. Bathroom full of black mould. I pressed dh on this as all that can’t happen in 2 weeks from what he’d said he’d not used the loo there for a while, probably months. Christ knows what happened. He said he could smell damp, and went in the front room and the plaster is crumbling away from the wall by the window, damp and he said the floor boards under foot were very creaky, I’m worried that they’ve rotted due to damp. The damp in the front room has been an issue for a while, dh managed to get FIL to send builders around to fix it and she sent them away as she didn’t want FIL to spend on it but wanted DH too, he couldn’t afford it.

but now FIL is saying he can’t afford to keep her anymore, hence the signing on, there’s no chance he’ll pay for any of the work and we can’t afford to, realistically 10k minimum probably more.

ive looked at the La to see if they have grants for this and they do for insulation but not for damp repair.

we can’t afford to keep her, for my mental health I can’t have her move in here, we also don’t have the space and she’s deeply traumatised one of my children in a past incident.

how on earth can we get around this? As mean as she is at points, and as abusive as she’s been to myself and DH, it’s no way to live.

Does anyone have any suggestions?

OP posts:
ConfusedDottComm · 12/09/2022 23:42

Technically you can't claim UC housing help as you are entering the agreement to intentionally take advantage of the benefit system. That's not allowed and can get you turned down. Look into it before saying anything, just to make sure you word things to go in your favour.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/09/2022 23:32

Lillonely · 12/09/2022 23:26

DH said he spoke to CAb about it and the adult social care would help see if she has capacity (she does) and then work to empower her by helping her get to classes and stuff, none of which she’d do, because why would you better yourself.

Is it worth revisiting and seeing if they will assess her again as she’s not engaged in any classes and is living in squalor.
It all sounds so stressful. I think all you can do is make clear that you won’t be supporting her or her living with you if fil dies or house becomes uninhabitable.

Tierne · 12/09/2022 23:28

I really feel for you. This must be very hard 💐

Lillonely · 12/09/2022 23:26

Dixiechickonhols · 12/09/2022 23:14

I know this was discussed on previous thread about possibly contacting SS as she’s a vulnerable adult. Was DH willing to consider it. I think from previous threads you mentioned her low iq/possible learning difficulties and her lack of care of house sounds like she’s not able to care for herself.

DH said he spoke to CAb about it and the adult social care would help see if she has capacity (she does) and then work to empower her by helping her get to classes and stuff, none of which she’d do, because why would you better yourself.

OP posts:
Lillonely · 12/09/2022 23:24

Tierne · 12/09/2022 23:10

To be honest I would actually walk away from your husband if it were me. Sorry but if hes going to keep refusing action on the basis of "its not the done thing" in his culture, but then simultaneously helping this woman out via the community "isnt the done thing" either, then you know how this is going to end for you. It's only going to end one way OP and that's her living with you.

I also find it morally wrong, this whole situation with not bothering to learn the language but signing on, being a home owner via DH but getting UC, etc. This isnt what the system is for. I understand being illiterate but that doesnt mean you cant learn to speak a language.

People are saying she is vulnerable but have I missed something? In what way? Does she have a disability?

I'm sorry OP. There is no good solution for you here. You can tear your hair out finding answers but it seems this woman is determined to be a burden on your DP and on you by proxy. She wont help herself because she doesnt feel it is her job to help herself. And if DP won't take a stand somehow then you arent going to get out of this situation.

I do agree, the welfare state is there for a small cushion if you fall on hard times.

she is vulnerable I’d say, to a degree and some of it is of her own making. She’s never been to school at all, not even primary school, she used to work the land for her ILs aka slave labour as she was never paid. She came here thinking she was coming to live with her husband and then bam, found out that he’s got this whole other life here and she was put on her own… not set up for anything. It’s easier to stay with your own than to integrate, we see it with Brits abroad, and that’s basically what she’s done

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 12/09/2022 23:14

I know this was discussed on previous thread about possibly contacting SS as she’s a vulnerable adult. Was DH willing to consider it. I think from previous threads you mentioned her low iq/possible learning difficulties and her lack of care of house sounds like she’s not able to care for herself.

Tierne · 12/09/2022 23:10

To be honest I would actually walk away from your husband if it were me. Sorry but if hes going to keep refusing action on the basis of "its not the done thing" in his culture, but then simultaneously helping this woman out via the community "isnt the done thing" either, then you know how this is going to end for you. It's only going to end one way OP and that's her living with you.

I also find it morally wrong, this whole situation with not bothering to learn the language but signing on, being a home owner via DH but getting UC, etc. This isnt what the system is for. I understand being illiterate but that doesnt mean you cant learn to speak a language.

People are saying she is vulnerable but have I missed something? In what way? Does she have a disability?

I'm sorry OP. There is no good solution for you here. You can tear your hair out finding answers but it seems this woman is determined to be a burden on your DP and on you by proxy. She wont help herself because she doesnt feel it is her job to help herself. And if DP won't take a stand somehow then you arent going to get out of this situation.

TeaAndBiscuitsAndWine · 12/09/2022 23:08

This sounds awful, op. I fear you are going to have to give her an ultimatum, either she start looking after the house or she moves to a country where she speaks the language and can afford to live on the house proceeds. It sounds like she is wallowing in mould and filth and ot cannot be down to you to deal with this.

Lillonely · 12/09/2022 23:04

Tierne · 12/09/2022 22:57

She hasn't even bothered to learn English? Why not?

I think you should leave her to it.

You talk about the "social stigma" DH would face if he sent her home but listen, at some point something in this situation is going to have to give. So what's it to be?

I do think when you’re illiterate in your native tongue learning another language is difficult, especially when it’s from a different family (Germanic v indo Persian) but beyond that it would require some effort and I actually think being as she is is a very ‘good’ means of manipulating DH.

i do agree with you, something has to give, what will inevitably happen is, she’ll let the house get into such a state it’s not habitable and then expect us to house her. I can see it now

OP posts:
Pixiedust1234 · 12/09/2022 23:02

Speak to citizens advice, shelter or local council. I was going to suggest her faith "church" to see if anybody there could talk to her.

Once you have the options (hopefully more than one), present them to mil to choose. She HAS to choose one. If she absolutely refuses then its time to walk away and get your dh into counselling. Make sure she understands that this is it.

What a crap situation for you all.

Lillonely · 12/09/2022 23:01

Whataretheodds · 12/09/2022 22:49

I remember your last thread - a difficult situation.

Lots of posters suggested getting FIL's Imam involved to remind him of his responsibilties.

If the community isn't going to provide support then their disapproval is irrelevant.

The community care enough to wag their finger at DH but there is this ‘respect’ for elders meaning they can be as abusive they want and get away with it basically; it’s toxic. The community know and have known for years, even when dh was a child and basically neglected, everyone was silent including ‘religious’ leaders (that’s sarcastic air quotes)

OP posts:
Lillonely · 12/09/2022 22:59

RaininSummer · 12/09/2022 22:56

As above it definitely isn't guaranteed and would go to a decision maker. As it has never been commercially let before that will also raise concern. She would only be entitled to the local housing rate for a 1 bedroom place which may not be enough.

The property apparently was let a few years ago according to DH, FIL used to do it, obviously he pocketed the money. It goes from bad to worse.

without the income we definitely couldn’t afford to pay an additional mortgage even a small one

OP posts:
Brigante9 · 12/09/2022 22:58

Seriously, send her on a permanent holiday back to Pakistan. She’s abusive, has refused to engage with anything you’ve done/offered. I read your other thread and she won’t change or suddenly start co-operating.

Tierne · 12/09/2022 22:57

She hasn't even bothered to learn English? Why not?

I think you should leave her to it.

You talk about the "social stigma" DH would face if he sent her home but listen, at some point something in this situation is going to have to give. So what's it to be?

RaininSummer · 12/09/2022 22:56

As above it definitely isn't guaranteed and would go to a decision maker. As it has never been commercially let before that will also raise concern. She would only be entitled to the local housing rate for a 1 bedroom place which may not be enough.

Dreamstosell · 12/09/2022 22:52

You are, I believe, able to rent from a family member as long as it is a genuine rental situation. I think it would not be accepted in your situation as she owns the house presently. To buy it from her and then charge her rent would be seen as a contrived situation in order to get the housing element of UC which she isn’t currently able to claim.

Hopeandlove · 12/09/2022 22:50

She hasn’t learnt the language and doesn’t want to. Has she family in Pakistan? In which case sell the house and buy a flat out there near family. Else sell the house and give her the money. She needs to be empowered but to do that she needs to want to be. No excuse for not keeping your house clean etc adult social care but you must step back totally if you have done this

Whataretheodds · 12/09/2022 22:49

I remember your last thread - a difficult situation.

Lots of posters suggested getting FIL's Imam involved to remind him of his responsibilties.

If the community isn't going to provide support then their disapproval is irrelevant.

inappropriateraspberry · 12/09/2022 22:42

It seems like she's using her culture as an excuse to not do anything and try to keep her son close at hand.
She won't help herself, so why should you help her? Unfortunately I think you need to leave her to it and wash your hands of her. I know it will be hard, but whatever you do will just encourage her to carry on as she has done.

Lillonely · 12/09/2022 22:36

cherrysthename · 12/09/2022 22:33

Wow I stand corrected, then. The system must have changed with the roll-out of UC. When it was housing benefit, your MIL wouldn't even have qualified for it. It's a bit like packing in work, claiming, but taking out a mortgage and having the system pay for it. Then obviously having the assets that being a homeowner brings. If you see what I mean- everyone would've been at it. It's extremely hard to get on the property ladder, after all.

Yeah I do get what you mean, I’m very unfamiliar with the system myself, never claimed anything in my life so this is all new to me

OP posts:
cherrysthename · 12/09/2022 22:33

Wow I stand corrected, then. The system must have changed with the roll-out of UC. When it was housing benefit, your MIL wouldn't even have qualified for it. It's a bit like packing in work, claiming, but taking out a mortgage and having the system pay for it. Then obviously having the assets that being a homeowner brings. If you see what I mean- everyone would've been at it. It's extremely hard to get on the property ladder, after all.

Lillonely · 12/09/2022 22:28

Dixiechickonhols · 12/09/2022 22:22

If I remember previous thread there was a concern DH dad was in poor health and disposing of assets. Did anything come of that?

He has a chronic condition but not one that would claim your life, it’s more of a quality of life thing but he’s using that as a scape goat

OP posts:
Lillonely · 12/09/2022 22:27

cherrysthename · 12/09/2022 22:25

Yeah, that's what I was meaning. It's not allowed because they are related. It doesn't matter what your DH would be spending the money on. If anything, it's even worse if it's spent on ameliorating the property as, as the owner, it would be benefitting him long term. I'm not meaning to piss on your chips regarding the idea, sorry!

ive briefly googled and it says you can still claim the housing cost if it’s from a close relative as long as they don’t live with you? Which he doesn’t… gosh it’s so hard

OP posts:
Lillonely · 12/09/2022 22:26

Beancounter1 · 12/09/2022 22:17

Can you find the resolve to just leave her to it? More importantly, will your DH be able to just leave her to it? Or is he too burdened with guilt to ignore her living conditions and demands?
If she is just left to her own filth, and the house becomes quite literally unfit for human habitation, then he will take a financial hit in that the value of his share will decrease, but it would be worth it for the peace of mind... if he can find it in him to just ignore her situation.

That’s the thing, he can’t and he won’t, for as messed up as it is, it’s his mother at the end of the day. Then there’s the cultural stuff and abuse he would get, it just won’t happen. He has to an extent left it and she’s let the house fall apart more, she’s got no house proudness at all

OP posts:
Iwonder08 · 12/09/2022 22:25

I remember you previous posts!
Based on them and this post there are only 2 options. Your DH gets a grip and threatens your FIL with divorce and financial claim on his entire estate. It requires balls, I am not sure if your DH has it. The second option is for you to disengage completely. Don't participate in the conversations re MIL with your DH, don't listen to financial troubles and completely separate finances.
This woman is too set in her ways to improve her behaviour in any way. There is nothing you can do with her.