Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be miffed about joint money account contributions??

82 replies

Lisjones · 12/09/2022 19:57

Just moved in with partner. He is the main earner.
My take home is around £1400 a month but some months can be less as I'm self employed; his is around 2500-3000 a month after tax.
Our joint outgoings including mortgage, energy, water etc. are around £1100.

When we moved in, we agreed I'd put £850 in and he'd put £900 but I'm sat here working out my costs now and he's saving a much bigger percentage than me.
WIBU to ask him if I could put around £750 in instead. I feel cheeky asking but Ill struggle to save otherwise.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hydrangeatea · 13/09/2022 13:19

We've always worked on a percentage contribution - I earn 6K a month and he earns 2K a month so I pay 75% and he pays 25%

CornishGem1975 · 13/09/2022 13:16

I am the higher earner but we've always just split 50/50. Worked out our outgoings and split it. I don't see why one person should subsidise the other.

TheNoonBell · 13/09/2022 13:11

We do 30% of our earnings each into the joint account, any excess at the end of the year goes to pay mortgage overpayments, anything above that goes to the holiday kitty.

When it is a percentage it feels fairer.

Izzy24 · 13/09/2022 12:27

luxxlisbon · 13/09/2022 06:33

I still want to know where you live that half your mortgage, bills, and food all come to £550 but your partner is taking home £6k after tax 😂

Me too!😂😂

luxxlisbon · 13/09/2022 06:36

trackerc · 12/09/2022 23:26

So after all the PP giving advice, providing you with an outline of proportions, against the backdrop of you creating the thread to saying you're not happy that you're paying about the same (him extra £50) for the same property that he earns 4times your wage in your partnership & build up personal savings & you hardship. Your update is in light of this you've now had a talk & you've modified payments this month (the month that you naturally in your role always earn less) to now this month you both will pay exactly the same contribution. So he's £50 up & you're down again from when you started this thread.
And it's all hunky dory now.
I'm baffled.

Why are you baffled? They both own half the property, they aren’t married and they would both get 50/50 if they split. Why is it fairer for him to pay more when the mortgage is still easily affordable for OP?

luxxlisbon · 13/09/2022 06:33

I still want to know where you live that half your mortgage, bills, and food all come to £550 but your partner is taking home £6k after tax 😂

TeaMoreToast · 12/09/2022 23:47

OK, so your DP has suggested putting in more than the £550 it takes to cover bills. The extra is to contribute towards future holidays.

You no longer feel you can afford to pay the extra.

So have a conversation with him, say you'll put in £550 to cover mortgage and bills.

When it comes to booking holidays, you'll see what you have saved (and want to spend) and base holiday choice on that. If he wants to go on a super expensive holiday, you can't afford that on your current earnings so it's up to him if he wants to pay extra to give you both an expensive holiday. If he doesn't want to pay extra but moans about having to take a cheaper holiday, that tells its own story.

trackerc · 12/09/2022 23:26

So after all the PP giving advice, providing you with an outline of proportions, against the backdrop of you creating the thread to saying you're not happy that you're paying about the same (him extra £50) for the same property that he earns 4times your wage in your partnership & build up personal savings & you hardship. Your update is in light of this you've now had a talk & you've modified payments this month (the month that you naturally in your role always earn less) to now this month you both will pay exactly the same contribution. So he's £50 up & you're down again from when you started this thread.
And it's all hunky dory now.
I'm baffled.

Lisjones · 12/09/2022 23:11

@Loki64 but I can afford the house and the bills? Half is £550ish each. I'm just saying that I'd rather keep my savings for other things like holidays in separate bank accounts so I can keep track of my money.
Anyway, I spoke to him tonight and for this month we're putting the exact in and then next month will put a bit extra in each month for emergencies. He was fine about it all and I feel so much better now I've expressed my worries to him. Thanks everyone x

OP posts:
Loki64 · 12/09/2022 22:39

Im going against the grain here.
I personally wouldnt ever feel comfortable not paying half my share of the house. It confuses me why its assumed because someone has a better paid job that they should pay more and why it shouldnt be equal for a house u both live in.
I wouldnt agree to live in a house i couldn't afford my half of and wouldnt expect my partner to pay more because i agreed to a house i couldnt afford.

TwinkleChristmas · 12/09/2022 22:28

If he’s earning 5-6k a month and you earn a lot less then he shouldn’t be expecting you to put in so much.

LarchDragon · 12/09/2022 22:27

Unless your lower income is due to caring responsibilities ( either now or in the past affecting your earning potential), or because you've jointly agreed for you to take a back seat in our career in order to take on more of the load at home, then you split the bills 50:50, surely? You can earn much more than £1400/m as a full time teacher.

What about just because you don't have a "career"? You just have a low-paid job? Splitting the bills 50/50 when that 50% could take 30% of one partners wage and 90% of the others doesn't really seem fair. So you just have one partner who is skint all the time?

Lisjones · 12/09/2022 22:16

I'm really sorry I've confused everyone, was not my intention!

OP posts:
Hotandbothereds · 12/09/2022 22:15

1FootInTheRave · 12/09/2022 21:51

You're part time?

Why should he subsidise your lifestyle choice?

She’s not asking him to, she just doesn’t want to put in extra for savings right now.

Although tbh no wonder the Op is having a hard time communicating this to her DP as she’s making the entire story incredibly convoluted!

Hotandbothereds · 12/09/2022 22:12

Aprilx · 12/09/2022 22:10

Not really. You say the mortgage is £550 and you put £850 into the pot. The other £300 a month surely is mainly swallowed up by the bills.

No, £550 is half the £1,100 mortgage & bills total, the extra £300 was savings for holidays.

Hotandbothereds · 12/09/2022 22:11

Lisjones · 12/09/2022 22:00

I do really feel like some posters are missing the point - I'm not asking him to pay my share of the house; I can afford half of our mortgage and bills; I just don't want to put extra in as the Extra is a lot of money to me;

I'm a supply teacher, I usually work full time but September is a slow month so I've taken on a role which pays me £450ish a week for now until things pick up and I'm back to £700ish a week.

People are missing the point because your information has been all over the place tbh!

Just tell him this, it’s perfectly acceptable, you’re still covering your side of the bills and saving for holidays isn’t something you can afford to do right now.

Aprilx · 12/09/2022 22:10

Lisjones · 12/09/2022 22:00

I do really feel like some posters are missing the point - I'm not asking him to pay my share of the house; I can afford half of our mortgage and bills; I just don't want to put extra in as the Extra is a lot of money to me;

I'm a supply teacher, I usually work full time but September is a slow month so I've taken on a role which pays me £450ish a week for now until things pick up and I'm back to £700ish a week.

Not really. You say the mortgage is £550 and you put £850 into the pot. The other £300 a month surely is mainly swallowed up by the bills.

Loachworks · 12/09/2022 22:06

NRTFT. You still live really cheaply considering what most people's monthly outgoings are. Will you still expect 50% of the house if you split? From your posts I have read there's no reason why you couldn't earn elsewhere or that you work PT because you have joint children so I think it's reasonable to split expenses equally in your case.

wellhelloitsme · 12/09/2022 22:06

I do really feel like some posters are missing the point - I'm not asking him to pay my share of the house; I can afford half of our mortgage and bills; I just don't want to put extra in as the Extra is a lot of money to me

That's all in your power though, so just tell him that?

Callingallbutterflies · 12/09/2022 22:06

Pay the £550.00 only. Sit down, talk through your incomes and point out the situation you are in. Have your own savings and see if you can afford a holiday when the time comes.

wellhelloitsme · 12/09/2022 22:06

Lisjones · 12/09/2022 21:35

I think some people have missed the point - I can afford half the mortgage and bills at £550 a month but I'm on about the extra money to put in towards holiday

Do you not feel able to just say to him "obviously I'll still pay my half of the house and bills but I can't put any more money into a holiday fund until work picks up again I'm afraid"?

If not, or if you think he'd have an issue with that, then this isn't a healthy relationship.

luxxlisbon · 12/09/2022 22:05

I don’t understand what the problem is then, if you can afford the bills and mortgage and you don’t want him to increase his share to cover it what is the issue?
Surely you just say “I’m not saving any money for a holiday while I’m working less”. Why aren’t you saying/doing that?

Lisjones · 12/09/2022 22:00

I do really feel like some posters are missing the point - I'm not asking him to pay my share of the house; I can afford half of our mortgage and bills; I just don't want to put extra in as the Extra is a lot of money to me;

I'm a supply teacher, I usually work full time but September is a slow month so I've taken on a role which pays me £450ish a week for now until things pick up and I'm back to £700ish a week.

OP posts:
sjxoxo · 12/09/2022 22:00

Flumpymc · 12/09/2022 20:10

Wow. He earns 4 times more than you and you are basically paying equal? What a guy. I'd be reconsidering the relationship not just my financial contribution.

Sorry it didn’t post the quote I was referring to! Deffo sounds unfair to me and he would need to be generous for me to consider him long term.. x

sjxoxo · 12/09/2022 21:58

This! Are you thinking of marrying him.. does he realise that if you did get married this is unsustainable and it would be all shared? Tread carefully xo