Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s my ILs…. Again. Serious advice needed

159 replies

Lillonely · 12/09/2022 20:20

So you may remember me from my previous threads and my almost farcical situation with my IL. Feel free to search my UN to pull them up, can’t work out how to link them…

but we’ve got another one now…

brief overview DH is British Pakistani, I’m the ‘wrong kind’ of Asian. 3 kids. FIL has 2 ‘wives’ islamically, in legal terms one wife (mil) and one mistress/ side chick or whatever SMIL. Long and short is, never wanted to marry MIL, married her, knocked her up, and dumped her here. Paid her pitance to live on, and made DH when he was 16 financially provide for her and the household. She speaks no English and has made no effort to. There’s a lot of backstory but she’s not as innocent as my synopsis makes her seem and has been very very cruel to me for years. FIL has now refused to pay for MIL, DH can’t as it’s an extra £700 pcm. She now signs on, that in itself was a battle. She has all her faculties. The house was bought cheap at auction (15k in the 90s) is in quite a bad state of repair but is habitable, (for now) I’m sorry there’s probably more detail but it’s in the other threads.

so the issue now is, dh goes around, we had covid so he’s not visited for 2 weeks and she’s just let the house go in to a state of ruin apparently. Bathroom full of black mould. I pressed dh on this as all that can’t happen in 2 weeks from what he’d said he’d not used the loo there for a while, probably months. Christ knows what happened. He said he could smell damp, and went in the front room and the plaster is crumbling away from the wall by the window, damp and he said the floor boards under foot were very creaky, I’m worried that they’ve rotted due to damp. The damp in the front room has been an issue for a while, dh managed to get FIL to send builders around to fix it and she sent them away as she didn’t want FIL to spend on it but wanted DH too, he couldn’t afford it.

but now FIL is saying he can’t afford to keep her anymore, hence the signing on, there’s no chance he’ll pay for any of the work and we can’t afford to, realistically 10k minimum probably more.

ive looked at the La to see if they have grants for this and they do for insulation but not for damp repair.

we can’t afford to keep her, for my mental health I can’t have her move in here, we also don’t have the space and she’s deeply traumatised one of my children in a past incident.

how on earth can we get around this? As mean as she is at points, and as abusive as she’s been to myself and DH, it’s no way to live.

Does anyone have any suggestions?

OP posts:
Twinsmummy1812 · 13/09/2022 06:11

if DH signed the house over to her and then contacted social services to say they didn’t think she was coping wouldn’t they have to get involved? She could end up being rehomed somewhere lovely and being taken care of properly?

If your husband won’t consider it because of cultural reasons then I’m afraid he is going to have to start rolling up his sleeves and start maintaining his property himself, he can clean the mould and ensure proper ventilation. Perhaps if his mother sees that he is having to do it himself she will start to have a bit of pride and make an effort herself? He could channel his angst into doing something productive and hopefully move you out of this stalemate?

please do not allow this lady to move in with you, she will make your life a misery.

custardbear · 13/09/2022 06:02

So she basically does literally nothing, no work, housework, repair? What's wrong with sone people!
If she moves back to Pakistan at least she'd have more of a life!

Iflyaway · 13/09/2022 05:47

Like a PP, I also do not understand people who move countries (I grew up in 3 different ones) but don't want to integrate, learn the language, go to school, make friends, work, take an active interest in local and wider community.....

I think it's a psychological thing, deep social anxiety, no confidence etc.

Yet their demands and inability to work on themselves have everyone else spinning on their axis catering to them...

Infuriating and so sorry you and your husband are going through that OP.

Stick to your guns! She has no right to sabotage your life. So don't let her.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 13/09/2022 05:02

ThunderwingDoomslayer · 12/09/2022 21:50

OP if she is a vulnerable adult, why don't you raise a safeguarding concern with the LA for self-neglect. Not maintaining one's property to the point it could be damaging to health comes under that umbrella. Just a thought.

This...

The local authority has a legal duty to assess.

I wonder? Are there any LD with MIL? I'm wondering if aversion to any modern life is covering up her lack of ability (I don't mean just reading and writing.... People can have nornal range intelligence levels and not be able to read and write.)

Lillonely · 13/09/2022 04:51

Ponderingwindow · 13/09/2022 04:45

This is a community that has condoned his mother being uneducated, isolated, abandoned by her husband, and financially abused by said husband. Why on earth does he care about their approval? The rational response would be to pull up stakes, move to a new city, and completely remove this toxicity from his life.

i completely agree, the shame is on them rather than him. I think In many ways he’s still stuck in the FOG of it all, plus the community are his wider family really, so there’s that emotional pull. They also have a bit of a mob mentality and would likely hound him, like in sofa gate

OP posts:
Lillonely · 13/09/2022 04:49

S0upertrooper · 13/09/2022 04:19

This is not an ideal suggestion and I'm not really sure if your FIL is still prepared to pay for repairs, but if he is could he give the money to your DH and DH tells MIL he's paying? He could tell her he had to take a loan, so not able to fund repeated repairs.

I detest people like this, my MIL had similar traits and it ate away at our marriage. Now she's dead, my DH can see the destruction she caused. You might have years of this, maybe you and DH need a few sessions of marriage 'talking' to decide how you tackle his family together?

there’s absolutely no way FIL would pay now, not a chance, unfortunately that ship has sailed

OP posts:
Lillonely · 13/09/2022 04:48

BloodyCamping · 13/09/2022 03:50

i wonder if there’s a community allotment she could join? If that’s where her interests lay previously?

Oh gosh, not if it involves associating with white folks (she’s not the biggest fan) it’s not anything she’s interested in, she doesn’t really have any interests except for religion, gossiping and TV shows

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 13/09/2022 04:45

This is a community that has condoned his mother being uneducated, isolated, abandoned by her husband, and financially abused by said husband. Why on earth does he care about their approval? The rational response would be to pull up stakes, move to a new city, and completely remove this toxicity from his life.

Lillonely · 13/09/2022 04:45

FacebookPhotos · 13/09/2022 01:57

I'm afraid I'd walk away too. I understand DH's fear of disapproval, that MIL has had a terrible life, and that she's his mum. But the only two options I can see are either face the fact that he can't fix it while she is unwilling to help herself, or force your family to accept an abusive MIL living with you. If he isn't willing and able to step back physically and mentally you will end up having to leave to protect your own children.

What does he think the next step is?

He doesn’t know, just let the house and her continue as is? But then what when it all crumbles down, no clue which is why he’s incredibly stressed, can’t see a way out

OP posts:
S0upertrooper · 13/09/2022 04:19

This is not an ideal suggestion and I'm not really sure if your FIL is still prepared to pay for repairs, but if he is could he give the money to your DH and DH tells MIL he's paying? He could tell her he had to take a loan, so not able to fund repeated repairs.

I detest people like this, my MIL had similar traits and it ate away at our marriage. Now she's dead, my DH can see the destruction she caused. You might have years of this, maybe you and DH need a few sessions of marriage 'talking' to decide how you tackle his family together?

BloodyCamping · 13/09/2022 03:50

i wonder if there’s a community allotment she could join? If that’s where her interests lay previously?

Boxowine · 13/09/2022 03:27

.

FacebookPhotos · 13/09/2022 01:57

I'm afraid I'd walk away too. I understand DH's fear of disapproval, that MIL has had a terrible life, and that she's his mum. But the only two options I can see are either face the fact that he can't fix it while she is unwilling to help herself, or force your family to accept an abusive MIL living with you. If he isn't willing and able to step back physically and mentally you will end up having to leave to protect your own children.

What does he think the next step is?

Obki · 13/09/2022 01:19

she is vulnerable I’d say, to a degree and some of it is of her own making. She’s never been to school at all, not even primary school, she used to work the land for her ILs aka slave labour as she was never paid. She came here thinking she was coming to live with her husband and then bam, found out that he’s got this whole other life here and she was put on her own… not set up for anything. It’s easier to stay with your own than to integrate, we see it with Brits abroad, and that’s basically what she’s done

I feel desperately sorry for her. Denied an education, sent to a foreign country to marry an unknown man, forced to slave for her in laws, left on her own whilst her husband has another wife and kids, abandoned with a child to raise alone.

I suspect the poor woman is traumatised. Some women are capable of rising above it all, fighting to learn English, remarrying etc, but it sounds like everything got too much for her and she effectively gave up on life Sad

I don’t doubt that she has been abusive to you, but what a waste of a life. I think this woman would have wanted to work and not be reliant on anyone, but when life deals you so many blows, it’s easy to succumb to the unfairness of it all sometimes.

I don’t know what the solution here is. I wish she would divorce FIL and take him for every penny he has, but that sounds unlikely. Shame on him for perpetuating the abuse heaped on her by parents and inlaws.

Aquamarine1029 · 13/09/2022 00:59

It amazing what someone can learn to do when they have to. Stop pandering to her.

jokingfox · 13/09/2022 00:53

It's hard op but you can't help someone who doesn't want to be helped i.e teaching them to fish instead of giving them fish which isn't helpful to your thread but don't give anymore headspace and remove yourself from the situation.

Lillonely · 13/09/2022 00:30

Kate0902900908 · 13/09/2022 00:17

I would seriously consider her going home?
She can't function on her own in the UK can't speak English, doesn't want to do anything for herself and expects your son to basically care for her entirely it sounds like? I would think she would be happier going home? Does she have family or friends back in Pakistan?

She doesn’t really have anyone there anymore either, maybe a few outstanding relatives, none that would take her in.

thing is, where they’re from, she definitely couldn’t function on her own, fundamentally from a safety point of view, and then bills etc she can’t read urdu or dial a phone, no maths skills, so even though she can speak to people she’d be more cut off. There’s no welfare state there either and land and property is still relatively expensive

OP posts:
Lillonely · 13/09/2022 00:28

The thing is, she made a huge huge deal about not ever wanting to live in our house when we bought it as it’s ‘too far’ away from the community. An entirely intentional decision but in real terms a 30 mins drive away but from how she talks you’d think it was in the outer Hebrides. On a few instances, some not too too long ago he’d offered her to come and stay around but she refused. Think she thinks that’s hurts us, she’a mistaken.

i actually think she’s trying to make the community pile on DH so he provides for her again, and trying to make him feel guilty and get herself in such a state that he has to step in. That’s what I think the intention is here. Maybe I’m a cynic

OP posts:
Boreded · 13/09/2022 00:20

I remember the previous thread. I think it’s time to cut her loose unfortunately

PermanentTemporary · 13/09/2022 00:18

She really is doing what she can to move in with you isn't she?

I think if she is literally willing to destroy a house around her, I wouldn't feel a twinge of guilt about making her a tenant, if your dh can buy her out. She doesn't sound able to make rational decisions.

Like others I do have a feeling of baffled sympathy for her. She's essentially been trafficked and abused so much. I don't think I could be part of a scheme to send her to Pakistan if she resisted it, which I'd imagine she would.

Kate0902900908 · 13/09/2022 00:17

I would seriously consider her going home?
She can't function on her own in the UK can't speak English, doesn't want to do anything for herself and expects your son to basically care for her entirely it sounds like? I would think she would be happier going home? Does she have family or friends back in Pakistan?

StClare101 · 13/09/2022 00:11

I do feel for her in a small way and I’m sure you do too OP or you wouldn’t be posting. She’s completely uneducated and innumerate and closeted within a community that has infantilised her. She was dumped in a strange country by her husband. No one advocated for her, because culture.

But I also agree with others. Your DH needs to stop caring about what the community thinks as they are doing nothing to help! Do you and your DH have a network outside of the community? If you sign over the house to her and walk away you will rebuild your network with new friends.

I honestly think she is beyond help and despite the unfairness of her own life, her emotional manipulation of your husband is disgusting.

If it came to it and she moves in with you, you will need to leave to protect your children… so walk away from this so called community now as a family and get on with your lives.

Lillonely · 13/09/2022 00:02

Cats23 · 12/09/2022 23:45

Tbh, Not ypur problem
She os more than capeable by the sounds of of it and I'd say trying to blackmail your Dp in to paying and sorting it.
I'd be inclined to give her numbers she can use- Citizens Advice ect...and thats it!
Not your problem she keeps refusing.

True of course but she can’t even dial a phone apparently let alone speak English. She was in charge of a bill once, and it got to the point of bailiffs and a court date. She was destroying the letter that came. She’s the type that someone says something daft like if you destroy the letter, they can’t prove you’ve had it, so you don’t have to pay, and she believes it.

OP posts:
marvellousmaple · 12/09/2022 23:58

I'd be tempted to walk away from the house. Sign it over to her. If she gives it away then she and the house become that persons problem. If you can't get her out then they won't be able to either.
After that I would organise and pay for a supermarket delivery once a week. If anyone questions it say you are doing all you can but it would be great if they could help out in some way. They will shut up pdq.

Cats23 · 12/09/2022 23:45

Tbh, Not ypur problem
She os more than capeable by the sounds of of it and I'd say trying to blackmail your Dp in to paying and sorting it.
I'd be inclined to give her numbers she can use- Citizens Advice ect...and thats it!
Not your problem she keeps refusing.