Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Argument situation with husband

259 replies

IHateArguments · 12/09/2022 18:41

I'm so ashamed of being upset about this that I've made a new u/n!

Lately my husband has been quite irritable and short fused. Flying off the handle about quite minor things, shouting and just generally losing his temper and saying quite mean things. Only with me (never with the kids) or about things or people.

I'm anti-confrontational to epic and annoying levels. I don't mind non-emotive confrontation, but I hate people being angry and upset. So I've found myself avoiding telling him things which I know will set him off.

I had a change of work plans for today due to the funeral bank holiday and I knew when I found out (Friday) that we'd have to rearrange childcare plans, because I'd be later home than I'd expected. And I caught myself that I was actually afraid to tell him, because I knew he'd fly off the handle.

I did tell him, but not as soon as I should have (Saturday afternoon). He completely flew off the handle and shouted at me for about an hour, swearing at me, saying stuff like he can't rely on me to sort out anything, I don't give a shit about anyone, I'm only interested in getting on at work.

I felt really - if I say not safe, I mean emotionally not safe in the situation, not that I actually felt threatened. Later I called a friend and had a bit of a cry, because some of the things he said hurt a bit. He obviously realised this, because he got angry with me over that.

Later he said sorry (but it was my fault) and he didn't mean those things, he just lost his temper. I still don't think it's okay and I wouldn't just say "yes, it's all fine", so he's now angry because I obviously don't give a damn about making things right.

It's not a LTB situation, or anything like that! But I can't just forget it and I don't know what to do. Maybe I am being unreasonable - holding a grudge and I should just drop it. But I don't like someone shouting and swearing in my face and saying unkind things, only to say "I didn't mean it" later. If you don't mean it, don't say it!

BTW, the childcare issue was solved. My youngest had a playdate and school agreed that the others could stay at after school club till 6.30.

OP posts:
Thurlow · 12/09/2022 21:07

I know you were looking for more constructive advice but… That’s not normal. In any way.

Having arguments is normal. Going through times when you don’t like each other as much is pretty normal. But the behaviour you are describing is a million miles from normal or healthy and no one should have to put up with this.

Cw112 · 12/09/2022 21:05

Op shouting at you, swearing at you and blaming things on you that you have no control over for an hour is way beyond normal couples arguing. I personally feel that's emotionally abusive. Then getting angry because you haven't swallowed your feelings and hurt from HIS actions and choices fast enough is bullying and manipulative. I'd sit him down and be really straight with him and say how it makes you feel and it needs to change or you won't be able to remain in the relationship and while you understandhe might be stressed, it's HIS responsibility to manage that stress and his behaviour accordingly. You're his wife and equal not his verbal punchbag when he's had a bag day or things don't go his way. I'd say to him that you feel afraid to bring things up because of his reactions. And he may not shout at your kids directly but it is just as harmful for them to grow up seeing one parent berating the other for an hour or on the regular and putting them down or speaking to them disrespectfully. I'd make arrangements to leave so you have the option if you decided to use it but this is on him not on you. The fact you're blaming yourself for his behaviour shows that you've got too used to hearing it. You would be well within your rights to walk away here and I'd be getting my ducks in a row. If you are financially dependent on him, from what you've said here you would qualify for support from womens aid. His behaviour is abusive unacceptable and it starts and ends with him.

k1233 · 12/09/2022 21:03

Personally I'd never tolerate being screamed at. It is an be absolutely awful environment for children - i grew up in it, so you know, it terrifies me. He will eventually start screaming at your kids for minor infractions and you'll all be on eggshells.

I know you don't want to LTB but it creates life long issues for your children to be in that environment.

ThirtyThreeTrees · 12/09/2022 21:02

He has taken your voice from you - you can't discuss it for fear of his reaction.

He has taken your sense of security & safety from you - you are threading on eggshells

He has taken your confidence from you - you feel you can't stand up for yourself without retaliation

He has taken your spirit and happiness away - you are sad and lonely

He is also making you doubt yourself - you think you are playing a part, you are second guessing yourself, somewhat in denial.

There's a hell of a difference where there is a once off argument than this. This is sustained,persistent and has become your normal.

The fact you aren't comfortable addressing it with him,means it is too much. It's abusive.

LibbyOTV · 12/09/2022 21:01

You're not being unreasonable. Let me repeat that. You are NOT being unreasonable.

He needs to deal with this anger situation. It's not ok. Quite simply.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 12/09/2022 20:57

He shouted at you for an hour because you told him on Saturday work plans had changed?

And there are some excusing this?!

I'm so glad you have a friend to confide it. I think you need to outright ask her what her true feelings are about the situation you have described here. I think you'll find that she's more than happy to help you get out of this situation.

And you know what? Maybe he is unwell. But it's not your role or responsibility to be his emotional punching bag. If he's unwell, he needs to engage with professionals and get well. Maybe he doesn't seen how bad he's got. But again, it's not your job to just put up with that.

Personally, I think this relationship is dead unless he has a major personality overhaul. And I think he should do this alone because I don't think you sound safe @IHateArguments. Only once he can control himself and can acknowledge and apologise for past behaviour can your relationship begin to heal.

beastlyslumber · 12/09/2022 20:53

Unfortunately your children cannot be immune to what is happening and how he behaves.

Your home is a truly awful environment to grow up in.

You have two choices.
You address honestly that you are a victim of domestic abuse and tell your husband he addresses his behaviour or leaves.

Or you remain a victim and rear your children to be victims too.

It's this, OP.

Aquamarine1029 · 12/09/2022 20:53

It is completely unacceptable that your children are being forced to live in this environment. I feel so sorry for them.

NettleTea · 12/09/2022 20:45

OP
take a look through here and see if anything rings a bell

You say he is mentally unwell or stressed, but does he shout at strangers in the street, at his boss, at his mum or his friends if they do or say something he doesnt like?

Can you pinpoint when it changed? was it after the child was born? Or after you went back to work and he was expected to do more because you picked up the slack during maternity, hence he resents your work and independance as he'd hoped you would carry on doing all the housework and kidwork as well as bring in an income? These are the two main starting flashpoints.

billy1966 · 12/09/2022 20:39

OP,
This is neither normal nor healthy.

He is now regularly emotionally abusing you and you are tired, sad and worn out by it.

Why wouldn't you be?
It must be truly awful.

Why would you quickly get over someone grinding you down like that?

It is awful.

Unfortunately your children cannot be immune to what is happening and how he behaves.

Your home is a truly awful environment to grow up in.

You have two choices.
You address honestly that you are a victim of domestic abuse and tell your husband he addresses his behaviour or leaves.

Or you remain a victim and rear your children to be victims too.

Call Womens aid for a chat.
Your children may well confide in someone as time goes on.

I appreciate this is a very difficult situation for you, but you have to hang on to the fact that he thinks it is acceptable to treat you like his emotional punching bag.

The only person who can stop this is you.

You and your children deserve better.

Suzi888 · 12/09/2022 20:34

He shouted at you for over an hour? I mean, if you had admitted to an affair, theft, something truly awful then ok…. But he sounds unhinged.

I’d record him next time- and there will be a next time. I’d see a solicitor too.

vipersnest1 · 12/09/2022 20:34

@IHateArguments, just how far are you prepared to let it go?
I realised, several years after XH and I separated, that I was afraid of making any man angry with me (I had a situation arise one day and I suddenly realised that was how I felt - it was horrible).
I'm several years on from divorce now, and I still can't trust that I can put that awful feeling behind me, so I've stayed away from meeting someone, as much as it would be lovely to have someone who values me and wants to take care of me. I just don't feel I can take the risk of being hurt so deeply again. Sad
You might not think that's not where you are and I sincerely hope not, but I would urge you to search your heart and have a good think about it.
Maybe the way forward is counselling for you both, but if he's already manipulating you so that you keep things like that to yourself, it might be too late already.

Travellingwomble · 12/09/2022 20:30

IHateArguments · 12/09/2022 20:15

Thank you for this.

I genuinely don't feel "in danger". I feel sort of emotionally not safe, because I feel like I'm under emotional attack (if that makes any sense). But while that makes me unhappy, it doesn't make me fear for my safety.

And I would like to work things out, or at least try to. Perhaps I am being unrealistic and minimising. But I just feel like something is wrong, and while that doesn't make any of this okay, I'd at least like to try to figure out what is wrong and look at whether it can be put right.

At the very very least and I mean VERY !!! he has NO respect for you. If you don't speak up now and defend yourself with limitations and consequences of his behaviour toward you , this will only escalate. I don't necessarily mean to violence, although it is possible if he struggling to hold his temper in check, but verbal abuse can be incredibly harmful too.

FinallyHere · 12/09/2022 20:29

Maybe I made it sound worse than it is.

My reading is that you are minimising how terrible it is. As abused people so often do. This is really no ok

The amount of someone shouting at you which is acceptable in a relationship is zero. You should not be feeling on tenterhooks around him, especially if you have 'bad news'. He should have your back, not blame you for things beyond your control. And then refuse to discuss a way forward.

It is disappointing when someone who was a good 'un changed behaviour. By all means have a conversation. Please keep at the back of your mind, though that his behaviour is not ok and that if it doesn't change, you need to consider your options, not just try and work around him.

Working round someone screaming is ok for a baby, even a toddler. It's not ok in a husband or any adult.

I'm very sorry.

FlissyPaps · 12/09/2022 20:26

IHateArguments · 12/09/2022 20:15

Thank you for this.

I genuinely don't feel "in danger". I feel sort of emotionally not safe, because I feel like I'm under emotional attack (if that makes any sense). But while that makes me unhappy, it doesn't make me fear for my safety.

And I would like to work things out, or at least try to. Perhaps I am being unrealistic and minimising. But I just feel like something is wrong, and while that doesn't make any of this okay, I'd at least like to try to figure out what is wrong and look at whether it can be put right.

Oh OP, please trust your gut. When you feel like something is wrong, it most likely is. An emotional attack is just as harmful and abusive as a physical attack.

Please do not minimise or excuse his behaviour. You have children. It is not okay for them to be around this toxic environment. Even if his anger is not directed at the children they will hear it. They will sense it. They will know something isn’t right.

If he can treat you like this then he isn’t a good parent. Period.

You say you want to work things out. Okay, so have you asked him what is wrong? Do you communicate with him about this?

If the answer is yes and you get show down or shouted at then I’m sorry but there will be no getting through to him.

If the answer is no, are you able to get a mediator? A trusted friend or family member to come round and be present in the house? Then ask him them. See if he is big and brave another to abuse you infront of someone else.

Couples therapy? Would you be willing to try? If so, would he also be willing to try?

Travellingwomble · 12/09/2022 20:22

ThirtyThreeTrees · 12/09/2022 19:55

This is from an Irish website but I'm sure someone can find a uk equivalent.

It's a list of warning signs that you are in an abusive relationship.

You have described the first 4

www.womensaid.ie/help/warningsigns.html?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIsZf5gPaP-gIViL7tCh02ugHAEAMYASAAEgKRvPD_BwE

Please check it out. You are minimising and excusing his behaviour

This is an excellent link. Thank you for posting this. If anyone is watching bad sisters, it is a tv drama version but spot on in regard to the doubt these types.of men instill in their partners.

FlissyPaps · 12/09/2022 20:20

Boreded · 12/09/2022 20:04

If everyone who got a LTB response actually did, I swear we would have just 4 people left in the country that were still married.

men and women can both be arseholes…but both can also react in an unreasonable manner, the question is what they do next. If his rage is an issue he needs to confront the source, counselling, medication, job change, etc…other things need to be considered.

op has stated she doesn’t feel it’s a LTB situation, so unless people think she is in danger, it’s not necessary to bang on about leaving him. That being said @IHateArguments you do need to carve out some time to actually have a frank discussion with him on what is and isn’t ok, because if it continues then you should
consider whether or not to stick it out or to seek better for yourself.

Oh come off it there wouldn’t be 4 married people still left married. What a bizzare comment.

A lot of women who are being emotionally abused don’t feel like they are in “LTB” situations. But this is because they’ve been gaslit, coerced and conditioned to think their husband/partners behaviour is normal and acceptable.

The OP’s H’s behaviour, from what we’ve read is neither normal nor acceptable. It’s nowhere close to that.

We can bang on about leaving him all we like thank you. There is clearly a sad and low woman and innocent children at the hand of this vile man. It isn’t okay.

I, and as well as many others do think she is in danger. This clearly isn’t a one off. This type of behaviour only escalates.

FinallyHere · 12/09/2022 20:17

It's not a LTB situation

I'm very sorry, I think it really might be.

Do you want to subject yourself to this for the rest of your life. I hope you find the strength to arrange a better environment for yourself. And your DC.

IHateArguments · 12/09/2022 20:15

Boreded · 12/09/2022 20:04

If everyone who got a LTB response actually did, I swear we would have just 4 people left in the country that were still married.

men and women can both be arseholes…but both can also react in an unreasonable manner, the question is what they do next. If his rage is an issue he needs to confront the source, counselling, medication, job change, etc…other things need to be considered.

op has stated she doesn’t feel it’s a LTB situation, so unless people think she is in danger, it’s not necessary to bang on about leaving him. That being said @IHateArguments you do need to carve out some time to actually have a frank discussion with him on what is and isn’t ok, because if it continues then you should
consider whether or not to stick it out or to seek better for yourself.

Thank you for this.

I genuinely don't feel "in danger". I feel sort of emotionally not safe, because I feel like I'm under emotional attack (if that makes any sense). But while that makes me unhappy, it doesn't make me fear for my safety.

And I would like to work things out, or at least try to. Perhaps I am being unrealistic and minimising. But I just feel like something is wrong, and while that doesn't make any of this okay, I'd at least like to try to figure out what is wrong and look at whether it can be put right.

OP posts:
sleepymum50 · 12/09/2022 20:14

I have been intimated by my H for a long time. I decided a while ago it was easier to keep quiet rather than face his sudden anger over stuff that seemed to come from nowhere, or if I ever pushed back.

We are both retired and I mentioned about perhaps sharing the cooking. I do it all. He started doing the dishwasher off his own bat and I took that as his answer ref cooking.

He has been putting stuff in the wrong places, it varies so when I’m cooking I’m opening and closing drawers looking for things. I haven’t felt able to tell him this because at best it will be ignored or he’ll get really arsey with me. Obviously this is just one example of very very many. But it meant second guessing myself everytime I wanted to open my mouth.

This is no way to have a marriage. I was so unhappy I went to therapy. I was told that he treats me like a child. More accurately he behaves like an authoritarian father that will permit no lack of respect to his senior position.

This is not a marriage of equals. I am divorcing him.

Even if you don’t think this is a LTB, it may well be in five years time. The resentment at having your voice silenced will be soul destroying.

I honestly believe if you don’t get this sorted soon you will be following in my footsteps. There’s been some good advice on this thread. Please try and regain some power in the relationship, or you’ll end up hating him by the time you decide to leave.

IHateArguments · 12/09/2022 20:10

The problem is that he has historically been a kind and caring husband. I would have said that he had a good relationship. But the last few years have been stressful (for everyone) and I think he's got into this pattern or mode of thinking or being. And I am also a little bit to blame because I have let it get like this.

I've tried to raise it a few times (I've said I don't like it - that it makes me really anxious - that it's unhealthy) but when he's in a good mood, he just brushes it off or changes the subject. When he's in a bad mood, he just blows up.

I do think it's a problem and I'm absolutely not saying it's fine, he's fine, there's no problem. I just wish there was a way to address things - like, properly. I never would have imagined myself feeling like I wanted couples' therapy or anything, but I feel that's what would be needed at this point. And I don't think he'd agree.

I'm sorry for coming across as feeble. I don't think I really am gaslit and worn down and subjugated because I know it's not right and I actually am not content to put up with it. But I just feel, I don't know... tired and sad.

OP posts:
GettingItOutThere · 12/09/2022 20:07

stop minimising his behaviour, it really is a LTB situation. YOu literally live in fear of him. That is not ok

Boreded · 12/09/2022 20:04

If everyone who got a LTB response actually did, I swear we would have just 4 people left in the country that were still married.

men and women can both be arseholes…but both can also react in an unreasonable manner, the question is what they do next. If his rage is an issue he needs to confront the source, counselling, medication, job change, etc…other things need to be considered.

op has stated she doesn’t feel it’s a LTB situation, so unless people think she is in danger, it’s not necessary to bang on about leaving him. That being said @IHateArguments you do need to carve out some time to actually have a frank discussion with him on what is and isn’t ok, because if it continues then you should
consider whether or not to stick it out or to seek better for yourself.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 12/09/2022 20:03

Why the fuck is that not a LTB. To give you a counterpoint to base your "normal" on, me and my DP have never shouted or sworn at each other in anger in 16 years. We've gotten frustrated with each other, we've snapped, we've said things we regretted. But if either one of us berated the other for an hour over anything less than a murder, let alone a child care issue, the relationship would be over.

Munchyseeds2 · 12/09/2022 20:00

You really have not made it sound worse than it is
I don't care how stressed or unwell he is.
There is nothing that can excuse his way of behaving